Re: Interesting: Shahmukhee & Gurmukhee
Harinder Singh · 25 Dec 2007
I met a pakistan punjabi in europe(their punjabi is so sweet and pure) and he wrote my name in shahmukhee.
But Gurmukhee is Gurmukhee. Gurmukhee has been created by Waheguru Himself.
Re: Interesting: Shahmukhee & Gurmukhee
kulbir singh · 01 Jan 2008
Shahmukhi script is inadequate to write Punjabi language and Gurmukhi is specially designed for Punjabi. Therefore, it is the correct script to write Punjabi. I was reading the an article by Sardar Bhagat Singh on this subject and was surprised to see that he was suggesting the Devnagri script for writing Punjabi. While Devnagri script may be better than the Shahmukhi script, it too lacks the strength to record Punjabi.
As for Punjabi spoken in Pakistan, I feel that the Punjabi has been totally burdened by Farsi words. Perhaps the Punjabi spoken in rural areas of Pakistani Punjab is good but the one spoken in Lahore, Sialkot or other cities is no good and has too much influence of Urdu and Farsi.
The Pakistani Punjabis are suffering from the worse kind of inferiority complex because they have given up their mother tongue to adopt Urdu. The Bangladeshi Muslims refused to give up Bangla as they were proud of their language and did not adopt the Shahmukhi script or the Urdu language but our Pakistani brothers in Pakistan are extremely shameless as they have already given up Punjabi. Why should Urdu be the national language of Pakistan and not Punjabi?
Kulbir Singh
Re: Interesting: Shahmukhee & Gurmukhee
Harinder Singh · 02 Jan 2008
<>
Pyare Kulbir Singh veerji,
Can u explain this a bit more. I had the impression that Gurmukhi Was designed to write gurbani and gurbani has lots of sanskrit, hindi,brij bhasha etc words.
Re: Interesting: Shahmukhee & Gurmukhee
kulbir singh · 03 Jan 2008
-----
Can u explain this a bit more. I had the impression that Gurmukhi Was designed to write gurbani and gurbani has lots of sanskrit, hindi,brij bhasha etc words.
-------
What I meant was that Gurmukhi is the best script to write Punjabi. I take back my original statement that Gurmukhi is specially designed for Punjabi.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Interesting: Shahmukhee & Gurmukhee
Harinder Singh · 05 Jan 2008
Veerji,
I have one more similar question. THere are many many sikhs who are very passionate about being punjabi, about punjabi language. Though punjabi is my mother tongue too and i do like punjabi but whts the relationship between punjabi culture/ language and sikhi way of life/ Gurbani. Is it easier for a punjabi person to understand or practice sikhi than say a sikh born in karnataka or maharashtra knowing gurmukhi but not knowing punjabi language ??? I hope my question is making some sense.
Re: Interesting: Shahmukhee & Gurmukhee
kulbir singh · 11 Jan 2008
-------
I have one more similar question. THere are many many sikhs who are very passionate about being punjabi, about punjabi language. Though punjabi is my mother tongue too and i do like punjabi but whts the relationship between punjabi culture/ language and sikhi way of life/ Gurbani. Is it easier for a punjabi person to understand or practice sikhi than say a sikh born in karnataka or maharashtra knowing gurmukhi but not knowing punjabi language ???
----------
There is no doubt that though the language of Gurbani is Sant-bhaasha but there are a lot of pure Punjabi shabads and North-Indian language shabads in it. A person from Haryana, Punjab, UP or other North-Indian states would have a bit advantage for the ease of understanding Gurbani but this does not mean that a person from South India as you mentioned, can't be a good Gursikh. I believe that once you start reading Gurbani, you start to understand it, irrespective of your background.
To be a good Gursikh, one has to keep rehit, japp Naam and do Nitnem. Anyone who does this can be a good Gursikh irrespective of their background. And yes, I agree that Punjabi culture is not equal to Sikh culture and as the Sikh religion will spread throughout the world, the relevance of Punjabi culture will decrease with that proportion. Now since the majority of followers of Sikh faith are from Punjab, they sometimes mix Punjabi culture and values with Sikhi but this will change in the future.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Interesting: Shahmukhee & Gurmukhee
Menu Ke Patha · 14 Jan 2008
Ghareeb Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> <<>
>
>
> Is there anything, any language, any script, or
> any being that is not created by Waheguru
> Himself?
>
> Bhul Chuk Maaf
>
> Ghareeb
AKAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAALUHHH
wel said jio!!!
everyfink is created by sree akaal purakh vahegurooooooooooooooo!!
vaheguroo jee ka khalsa
vaheguroo jee kee fatehh
Re: Interesting: Shahmukhee & Gurmukhee
Harinder Singh · 15 Jan 2008
<>
designing a script is a science. Gurmukhi script has been made by Satguru jee/Waheguru jee who is the souce of all science/knowledge.
Same with grammar. Grammar is also a science, but the grammar of gurbani is perfect. At present we use the help of dunaivi grammar life nouns, adjectives, prepositions, etc to understand Gurbani Grammar but I feel a person who has become one with Waheguru jee wikll get to know the TATT grammar science.
what a play!