Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

6 kakkars

6 kakkars

hardeep sengh · 14 Jan 2008

if ur undecided have six not five i know they put it up there to please everyone

Re: 6 kakkars

Koi · 14 Jan 2008

Keski is not a Kakkar

Re: 6 kakkars

Singh · 14 Jan 2008

shabash koi. you are going to turn this thread into a heated debate.

Re: 6 kakkars

hardeep sengh · 14 Jan 2008

Keski It took a long and hard think before writing this article because I didn’t want to offend anyone, but then I thought ,why am I scared of what people think, do we want the happiness of the guru or people. thaeree bhagath n shhoddo kiaa ko hasai || I shall not renounce Your devotional worship, O Lord; what does it matter if people laugh at me? So with maharaj's appar kirpa this seva has been passed on. Please read the article with an open mind and please do not attempt to challenge the writer. If any mistakes are made then please forgive me. I have been inspired by reading the book, Keski, not Kes, the kakkar by Bhai Udai Singh, please read the book and make your own decisions. Keski Why are people constantly arguing over this little issue? Whether you believe in keski or kesh as a kakar has no relevance. Either way, every gursikh should have a dastar (keski) on their head. It’s not the hardest thing in the world. Everyone knows that whilst sleeping, if your wearing a small keski then it will inevitably prevent your hair from knotting. Our kakkars are given to us when we take amrit from the Panj Piyare, let’s look at each kakar in more depth. • Kanga – A wooden comb, handmade by man. The kanga takes the knots out of the kesh. • Kara – An Iron Bracelet made of pure Iron, handmade by man and is normally worn on both arms. • Kashera - A white, knee length and sewn in a special way, underwear is handmade by man. It protects the amritthari from having sexual relationship with anyone, expect the partner. • Kirpan – A Iron sword, handmade by man to protect the innocent All kakars mentioned above must be worn at all times, even if the Sikh does not have an arm for example, the karra should always be connected to the body, spiritually by the soul. Kesh or keski Kesh is a beautiful gift which is given to us by God. It begins growing whilst the unborn baby is still in its mother’s womb. Proving that hair (kesh) isn’t man made, it is god made. We have no control over kesh, it is naturally there, it is not in our hukam (will). Keski on the other hand is a small turban which is normally worn under the large Dastar (turban); it is manmade and protects the kesh at all times. How can Guru Gobind Singh ji introduce to us the kesh when it was already there, it was already given to every Human being by god- the gift of god, and would it not make more sense if the Guru had offered us the keksi, like he already has. It kinda makes sense doesn’t it? Kesh If an amritthari sikh who loses all his hair because of a disease such as typhoid, then will that person be classed as a sikh with only 4 k’s, if kesh is considered one of the 5ks? One could say that if one losses there kesh then will that mean that they lose their keski and kanga, meaning they only need to have the kashera and the kara to be a sikh, NO! Let’s take an amritthari gurikh who loses both his arms, will this mean they don’t need to wear a kara. Let’s look at the logic of this, is karra the kakkar of the Sikhs arm, or the Sikh himself? The karra is the kakar of the Sikh remaining alive after the loss of his arms. So arm or no arm, the kakkar must still be carried, no less by the armless sikh, because after all, karra is a kakkar, and at that, of a sikh not of his arms. So the keski and kanga should always stay connected to the body, if for some unfortunate reason the kesh is not blessed then does that mean that the sikh is of only 4 kakars. Even after death, the sikh soul is still alive. The dead Sikh’s living soul must still be accompanied by kakkars, at least during his journey through death, and also during cremation, at which points, alas, the material kakars, perforce, will part company with the spiritual soul. Let’s say kesh is the kakkar, then why is it that removal from the body of the kesh is considered an bujjar krehit (unexcusable), which is not forgiven till, after re- growing kesh, and can only be pardoned by the panj piyare. So why is it that when we take off the kirpan, when going abroad is not a Bujjar krehit, as a little ardaas can be done by the person by himself for forgiveness, Why is there this tremendous distinction between kesh on the one hand and the remaining four Ks on the other? No body can take Amrit without Kirpan, Kashera, Kanga or Kara. This would be unthinkable. Then why is it that if a Sikh was to lose their hair due to a disease that they would still be allowed to take Amrit. Why the sudden difference? Lets say for example say that Kummar (waist) is classed as a kakkar, what lesson will this give us. Or even a kuni (elbow), what teachings will this give us, not to elbow someone perhaps? It does not make sense does it, so when did it make sence to make kesh the kakkar. Anything natural cannot be a kakkar, anything not in mans control, not manmade, not taken on from outside, cannot be a kakkar, nor can kesh be one. Bhai Taru ji, Importance of KESH! Some peoples responses are that kakar by force, accident, disease or authority is not the Sikh’s fault and is therefore pardoned easily and immediately. For example taking off one’s kirpan when flying abroad is ok, and can be easily forgiven, all kakkars are equal never forget. So, Bhai Taru Singh wouldn’t have needed to get his skull removed, because the removal by force of any kakkar (including his kesh kakkar) wouldn’t be his fault, and the pardon for such removal would be easy, by offering an ardaas. Surely Bhai Taru Singh must have sometimes had his kanga fall off whilst asleep and he mush have sought and asked forgivness for the lapse. Likewise if kesh were a kakkar, wouldn’t he have similarly requested and received forgiveness for forcible removal of his kesh, rather than having his skull removed for refusing to have his hair removed? Ask yourself why did bhai sahib resist the removal of his kesh, only to dare to have his skull removed? Because the status of Kesh in sikhism is not that of a kakkar, it is way higher. Kesh has a much higher role in sikhism In short: • Kesh is the distinguishing mark of sikhism • Kesh are god’s abode on the human person • Kesh are so many tongues on the Sikh’s body with which to utter Gods name • And kesh are as important for the Sikhs to adhere to as is the breath for the continuance of life in his or her body. All these comments are backed up by gurbani, such as ‘rom rom har oochreh’, meaning a Sikh utters Gods Name using every hair on his or her body. Kesh is the correct, the exact and the complete, one word description of sikhism. Bibia This is more of a benti to bibia (women), as the maryada of keski for bibia are fading at some places but not all. Bibia have gone from keksi, patka and now choonia in the future it will come to fasion with the hair and then finally cutting of kesh. This to some extent is already happening. There is no such thing as the bibi with no keski does more sukmani sahibs then a keski bibi, it is not about the keski being more spiritual it is more of sikh rehit, and principles which need to be followed. Ask yourself, why aren’t you wearing a keski, is it because of beauty, fashion or is it because your elders tell you it does not need to be included in the kakkars, well ask yourself again, do you want the roop of a Khalsa or do you want to walk around as just another member of the panjabi community? Without the keski, especially the bibia, forego two kakkars, including kanga, because the right place for keeping kanga is the topknot, which is impossible without the keski. It is unthinkable that conditions of Amrit for singhs are different from those of singhnis. For taking proper care of the kesh, if the Guru gave Kangha and keski to singhs, then the same kanga and keski cannot be allowed to remain missing from the heads of singhnis. If a singh cannot go bare headed to the market or to his office, then who gave permission to the singhnis to roam around bareheaded? This needs to be looked in to, think about it yourself! In Maharaja Ranjit Singh’s fort in lahore and in Victoria Museum in Calcutta, the old pictures depicting sacrifices of brave singhnis and singhs show them ALL wearing keski. Very important point, Guru Gobind Singh says, “the khalsa is in my own image and I reside in the khalsa”. But how can those Singhnia even get close to looking anything like Guru Gobind Singh Ji when they reject the truth of keski. Braids, straight or tangled hair-knots and the kesh made into curled hairdos were NEVER and will NEVER be the features of the Gurus very own appearance. If a woman puts on the keski, she has to forsake all the hair-fasions, which is why sikh women want to be excused from the keski, but which is eactly why they shouldn’t be so excused. So it is a benti to bibia to please look into this and realise the mistakes that our elders have made. If the youth don’t do anything about it then future will not be good for the khalsa raj. One last point KESH HAS A HIGHER VALUE AND IT IS BLESSED ONLY BY WAHEGUROO, THE GURUS HAVE GIVEN US THESE KAKARS FOR A REASON. IF WE BEGI TO GO OUR OWN WAYS THEN THIS WILL NOT LEAD TO THE GURUS HAPPINESS. Benti Personally I think other singhs don’t want to admit that their wrong because of hankar and pride, they are not sikh enough to say they are in the wrong and will not change there ways. If so let it be, but this is more of a benti to the younger generation. I have seen in other jathe bibia wearing keskia, which really brings happiness to one’s heart, the guru will do his kirpa and the rehit of keski will again be in every sikh wanting to be amritthari. Please do not challenge this article, it’s own choice, to follow gurus mat or your own. Make your own decisions by reading the book in full, as it is goes into more depth. Keski, Not Kesh, The Kakkar by Professor Uday Singh. People that know me, know that I am not attacking any jatha bandi, so please this is a benti to show your brother love not hatered, as your brother is in love with the panth and not people. Waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

