Forum
Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Ekta Singh · 25 Dec 2007
http://damdamitaksaal.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=84&Itemid=51
THE LAST TIME WHEN SANT GIANI GURBACHAN SINGH JI KHALSA BHINDRANWALE MET BHAI SAHIB BHAI RANDHIR SINGH
On 19th February 1960, Sant Giani Gurbachan Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale met Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh in Ludhiana at Bhai Sahib’s residence. They did vichaar on Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s Manglan.
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh was ill at the time. Sant Giani Kartar Singh Ji Khalsa was also present and other members of the jatha.
They started vichaar on Gurbani. Sant Ji said to Bhai Sahib that the anand Bhai Sahib get’s from doing simran, and the avasta they’ve got, that they have ras. After hearing those words of Sant Ji, Bhai Sahib got very emotional. Bhai Sahib then replied by saying that Sant Ji was saying all those things to him in nimrata, and that the truth was that Sant Ji is the Jathedar (Mukhi) of Kalgidhar Paatshah’s Taksal and that they have Brahm Vidiya and that they are a Mahapurakh. Bhai Sahib then told Sant Ji that they have read their antreev meanings of Raag Mala, the ones that you can’t find anywhere in any teeka’s. Then Bhai Sahib did vichaar and agreed that Raag Mala is Gurbani and said that “Bani Agam Hai, Sikh Bhulanhar, Teh Guru Bakhshanhar Hai.” Also Bhai Sahib said that Sant Ji had Apaar Kirpa.
This was the last time Sant Ji and Bhai Sahib met. After the vichaar ended, Sant Ji and the jatha had something to eat and drink and then Sant Ji and Bhai Sahib said fateh to one another and then Sant Ji left.
After that, the next day, Sant Giani Gurbachan Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale went to Rara Sahib to attend a meeting which included other Mahapurakh’s, Sant Isher Singh Ji Rara Sahib Wale, Sant Giani Kirpal Singh Ji Sato Gali Wale, Giani Niranjan Singh Patiala Wale, and Giani Arjun Singh Ji Muni. After this meeting another two-four other meetings happened. These Mahapurakh’s then had meetings with the main Shromani committee members and other vidvaan’s and made the final decision regarding the Manglan.
(Whats the sangats view on this story and if bhai sahib admited raag mala was baani then why did'nt he tell rest of the jatha?)
Article on Taksaals latest site
khaalsaa · 25 Dec 2007
So much so for the 'new offical site' of Taksaal. We all know the stand of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee on Raag Maalaa and most are aware of the very interesting lineage of Taksaal. I fail to see the motive behind articles such as the one below. When will such trash stop being cirulated by internet Taksaali's who seem to make up such amusing and stories to support their agendas? Fairytale or dream like stories that are being circulated are nothing more than laughable. First you have the story of Guru Sahib slapping a Sikh for reading Gurbani incorrectly, then one of raags crying for acceptance hence Raagmaala (im not too bothered to remember these stories correctly) and now you have more cheap shots such as this crazy 'account' of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee 'accepting' Raagmaalaa at meeting with Gyanee Gurbachan Singh Jee. Sharam karo
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Last time Sant Giani Gurbachan Singh and Bhai Sahib Bhai Randir Singh met
THE LAST TIME WHEN SANT GIANI GURBACHAN SINGH JI KHALSA BHINDRANWALE MET BHAI SAHIB BHAI RANDHIR SINGH
On 19th February 1960, Sant Giani Gurbachan Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale met Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh in Ludhiana at Bhai Sahib’s residence. They did vichaar on Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s Manglan.
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh was ill at the time. Sant Giani Kartar Singh Ji Khalsa was also present and other members of the jatha.
They started vichaar on Gurbani. Sant Ji said to Bhai Sahib that the anand Bhai Sahib get’s from doing simran, and the avasta they’ve got, that they have ras. After hearing those words of Sant Ji, Bhai Sahib got very emotional. Bhai Sahib then replied by saying that Sant Ji was saying all those things to him in nimrata, and that the truth was that Sant Ji is the Jathedar (Mukhi) of Kalgidhar Paatshah’s Taksal and that they have Brahm Vidiya and that they are a Mahapurakh. Bhai Sahib then told Sant Ji that they have read their antreev meanings of Raag Mala, the ones that you can’t find anywhere in any teeka’s. Then Bhai Sahib did vichaar and agreed that Raag Mala is Gurbani and said that “Bani Agam Hai, Sikh Bhulanhar, Teh Guru Bakhshanhar Hai.” Also Bhai Sahib said that Sant Ji had Apaar Kirpa.
This was the last time Sant Ji and Bhai Sahib met. After the vichaar ended, Sant Ji and the jatha had something to eat and drink and then Sant Ji and Bhai Sahib said fateh to one another and then Sant Ji left.
After that, the next day, Sant Giani Gurbachan Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale went to Rara Sahib to attend a meeting which included other Mahapurakh’s, Sant Isher Singh Ji Rara Sahib Wale, Sant Giani Kirpal Singh Ji Sato Gali Wale, Giani Niranjan Singh Patiala Wale, and Giani Arjun Singh Ji Muni. After this meeting another two-four other meetings happened. These Mahapurakh’s then had meetings with the main Shromani committee members and other vidvaan’s and made the final decision regarding the Manglan.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://damdamitaksaal.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=84&Itemid=33
Re: Article on Taksaals latest site
Khalsaspirit · 26 Dec 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
Khalsaspirit.com strongly believes as you mentioned the fake stories/sakhis created by this splinter group from Bhindra Taksal are laughable. This splinter group Mehta Taksal(which is now further divided to Sangranva Taksal) who runs above websites Damdamitaksal.com/.org/.net has nothing else just to split the panth further with their smartness (Developers of interesting fake stories). This splinter group is so desperate to prove Raagmala as Gurbani that no matter what fake story they have to develop they do it and this Bhai Sahib's story has no exception. This story is one of the series of their own fake stories of their lineage to Guru Sahib.
