Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

pronounciating bani

pronounciating bani

gurmantar · 06 Jan 2008

VAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA VAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!! We say that our Guroo is poura but if so why do we make s into sh when reading bani. I am not saying it is wrong, but was just wandering why it is done? Some say that if you look at bani it has the letter m but not the word mehala which we say, also that it is to pronounce the words properly, as some of them would not make sense if you said exaclty the way it was written but in my mind this topic is still not clear and at times it helps when things are written down for you to read as you are able to think and consider it properly... Atma Singh Kulbir Singh and others if you could help explain this to me it would be very much appreciated, *Thank you in advance* --VAHEGUROO--

Re: pronounciating bani

Khalsaspirit · 07 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh gurmantar jio, You question is very valid and we think when some one reached to that state when this question comes up means Guru Sahib are doing kirpa to read the gurbani the way Guru Sahib wanted to. As you mentiond "We say that our Guroo is poura but if so why do we make s into sh when reading bani" You will understand easily when to answer this following: [gurbani]ÅÆ[/gurbani] Now could you write in next post how you read it? Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: pronounciating bani

khalistan_zindabaad · 07 Jan 2008

ik oankaaar

Re: pronounciating bani

gurmantar · 08 Jan 2008

ÅÆ i am not sure how to read the above lol.....

Re: pronounciating bani

chatrik · 08 Jan 2008

some even read it as.... IK-E-YongKar. btw...adding SH instead of S is not same at reading the above veer Khalsaspirit jeo. it clearly says SASSA not SHASHA.

Re: pronounciating bani

Khalsaspirit · 08 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka kahlsa Waheguru ji ki fateh gurmantar jio, You probably know but let's go further this word is combination of alpha numeric letters and if we see carefully they are not touching each other (in other words not continuous) so the shudh ucharan will be ਇੱਕ pause ਓਅੰਕਾਰ (Ik Oan(g)kar) Here ura ਓ is open at top so ucharan will be with vertically wide open mouth. But many people pronounce it together or ਏਕਮਕਾਰ etc. Which means if the first word of Gurbani needs so much attention then how ignorantly we can read rest. Now come to s or sh sounds there are many places in Gurbani that sh sound is the proper sound to pronounce sensible (shudh) words. We do not know much about rest of Gurbani but knows about some places in Nitnem Banis. We think following tuk can present here a perfect example because we read this tuk not just once or twice but thrice a day in the Salok (first after Sri Japji Sahib then after 5 bani Then after Rehraas): ਜਿਨੀ ਨਾਮੁ ਧਿਆਇਆ ਗਏ ਮਸਕਤਿ ਘਾਲਿ ॥ ਨਾਨਕ ਤੇ ਮੁਖ ਉਜਲੇ ਕੇਤੀ ਛੁਟੀ ਨਾਲਿ ॥੧॥ Now word ਮਸਕਤਿ if one argues that it should be read as written then the word will be pronounced as ਮਸ ਕਤਿ mus kit which has no meaning. Try your self to pronounce as written will make two words ਮਸ and ਕਤਿ but you will be surprised to know your surat would not pronounce that instead it will pronounce naturally with Adhak on Sasa means you and many others pronounce as ਮਸੱਕਤਿ. Now the naturally added Adhak kept the word intact which sounds good to everyone but then it overrides the argument that bani should be read as written. But now you have to make decision your self that where this Adhak came from? Still with added Adhak it is not pronoucing the word which is meant in the tuk but who have knowledge/abhiyaas of Gurbani knows that it should be pronounced the way this word should be pronounced with bindi under Sasa ਮਸ਼ੱਕਤਿ then the real meaning of word and tuk comes out. So it is very clear that bindi in Gurbani Ucharan plays tremendous role so we should be very careful to the ucharan. Now where this is needed or not or comes out naturally for that information one must have santhya or spend time to learn from Gurmat books. We think Santhya of Nitnem is a good start. If you are not able to arrange that then following is our recommendation: Saral Steek of Nitnem Bani by Bhai Joginder Singh ji Talwara Or Bhai Kulbir Singh Jee is doing exclusive online seva (see the thread "Important Bishrams in Sri Japji Sahib") and if you follow that you will learn a lot. We would like to do benti (request) to bhai sahib that please keep the pace on priorty. Just a note: We have not taken Santhiya our self yet but extremely eager to do so, this is what we learned our own from reading different Gurmat books. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: pronounciating bani