the paradigm shifter · 15 Jan 2008

I always wonder who will provide the kakkaar of kesh when they advertize on posters at amrit sanchaars "all kakkaars will be provided". Pray tell us how do the panj pyare sort out new kesh for those partaking in amrit? Satnam Singh

Re: 6 kakkars

Koi · 15 Jan 2008

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I have no intention of starting any heated debate, and I apologise if you think I do. I only have the intention of attempting to clarify the "6 Kakkar" question post started by hardeep sengh ji. Though I do not agree with hardeep sengh ji's second post (obviously), I commend this brother's humility and respect in their reply. My personal opinion is derived from this shabad in the Dasam Granth: [gurbani] < sRI vwihgurU jI kI Pqih ] sRI muKvwk pwiqswhI 10 ] inswin isKI eIN pMj hriP Asq kwP ] hrigj nw bwsd eIN pMj muAwP ] 1] kVw kwrdo k`C kMGy ibdW ] iblw kys hyc Asq jumly insW ] 2] hrP hkwieq Asq AjI pMj kwP] ibdw nMd bwvr n goXm iKlwP ] 3] hu`kw hjwmq hlwlo hrwm ] bwrIsy ihnw krd rU isXw Pwm ] 4] 1] (AsPokt sÍYXy, sRI dsm gRMQ)[/gurbani] (Apologies, I don't know how to post in Gurmukhi!) Like hardeep sengh ji, I am not associated with or attacking any jatha bandhi, this is my own personal belief. I don't intend on starting any "heated" debate. Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

kulbir singh · 15 Jan 2008

According to famous scholar Dr Pyara Singh Padam This quote by 'koi' jee is not found in older copies of Dasam Granth. Pyara Singh Padam believed in whole of Dasam Granth baani to be Dasmesh baani but regarding this quote he has written that it's not found in older copies of Dasam Granth and that some premi wrote this in the 1800s. Kulbir Singh

Re: 6 kakkars

Bundha · 15 Jan 2008

Koi, please can you give shabad n translation as I do not have correct font (and I am at work!) <<< I always wonder who will provide the kakkaar of kesh when they advertize on posters at amrit sanchaars "all kakkaars will be provided". Pray tell us how do the panj pyare sort out new kesh for those partaking in amrit? >>> You dont think the person who goes to shack amrit should bring anything of his own with him, he should come 'khalli hath'? As long as the person has one hair on his/her body and does not intend to cut it in the future he/she is bringing the first kakkar with them. This is just common sense. You can make whatever arguments you want, convoluted or not, Kesh is first kakkar, period.