According to Giani Gurbachan Singh Jee the Taksal lineage is to Bhai Mani Singh Jee but this splinter group did not like that lineage and linked themselves to Baba Deep Singh Jee. After 1984 for 21 years how this group was kept saying Baba Jarnail Singh Jee is not Shaheed but finally had to accept the truth and now this group is blaming Baba Thakur Singh Jee for this lie. On the other hand this group claim Baba Thakur Singh Jee as a Brahamgiani. Whole panth knows truth about this group.
Those two examples are good enough to know the state of their mind but one thing is very clear now that this group very vividly knows Raagmala is not Gurbani yet do not want to accept it. The strange thing is Giani Mohan Singh Jee (the approved successor) of Bhindra Taksal never made comments about Raagmala as this splinter group does.
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Article on Taksaals latest site
khalistan_zindabaad · 26 Dec 2007
There must be some truth in the sakhi for them to put it up. . .
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
kulbir singh · 26 Dec 2007
Following is from an old post:
It’s totally absurd to think that Bhai Sahib admitted to Raagmala being baani in secret but did not admit it in front of Singhs out of the fear that they will lose faith in him.
It is further ludicrous to imagine that Bhai Sahib got impressed with the deep meanings of Raagmala that Sant Gurbachan Singh jee told Bhai Sahib. I have read these meanings and they absolutely make no sense and are totally meaningless. Bhai Sahib who was a master of Gurbani Viyakaran, could have not got impressed with these meanings since they are against Grammar and even simple human logic.
Bhai Sahib would have never felt ashamed if he had realised his mistake of not reading Raagmala all his life. Bhai Sahib was a man enough to admit his mistake. The fact of the matter is that such conversation never took place between Sant jee and Bhai Sahib. Sant jee and Bhai Sahib respected each other despite this minor difference.
During the times of Bhai Sahib, he was not the most prominent opponents of Raagmala. At that time Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha and Bhai Shamsher Singh Ashok were leading the movement against Raagmala. Who in Panth could have dared to talk in front of Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha? Ordinary so called gyanis used to tremble before him. Pandit jee was an ocean of knowledge and many scholars of that time had been his students at some point in life. If Sant Gurbachan Singh had to resolve to issue of Raagmala, he would have gone to convince Pandit jee and his group of scholars and not Bhai Sahib who was not leading the movement against Raagmala. Once Sant Amir Singh of Taksal tried but lost miserably to Pandit jee.
Rumours like this one are lurking within Taksal for long time. Another one of the rumour is that during his end days, Bhai Sahib was suffering a lot and requested Sant Gurbachan Singh to save him. Sant jee asked him to admit his mistake of Raagmala and only then he was released from the suffering. Such a bogus story this is. Total nonsense. Dr Tarlochan Singh was there during the last moments of Bhai Sahib and he has written how peaceful Bhai Sahib was. He was in total bliss and had no suffering.
Another absurd story about Bhai Sahib is that when Bhai Sahib tried to enter Sach Khand after passing away, doors were shut on him because he did not read Raagmala. These jokers who make up these stories don’t know that Bhai Sahib was a resident of Sach Khand right while living. Who could have denied him Sach Khand after leaving this body?
Don’t believe such stories. Bhai Sahib stayed in Chardi Kala till his last days on this planet and he never admitted Raagmala to be baani.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Death · 26 Dec 2007
completely agree with kulbir singh ji.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
NiranjanSingh · 27 Dec 2007
Actually, the entire site is kind of a joke. Despite 23 years after '84 this group continues to believe Sant Jarnail Singh is still alive and hiding out someplace. First Pakistan, then China, Russia, who know where now. That alone should explain the mentality of these people.
Afters 23 years they continue this fairy tale lie, and are not even willing to call yodha Sant Jarnail Singh a Shaheed. Do you think they really feel any guilt when lying about Bhai Randhir Singh Ji?
Regardless, this site looks like the work of some illiterate teenagers. There are so many errors, misspellings and typos, it is not even funny.
Take a look at their interpretation of "Mool Mantar", each word has multiple meanings, many contradicting each other.
http://damdamitaksaal.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=32&Itemid=33
For example they interpret the word AKAL as :
(A) Vishnu, (Ka) Brahma, (La) Lord Shiv
(Typical for Nirmala/Sanatan oriented samperdayas)
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
khalistan_zindabaad · 27 Dec 2007
To correct khalsa spirit,
1) sant gurbachan singh clearly states that the taksal is from guru gobind singh jee and baba deep singh jee.
2) i think your confused with these splinter groups, you make me laugh with the statement as half of what you said is utter nonsence
3) Baba thakur singh for all his life said sant jee wasnt shaheed so alot of gursikh stand with this bachan
4) Baba mohan singh clearly mentions about raagmala and states it is bani in his santhia which has been relaesed on gurmatveechar.com and cusses those who dont beleive in it.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Khalsaspirit · 27 Dec 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Bhai Niranjan Singh jio,
"Regardless, this site looks like the work of some illiterate teenagers"
We would further say that, not just this website the whole game show is the work of illiterates and one thing is crystal clear who ever fabricated these stories ਉਸਨੇ ਅਸਿੱਧੇ ਰੂਪ ਵਿਚ ਭਾਈ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਭਾਈ ਰਣਧੀਰ ਸਿੰਘ ਜੀ ਦੇ ਤੱਤ ਗੁਰਮਤਿ ਗਿਆਨ ਦਾ ਲੌਹਾ ਮੰਨ ਲਿਆ ਹੈ। ਹੁਣ ਭਾਂਵੇ ਮੂੰਹੋ ਕਹਿਣ ਜਾਂ ਨਾ ਕਹਿਣ।
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
sikhstar · 27 Dec 2007
Thank you for the link Gursikho, Its a really inspirational website.