Atma Singh · 08 Jan 2008

vaheguroojeekakhalsa,vaheguroojeekeefateh! veer jee, i must tell u that i'm a 'kindergarten student' when it comes to doing paath; certainly with much less experience than kulbir singh jee. i only repeat what i have been taught by singhs - where they disagree, i come to my own conclusion as to which explanation 'feels correct'. luckily i get to do quite regular sangat with singhs who seem very proficient. as individuals and as jathebandeeaa(n), we must remember we exist in a panth which consists of many different schools of thoughts. some say sabad, others shabad, some say sudh / shudh when it appears in gurbaaNee, others stay silent, some read raagmala, others don't etc. even more interestingly, the jatha's singhs do not do paath the same amongst themselves; this is not a bad thing. the main lesson to learn in all this is that yes - let's have our own opinions but no - never say someone does 'wrong paath'. maharaaj jee alone knows shudh pad-ched, bishraam, ucharan and correct meanings. i personally add bindeeaa(n) in many places. this does not mean our guroo sahib is not poora. look at this: knight/night. the k is silent but by it's presence, it changes the whole meaning of the word. by the same token, many alphabets are pronounced in different ways. organisation in english turns sassa into zazza to get the correct meaning. those who pronounce bindeeaa(n) view the gurmukhee alphabet in the same way. however, if someone pronounces without bindeeaa(n), that is because of their sharda and we should never label their paath as 'ashudh'. are we now siree guroo sahib jee, who alone knows shudh paath? as gurbaaNee teaches, he is never mistaken, we are always liable to be mistaken. "aap aapnee budh hai jethee..." let's leave all judgement about such things to maharaaj jee who alone is capable and simply do veechaar in a humble way to 'arrive at sense within ourselves'. if we decide guroo jee is not poora by this token, then we will next say he is not poora because he depends on humans to read him or because someone has made un-intentional spelling mistakes when writing his saroop etc... ucharan is about personal choices, just as pad-ched, bishraam and meanings are - we should all follow what makes sense to us. also, let's not act like sheep; i think maharaaj jee values us connecting directly with him as opposed to 'going along' with a crowd or group. i think he does more kirpa on us if we beg for gifts such as shudh paath from him as opposed to TOTALLY relying, WITHOUT questioning, on intermediaries such as 'sants, 'bhais' etc. there is a lot to say, more than can ever be said, for love-drenched and heart-felt intentions when it comes to 'having a conversation with maharaaj jee' i.e. japping naam, doing paath. i believe maharaaj jee either ignores, covers-over or eliminates the un-intentional mistakes of his premee gursikhs. as kulbir singh jee explained recently in the jap jee sahib thread, vaheguroo's language is love. love of vaheguroo conquers and subjugates all issues and things in it's wake - including 'shudh' and un-intentionally 'ashudh' paath.

Re: pronounciating bani

Xylitol · 09 Jan 2008

Dhur ki Bani came complete and perfect from Sach Khand. No mere human has the right to change it by adding or removing things. We should endeavour to pronounce it as the Guru has written it out for us. It is like that for a reason. We should keep the Guru's way of thinking above our own on this issue.

Re: pronounciating bani

Atma Singh · 10 Jan 2008

vaheguroojeekakhalsa,vaheguroojeekeefateh! veer/bhain 'xylitol' jee, may i humbly say that people who are pronouncing gurbaaNee with bindeeaa(n) etc. are not 'changing' dhur-kee-baaNee in the way you suggest. they're feeling is that this is the way certain words must be approached and it is an issue of their 'personal sense of common-sense'. by your rationale, we should say 'mama pehila, mama panjvaa(n) etc.' whenever m1 or m5 etc. appear in gurbaaNee. you could argue that this would be silly because they are abbreviations but by your rationale, and the way you have presented it, you seem to suggest we must do this on order to not 'change anything'. you could argue that 'it is like that for a reason' so let's pronounce it that way but you will have a hard time convincing 99.9% of the panth regarding this. although many people may not be aware of this, even singhs linked to taksaal should be pronouncing bindeeaa(n) in many places where they do not physically appear, if they are to go along with the way panth-da-rattan, baba gurbachan singh bhindraa(n)valae, described they should do so in one of his books. i can find the exact reference if need be; a singh i know very well was telling me about this recently.

Re: pronounciating bani

Aparadhee · 10 Jan 2008

[gurbani] jo mwgih Twkur Apuny qy soeI soeI dyvY ][/gurbani] jo maagehi t(h)aakur apunae thae soee soee dhaevai || Whatever I ask for from my Lord and Master, he gives that to me sant gurbachan singh ji used to pronounce maageh as maangeh, is that not adding to gurbani then just like adding a bindi? why is a bindi at the top, meaning to add nunna sound acceptable in maangeh for example? when on another hand we are saying we should never put bindi on charan to change sabad to shabad for example. if we pronounce maageh as maangeh or indeed deeda deh, leeehndeh thak paaheh, surely we are changing gurbani and not reading gurbani how it is written by maharaj. why does taksal accept adding bindi in this case and so strictly rejects placing bindi in charan of akhar. surely the same rule of pronouncing gurbani how its written should apply to all situations? xylitol i am assuming you prescribe to the view of taksal on santhiya. there is nothing wrong with it, like atma singh ji said, there is no right or wrong way. but for reference even sant gurbachan singh used to add stuff to prnunciation. taksalis and people who condemn others who say shasha cannot deny that