Re: 6 kakkars

Pwalla! · 15 Jan 2008

waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh Dear sangat ji, please think about this topic with an open mind and not what babeh and people believe in. Again something to point here people can make mistakes but the guru is perfect, for example every one respected Baba Ranjit Singh and Baba Maan Singh but look at what mistakes they have made. Yet if their mistakes didn’t come out in the open, then we would have still believed that they are some Chardikala 'SANTS', they would have passed away and no one would have known about their actions. Chalo, that’s another topic. Guru Gobind Singh ji was around 9 years of age when Guru Teg Bahadar ji had sacrificed his family, body and wealth for the pandits but mostly for humanity, and service to waheguroo. The Guru attained Shaheedi. The thunder reaped the skies above, lightning hit the airs and the crowd sought shelter. While this was happening a Gursikh named Bhai Jaita Ji ran forward took the gurus head and escaped. Also Lakhi Shah Labana took hold of the body and placed it on his cart, he too had escaped. Bhai Jaita Ji took the Gurus head to Gobind Rai (Guru Gobind Singh ji ), Guru Mahraj asked Bhai Jaita, 'how many devotees of the guru could be seen?'. Bhai Jaita replied that he could not tell who was who, and how many Sikhs were in the crowd. Guru Mahraj at that stage decided to put such a stamp on the Sikhs that even in a million a gursikh can be spotted. Now that’s a very basic introduction of what happened at that time, but let’s look at this in more detail. The Guru was upset that no one came out to say what you guys are doing is wrong. Sikhs hid in the crowed, and watched while there guru was attaining shaheedi. The Guru decided to put such a stamp on the Sikhs appearance that they could be spotted within millions. The Guru introduced Amrit, Kakkars and Banna showing this unique appearance. Now let’s look at the Kakkars that the guru had blessed us with: • Kirpan • Kara • Kashera • Kanga Now, the above mentioned can ALL be worn by male and female. Let’s say Kesh is the 5th kakkar, the male could wear a dastar and he would be fine, but what about the female gursikhs? The guru forgot about them, because they got kesh but even with this, there is not a difference to their appearance. Why did the guru do this? Why is it that the male gursikhs were targeted, to have this change but the bibia can carry on wearing chuniya on their heads and not much of difference to their appearance, why? Even if the male didn’t want to wear a keski, he doesn’t have to because he has got his dhari (beard) to show that he has a different appearance from the rest of the world. Yeh BUT the bibi can’t grow a beard, so what was so different about their appearance. Again why, why did the guru penalise the Male gursikhs? On the other hand let’s say Keski is a kakkar. Now let’s see if this is more practical. Now a bibi or a Singh can’t have the excuse of putting their hair down because the keski is there as a kakkar. It has such a big difference to the bibia and Singh, so beard or no beard both singhs and singhni can be seen as the Gurus Sikhs. Both will have to tie a joora (top nop) on top of their heads with the keski, so no beadbi can be done to the kesh. This shows that the guru did not make a mistake, where as the 1st example it shows weakness in the guru, which we all know is not true. So please it’s a benti lets get rid of this petty debates and agreements, let’s think about it other jatha bandia believe that keski is a must, so what difference does it make if this is a kakkar or not, please explain this? It just doesn’t make sense. Is it because our elders can’t sacrifice their fashion? Or is it because a shaheed singhs singhni or a chardikala gursikhs singhni doesn’t wear one, so that makes it fine because there chardikala, and we can’t question them. Well some of us do, and it’s time we stop idolising people, and look at our gurus teachings and examples. It don’t matter if Bhai Randheer Singh said it was a kakkar, it don’t matter if gursikhs had darshan of the Guru saying that keski needs to be brought back in to the panth, but it does matter when someone makes a mistake and hides it, scared that we will have to put our hands up and say that we were wrong. Guru Rakha. Waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

the paradigm shifter · 15 Jan 2008

You can make whatever arguments you want, convoluted or not, Keski is the kakkar, period. It is also easy for me to write that and expect you to take it for granted. A person takes their head to the Guru who in turn bestows the panj gifts of the kakkars to them. A gift from the Guru cannot be brought from elsewhere. If i can bring kesh , what is stopping me from bringing the rest of the kakkars? To take it further why go to the panj pyare for amrit if the question is only about wearing the kakkars?? I might as well simply buy the kakkars and call myself a sikh of the Guru, why attend the amrit ceremony? I think many of those who say kesh is the kakkar would prefer to have an uncovered head at home (in their own environment) and more so support it because they are lax in implementing the will of our Guru upon our fellow sisters, mothers and daughters. I have no doubt that "bundha" will be wearing a keski. Keski and kesh go hand in hand for all sikhs. satnam singh

Re: 6 kakkars

Singh. · 15 Jan 2008

Thanks for that article Bhai Hardeep Singh. very informative and made alot of sense. Alot of the points I had not thought about previously. Thanks again. :)

Re: 6 kakkars

hardeep sengh · 15 Jan 2008

I THINK EVERYONE HAS FIGURED OUT THAT THE KESKI ARTICLE UNDER MY NAME WAS WRITTEN BT THE MIGHTY PWALLA ਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹੀਹਾ

Re: 6 kakkars

Pwalla! · 15 Jan 2008

hahaha you should have took the credit lol rather then giving me pamp lol Waheguroo All gurus kirpa!

Re: 6 kakkars

Khalsaspirit · 15 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Despite the fact that their strand did not accept KESKI as kakkar but still many Gursikhs of past and present accepted it as a strict Rehat including Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji’s Singhni and Baba Kartar Singh Ji’s Singhni who wore KESKI. Except in Baba Kartar Singh Ji's case his Singhni ji removed after Baba jee left this world. Now KESKI for both male and female is being widely accepted by concerned Gursikhs and we think what ever people officially think that does not matter now because actions are enough to tell the truth. On this point personally we have seen that many Parchariks including Takhat Jathedaars have had their Singhnis wear Keski regardless of thru what Jathaybandi they received the Khanday di pahul SGPC, Taksal, Sikh Missionary, Nihung Dals, 3HO etc. Now many female Amrit ablakhis like to keep this Rehat. We admire this positive approach by many Jathaybandees and the trend is improving day by day, year by year and we are very hope full that by the end of this century whole Panth will accept KESKI as kakkar officially. Now this issue is only a matter of personal relaxation rather than any Jathaybandees however, SAVDAN! (BEAWARE!) There is a splitter group in Panth who has nothing to do just to split the panth on as many as issues they can because they do not like to see the chardi kala of Panth. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

khalistan_zindabaad · 15 Jan 2008

why try to use taksal for your arguments. hey, on one hand you disagree with baba gurbachan singh jee and baba kartaar singh jee, and then say. . .ohhh ahhh there singhnees wore keskis. a bit childish i say.... i like the name pyara singh padam, as there nothing controversial with him is there? lol

Re: 6 kakkars

mpsingh86 · 16 Jan 2008

6th kakar is KamarKasa. If u see the picture of nihangs singhs or our guruji's( Guru Gibind Singh ji) and Mata Gujri Ji, they all are wearing Kamarkasas

Re: 6 kakkars

Harinder Singh · 16 Jan 2008

I believe there are only 5 kakkaars and keski is a kakkaar and not kesh. However if someone is ready to accept the 6 kakaar theory, thats great.And if somebody does not want to accept keski as kakkar but is ready to keep hair covered with dastaar, thats the next best thing to happen. And if some bibi doesnt wear keski but keeps rehit and reads gurbani, she shud also be given respect and love.I have seen some people in akj ridicule or maltreat bibis without keski, I find that terribly wrong and a huge sin.

Re: 6 kakkars

00Singh · 16 Jan 2008

I think this debate is pointless. One should wear a keski/dastaar etc whenever regardless. Kesh is also a necessity so what's the point of arguing?

Re: 6 kakkars

khalistan_zindabaad · 16 Jan 2008

''Or is it because a shaheed singhs singhni or a chardikala gursikhs singhni doesn’t wear one, so that makes it fine because there chardikala, and we can’t question them. Well some of us do, and it’s time we stop idolising people, and look at our gurus teachings and examples''. interesting quote. thank you. . . just thnik what you wrote.