I personally dont doubt that the stories above are true however I think there needs to be more in depth information available on its basis and i think if you spot mistakes in the website, you should do the seva of telling the guys who run it that it is wrong so they may correct it. No one or no website is perfect so lets work together to spread Gurbani world wide.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Khalsaspirit · 27 Dec 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Zindabad jio,
"1) sant gurbachan singh clearly states that the taksal is from guru gobind singh jee and baba deep singh jee."
Bring the evidence. Not a link to some flashy websites.
"2) i think your confused with these splinter groups, you make me laugh with the statement as half of what you said is utter nonsence."
We are crytal clear about this splitter group and we have no control if you laugh or beep.
"3) Baba thakur singh for all his life said sant jee wasnt shaheed so alot of gursikh stand with this bachan"
Here you go, now you are confused about spilitter group who now declared him shaheed too.
"4) Baba mohan singh clearly mentions about raagmala and states it is bani in his santhia which has been relaesed on gurmatveechar.com and cusses those who dont beleive in it."
You misunderstood. This is childish thing for anyone to assume that Baba Mohan Singh would say some thing which will be agianst what they were taught but what we meant is if you read again "The strange thing is Giani Mohan Singh Jee (the approved successor) of Bhindra Taksal never made comments about Raagmala as this splinter group does"
Means the approved successor of Bhindra Taksal never made those comments (fake stories of Bhai Sahib & Raag mala) as this splitter group does. Is that clear enough.
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
malton · 27 Dec 2007
The Damdami Taksal has had rich tradition, but many believe they fell into disarray after 1984 because of lack of true leadership. Baba Takhur Singh was given the 'sevadar' title, which resulted in constant jockeying for position for the leadership before he passed - which led to inner division.
As an organization for the betterment of the panth, many felt felt the taksal was involving itself in ritualistic and meaningless battles, rather then fighting the growing radasuomi problem, promoting gurbani, or countering the countless sardars cutting their hair.
It seems there have been many stories that have no basis, ie the randhir singh and raag mala story, and the story that sant ji will be brought back hand in hand by baba takhur singh - which was in turn supposed to set off world war 3. There was also rumours started that sant ji was hiding our in pakistan or california, and sangat was encouraged not to lose faith. Stories like this only lessened the credibility of the taksal, and the Dhumma/Raam Singh incident further tainted taksals image.
We are One panth, stories that are made up to prove a point dont do anyone any good. Examples that dont have any gurbani backing, and are still insisted as truth, dont do anyone good, ie 'dont worry everything will be ok when sant ji comes back' or 'it has to be true because babaji/santji were brahm gianis'.
We must learn to respect our great sikhs, but not knock others down only to raise them on a pedestal.The only suggestion is to have pyar with gurbani and guru, and to not believe everything we here as true.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
SENGH · 28 Dec 2007
Vaheguru je ka khalsa Vaheguru je ke fateh
i havent bothered reading your topic as i dont understand the point of it!!!
you know by posting this kind of topic it is just going to cause an argument!!! if you REALLY want to know whether Raagmala is bani or not go ask the panj payare!!!
sorry for the little rant
Vaheguru je ka khalsa Vaheguru je ke fateh!
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
yes · 28 Dec 2007
This is from the ragmala section of www.damdamitaksaal.net website:
"In 1945 the SGPC set up a sub-committee to investigate whether Ragmala is included in the original Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Saroop that was compiled by Sri Guru Arjan Dev Jee. The following is from their:
“We can most definitely say that nobody other than Bhai Gurdas Jee, who was the scribe, included Ragmala in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Ragmala is an ang of Sri Guru Granth Sahib.”
They also stated that they the ink, paper and handwriting of Ragmala was consistent with the rest of the saroop."
Some arguments made on the site do make sense and have basis but can someone please explain the above point?
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
baba jee bachan · 28 Dec 2007
message FAO: Khalsaspirit
i think u have got some deep personal issues. everyone in this world is different, therefore is expected to have slightly different views. however we all share the same light..... so on them grounds i really believe you need to understand there is a way to speak to people and about people. u call urself khalsa spirit but ur not representing the views and way of guru gobind singh jee.
gurfateh.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Manmat · 28 Dec 2007
vjkk vjkf
gursikho , what is the point of all this, we are just wasting our time and missing out on earning laha of naam/banee/seva
everyone stick what they believe end of, this is a joke
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
baba amarjeet singh · 28 Dec 2007
the answer to the question "did bhai sahib admit raagmala was gurbani" is, no.
whoever says otherwise is lying.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
baba jee bachan · 28 Dec 2007
the answer to the question "did bhai sahib admit raagmala was gurbani" is, no.
whoever says otherwise is lying.....................
you wasn't there so u can answer that question.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
baba amarjeet singh · 29 Dec 2007
by that logic u werent there when hitler was around
so hitler could have been a great kind, generous man right?
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Atma Singh · 29 Dec 2007
vaheguroojeekakhalsa,vaheguroojeefateh!
'baba jee bachan'
if i stated on the ddt site that bhai sahib mentioned on his 'death-bed' that he was a big fan of michael jackson and amarjeet singh denied this, would you still respond by saying: "you wasn't there so u can[t] answer that question".
no - because my proposition would be so contrary to bhai sahib as he was known as to render it absurd...just like it is absurd to say he 'died painfully' or he 'changed his mind about raagmala but kept it gupt'. ALL the evidence suggests otherwise whilst, wait for it, those who make these frankly pathetic and immature claims have presented NO evidence.
this is just the latest example of how low some self-proclaimed or otherwise official 'taksalees' will go. these ppl need to grow-up.
jatha and taksaal need to recognise their many commonalities and overlook their very few differences if they are to truly act in the best interests of the panth.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
baba jee bachan · 29 Dec 2007
lol but there are people who believe he was great. all im saying is that ur expected to have ur own views, just don't try to protray them as facts. only maharaaj knws the truth.
gurfateh parvaan.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Waheguru Rules · 29 Dec 2007
baba amarjeet singh Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> the answer to the question "did bhai sahib admit
> raagmala was gurbani" is, no.