Re: pronounciating bani

gurmantar · 10 Jan 2008

It would be appreciated if you could show what Baba Gurbachan Singh says Atma Singh.. Im sorry that this post is causing an argument between the two of you, please remember that the khalsa panth is one family...we are all children of Guroo Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj... However i also have to say that what Atma Singh and Khalsa Spirit are saying is making alot of sense to me... --VAHEGUROO--

Re: pronounciating bani

Khalsaspirit · 10 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Xylitol jio, We respect that you have shown interest in Gurbani Ucharan. Let's see how far you can go when read it with Sharda and understanding. Tonight when you recite Keertan Sohila please pay attention to the last tuks and you will suprised to know how vital the bindeea(n) are. ਅੰਤਰਜਾਮੀ ਪੁਰਖ ਬਿਧਾਤੇ ਸਰਧਾ ਮਨ ਕੀ ਪੂਰੇ ॥ ਨਾਨਕ ਦਾਸੁ ਇਹੈ ਸੁਖੁ ਮਾਗੈ ਮੋ ਕਉ ਕਰਿ ਸੰਤਨ ਕੀ ਧੂਰੇ ॥੪॥੫॥ Word ਸਰਧਾ and ਮਾਗੈ will definately ask your attention and with Guru Sahib's grace we can surely say that you are already placing bindi naturally in one of the word either on top or in bottom but you are doing it. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: pronounciating bani

Xylitol · 10 Jan 2008

Atma Singh ji, could you please find the exact reference?

Re: pronounciating bani

Xylitol · 11 Jan 2008

There is a right way and a wrong way to pronounce bani, that is why the Guru created Gurmukhi, that is why the Guru so strongly emphasised correct pronounciation of bani, and that is why the taksaals of the Giani Sampradha were started by the Guru's order, both what's Baba Deep Singh taksaal and Bhai Mani Singh Taksaal. Note that both taksaals teach the same thing regarding pronounciation. To pronounce differently can change the meaning of the word. It is also disrespectful to the Guru to place our mat above the Guru's and add tipi's and bindi's here and there.

Re: pronounciating bani

Singh. · 11 Jan 2008

I have always wondered how one would pronounce Gurparsad. I personally pronounce it as it is read.But I have heard some Singhs pronounce it with a Bindi under the sassa...making it GurparSHad. What would everyone say to this.

Re: pronounciating bani

gurmantar · 11 Jan 2008

Both schools of thought in this topic, have their own thoughts and will not change on them, lets agree to disagree, like Atma Singh said only Maharaj jee know what is truly shudh bani and no mere human being will be able to tell you thus it is important to follow what you feel inside to be right and that makes sense to you personally. It would still be appreciated if the reference from Baba Gurbachan Singh Jee could be presented as i feel some people do have a greater understanding which is why i initially brought up this topic. We also must consider that the individuals who do have more knowledge but still belong to either school of thought must have followed what felt right to them also, and again like Atma Singh said we can not just follow what 'Sants' tell us without question; Sikhi is very personal and we must go with our hearts just like these 'Sants' did... --VAHEGUROO--

Re: pronouncing bani

Atma Singh · 11 Jan 2008

vaheguroojeekakhalsa,vaheguroojeekeefateh! khalsa jeeo, i'm sorry if it seems that i am encouraging an argument. i will talk to the singh jees that i learn paath with and get exact references; i believe one of them has read the whole pustak. i know that the pustak is ‘gurbaaNee paath darpan’. i have not read it but we have discussed small excerpts amongst ourselves. my only aim in sharing what baba gurbachan singh bhindraa(n)valae has written is to make clear that that those who say ‘paath should always be pronounced exactly as it is written’ should at least be careful as to why they believe this. they should not make ‘assumptions’ which are then used to label others as ‘ashudh paathees’ or as people who are ‘placing their mat above siree guroo sahib jee’s gurmat’. if any taksaal / sampradaya believes that they have 100% correct knowledge re: gurbaaNee ucharan, then that is between them and siree guroo sahib jee. i have no wish to become involved and say ‘they are correct’ or ‘they are incorrect’ – only siree guroo sahib jee is aware regarding the veracity of such statements. i will aim to provide detailed references within a few days. that will be my last post within this thread because it seems the thread is on the verge of turning into a 'my way' or 'no way' thread. when it comes to gurbaaNee ucharan, i do not wish to continuously take part in such a debate because i do not think it helps things; it is for people to do their own research and formulate their own opinions – not to label one another.