Re: 6 kakkars

khalistan_zindabaad · 16 Jan 2008

''So please it’s a benti lets get rid of this petty debates and agreements, let’s think about it other jatha bandia believe that keski is a must, so what difference does it make if this is a kakkar or not, please explain this? It just doesn’t make sense. Is it because our elders can’t sacrifice their fashion? Or is it because a shaheed singhs singhni or a chardikala gursikhs singhni doesn’t wear one, so that makes it fine because there chardikala, and we can’t question them. Well some of us do, and it’s time we stop idolising people, and look at our gurus teachings and examples. It don’t matter if Bhai Randheer Singh said it was a kakkar, it don’t matter if gursikhs had darshan of the Guru saying that keski needs to be brought back in to the panth, but it does matter when someone makes a mistake and hides it, scared that we will have to put our hands up and say that we were wrong.'' A benti to my fellow brother pwalla, even tho we dont meet or speak much anymore, i still have that same respect and pyaar for you as i always did. even tho we disagree on several points. 1) Who are we to judge the singhnia of shaheed singhs? would you ask the question to bhai sukhdev singh jees singhnee or bhai amrik singh jees singhnee who both dont wear dastaar 2) you are indirectly implying the singhs are kuretieh by not making there singhnees wear dastaar 3) Wear has GURU JEE stated that keski is kakkar? 4) In katha puuran brahm giani mahapurkhs have states kes is kakkar 5) wrt panj pyareh and womens equality issues. . aka men have to wwear dastaar and bibia dont, there is another issue aswell why do panj tell men to take off pajama and not to bibia . . .ohhhhhhhhhhh is that FAIR? lol 6) ALL panthic jathebandia and sampardas state kes is kakkar be they Both Taksals budha dal tarna dal Sursingh valeh aka Baba bidhi chand jees dal from time of guru hargobind sahib jee Hoti Mardan Samparda Nanaksar Rara Sahib harkhovale 5 takht sahibs sgpc missionary (who reject everything BUT still say kes is kakkar) nirmalas etc etc. . . in the above samparadas stc there have been many many many BRAHM GIANIs and puuran gursikhs who reached they highest avastha, they all may have minor differences but all clearly state raagmala is gurbani and KES is kakkar... i would rather believe them then a jatha made up 60-70 yrs ago. i personally do agree that dastaar show be worn by both genders. Thank you

Re: 6 kakkars

Khalsaspirit · 16 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ki khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Zindabad jio, Quote "i personally do agree that dastaar show be worn by both genders" ਬਾਈ ਜੀ ਆਹ ਗੱਲ ਜੇਕਰ ਤੁਸੀ ਮੰਨਦੇ ਫਿਰ ਤਾਂ ਰੋਲਾ ਕੋਈ ਨਹੀ ਰਹਿ ਜਾਦਾਂ ਆਹੀ ਗੱਲ ਤਾਂ ਊੱਪਰ ਸਾਰਿਆਂ ਨੇ ਕਹੀ ਹੈ। ਬਸ ਹੁਣ ਕ੍ਰਿਪਾ ਰੱਖਿਉ ਮੁੱਕਰਿਉ ਨਾ। Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

Aparadhee · 16 Jan 2008

to khalistan zindabad: dont compare dastar to pyjami, they are two completely different things. the dastar is a fundemental part of sikhi and maharaj's roop, it is important to stop beadbi of the kesh, how can a chuni fulfill this role? there are chardki kala bibia out there without keski and big up to them. we should not insult them like harinder singh said. even before taking amrit a person can acheive spiritual experiences and powers, does that mean we dont need to take amrit (if these things were what we desired) this is not a matter of how chardi kala a person is, no matter how chardi kala a person is they are still not higher than maharaj and maharaj's rehit. yes these people can have maharaj's kirpa on them n they are gursikhs, but we should not compromise on rehit for the up and coming generations. bhai sahib randhir singh was brhmgiani and had mahrajs darshan but didnt give up sarbloh, because he had pyaar for maharajs rehit. he could have said forget it i dont need it anymore but he would rather starve than break the rehit. (sorry for bhai shb story you probs think im typical akj who only ever talks about bhai sahib lol but its true you got to admit huna bhai sahib set an example for the whole panth) there is plenty of evidence and logic behind keski being kakkar, the arguement you make is based on soo many chardi kala sants n brahmgianis beleiving kes is kakkar, but thats exactly the kind of mentallity that pwalla is trying to expose in us. its true we believe something because our sants believe it. akj does it aswel sometimes, we might believe something cos bhai randhir singh believed it. you are the same aswel veer ji, if sant gurbachan singh said something you would believe it straight away, as this is a sign of the pyaar you have for him. same with jatha and bhai randhir singh. infact your arguement doesnt hold up in court veer ji cos bhai randhir singh was pooran brahmgiani aswel who had waheguru jis beautifull darshan. not any old random person can attain that. your arguement bout such and such sant said this therefore it must be true is not a strong arguement. veer ji i can play your game aswel, you see bhai rama singh had partak darshan of guru gobind singh ji and maharaj told him to go to an amrit sanchar which gives keski as kakkar. now how do you like that? are you going to question bhai sahib? my point is research things fully, look at the real evidence and logic behind something and then make your mind up on it. dont just believe it cos a sant said so. thats what pwalla is getting at. people are afraid of change, they dont want to admit to things, cos they think "oh if i believe keski to be kakkar then im no longer a taksali or a nihang etc etc and my friends are going to disown me etc etc" same with akj aswel, if it turned out raagmala is gurbani then alot of jatha singhs would stil not admit to it, and vice versa with taksalis. thats the chakkar we are stuck in, we do not have open mind to research and make our own opinions. face it we havent got the guts to go against what our mates think or what our jatha believes. we are all a bunch of baba followers, we have no capacity to think for ourselves. there is evidence for keski being kakkar, rehitnamas, accounts etc. and quite frankly the logic behind it is just blatently looking us in the face but we dont want to aknowledge it. but then agn the future is looking bright as alot of youth are wearing dastar anyway. and yes veer ji you said it yourself you think both bibia and singhs should wear dastar, but the next step would be for jathe like taksal to keep strict maryada and say you can only take amrit if your wearing a dastar, you can believe kes to be kakkar if you want, but to mke it mandatory for every abhlaaki to wear keski would be a real positive step forward and a step which would be applauded by all "akjers". however it will be hard as all people care about these days is how many people took amrit. jathe just think about numbers and they dont want to scare people away by making the rehit tougher. if taksal can get over this issue and implement this then there wont be a problem between the jathas and surely it will lead to maharajs happiness. so khalistan zindabad jio pls go and talk to your elders and suggest this idea, dont be afraid of loosing face, if you think dastar is a must for both singhs n singhnia then pls talk to your jatha and try and make a step in the right direction for a change, chull chuk maaf