> whoever says otherwise is lying.
Vaheguru jee ka khalsa,Vaheguru jee ke fateh!
This is a very narrow-minded way of putting it!
An like when you put,
"by that logic u werent there when hitler was around
so hitler could have been a great kind, generous man right?"
This is a ridulous comparision to say in the least. How can you compare Bani to some hitler human? The two issues are completly different because everyone agrees to what kind of person hitler was, where as not everyone agrees to the Raagmala issue.
Pull chuk marf,
Vaheguru jee ka khalsa,Vaheguru jee ke fateh!
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
gurmantar · 30 Dec 2007
I agree completely with the statement made by Atma Singh, We should look at the 95% thats the same rather than the 5% thats different otherwise how will the panth ever go forward.
Also why are people trying to change what has happened just to try and prove their associated jatha bandi right, Bhai Sahib Bhai Randear Singh did not say Ragmaala was bani...end ..just leave it that, and look at your own jeavans rather than try to put down the jeavans of such pavitar gurmukhs like Bhai Sahib.
bhul chuk maaf karni
vaheguroo ji ka khalsa vaheguroo ji ki fateh!!!
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
baba amarjeet singh · 31 Dec 2007
"
Vaheguru jee ka khalsa,Vaheguru jee ke fateh!
This is a very narrow-minded way of putting it!
An like when you put,
"by that logic u werent there when hitler was around
so hitler could have been a great kind, generous man right?"
This is a ridulous comparision to say in the least. How can you compare Bani to some hitler human? The two issues are completly different because everyone agrees to what kind of person hitler was, where as not everyone agrees to the Raagmala issue.
Pull chuk marf,
Vaheguru jee ka khalsa,Vaheguru jee ke fateh!"
everyone knows bhai sahib didnt belelive in raagmala just like everyone knows hitler was an evil man.
im not comparing bani im comparing 2 beleifs
bhai sahib was a staunch beleiver than raagmala aint bani, just like hitler was a staunch beliver tht jews were evil
both are well known facts
until certain ppl try to twist facts
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
hardeep sengh · 01 Jan 2008
baba jee bachan Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> lol but there are people who believe he was great.
> all im saying is that ur expected to have ur own
> views, just don't try to protray them as facts.
> only maharaaj knws the truth.
> gurfateh parvaan.
baba jee bachan
only maharaaj knws the truth.
_____________________________________________
show us some evidence that prove bhai sahib admitted raagmala was bani
frankly i think whoever says bhai shaib believed in raagmala is looking to discredit bhai sahib
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
jasdeep · 02 Jan 2008
VAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHALSA VAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATEH!
i am a member of akhand kirtani jatha so is my grandad & dad, my grandad met bhai sahib bhai randhir singh jee and spent some time with him, i asked him about this situation he told me its true (i was very shocked to hear this) my grandad and other singhs were present when the taksal singhs came to meet bhai sahib ji at his house in ludhiana,bhai sahib ji did admit raag mala was bani,bhai sahib bhai randhir singh ji's son was also present at the time as he was the one who helped serve langar to the singhs, my grandad says some of the singhs that were present are still alive and so is bhai sahib jis son they can tell you if its true too. my grandad is an akhand pathee from bhai sahib jees time, even in india now akhand kirtani jatha singhs do akhand paath samaptee with raagmala.
i read all the comments to my grandad he was very shocked he said singhs are getting into alot of krodh (anger) about this subject, he said this is not what bhai sahib jee would hav wanted, and same to you taksal singh sant gurbachan singh ji wudnt hav wanted all this anger either.
my grandad said bhai sahib ji was a very calm person with a lot of nimrataa (humbleness) and love for everyone in the jatha and out of the jatha too. my grandad said this to you all - ''singho bhai sahib vangu nimrata vich rehio bhai sahib ji ne inee charcha raag mala barey nahee kitee phir asi hun kyo shuru ho geye? apney nitneym badhawo, simran badhawo is cheeza wich bhai sahib ji khush hundey yaa.'' (''singhs keep in nimrata like bhai sahib ji did, bhai sahib did not do this much of a discussion on raag mala so who are we to do it now? increase your nitneym, increase your simran this is what will please bhai sahib ji.'')
my views changed alot too after finding out what my grandad said to me as i also believed bhai sahib ji cud not hav admitted to it..
bhul chuk maafi to every one if you do not like what me and my grandad said
VAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHALSA VAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATEH!
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Khalsaspirit · 02 Jan 2008
Waheguru ji ki Khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
ਆਹਾ ਅਸ਼ਕੇ ਖੁੰਬਾ ਵਾਂਗੂੰ ਉਠ ਰਹੇ ਪੋਸਟਰਾਂ ਦੇ ਅਤੇ ਦਿਲਚਸਪ ਮਨੋਕਲਪਿਤ ਕਹਾਣੀਆਂ ਦੇ। ਦੇਖਿਉ ਕਿਤੇ ਇਸ ਚਲ ਰਹੀ ਗੰਗਾ ਵਿਚੋਂ ਕੋਈ ਹੱਥ ਧੋਣੌ ਰਹਿ ਨਾ ਜਾਵੇ।
Jasdeep jio, sorry for your grand dad. Didn’t he also tell you that he (grand dad) was beaten up a lot and almost broke teeth for this conspiracy story and insects started to come out from his (grand dad) mouth?