Re: pronounciating bani

Aparadhee · 11 Jan 2008

but both taksals add bindis to bani aswel like stated in das's previous post veer ji. the taksals that you mention being created for the very purpose of gurbani uchaaran themselves accept the adding of bindis on top of akhar, therefore "they are changing gurbani" aswel. if they are then who do we turn to? everyones doing it. therefore everyones doing beadbi right even the guru's beloved taksal. thats if we go by your way of thinking veer ji. guroo

Re: pronounciating bani

kulbir singh · 11 Jan 2008

Regarding this subject of Gurbani pronunciation I would like to share the following thoughts with sangat: 1) There are 35 alphabets in Gurmukhi but far more sounds. So, many of the alphabets have more than one sound e.g. jajja and zazza are represented by one alphabet that is called jajja in Punjabi (because they have created another alphabet for zazza by placing bindi under jajja). Same way Khakha for khota and khakha for khargosh are different. In Gurmukhi only one alphabet is used for both of these sounds but in Punjabi we have place bindi under khakha when writing khargosh (rabbit). 2) In the light of point mentioned in point 1 above, I believe it is unfair to read Gurmukhi using the standards and rules of Punjabi. It’s true that in Punjabi jajja means jajja and for the sound of zazza we place bindi under jajja but in Gurmukhi only one alphabet represents both jajja and zazza. The ones who try to read Gurmukhi using the standards of Punjabi do ashudh (wrong) uchaaran (pronunciation) of Gurbani. It is imperative that the correct sound of the alphabet be pronounced at a given place. 3) Now coming to the uchaaran of bindi the nasal sound, it is clear that Guru Sahib did not place bindis for nasal sound since it was so clear. The ones who can read Urdu too notice that the obvious symbols are not placed in writing. If you want to write Dil in Urdu, the correct way to do is to place a zer (the sound of sihaari) after and below daal (the sound of dada) but many times you notice that in newspapers they write just daal and laam (sound of lalla) and if a new person was to pronounce this he would pronounce dal instead of dil because of absence of zer (sihaari). Same way, it seems to me, that at obvious places, nasal sound bindis have been omitted but have been placed at few places as to set precedent for other places. 4) Look at the word [gurbani] puqRI [/gurbani]. This word appears in Ramkali kee Vaar as follows: Putree kaul naa paaliyo, kar peero kann muratiyo|| Now if you don’t pronounce the bihaari of ‘putree’ with nasal sound, the meaning would be clearly daughter but if you place the nasal sound then the meaning is sons (plural of son). This pankiti is referring to sons of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee who did not obey the hukam of Guru Sahib. At another place this word ‘putree’ comes in the meaning of daughter and at that place there should be no nasal sound – Gachho Putree Raaj Kuaar. This pankiti means ‘O Princess daughter leave now’. So we see that not pronouncing the nasal sound can have disastrous affect on the meanings of Gurbani. 5) As Khalsaspirit jee already wrote, if you don’t place adhak where required, the meanings get distorted. The word “Mashakat” must be pronounced with an adhak and only then it would means hard-work, otherwise it would mean the place of falling down. 6) Not only adhaks but sometimes half-words have to be pronounced in some words. Take a look at 6th pauri of Siri Jap jee Sahib. The first pankiti is “Teerath Naava, je Tis Bhaava”. The word ‘naava’ must be pronounced with a half haaha under nanna as suggested by none other than Sant Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwalay. Only then the meaning would be ishnaan or bathing. Please refer to his book Gurbani Paath Darshan published by Giani Mohan Singh. 7) ‘Salok Mahalla 1’. In this heading of Gurbani how do you know that it is Salok Mahalla Pehla and not Salok Mahalla Ik. Why is the numerical ‘ 1 ‘ being pronounced as Pehla but the same numerical when it comes with Ik Oankaar, it is pronounced as ‘ikk’. This proves that you can’t read Gurbani as it is written. If this was the case then you would either have to say “Pehla Oankaar” or say “Salok Mahalla ikk” for the sake of consistency. A Veer has mentioned the uchaaran of “Gur-prasaad”. The sassa in “Prasaad” should not be pronounced as ‘shasha’ of Punjabi language but as sassa. Baaki as Veer Atma Singh mentioned, no one can know the limit of Gurbani. We should just honestly try our best to do the best pronunciation we can do. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: pronounciating bani

Khalsaspirit · 11 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Sorry to say that if this thread is turning to 2 schools of thoughts and if that is the case then one of the school must be wrong because there is no duality in Gurmat. Gurmat starts with ONE and stays with ONE so there is no question about duality (ਦੁਬਿਧਾ) if you are following the path. However, there are some Sikhs like Xylitol ji that are very good at vogue (ਗੋਲ-ਮੋਲ) answers to almost every point in Gurmat. There UNIVERSAL ANSWER is our taksal started by Guru Sahib. Which means the rest of the panth was created by some one else? They never read what they suggest to others for example this following question address to Atma Singh ji by xylitol ji "Atma Singh ji, could you please find the exact reference?" These guys always refer to Gurbani Paath darshan book but we extremely doubt if they ever read it them self otherwise they would not have raised this question. OH school of 2nd thought (duality) jio HAVE YOU EVER READ GURBANI PATH DARSAHN YOURSELF? If your answer is no then Bhai Atma Singh ji you should not spend your precious time to find something to show to blinds. Xylitol jio dare enough to read the book and find answers your self. Best of luck when you argue next time with base less and fact less UNIVERSAL ANSWER. Kirpa Karo ji try to eliminate the habit of living on hear say. Khalsa jio, sorry for our little harsh words. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: pronounciating bani