Re: 6 kakkars

hardeep sengh · 16 Jan 2008

OK ^^ LETS FOLLOW THE CROWD

Re: 6 kakkars

NiranjanSingh · 17 Jan 2008

khalistan zindabad wrote : >>>>i would rather believe them then a jatha made up 60-70 yrs ago. zindabad ji, here is a quick history lesson for you. It is based on actual referenced history rather than made-up history. None of the groups you listed are very old, except the groups known as Budha Dal and Tarna Dal, and even those are by name only. They have no direct links to the original Budha Dal and Tarna Dal. Linking them to the original Dals is like linking the current day political group Dal Khalsa to Nawab Kapur Singh Ji's 'Dal Khalsa'. Study the state of Nihangs after Ranjit Singh's Raj when so-called Nihangs began to support Sanatan groups including the Mahants and you will understand why there is no linkage. Also, Sursingh valeh are just part of the new Tarna Dal, they have no links to Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji, other than their Jathedar is genetically linked to Bhai Bidhi Chand Ji. Genetic links are no guarantee of maryada, see modern day Bedis and Sodhis for proof of that. As far as the other groups you mentioned the oldest one mentioned might be the Hoti Mardan Dera (founded mid 19th century by Baba Karam Singh) but their current successors are doing very strange practices. Both Taksals (both founded in mid 20th century by Giani Sundar Singh) Nanaksar (founded first part of 20th century by Baba Nand Singh) Rara Sahib (founded mid 20th century by Baba Isher Singh) harkhovale (founded late in 20th century) How can you call them 'old' and the other Jathas 'new' ? In fact almost all of these groups sprouted after the Singh Sabha Lehar. One last point is that Sri Akal Takht Sahib used to require all Bibi to wear a Keski when Amrit Sanchar administered there in the frast part of the 20th century. Gurmukh Singh Musafir is the one who changed that Marayda afterwards.

Re: 6 kakkars

Maha parlo · 17 Jan 2008

Ok here is a very simple question to the only jatha in the panth who doesnt accept kes as a kakkar; According to the views above the keski is to be considered a kakkar. Now if an amrithdhari singh was to NOT wear one of his kakkars or just took it off, e.g. his kirpan then he would be considered a khrethi, a patit. His singhni with whom he lived and had children would also then be considered a kherethi. Both would then be expected to go pesh before the panj pyareh otherwise their bhagti, seva etc would not be parvaan to guru sahib. So according to the keski is a kakkar crew, EVERY SINGLE singh who's singhni didnt wear a keski is a khrethi. Therefore everysingle singh whose singhni didnt wear a keski will definetly have to come back into charasi lakh joona because of his relationship with his wife who was a krethi for not wearing a keski. So lets put this in perspective, of the thousands of singhs whose lives revolved around gurbani and who gave their lives since 1984, MOST of them will have been krethi's and will not have guru sahibs kirpa on them? All because their wives didnt wear a keski. Which if you follow logic means that both were krethi (unless of course they kept no sanjh but lets be realistic here). Wah vei wah, what a panthic stance this is. Even the government of india doesnt disrespect our singhs as much as this! Chalo at least you people will be saved, I guess all the shaheed singhs (including bhai sukhdev singh babbar) will simply have to take janam again as their lives were not pavitar enough). Sharam karo Ps this is logic based on the views above. Personally i love the shaheed singhs and believe as amrithdhari gursikhs their lives were pooran. As their singhnia had their kes, they also had kirpa and remained true children of vaheguru. So please, lets not beat around the bush. You say you want to question the shaheeds and the sants. Well lets hear you say it straight up. That if a singh who is married to a singhni (who doesnt wear a keski) then IF he keeps physical relations with her, this makes him a krethi. I want to hear somebody openly say this please.

Re: 6 kakkars

Manmat · 17 Jan 2008

But still the change of this rule by Musafir caused much damage: As Jathedar Shamsher Singh Ashok, a renowned Sikh historian, has said that wearing “keski” was a precondition even for women before they were baptized. Any woman who was not prepared to wear Keski was not baptized. This practice continued even after the end of the gurdwara movement. A relaxation was made only when Giani Gurmukh Singh Musafir became the Jathedar of Akal Takht.

Re: 6 kakkars

khalistan_zindabaad · 17 Jan 2008

The same mentallity that pwalla is trying to expose exists in all the above posts, bhai sahib (ur baba) said this so it must be right. The whole panth states something totally different, my point you state bhai randheer singh jee was a brahm giani, i state baba nand singh jee, sant isher singh jee rara sahib, sant isher singh jee nanaksar, sant jwala singh jee, sant karam singh jee, sant sunder singh jee, sant gurbachan singh jee. . .etc were brahm, gianis and agreed that kes is kakkar. Taksal started by guru jee, ur rather funny in ur comments. . .ur indirectly calling all the jathedars liars as sant jarnail singh jee etc several times states that taksal is of guru jee, baba deep singh being the first jathedar. anyway. my last post on this topic, so do as you please.

Re: 6 kakkars

Khalsaspirit · 17 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Bhai Niranjan Singh jio, Great lessen of history. Waheguru! learned a lot with this short flash back. Anyway this Zindabadi guy accepted the Dastaar for both Genders. Now if he thinks he is a Singh of Guru then he should stick with his Bachan. Otherwise... BACHAN KAR JO KHISK JAIY SOI NAR KACHA. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

Khalsaspirit · 17 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, We do not understand that reading the straight facts why Maha Parlo now? One should have a gut to digest the truth. Quote "if a singh who is married to a singhni (who doesnt wear a keski) then IF he keeps physical relations with her, this makes him a krethi." This is very straigt forward. IF HE/SHE WAS NOT TOLD THE REHAT OF KESKI BY PANJ PIYARE THEN ITS NOT MAKING HIM/HER TANKHAYIA or Krethi in your words". Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