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
NiranjanSingh · 02 Jan 2008
Thanks for sharing your grandfather's story jasdeep ji, but there is one problem with it. Why did it take your grandfather more than 45 years to share this story with others? Why just now ?
I can easily say my grandfather witnessed the opposite where Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji admitted that Ragmala was not bani, but that does not prove anything. Your grandfather needs to collaborate his account with details of what else happened that day, who else was there, etc.
Can your grandfather name anyone else who is still alive and witnessed this event also?
If so then this information needs to be shared.
Also what is your grandfather's recollection about anything else they talked about that day. Was Keski as a Kakkar discussed by Baba Ji and Bhai Sahib ?
I am sure other things besides just Raagmala was discussed by those great souls.
There was still quite a few Gurmukhs who are still alive from Bhai Sahib's days. Further details about this even can be easily verified by those GurSikhs.
Looking forward to the details...
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Atma Singh · 02 Jan 2008
vaheguroojeekakhalsa,vaheguroojeekeefateh!
dear veer/bhain 'jasdeep' jeeo,
i would have emailed you privately instead of posting here but you haven't given an email address; i think this thread has gone on as far as it should really and so didn't really want to add to it but here goes (typical me!):
if you really believe what you say is true, then i suggest you name your grandfather to some respected elder jatha singhs, preferably who carry out amrit sanchaar seva, so that they can proceed from there.
if bhai sahib really did believe in raagmala all of a sudden, then your grandfather should feel like letting the jatha and panth officially know so that jatha can be requested to take stock of this development and respond accordingly. he could of course give them the info he possesses, whether oral, documentary etc. and remain anonymous. if raagmala was indeed gurbaaNee, this would be a great seva for your grandfather to be blessed with.
my personal and firm belief is that anyone who knows anything about bhai sahib knows that his whole life, his thoughts and deeds, portrayed someone who was in love with the truth and simply could never keep quiet in the face of falseness or dishonesty. there is no need to even quote examples i am sure.
do we really think that upon finding-out that raagmala was gurbaNee after all, he would have stayed quiet? that notion goes against eveything he represented. to think he would let a jatha of singhs and singhneeaa(n) who had a lot of love for him and vice-versa, carry-on not reading raagmala while he himself did means he must have 'kept the real truth a secret'. this is preposterous...
that he would effectively let them remain unaware of this seismic change in his outlook - an outlook which influenced so many others...that he would let them continue 'disregarding maharaaj jee's baaNee'...i think you get my point.
veer/bhain 'jasdeep' jee, coming onto this forum, with just a first name and no email address, without naming your grandfather and offering no real proof apart from hearsay is not really helpful - i am sure you understand the reasons why.
lastly, every jatha singh/singhnee who doesn't believe in raagmala should do their best to read both anti and pro stance literature so that they do not simply believe something because bhai sahib did.
if you are about to disregard something which appears in many puraatan saroops then be very firm in your belief by looking into it DIRECTLY off your own back; of course, ardaasaa(n) to maharaaj jee are part of this. bhai sahib certainly wouldn't weant you to simply believe something upon the basis that you only believe it because he did - i am sure he would feel that you have turned him into a 'guroo'.
Like-wise those reading this who believe raagmala is gurbaaNee should do the same. it should not be a case that 'so and so said it is so i believe it is'. the issues regarding raagmala are too many and too important to simply formulate an opinion in such a rudimentary manner. shardaa in a kamaee-vala gursikhs/'sants' and their bachans is not a bad thing when it comes to your sikhee but when it comes to your guroo jee's roop, the connection and searching should be direct, not with someone deciding for you in the middle.
always remember when looking into raagamala that the raagmala issue aside, kachee baaNee was historically placed into maharaaj jee's saroop e.g. ratanmaala, saloks regarding prophet muhammad, ink recipes, etc. it was agreed at a panthic level historically to take it out. so please do not let the heartfelt emotion caused when thinking 'how can we removes something mahraaj jee's saroop' be your overarching factor for being pro-raagmala. the fact is that if the panth previously had this attitude, we would all be doing paath of those kachee baaNeeaa(n) mentioned above.
treat the raagmala issue as something you have to PERSONALLY look into, and PERSONALLY decide regarding. do not tell yourself you will discuss the ins and outs on worldwide forums. do not get into arguments and tit-for-tat wars - these only decrease the love within the panth and bring the panth into dehndee kalaa. If someone asks for your opinion, give it. If someone doesn’t, don’t. if someone is thirsty, give them water, if they are not, do not ram it down their throats.
i write the above as someone who realised that this was the way that i had to go about finding-out about and deciding re: the raagmala debate.
ps - i spoke to a young singh the other day. he told me, proactively, that he believes in naam-dhrir, that he believes that keskee is a kakaar and that raagmala IS gurbaaNee - excellent! this means he is thinking for himself, looking into it for himself and treating these issues with the importance they deserve - not becoming some sort of 'un-questioning gang-member' which sadly a lot of youth, especially so-called 'jatha' and 'taksalee' youth, have become.
although i humbly believe that the below panktee is referring, generally speaking, to the way gursikhs approach gurmat and their bhagtee, the first part also has some relevance given what we are talking about:
[gurbanee]riKriKcrnDryvIcwrI ]
duibDwCoifBeyinrMkwrI ][/gurbanee]
rakh rakh charan dhharae veechaaree ||
dhubidhhaa shhodd bheae nira(n)kaaree || (pad-ched according to STTM)
After CAREFUL DELIBERATION, the thoughtful person takes a step.
Forsaking duality, he becomes a devotee of the Formless Lord.
maharaaj jee sadae kirpa karae.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Aparadhee · 02 Jan 2008
atma singh ji that was a brilliant post, this is the way to tackle these issues on a personal level.
gurbaaNee quote was supposed to appear as....