Xylitol · 11 Jan 2008

I'm not saying there's anything wrong with, for example, adding an adhak where necessary. This is correct santhiya, as I was taught. But My contention is that the Taksaal that Guru Sahib started is the one that teaches correct pronounciation, as it was taught to them by Guru ji. Baba Gurbachan Singh ji himself stated that the taksaal's first mukhi was Baba Deep Singh ji and that its founder is Guru Gobind Singh ji. Deviations from the taksaali santhiya are not necessarily correct just b/c they make sense to people.

Re: pronounciating bani

gsingh · 11 Jan 2008

Xylitol,first you posted santhiya by gyani takhur singh, then you posted santhiya done by bhindri taksal. I dont know if you noticed, but Bhindri Taksal doesn't add any bindis or tippis (contrary to Gurbani Paath Darshan by Sant Gurbachan Singh), and even go to the extent of calling it manmat to add them. Gyani Takhur Singh on the other hand, adds bindis and tippis, and even says paatisaah, as paatiSHaah. Then you wrote: "To pronounce differently can change the meaning of the word. It is also disrespectful to the Guru to place our mat above the Guru's and add tipi's and bindi's here and there." I have no problem with you not putting in any tippis or bindis, I personally am double minded on this topic, but am leaning towards believing that bindis and tippis should not be added. However, please be careful before making such broad statements as the one pasted above. Sant Gurbachan Singh, Sant Kartaar Singh and Sant Jarnail Singh all added in tippis and bindis, and after referring to them as brahmgianis in another thread, you are now accusing them of manmat. Although I don't agree with what seems to me as the over-addition of bindis and tippis, people that add them are doing so based on their understanding of bani. Bani is sargun saroop of akaal purkh, and thus different people will always have different veechar on bani. As Guru Gobind Singh Jee says: ਆਪੁ ਆਪਨੀ ਬੁਧਿ ਹੈ ਜੇਤੀ ॥ ਬਰਨਤ ਭਿੰਨ ਭਿੰਨ ਤੁਹਿ ਤੇਤੀ ॥

Re: pronounciating bani

NiranjanSingh · 11 Jan 2008

Xylitol, Your argument that the Taksaal was started by Guru Sahib and it is following the very same exact pronunciation rules from Guru Sahib, has absolutely no basis. The only people who believe this story are the Taksalis themselves. There is not a single shred of historical proof or evidence to back that claim. This type of claim is no different from the Kookas claiming that Guru Gobind Singh Ji passed on his Guruship to their kooka guru. We all know that in reality the Bhinderan Jatha was started by Giani Sunder Singh Ji of Bhinderkalan, anyone before them were Nirmala oriented. This is historically evidenced. Anyways, there is no sense in arguing about the validity of your claims since they truly are baseless. One thing for sure is that there is no single method followed by the Taksalis for pronunciation. Every other Taksali has his own theory and method of pronunciation. I have heard Gurbani recitation by Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji, Baba Kartar Singh Ji, and modern Taksalis like Thakur Singh, Daljit Singh, and Bhai Jarnail Singh, and their pronunciations contradict each other. I think before the Taksal claims absolute authority over pronunciation rules, it needs to first convince its own members to follow those rules. Please shares with us those rules, once that is done. You know that is never going to happen since no one wants admit their way is wrong.

