Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Harinder Singh · 12 Jan 2008
Dear veer,
its a tough question. I will answer to the best of my ability. I feel that Angs of Satguru Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is NIRANKAAR. Now one has to become a brahamgyani to understand how this bani is nirankaar, but its nirankaar no doubt.Neither any word can be added nor deleted from this Bani. And its not written by different individuals, this dhur de baani is written by ONLY SATGURU JEE. For example when we say bani of mahalla 2, this does not mean that this bani was written by Bhai Lehnna Jee. This bani was written by SAtguru Jee staying in Mahal(palace) of Bhai Lehna jee making him Guru Angad Dev Jee Maharaj Jee.
NOw bani of DAsam Granth is Gurbani(the enemies of panth dont want sikhs to read Dasam Granth Jee).Gurbani means bani or set of words coming from the mouth of SAtguru Jee. Like there are many words that SAtguru Jee spoke that we find in rehitnamas or Bhai Nand Lal Jee' bani, even those words are gurbani. SAtguru Sri Guru Granth SAhib Jee is not just Gurbani bani but is Nirankaar. I hope I am able to explain my views properly.
Bhull chukk dee maafi bakshanni
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Harinder Singh · 14 Jan 2008
<>
Yes,all gurbani is guru But then the gurmantar or gurshabad or Naam is Guru as well. But ONLY Satguru Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaaj Jee's Laridaar saroop has the JYOT. Thats the key to understand.Dasam bani is Gurbani but only the words of gurbani(in larridar format) in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaaj Jee has the JYOT.
Another thing I will like to say is that all bani belongs to Satguru Jee. So Dasam bani or bhattan de bani or bhagtan de bani all bani came from Satguru Jee.
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Harinder Singh · 16 Jan 2008
<>
Comeon! its not that tough to understand this. SAtguru jee's jyot stayed in 10 human bodies from Guru Nanak Dev Jee Maharaaj to Guru Gobind Singh Jee Maharaj.At present this jyot is in a book(making this book LIVING GURU).Earlier this jyot was in flesh, now its in paper. Gutkas, Dasam Granth shud be given top respect but they dont have the jyot. Dont assume this jyot to be some candle flame,become a brahamgyani and u will get to kow what this jyot is.Its cant be explained via words,language.
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Harinder Singh · 17 Jan 2008
Dear xylitol, I admire and respect your love for Gurbani but unfortunately wont be able to agree with u on the point that all Gurbani has the jyot. Only words of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj Laredar's Saroop has the jyot.But Even for this disagreement, u are still a dear brother of mine.
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Harinder Singh · 18 Jan 2008
Dear Veerji, Satguru jee is sabnan gallan samrath. If Satguru jee wishes, He can give darshan through a gutka. If Satguru jee wishes, He can give Naam withuth the amrit sancahr ceremony.(Bhai Sahib has written in some book that there was a singh in jail who was really desperate to get amrit. Bhai Sahib told him to do ardaas before dunia de malakk, he did that and soon after his naam khanda started running).But these are exceptions and these exceptions shud not be allowed to violate the maryada or sanskaars put into practice by Satguru Jee.
<>
There is a difference. if breaking of words is done by reader. mistake committed by him would be his mistake, but if the saroop has a mistake then it means that Satguru jee is making a mistake which is not possible as
satguru/waheguru is above mistake. "bhullan andarr sab ko abhul gur kartaar."
Breaking words is maha manmatt. It can do anarth of meanings and other than this this breaking of words will have other problems too which some brahamgyani might be knowing, we mortals cant understand this.
Pad chedd sarropps are maha manmatt and people who print such saroops(for maya) dont know that 84 da gerra is extremely painful and they might have to wander through many 84 de gerraas.
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Anonymous User · 26 Jan 2008
Gurfateh
Das is dead busy to carry out checks and editing of one Sikhism related website,which RSS will be launching soon(das will give its details later).So more input could not be given but there is simple reason that why there are three texts?
If we carry out Prakash(bringing Guru to devotees for thier glimpse) and Santokh(let Guru go to rest).
We find that to carry Guru on head needs good lots of labour.
Then if we imagine three times the size of one standard copy of Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
So fact is that in order to let Sangat handle three volumes of Adi Guru Granth Sahib,Shri Dasham Granth Sahib,Shri Sarbloh Granth sahib with ease so three differnt texts were ben made.