Atma Singh · 02 Jan 2008
[gurbani]riKriKcrnDryvIcwrI ]
duibDwCoifBeyinrMkwrI ][/gurbani]
rakh rakh charan dhharae veechaaree ||
dhubidhhaa shhodd bheae nira(n)kaaree || (pad-ched according to STTM)
After CAREFUL DELIBERATION, the thoughtful person takes a step.
Forsaking duality, he becomes a devotee of the Formless Lord.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
khalistan_zindabaad · 02 Jan 2008
thanks for sharing that jasdeep singh
There are still singhs alive from the taksal side that were present.
sant kartaar singh was present, baba thakur singh was there and 2 other singhs.
the whole episode is written in giani pritam singhs book on sant gurbachan singh jees jeevan, and also in sant kartaar singhs jeevani.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
khalistan_zindabaad · 02 Jan 2008
could you also put down which other jatha singhs were present, as we know who was present from the taksal.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Khalsaspirit · 02 Jan 2008
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Bhai Nirajan Singh jio,
Seems like this person Jasdeep is a part of splitter group. His post clearly indicates this from the flaws he left in the story and pretends to be Jatha singh.
First he wrote Fateh in larrivaar "VAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHALSA VAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATEH!" to give the some jatha impression.
Second he claimed to be a member Of Akhand Kirtani Jatha Quote ”I am a member of Akhand kirtani jatha so is my grandad & dad".
If he is a member then does he have the membership number and date he registered his membership or any slip. Jasdeep jio could you post that here?
Third he fabricated for Grand dad, which mean he is merely a kid and got this grand pa story from Bhai Veer Singh Jee idea.
Fourth the big flaw he made is about Bhai Sahib's son Quote” some of the singhs that were present are still alive and so is bhai sahib jis son they can tell you if its true too"
This guy does not know that Bhai Sahib's son is not alive. So this claim itself tells the conspiracy of whole story.
Fifth he claims that quote "even in india now akhand kirtani jatha singhs do akhand paath samaptee with raagmala".
Which indicates this guy is living abroad and without having any first hand concrete information he made up this based on hear say.
Sixth he talks about his grand dad's opinion about this thread. Reading this thread any one who can read plain English can tell who is on Krodh? The fake story makers or ones who are asking the evidence.
Seventh Quote "singho bhai sahib vangu nimrata vich rehio bhai sahib ji ne inee charcha raag mala barey nahee kitee phir asi hun kyo shuru ho geye? apney nitneym badhawo, simran badhawo is cheeza wich bhai sahib ji khush hundey yaa."
Again this guy know nothing about Jatha but showed his Dera influence "bhai sahib ji khush hundey yaa"
Eigth Quote "my views changed alot too after finding out what my grandad said to me as i also believed bhai sahib ji cud not hav admitted to it.."
Here comes the climax of story as Bhai Veer Singh Jee style on Raagmala.
Fabrication of this story is even worst than the first one on website. By seeing these stories we can bet the fabrication of next story is under way and this time may be on the name of some one from Bhai Sahib‘s family. What a low level an organization can go to prove a baseless point.
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
NiranjanSingh · 03 Jan 2008
KhalsaSpirit Jio,
Jasdeep's post is obviously a hoax like the Taksal web site's story on Bhai Randhir Singh Ji.
First of all, if his grandfather has been reading Ragmala all this time, why didn't Jasdeep know about it before ? If he know knew about then why was he shocked just now ? Obviously his grandpapa must have told his dad also, after all it has been over 45 years when this all occurred. So, why all the shock in his family now.
Anyways, it is just too convenient to name people who are no longer alive (Balbir Singh, Baba Thakur Singh, Sant Kartar Singh, etc)
I am still waiting for the names of currently alive Taksali and Jatha Singhs, so far I have not soon seen any.
Baba Gurbachan Singh and Baba Kartar Singh were great writers and orators, why didn't they ever say a word about this or anything against Bhai Randhir Singh.
Take a look at how much respect Baba Gurbachan Singh had for Bhai Sahib Ji, this is what he writes in the book "Sri Gurmukh Parkash" about Bhai Sahib Ji in prose.
(Published by Baba Mohan Singh Ji of Bhinderkalan- 1984 by Locket Printers Amritsar)
[gurbani]id`lI my rkwb gMj kMD FwhI jo iPrMgI, isMG swvDwn jwgy sIsW qWeIN lwvny[
BweI rxDIr isMG sIs dyx Awp gey, kMD ausrwlI Pyr monI Gbrwvny[
sMq rxDIr isMG nwmu ilvlweI ijnWH, kIrqn AKMf krY mn iqpRqwvny[
sqwrW swl jylH ktI srb loh bIc CkY, DMn gurU ipAwry mn qn rMg gwvny][/gurbani]
Such was the love and respect Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji has for Bhai Sahib. He refers to him as "Dhan Guru Piaray, and Sant."
On the opposite fence, the current thekaydars of the Mehta group continue to make up fairytales and paint Bhai Sahib Ji as a lier and a hypocrite. Now a days all you hear from Taksali youngsters is how awful of a death Bhai Sahib had, some even claim he has keerray in his mouth. Compare that to what Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji says.
During the 1970's Baba Kartar Singh used to hold joint Smagams with the Jatha when Bhai Fauja Singh Ji and he were alive. They were both very close. Bhai Fauja Singh Ji and the rest of the Jatha never ready Ragmala then, but there is not a single recording or written statement by Baba Kartar Singh against the Jatha or Bhai Randhir Singh. You would think if he was a witness (as khalistan_zindabaad claims) he would have brought this up in the public.