Re: pronounciating bani

Ghareeb · 12 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Kulbir Singh ji, you have given very pertinent instances where while reciting gurbani one has to keep context of the tuk to pronounce words in such a way that the intended meaning comes forth. The example of word 'Putri' to be pronounced as 'Putreen' in my humble opinion is very appropriate, otherwise it would mean daughter that is not the intended meaning. The problem is that at the time of Guru ji when Gurbani was being written or compiled the 'Bindi' for nasalisation was not known. Only 'tippi' was used mostly with 'mukta' letters or letters carrying aunkar or dulainkre. The 'Bindi' was being used in Gurbani at that time purely where now we have 'kanna'. Mind you in the original Gurmukhi (for verification see Gurmukhi in Goindwal Pothis or ancient manuscripts of Gurbani) there was no 'Kanna'sign. Bindi between letters implied a kanna. The bindis in the modern printed beers were introduced only recently. These too are at haphazard positions. For instance these are sometimes behind a biharee and at other times before biharee. Same is the situation with the 'paireen bindi'. This practice was introduced a little over a century ago to make it possible to write Farsi sounds in Gurmukhi. Thus, Sasse paireen bindi is equivalent to 'Sheen' letter of Farsi. In Punjabi spoken in rural Punjab the sound 'Sh' was never spoken especally in rural Punjab. Thus 'Sher' with sasse pairee bindi was pronounced as 'Chher' with Chhachha that follows 'Chacha' in the thrid line of Gurmukhi painti. This is still the case. The sound 'z' as in Zameen is still pronounced in rural Punjab as 'Jameen' because Punjabi did not have any 'z' sound. It was the elitist urban sikhs in Punjab who added five more letters with 'paireen bindi' to Gurmukhi painty to make forty letters to be able to write Farsi words in Gurmukhi. These never existed in Guru ji's time. Thus in the sabas 'Yak araj guftam...' the word 'araj' in original Farsi is 'araz' but Guru ji wrote it as 'araj' in the absence of any appropriate letter equivalent to 'zey' of Farsi. The intersting example of this absence in Guru Nanak Dev ji's time is the absence of a proper way to deal with the 'z' sound that existed in Iran or Farsi but was not known to Punjabis. Thus for the word in Farsi for paper namely 'Kaghaz' first Guru ji wrote it as 'Kagad' in Japuji, that is 'Kagad kalam na likhanhar' or the word 'Kazi' for the Muslim religious official Guru ji wrote 'Kadi'. For instance, 'Wakhat nw paio kadian'. There is even a town 'Kadian' near Batala which in Farsi must have been 'Kazian'. Again in Asa Di Vaar, we have the tuk 'Kadh Kagal dasai raho'. Here 'l' sound is used in the absence of any appropriate letter in Gurmukhi for 'z' or 'zey' or Farsi. In my humble opinion, pronuciation should not be carried out blindly if it changes the meaning intended. In this respect, the context of a word is extemely important. To think that this would be sacreligious, this in my opinion is not appropriate because in Farsi that was the official language and script of the times of Guruji it was a rule rather than the exception that the meaning of a word is taken from the context. To illustrate this, one can see this practice continuing in Urdu even today that came from Farsi. Thus the word , Is (meaning this) or 'Us' meaning He or That is written in Urdu by just writing 'Alif' followed by 'seen'. Without any context it would be pronounced as 'Us'. But according to the context it is pronounced as appopriate assuming that another sign 'pesh' equivalent to 'aunkar' in Gurmukhi is there even though it is not written when the meaning is to be assumed 'He' or 'That' and another sign 'zer' equivalent to siharee in Gurmukhi is assumed to be there when the meaning is expected to be 'this' as in 'is' of Punjabi. My contention is that Guru ji left it to the reciter of Gurbani to pronounce the word 'Putri' as 'Putreen' to keep the meaning intact because at that time there was no appropriate sign for nasal sound when it accompanied a kanna, siharee, biharee or other vowel sounds. This my two cents. Bhul chuk maaf. Ghareeb

Re: pronounciating bani

Xylitol · 13 Jan 2008

I would like proof of the claimed contradiction in santhiya that some are referring to. Also, I am aware that adhak may not be written in Bani but is meant to be pronounced etc., this is proper santhiya as was taught to Singhs by the Guru. Please read my above post which clarified what i meant.

Re: pronounciating bani

gsingh · 13 Jan 2008

proof of what? that different singhs from taksal pronounce bani differently? Listen to Sant Kartaar Singh's ucharan of anand sahib where they say soup as soump (thereby adding a bindi), or when they say daedaa lae laidai thak paahi as daendaa dae laindae thaak paahi (thereby adding a bindi), or listen to sant gurbachan singhs katha where the person reading bani puts in bindian and tippis as well. In Gyani Takhur Singh santhiya DVD (I've only seen parts of it), he even says in the jap ji sahib part that bindis and tippis need to be added to some parts where arth arent spasht. To anyone that has done santhiya with a taksali ustaad, the differences between gyani takhur singh's santhiya DVD and the recordings by bhindri taksaal are obvious. Furthermore, anyone that has listened to Sant Gurbachan Singh's katha, read Gurbani Paath darshan, listened to sant jarnail singh's katha or has listened to ucharan by Sant Kartaar Singh, should know that the Bhindri Taksaal recordings where they add no bindis or tippis are not in accordance to Taksal's parampara. None of this is to say that Taksali santhiya is wrong...I personally do santhiya with taksaali ustaads and believe that if one is to add bindis or tippis, it should only be done where arth arent clear and the word could mean a number of different things if bindi/tippi isnt added...my only point is that we should be careful before labelling others as wrong or their beliefs as manmat, especially when we are not fully informed, or maybe even completely ignorant of the topic at hand.