Pwalla! · 17 Jan 2008

Waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh Bhai jio thank you for your reply it shows you are interested and that’s a big step. You see bhai sahib I dont idolise Bhai Randhir Singh note: respect is a total different wave lenghth. If we had not idolised other gursikhs so much then there might not have been this big issue. Bhai Randhir Singh was a great gursikh, a great brother (this is the reason we call him bhai sahib and not SANT or BRAHMGIYANI) basically, according to his books written by him and not a second person we can see he had met waheguroo. He was one with waheguroo, but yet we don’t call him a SANT or BRAHMGIYANI. Why is that? It’s because we are still brothers doesn’t matter how big the avastha might be, we are still the sons of Guru Gobind Singh. Same with Bhai Sahib Rama Singh, why is it that we don’t call him a Brahmgiyani or a Sant, basically it says in gurbani. Yet he had darshan of Guru Gobind Singh ji, stating that keski should be brought back in to the panth. breham giaanee kee gath breham giaanee jaanai || Only the God-conscious being can know the state of the God-conscious being. Now for the people that call bhai sahib or any other gurmukh a Brahmgiyani, it’s a no go area. Only one bramgiyani knows another, so please benti lets stop being fake brahmgiyanis and let us do our own abhiyaas and get past the basic stages, which is very hard itself. breham giaanee kai gareebee samaahaa || The God-conscious being is steeped in humility. Now Bhai Sahib and other Gurmukhs had so much gareebi, Bhai sahib Randhir Singh didn’t even want to be called baba or SANT. So please let’s not fall in to this situation, as gurmukhs they didn’t want this to happen. No gurmukh, doesn’t matter how high his avastha may be, won’t want to be higher than the sangat (something I see lacking in so called SANTS of today).Have you ever seen a picture where Bhai sahib Randhir Singh is sitting on a chair and the sangat is sitting on the floor. I wonder why? Let’s now go to some points that have been made: 1) Now this is why we don’t get nowhere, it’s because we are so much in to his from our jatha so let’s not take their faults out. Well people believe that I am from the Akhand Keertani Jathat uk, now the points I raise is. Why isn’t Sarbloh rehit mandatory in amrit sanchars, why jatha resnbhis don’t do parkash of Lareedar Guru Granth sahib ji etc. Now does that make me less of a person. Bhai sahib where we are wrong we must put our hands up and say we are wrong! 2) Shaheed Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbars singhni did wear a keski, if other singhni don’t choose to wear a keski then we must question this, because if we don’t then we are not gursikhs. We are fakes, because we are scared of telling the truth. We see the shaheed singhs singhnia as role models of the panth, if we see a dhil in a gurmukh then we get disheartened. 3) Now people here can argue that a bibi with no keski can have a way bigger avastha then one with a keski, now this is true in many cases, BUT it’s the principle, it’s the discipline that we need to take in to account. Rehit Piyari mujh ko, Sikh Piyare Nahi. What do we learn from this! Tomorrow we will start saying that we don’t need to wake up at 2am in the morning, because I can wake up at 10 in the afternoon and jaap way more naam and do way more gurbani abhiyaas. Principle my friend, it keeps us disciplined. 4) Now please can someone tell me because I seem to be confused, where does in Guru Granth sahib ji mahraj does it state that, Kesh is a kakkar, Kirpan is a Kakkar, Kashera is a kakkar etc. If someone can then I’ll believe that keski is not a kakkar. BUT mahraj does say: mai gur mil ouch dhumaalarraa || I met with the Guru, and I have tied a tall, plumed turban. dhue dhhothee basathr kapaatta(n) || upon your head is a turban, and you wear two loin cloths. khoob thaeree pagaree meet(h)ae thaerae bol || How handsome is your turban! And how sweet is your speech. naapaak paak kar hadhoor hadheesaa saabath soorath dhasathaar siraa ||12|| Purify what is impure, and let the Lord's Presence be your religious tradition. Let your total awareness be the turban on your head. ||12|| fareedhaa mai bholaavaa pag dhaa math mailee hoe jaae || Fareed, I was worried that my turban might become dirty. So please do your own research on what you think the guru has told us. Note: Singhs and Singhni, gurbani is for all gursikhs not just males. Look at what the guru teaches us not what a gurmukh states in his katha, it’s his katha, his own knowledge. Only Gurbani is the true katha, it’s straight from what the gurus has to say. No third person, when a person does katha he is coming in the way, listen to true katha in gurbani (keertan) and then you will get a direct meaning through avastha and not from what a person thinks what it means. Example, we see Bhai Maskeen ji as a great katha vajik, he has done too much research in to gurbani. Even he said that he don’t agree with some of the gurbani translation he did years ago on Jap Ji sahib. He said the further we get in our abhiyaas the more understanding we get from gurbani. The true katha is keertan, naam the veechara you do with guru sahib. Look some gursikhs here want to prove a point, to show others (friends mainly) that we stand for this believe so that means I’m in this jathabandi, I used to do the same. I to would debate with others so that others can see that I’m with them and in there jatha. In this we will not get far in our sikhi, what we need to do is go forward, if we don’t agree with something then we must bring it forward. Example, once a Singh was speaking to a bunch of us, he said that he believes that this gurbani thuk should be said this way, but he won’t because he learned from his jathabandi that it should be said another way. He said that he won’t change it because others from his jatha will think that he is making a new jathabandhi. Think about it. Thank you Benti- This is gurmat veechar we should not get angry at each other, love my brothers - this is the way we will learn and go forward. Waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

baba amarjeet singh · 17 Jan 2008

khalistan zindabad, how can you accuse akj of blindly following bhai sahib randhir singh, when NEARLY ALL OF YOUR OPINIONS, are base on "sant baba ...... said this" maha parlo, if being married to someone without 5 kakkars and having relationships with them makes you a kurehiti, and if being a kurehiti means that you have to come back, then logically, (according to you) anyone singh married to any bibi that didnt wear all 5 k's will have to come back. youve answered your own question. although in my opinion i dont think these singhs will have to come back, as you said they did a lot of gurbani and naam abyaas and kept strict rehit, it was due to their karma that they did not know the correct kakaars. i think maharaaj would do kirpa on them. btw sukhdev singhs singhni DID wear a dastaar

Re: 6 kakkars

Ekta Singh · 17 Jan 2008

Both Taksals (both founded in mid 20th century by Giani Sundar Singh) Can you prove this, because a lot of singhs say that taksal was started by guru gobind singh jee or Baba Deep Singh. This is just a educational question and truth is truth! I dont want to start any arguements!!

Re: 6 kakkars

raj karega khalsa · 17 Jan 2008

I just wanted to point out that AKJ is NOT -yes i said NOT- the only Jathhaa that believes in Keski as a Kakaar. There are MANY more. Just because they are not that well known, does not mean that they don't exist.

Re: 6 kakkars

csingh · 17 Jan 2008

khalistan zindabad - if a singh went to a taksal amrit sanchaar with no dastaar and just open kesh, would taksal give him amrit, or would they tell him to go and cover his head before he comes back for Amrit? Why are women allowed to take amrit with just a chuni and not men? If you are against keskhi, then you should allow men to take amrit with a chuni ?