From what I know about Baba Kartar Singh is that he was very up front and truthful, if he had witnessed such an event he would have never held it back from Bhai Fauja Singh Ji or the Jatha. On a side note, there is also another similar fairy tale that claims that before Bhai Fauja Singh Ji became Shaheed he also admitted that Ragmala was bani and that Bhai Fauja Singh then told them that Bhai Randhir Singh had to sit outside the gates of SachKhand until he was let in from pleas of Baba Gurbachan Singh and the Shaheeds.
It is a shame that the people who claim to hold the torch of Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji and Baba Kartar Singh Ji have stooped so low.
Then again, what else can you expect from them, they continue to lie about Baba Jarnail Singh. Look at the current Taksali Gutkas and Senchees, they still claim he is alive in those Gurbani Gutkas. If they can print lies inside Guru Ji's own bani, what else can we expect from them regarding Bhai Sahib?
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Atma Singh · 03 Jan 2008
vaheguroojeekakhalsa,vaheguroojeekeefateh!
veer 'khalistan zindabad' jee
you wrote:
"...and 2 other singhs. the whole episode is written in giani pritam singhs book on sant gurbachan singh jees jeevan, and also in sant kartaar singhs jeevani."
let's treat this logically; we need first-hand evidence to really make this story stick. anything short of this will mean that there will always be doubts. we need to accept this point firmly.
so with this in mind, let’s name these two other singh jees and the singh jees from taksaal who are still alive and were present there; if they wish to keep anonymous please email me their details and I will promise to keep their names gupt. if you can do this, i will personally take the seva of contacting them and getting them to give their account and would make audio recordings (of course, keeping anonymity) for the benefit of the sangat. however, please remember that anonymity will mean that their ‘accounts’ could be mistrusted by the sangat - singhs should stand by the truth, however uncomfortable it may make them feel.
also, baba thakur singh jee and baba kartaar singh jee have both left their mortal frames so cannot be relied upon to give any 'first-hand' evidence. sadly, we have to rule them out of our investigation as any kind of first hand witnesses - their personal testimonies would have put a line under this issue as i could never believe that they would intentionally lie about this given their jeevans.
secondly, the writer of baba gurbachan singh jee's jeevan would need to be personally questioned if he were alive which i doubt and the same goes for the person who wrote baba kartaar singh jee's jeevan. we would have to then ask them if they were first-hand witnesses and if they were not, how did they learn of this incident and from who - these people would need to be contacted and so on and so forth. writing something in a book does not necessarily make it truthful.
until this happens, as a minimum, these accounts are completely unsubstantiated and should be treated as such.
if someone argues that bhai sahib has not written any anti-raagmala statements in his many writings and so this proves he was pro-raagmala, then this is also pure conjecture. bhai sahib obviously felt that people need to come to their own conclusions regarding such matters but certainly shared his opinions when requested. this is evident because those close to him and those of the jatha during those days certainly knew his stand and themselves did not read or promote the reading of raagmala.
i personally won't be contributing to this thread anymore until 'jasdeep', 'khalistan zindabaad' or anyone else provides clear first-hand details regarding 'bhai sahib being pro-raagmala' BACKED-UP BY TESTABLE EVIDENCE. until then, the term 'fairy-tales' springs to mind...
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Harinder Singh · 03 Jan 2008
Bhai Sahib was one of the best sikhs ever to come to earth.Even if i take crore human births, i cant even think of becoming a kuttaa of Bhai Sahib. Bhai Sahib was a MAN of his word. His entire life demonstrates this. He dint consider raagmala to be Gurbani. And taksal, well.. i have great respect for Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Bhindrawale and some other previous jathedaars of taksaal but after 84, the taksal has got completely infiltrated and has badly degenerated.Before getting pesh, i read their book on nitnem, well they had given so many complex meanings and then I had the impression wow. how much giaaan they have but now i have realized that though some meanings were accurate but many meanings were just goodie goodie phurrnaas of mind.I guess same is being done to raagamala to prove it to be gurbani. What Bhai Sahib wrote, he either saw it or heard it from Waheguru Jee.
and I am not some akj-ite infact I have quite a few problems with the present akj but i have TREMENDOUS TREMENDOUS respect for Bhai sahib Randhir Singh Jee.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
kulbir singh · 03 Jan 2008
Veer Naranjan Singh jeeo,
Thank you so much for sharing Sant Gurbachan Singh jee's poem. I have been long thinking of reading this book but never got a chance to do so.
Indeed Singhs of that time had so much pyaar for each other.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
khalistan_zindabaad · 03 Jan 2008
when required and when satguru jee wishes all details will be revealed, untill then. peace. ps the 2 singhs are still alive.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Manjot Singh Khalsa · 03 Jan 2008
Growing up, I have seen many gursikhs speak to other people who try to push their views on them or talk about topics they don't with to discuss. The gursikhs answer is most often "Sat Bachan". Beyond that they remain silent.
From what I have read on both sides, perhaps Bhai Sahib just said sat bachan and left it at that as he didn't want to discuss a useless topic.
If both sides can agree that he said that, there is no argument. Jatha people will see it for what it is, and those who wish to be delusional can see it as a victory for pro-raag mala.
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Manmat · 03 Jan 2008
bhai khalistan_zindabad dr d
please take a time out on focus on your self, you love talking on forums and arguing
please take a time out, you have upset a lot of people around the uk, because you just enjoy bringing up this nonsense
this our chance to meet the lord of the universe
don't waste it talking about the same old things and getting into heated debates
vjkk vjkf
bhul chuk marf karna
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Khalsaspirit · 03 Jan 2008
Waheguru ji ki khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
Here is what Khalsaspirit.com has to conclude in response to following quote and in the wake of the fake stories about Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh jee by damdamitaksal.net/.com/.org.
"when required and when satguru ji wishes all detailes will be revealed,until then.peace.ps the 2 singhs are still alive"
The above statement by the writer sounds like the "baba" we had in our village who was pretty good at vague answers. He would tell women go eat this and you will have a boy. When a girl was born the 'cheley" stated we think you did not have enough "sharda" go back to the baba ji and take his blessings again.