Re: pronounciating bani

gsingh · 13 Jan 2008

one more point I would like to make about any aparent contradiction within Taksal... just because some people that have learned from Taksal pronounce bani differently, this should not be taken as any sort of reason to doubt Taksali santhiya or its parampara. If tomorrow someone that has done santhiya at Tapoban starts saying all the lagamataraan, are we going to say that Tapoban santhiya is wrong? It's a foolish way to make an arguement. Listen to ucharan from Sant Gurbachan Singh, Sant Kartaar Singh and Sant Jarnail Singh...it is all very, very similar, and close to being identical. The last point I would like to make is that for some reason every small difference seems to be exxagerated and magnified 1000x on internet message boards. Talk to true abhyaasi Singhs and an issue of adding bindian or not will rarely come up. One time in India I was talking to an abhyaasi singh, someone that I consider to be a true gurmukh about gurbani ucharan. He has also learned from Taksaalis and has spent a considerable about of time learning arth of bani and now spends most of his time either doing bahyaas or prachaar. This Singh believed in saying all lagamatars and not putting in bindian at all. I at the time believed that bindian should be put in at certain spots. After about 10 minutes of us talking about this issue and raising our points about why we believe what we believe, the singh said to me that, its ok that we dont agree on this point, you believe what you believe, and I believe what I believe, but when it all comes down to it, the most important thing is 'Jo Praanee govind dhiaavai. paRRiaa, unpaRRiaa, paramgat paavai'.

Re: pronounciating bani

Khalsaspirit · 13 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, 'Jo Praanee govind dhiaavai. paRRiaa, unpaRRiaa, paramgat paavai'. Here comes the absolute tat Gurmat because we have seen with our experience that there are many Singhs (male & female) who can not read and write Gurmukhi but they remember the nitnem just listening to other Singhs and when accompany them we felt enormous amount of energy coming from them. That was only because they kept the GURMANTAR running in side which needs no Santhya at all after Naam Drirrta. Guru Mehar Karay Sada ve Charkha Shookda chal pavay. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: pronounciating bani

Menu Ke Patha · 13 Jan 2008

vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh.. firstly...and clearly... i dnt assign my self to any jatha..veer above you talk of one..but also remember that there is ONLY one khalsa panth...!!! also a curious question: i no many jatha/taksaal and a few nihang singhs... bt why isit that all the old school of thoughts (nihang, taksali) prounce bani as it is written...but not the new skool of thought..i.e the jatha valleh?...@ the moment im refering to prouncing sihaariaan etc..? any1 care to expliain to this neech papeee? also about the bindi stuff..if you lissen to Bhai Jarnail Singh's (Dam Damee Taksal) Nitnem Baniaan and you listen to Sohila Sahib you will see that in the gurbanee tuk antarjameee purakh vidateyy sardaa man kee pooreh...nanak dass ihhai sukh maa(n)gayy...mo ko kar santan ke dhoore! he prounces maagai.as maangai... just a little side note to bak veer atma singh and others... maaf karo... neech low gareeb papeee.. dass...

Re: pronounciating bani

gurmantar · 14 Jan 2008

How would one pronounce the word hunkaar, as hunkaar or Ahankaar? Atma Singh made the example of knight and discussed silent letters that are there to change the meaning but not be pronounced in the word, is that the case with hunkaar? --VAHEGUROO--

Re: pronounciating bani

NiranjanSingh · 14 Jan 2008

"Menu Ke Patha" stated : >>>>why isit that all the old school of thoughts (nihang, taksali) prounce bani >>>> as it is written...but not the new skool of thought..i.e the jatha valleh?...@ Bhai Sahib/Bhenji, Can you point to an old school that truly reads Gurbani as it is written? One can easily hear the recitation of Gurbani on the web by Baba Gurbachan Singh, Baba Kartar Singh, Baba Nihal Singh Nihang or Tarna Dal, and they also apply bindis and tippis various places. In fact one has to conclude that doing it not a new maryada but a puratan one. Take the word ਗੋਬਿੰਦ (GOBIND) for example, in dozens of places in Guru Granth Sahib Ji it is written as ਗੋਬਿਦ (GOBID) without the tippi; but who pronounces it as "GOBID" without the tippi ? Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji and others clearly explained that the numerics 1,2,3,4,5,9 next to ਮ: are recited as ਮਹਲਾ ਪਹਿਲਾ, ਮਹਲਾ ਦੂਜਾ etc. I believe anyone who makes the claim that they are reading Gurbani exactly as it is written are just fooling themselves and others. Also, I don't think we can state that nihangs and taksals are old schools of thought, since a lot of their maryada was also directly influenced by the Singh Sabha movement. I don't think any Jatha can boast that they had perfect maryada before that prominent movement. I think if Singh Sabha movement had not been around Sikhi would have been swallowed by Sanatanist practices. The proof of that is that Sikhs before that movement had discarded the Anand-Karaj maryada and it was due to the influence of that movement and the original Nirankari movement that the Anand-Karaj maryada was revived back into the Sikh panth. The same can be said for many others practices the Singh Sabha movement brought back into the Sikh panth that had been either manipulated or abandoned after the demise the Sikh Raj in Punjab. Let's keep that in mind before dismissing something as "new".