Lastly often missionary related to Kala Afghana ask why did not Guru (Dasham Patsah) added at least one verse of him.
Das can prove one verse in Guru Granth Sahib Ji could be from poet Ram.And as per grammer missionary follow but wil not post here.
But there could be one counter question over here that,that verse only could be from Guru and rest is a hoax.
Thinking that das thnks that Guru did not add even a single verse of him in Guru Granth Sahib.
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Harinder Singh · 28 Jan 2008
<>
Veer jeeo
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee used these words. Sometime back there was an article on this very website about it. U could email admin jee to know more about that in detail. Bhai Sahib who was one of the top sikhs ever to visit this very earth used these words.
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Harinder Singh · 28 Jan 2008
Why is Gutka not a saroop of Satguru Jee?
Because it does not contain all the sentences or words of Satguru Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj.Say some jathebandi starts to publish a massive gutka that contains around 1400 angs of Satguru jee but still it will remain a gutka untill all the angs are included.
Now the question is that does the pad chedd include all the sentences or words of Satguru Jee?
Answer is NO?
What is Gurbani? Gurbani is a set or collection of sentences coming from the lotus mouth of Satguru jee. These sentences are further a collection of words.If the words gets changed, sentence gets changed and the new sentence does not belong to Satguru jee.
Lets say there is some place on this earth called morrow.
Now if i speak: I am going to morrow. Thats my sentence.
Now if somebody changes my statement to: I am going tomorrow.
Will this new sentence by my speech. NO.Its not mine. In the same way pad chedd contains many sentences that do not belong to Satguru Jee. Those sentences belong to the printer who did the pad chedd. Now this is maha paap.
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
kulbir singh · 28 Jan 2008
Well said Veer Harinder Singh jeeo. The problem with padd-chhed is that it does not contain all baani because of the way it separates words can be different from the original baani that was revealed to Guru Sahib.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Ranbir Singh · 29 Jan 2008
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Veer Harjinder SIngh Ji you wrote:
"Comeon! its not that tough to understand this. SAtguru jee's jyot stayed in 10 human bodies from Guru Nanak Dev Jee Maharaaj to Guru Gobind Singh Jee Maharaj.At present this jyot is in a book(making this book LIVING GURU).Earlier this jyot was in flesh, now its in paper. Gutkas, Dasam Granth shud be given top respect but they dont have the jyot. Dont assume this jyot to be some candle flame,become a brahamgyani and u will get to kow what this jyot is.Its cant be explained via words,language."
Are you a Brahm Giani?
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Harinder Singh · 29 Jan 2008
<< The problem with padd-chhed is that it does not contain all baani >>
Veerjee,
yes it does not contain all bani, infact it contains the bani of the mortal who did pad-ched. Its maha maha paap. People dont know that Gurbani is a sumandar whose depth can never be measured. This means the words of Gurbani are also sumandar. As our avastha increases, we get to know the deeper meanings of words and sentences.
to alter the words and sentences, well such people deserve serious punishment.
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Marad Khalsa · 14 Feb 2008
yes Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> If Guru Gobind Singh Ji was being humble then what
> does that make the other Gurus?
> If they all had the one Jyot then how come they
> act differntly in this sense...
>
> pardon my ignorance.
Was Guru Arjun Ji Sahib any less "humble" because Guru Ji added His own Gurbani Himself to AAd Granth Ji ???
The Ten Nanaks are ONE JYOT - they all acted as ONE.
Re: Dasam Patshah di Bani....
Harinder Singh · 15 Feb 2008
<>
Thats a great question. I know people might call me ritualistic or crazy or trying to act siyaannaa, etc etc... but I feel paper and ink also matter alongside the larreevaar script. These days we have synthetic paper(which is formed by mixing of 5 tatts by humans and all synthetic things have only harmed the nature and living beings).Same notion stands for ink. Maya not only pollutes the mind(soul) but also the 5 tatts.
So ideally a saroop of Satguru jee shud be prepared by:
1. using puratan natural paper(which will be sucha and maya rahit)
2. using natural ink(which unlike synthetic ink will be suche and maya rahit).
3.Person/s who shud be doing seva of writing shud atleast be jyot vigaassi and shud ideally be Baba Budha Jee(who is sikhi de haddd).
Such a saroop will have maximum tejj of Satguru jee's jyot.
Regarding printing, I am totally against printing.I find it BEADBI. If somebody finds my views completely mad,I dont care 1 bit,lol.