Re: 6 kakkars

Xylitol · 18 Jan 2008

Baba Gurbachan Singh ji Bhindrenvale stated that Sant Sunder Singh ji's teacher was Baba Bishen Singh ji Muralewale, exactly as the DDT claims. Baba Gurbachan Singh was student of Sant Sunder Singh, so there is no way he can be mistaken about this. The only other alternative is for the nindaks to call him a liar. most nindaks choose to not say this outright as it makes them look bad, so they use a roundabout technique and say that he was mistaken. But how can the very student of BAba Sunder Singh be mistaken about who Baba Sunder Singh's teacher was? he can't. Also, Bhai Daya Singh Samprada has an unbroken lineage as well going back to Bhai Daya Singh ji. I've noticed that nobody tries to challenge that b/c they cannot. Sants of both lineage recognise each other and both sampradas (giani samprada which includes Bhai Mani Singh taksaal and DDT) as well as Bhai Daya Singh samprada have the same basic teachings about sikhi. It's not a simple matter of ''believing in'' what a sant says - Raagmala as bani and Kes as kakkar and other teachings are the true teachings of sikhi as passed down through distinct lineages which go back to the Guru's time.

Re: 6 kakkars

Pwalla! · 18 Jan 2008

waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh Maha Parlo ji, firstly please talk with respect to other singhs. Anyway, I don’t know where your post is going, but it’s very simple. It’s about intention, and knowledge. Now if the Singhs Panj Piyare say Kesh is a kakkar, then obviously the devotee is going to believe that. Bhai sahib I don’t think you know what Krehit means and that is why you wrote such a post, about the shaheed singhs, no worries everyone is learning. A krehti is someone that receives amrit and goes against the word of the panj piyare, in this case. So please explain to me why those singhs are krehitis if they did not have the knowledge of Keski as being the kakkar. Nor is it our Gurus fault, because our guru gave us this beautiful kakkar, but it is our ManMat ways that think that we know more than the guru. Maha Parlo. No one is saying anyone is Kurehiti. You yourself are justifying this through your posts. So it’s you who should actually think about what you write, and not the Keski is a kakkar crew, I like the name tho! I know this is going a bit of topic but it’s a question that I’m not too sure about, and need some knowledge on. Why did Bhai Attur Singh Mustanna and gursikhs like Bhai Delal Singh not wear a kirpan? Thank you Waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

NiranjanSingh · 18 Jan 2008

Xylitol Ji, Your points are very off topic, but since you posted them, they require a response. Please read Sikh history. Bhai Sant Singh (who the Taksal claims to be one their Jathedars), and his student Kavi Santokh Singh, and his student Giani Gian Singh, and Baba Bishan Singh Muralewale were all Nirmalas. This is 100% true according to history. Nirmala heads are often called Mahants. Baba Bishan Singh was also called Mahant Bishan Singh. Read 'Amrit Jiwan' Giani Sunder Singh Bhinderanwale and you will learn a lot about what I am talking about. Go ask the very family of Baba Bishan Singh their grandfather was a Nirmala or the Jathedar of the Taksal and then you will realize what the truth is. Also remember Bhai Sant Singh passed on his teachings to Bhai Santokh Singh who then authored Suraj Parkash, in which he clearly wrote that Ragmala was not Bani. The same is for the next student Nirmala Giani Gian Singh who also stated that Ragmala was not Bani. I believe both Granths are used in the Taksal for Katha and parchar purposes. Regarding the Bhai Daya Singh 'Samparda', that is another joke. Again, no historic proof of that at all. Why would Bhai Daya Singh Ji start his own shareekponna ? Did the other four other Piyarays do the same ? Give it some time I am sure their 'Sampardas' will pop-up to. I believe the rapist Mann Singh Pehowa claims to be the current Jathedar of Bhai Daya Singh 'Samparda.' Please give us a break Singho. This seena-baseeena Brahmgiani stuff is becoming a joke. Is Dhumma the current day Brahmgiani in this seena-baseeena lieange ? As far as calling Baba Gurbachan Singh a liar, I don't think anyone is doing that except the Kala-Afghan crowd. I would say he was mis-informed like he was of several things he published in his books that have become the target of Kala-Afghanis and Ghagga supporters. Yes, anyone can be mis-informed, only our Guru Sahib can not - He is Perfect. Everyone else can have faults.

Re: 6 kakkars

Maha parlo · 18 Jan 2008

You guys make me laugh. Everything is twisted and you dont actually say what you truely want to in your hearts do you? Look its very simple, the whole keski kakkar debate has been on for years, most of the singhs would have known that there was some issue over the keski. And yet many would have continued to hold the belief that kes was the kakkar. So its not a lack of knowledge, its having the correct knowledge that kes is the kakkar. and pwala, if i follow your last post that a krthei is one that goes against the word of the panj pyareh, well seeing as the rest of the panth's panj pyareh give kesh as a kakkar, any of these amrithdharis who then goes on to declare that kes isnt a kakkar but instead a keski is, is going directly against what his panj pyareh have told him/her. This would hence make them a krethi according to you yes? So in one way i could see your attempts as trying to make krethis of the rest of us who hold and believe kesh to be a kakkar, you wish for us to go agaisnt what our panj pyareh have told us? How wonderfully panthic and loving of you. And im sorry but you cant say one thing and then try and sidestep it. Either keski is a kakkar or it isnt. Everyone keeps saying how rehat is most important to the guru, well then how can a singh say that he didnt know what the correct kakkars are? If a singh can take amrit and he and his singhni can pratice sikhi without having keski as a kakkar and can still get to vaheguru then what is all your fuss about? Either he can, or he cant. You said we should question the actions of the shaheed singhs (how very humble of you to question them) chal lets question them then. If a shaheed singh firmly beleives that kes is his kakkar and his singhni does also, and they have a family together and do not beleive in keski as a kakkar, are they not following the rehat of guru sahib and as such, will they be destined to come back to joona? Let me hear you condemn thousands of wonderful gursikhs all because they didnt believe that a keski was a kakkar. Let me hear you say that because their wives also didnt believe in the keski as a kakkar that they were also not following guru sahibs rehat. Once you've done all that, then tell me what yo have done for the panth and how much of your blood you have sacrificed, that you can stand here and say that those who dont accept keski as a kakkar are hunkari and too egotistic to accept thay they are wrong. Those that died hanging fighting beneath the nishaan sahibs in front of akal takhat were too hunkari or didnt have kirpa to know the correct kakkars. But you do. Chal very good, bit of advice, first do something to match the kurbania of those who you wish to question, and then ask questions. Best of luck. ps Thank you khalsa spirit, so for the rest of the panth who listens and accepts their panj pyareh's bachan that kes it be considered as a kakkar, i would humbly request that the keski is a kakkar parchar be kept within the people who have taken amrit from the panj who say this. As if i came to you and tried to convince you that it was a kamarkasa and not a kirpan that was a kakkar, people would say that i was trying to break you from your rehat. So please respect the rehat followed by others. best of luck again