Re: pronounciating bani

kulbir singh · 14 Jan 2008

------- How would one pronounce the word hunkaar, as hunkaar or Ahankaar? Atma Singh made the example of knight and discussed silent letters that are there to change the meaning but not be pronounced in the word, is that the case with hunkaar? ------- Ahankaar is a Sanskrit/Prakrit word and Hankaar is the Punjabi form of it and these should be pronounced as written. There are no silent alphabets here. Kulbir Singh

Re: pronounciating bani

Khalsaspirit · 14 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Bhai Niranjan Singh jio, We think people who are arguing with base less and fact less point of "Older" should argue with so called parchariks who preach something and practice some thing else and on top of that they charge money for that from innocents. What a blunder practice going on under the name of GURMAT. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: pronounciating bani

Menu Ke Patha · 14 Jan 2008

veer jee.. so much for "khalsasprit" persoally, dass feels u are a narrow minded being... dass is younng nd noes nuffing, but seein ur post etc...wich show such negativity to certain group of people, dass feels he doesnt want to lern anyting more about the jatha..or even sikhee.. dis isnt the sikhee..wich dass has come to love... challo rab rakha.. papee da kee ay..im jus a low papeee..forgive me veer jee.. thanks vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh rab rakha!!

Re: pronounciating bani

gurmantar · 16 Jan 2008

How many different languages are there in Guroo Granth Sahib jee maharaj? If anyone could list them? and also say where abouts in the world they come from it would be appreciated. Kulbir Singh? --VAHEGUROO--

Re: pronounciating bani

Atma Singh · 02 Feb 2008

ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫਤਹ Sadh-Sangat Jeeo, I'd previously mentioned that a gursikh could, if required, lend me a book to show that Panth Rattan, Baba Gurbachan Singh BhinDraa(n)valae, believed that bindeeaa(n) do need to be pronounced in places where they are not normally pargat (visible). I had second thoughts abuot posting the below given the delay but since someone had requested proof (I think veer/bhain 'xylitol'), and I had made a statement, I should back it up. Sorry for the delay - been a bit busy. Here are two examples from Baba Jee's book 'GurbaaNee Paath DarpaN', published via Damdamee Taksaal (Jatha BhinDraa(n)), Mehta. Please note I have not read the whole darpaN - I have been pointed to these sections via notede made by a gursikh. If people need more examples, I can find more using his notes. The first is useful because this panktee is recited by us all before we go to sleep as part of Sohila Sahib: ਨਾਨਕ ਦਾਸੁ ਇਹੈ ਸੁਖੁ ਮਾਗੈ ; ਮੋ-ਕਉ ਕਰਿ ਸੰਤਨ ਕੀ ਧੂਰੇ (Ang 13) This panktee is mentioned on page page 223 of the book and Baba Jee has written regards ucharan: ' ਮਾਂਗੈ ਬੋਲੋ ' (recite/speak maa(n)gae) The second example involves adding two bindeeaa(n) to one word in order to make sense of it, and mentions adding an adhak to a second word in the same panktee, again to make sense of it: ਸਾਈ ਅਲਖੁ ਅਪਾਰੁ ; ਭੋਰੀ ਮਨਿ ਵਸੈ (Ang 397) This panktee is mentioned on page page 330 of the book and Baba Jee has written regards ucharan: ਸਾਂਈਂ ਤੇ ਅਲੱਖ ਬੋਲੋ (recite as saa(n)ee(n) and alaKH). I hope the above helps to clarify the fact that: 1) No-one should ever say that someone else's Paath is ashud because they believe in the concept of adding bindeeaa(n) and/or adhak. To use Taksaal as an example to back-up their point would be false given the above. 2) People should research regarding pronounciation themselves. That is to not say we shouldn't can't 'copy' others to get along. Otherwise, it would take us perhaps 50 years or even more before we plucked-up the courage to do Paath! I pronounce ਸੀਤਲ as ਸ਼ੀਤਲ because a gursikh whom i believe has a lot of gurbaaNee-based knowledge does so. However, it would be very silly of me to tell people that saying ਸੀਤਲ is incorrect just because I do it this way. I have not done sufficient research to start 'preaching' to others.

Re: pronounciating bani

khalistan_zindabaad · 03 Feb 2008

A teacher may teach a student somoething, if the student revises what he is tought then he will get good marks. . .if the student does more the revision and becomes like the teacher then that is maharaj sahib jees kirpa. . the mukhis of taksal more or less all pronounce gurbani the same, there maybe slight differences, students always make mistakes. . .depends on how much bakshish one has and how much abhiyaas they do of the paat, hence i would believe sant gurbachan singh jees etc etc ucharan to be shud. . if you dont, then thats your own issue. Giani thakur singh may pronounce sum paat differently, that upto him, but its not what he was tought, bindra taksal wasnt given jathedari, there ucharan may vary also. . . at the end of the day, do as much paat as possible. . . thats what matters. thank you.

Re: pronounciating bani

gurmantar · 06 Feb 2008

Thank-you Atma Singh for providing that information for us all to take notice of. --VAVEGUROO--