The Khalsa does not believe in vague/dual promises or Rehit. The SatGuru has already wished the khalsa and Gurbani is clear in what a Sikh should/should not do. To every Guru Ka Sikh who belongs to the Khalsa Panth the Panj Piyare have made clear what is required and what the SatGuru wishes. There will be no other details. In our mind if we can walk on the Path the Panj have told us SachKhand is guaranteed. The problem is we caught in our duality waiting for answers from some where from where they will not come. We have spun stories to prove Raagmala is Gurbani. In the process we are ready to malign GurSikhs who stood steadfast in their Rehit even when the jailer ordered their teeth to be broken when they refused to eat without Sarbloh/Bibek. The same GurSikh spent years behind bars for his country and faith so much without a complaint knowing what he was doing was Guru's Hukam. He did not accept freedom fighters pension or give an application to the Indian Govt. to get back his land which had been taken away by the British. Mr. Kairon had contacted Bhai Sahib for the same and the answer was "If I need anything I will ask my Guru for it not a Chief Minister". The application was filled out WITHOUT Bhai Sahib's signature and the ancestral land was returned.
Bhai Sahib went to a gathering in Patiala where the then maharaja was also present. So were present politicians and other important people. When the maharaja got up to speak people raised their hands and started shouting maharaja "zindabad" at very instance Bhai Sahib got up and said in the Guru's presence he is a false patshah only Guru is Sacha Patshah how can you raise slogans maharaja zindabad. The maharaja left without giving a speech. There are numerous such examples of great soul of panth. It will take a book to put them on paper. Bhai Sahib did what he said, he practiced what he preached and his legacy as a GurSikh carries on. For people to prove raagmala Bani they (we assume) need to prove Bhai Sahib a fraud? The Panth does not think so or else he would not have the honor of being the only GurSikh to have been "Sanmanit" by all the Takhts at the time and be named as "Panth di Sonay di Chirri".
The question of 2 Singh’s being alive does not matter. There are still Sikhs alive who spent that time of their lives with him. They have already written and openly stated raagmala not Bani. Bhai Sahib has written many books and his belief in Rehit is clear. He was not afraid to write what he believed. In the true sense he was a Khalsa; crystal clear inside and out.
Baba Kartar Singh Ji held RainSabai Kirtans at Chownk Mehta. He invited Singhs from the Akhand Kirtani Jatha. Whenever they reached there Baba Ji walked out bare feet to receive them with respect and humility. After the Bhog he would walk bare feet to send them home. Baba Kartar Singh's Singhni (wife) in those days used to wear Keski which after Baba Ji passed away she stopped. This can be verified by people who are ALIVE and went to those samagams at Chownk Mehta. The original GurSikhs from the Taksal should also be able to verify this. Bhai Ram Singh ji is a good example. If Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji was a fraud why so much respect for the people who were his "Sathees" (companions)? Did Baba Kartar Singh Ji not know or.......
We have strong belief and do not think that Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee said something different all his life to his Gurbhais if he knew the truth was something else. However, some people do this and this recent news article below should be of interest to all of us. This is after the fact that Baba Jarnail Singh Ji's Singhni (wife) and son have been honored by Sri Akaal Takht as a wife and son of a great Shaheed in late 90's and they have accepted the same.
Veer Manjot Singh Ji Khalsa:- Your suggestion is good but we disagree. You are suggesting something a person should practice for oneself, but when somebody calls a GurSikh a liar and that for a GurSikh who happens to have passed away we don't think it is such a good idea.
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Did Bhai Sahib admit raag mala was bani??
Aadsach · 04 Jan 2008
Manmat Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> bhai khalistan_zindabad dr d
>
> please take a time out on focus on your self, you
> love talking on forums and arguing
> please take a time out, you have upset a lot of
> people around the uk, because you just enjoy
> bringing up this nonsense
> this our chance to meet the lord of the universe
> don't waste it talking about the same old things
> and getting into heated debates
>
> vjkk vjkf
>
> bhul chuk marf karna
Vjkk Vjkf,
First of all khalistan_zindabad did not start this topic!!
And if it is upsetting alot of ppl then it is upto the admin to close it.
Also, the things you put about "khalistan_zindabad" are not very nice to say in the least, and the same could apply to you because by trying to make one person feel responsible, it is very upsetting.
Generally, and in reply to "Khalsaspirt"s post:
I have utmost deep admiration for Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh ji, but going by your theory are you trying to say Sant Baba Jarnail Singh ji Bhindranwale - Jeene Suthee Qaum Jugaee, Sant Baba Thakur Singh ji, Sant Baba Isher Singh, Sant Baba Nand Singh Jee and countless COUNTLESS others are liars?
And what you have posted are some very inspirational stories of Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh ji life. It is a different issue that the above Brehamgianee's did not write autobiographies about their inexperiencable jeevan's, because their jeevans were so Ucher and Sucher and kept Gupt, something that losers like me can never ever even dream of realising. However, there is still alot of literature that you can find about them, and be inspired! So, regardless of what jathabandi, we should be inspired by the elder's rather then use them to promote your own jathebandi issues.
Anyways, I think every jathebandi has there own website, so everyone can put what they conceive to be correct, so that there would be no topics like this were everyone is just fighting with each other and not doing veechaar with pyaar, everyone can then just decide for themselves because we just dont have the pyaar elders gursikhs had for each other, its all about trying to prove or not prove Raagmale is gurbani, rather than trying to improve our pyaar for each other so there can be more etka in the panth,
If anyone disagrees with one another, the best thing to do is to go do ardass for each other rather than argue and slander each other on a public forum,
pull chuk maarf kaarni,
Vjkk Vjkf