Re: 6 kakkars

Khalsaspirit · 18 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ki Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Hanji Maha Parlo ji "As if i came to you and tried to convince you that it was a kamarkasa and not a kirpan that was a kakkar, people would say that i was trying to break you from your rehat" First of all maha parlo can do whatever she wants because when its time of parlo anything is possible. So yeah if you feel kamarkasa is KakKar than Kirpan so, be it because there are many other groups who do not think Kirpan is Kakkar and they do not wear it. "So please respect the rehat followed by others". Yes, thats what we were saying Keski is Kakkar so do not disrespect it. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

the paradigm shifter · 18 Jan 2008

Dearest brother Maha parlo, I am glad some people make you laugh and not cry.....but here are some things you say but don't really understand what you say: >, well seeing as the rest of the > panth's panj pyareh give kesh as a kakkar, any of > these amrithdharis who then goes on to declare > that kes isnt a kakkar but instead a keski is, is > going directly against what his panj pyareh have > told him/her. did you just say "give kesh as kakkar"?? please tell us how that is possible?? But ofcourse you are going to say its what they "say" and not what they "give". Its not just about semantics but totally understanding what is given as a gift by the Guru and what the Guru says we can do or refrain from doing. > This would hence make them a krethi > according to you yes? So in one way i could see > your attempts as trying to make krethis of the > rest of us who hold and believe kesh to be a > kakkar, you wish for us to go agaisnt what our > panj pyareh have told us? How wonderfully panthic > and loving of you. Being misinformed does not make one a kurethi, but accepting anything without proper research encourages dhil in ourselves. Perhaps it is panthic and truly loving to ask you to question your panj pyareh on this issue. If the Panj Pyareh are rehitwale kamaai wale gursikhs this should be no problem. If they simply commit you without explaining why then i'm afraid you are getting a raw deal. > And im sorry but you cant say one thing and then > try and sidestep it. Either keski is a kakkar or > it isnt. Everyone keeps saying how rehat is most > important to the guru, well then how can a singh > say that he didnt know what the correct kakkars > are? If a singh can take amrit and he and his > singhni can pratice sikhi without having keski as > a kakkar and can still get to vaheguru then what > is all your fuss about? Either he can, or he cant. By the Kirpa of Guruji anyone can have darshan of Waheguruji however it is impossible to practise sikhi without accepting keski as a kakkar as you will only be fooling yourself. If you accept that Guruji is beant then any dhil can be forgiven. Remember one does not do these things to please Waheguru because Waheguru has NO NEEDS, waheguru is self sufficient!! We only wear the kakkars as they are special gifts from the Guru. Wearing the kakkars alone is no guarantee of getting to waheguru. In fact why are we trying so hard to get to Waheguru like He/She is some place else?? when in fact Waheguru is right here beside/within you and I and the shaheed singhs!!! > You said we should question the actions of the > shaheed singhs (how very humble of you to question > them) chal lets question them then. If a shaheed > singh firmly beleives that kes is his kakkar and > his singhni does also, and they have a family > together and do not beleive in keski as a kakkar, > are they not following the rehat of guru sahib and > as such, will they be destined to come back to > joona? Let me hear you condemn thousands of > wonderful gursikhs all because they didnt believe > that a keski was a kakkar. Let me hear you say > that because their wives also didnt believe in the > keski as a kakkar that they were also not > following guru sahibs rehat. There are some souls that only come to this world to carry out acts in the propagation of righteousness. Worldliness is something they have to live within but are not part of it. And these souls choose to come over and over again to show us weak minded people a clear path in achieving Oneness with Waheguruji. One can only have a longing for Waheguru when one is apparently detatched from Waheguru hence the shaheed singhs visits to this earth. And yes anyone not wearing a keski is not following the Guru's rehat. It's a different thing if they believe its a kakkar or not. Kesh and keski go hand in hand always. > > Once you've done all that, then tell me what yo > have done for the panth and how much of your blood > you have sacrificed, that you can stand here and > say that those who dont accept keski as a kakkar > are hunkari and too egotistic to accept thay they > are wrong. One does not have to spill blood to speak the truth, the very fact that Pwalla speaks the truth ( very aptly and without harsh words) means he understands it from another perspective. Your truth is seen through your perspective. Ours is just an invitation to change your perspective, hence a paradigm shift. > Chal very good, bit of advice, first do something > to match the kurbania of those who you wish to > question, and then ask questions. Once again, with all due respect to the huge kurbania the singhs/singhnia in the panth have given it may not necessarily be their fault at not being told about the issue of keski as kakkar. We do not question them or their wisdom but bow down to the sacrifices they gave. At the same time we pray that those with an abundance of knowledge in this day and age similar to you will simply not just take for granted what they are told but dig deep within themselves to find the correct answers. If you look hard enough you will find. > i would humbly request that the keski is a kakkar > parchar be kept within the people who have taken > amrit from the panj who say this. So please respect the rehat > followed by others. Again i am afraid it will be impossible to pigeon hole certain people simply because you do not agree with them. Many have found that it is always very hard to hide the truth and when it emerges it sometimes hurts. Don't hurt, accept others see it differently. > best of luck again bhul chuk maaf. Satnam Singh. ps. Pwalla, see you at the rhensabhai this weekend!!!

Re: 6 kakkars

Pwalla! · 18 Jan 2008

Sorry Maha Palo, didnt get one bit of what you said. Can you please make it more clear! Thank you Sorry for that! Waheguroo jika khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

Khalsaspirit · 18 Jan 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Xylitol jio, "Also, Bhai Daya Singh Samprada has an unbroken lineage as well going back to Bhai Daya Singh ji." For the sake of Sikh history would you please tell us or let us know the brief history of all 1699 PANJ PIYAREs so that we can decipher the junk you brought up here. Thank you in advance. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: 6 kakkars

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 18 Jan 2008

Xylitol Jeeo, Weren't these Brahmgyani lineages also very firm in their beleif of rattan mala as they came straight from guru sahib and therefore they are correct? Where is this strict stance on rattan mala being bani now? Why are you arguing over things people still beleive in, why not revive this beleif as that seems more pressing? On other issues, I have heard many times that the Singhs that give amrit at Akal Takht sahib do not beleive in eating meat but only say its ok when they give amrit at akal takht sahib. They admit that when they took amrit they were told not to eat meat period. So are they kuraitees along with everyone who took amrit there? How about the first panj at akal takht sahib that said it was ok to take amrit without keski, or the first panj in taksal that said that? What about them? Nearly everyone admits it was a requirement before musafir, so does that mean the entire lineage of amritdharis from then on is tainted??? :O:O Come on! Be realistic singho, people can learn and admit their galtees and then move on!! I admit that at one time I hated sarblohees and bibekis. I was stupid then. Now I know better. Learn to change and grow and open up!