Re: yugas and raam
Harinder Singh · 10 Mar 2008
If vishnu and raam are vaheguru, then I am vaheguru and u are vaheguru, basically everything is vaheguru, even maya which is sitting at the feet of vaheguru is vaheguru roop. I hope u are understanding what my aatma(not my brain) is trying to say, haha.
But reality is that vajood/existence of Vaheguru jee is different from existence of any other entity.(aapenai aap sajeeo). Vaheguru created Himself.(aapenai rachiyoo nauuu). Than He created His Name. And it was after this that He created nature, 5 tatt, brahma, vishnu etc.. etc..(endless).
<>
Raam vishnu, brahama are not Vaheguru, they were created by Vaheguru(thats what I have tried to explain above)
Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Jee's bani is TRUTH, its not against/with anybody. Brahma/ vishnu etc get defeated by Maya. Even Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaaj Jee tells us in Bani Sri Sukhmani Sahib Jee(brahamgyani ko khojhe mahesur). It means that Shiv is trying to find a Brahamgyani.
Satguru jee has used the word insect for Krishan and Raam in Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Jee. Krishan and Raam were given lots of powers by Vaheguru Jee but they misused them, made mistakes and as a result got defeated by Sri Kaal Jee.
WHAT A PLAY!
Tudh jevadd tun hain parbrahm Nanak sarnayee ||
HAR JAISA PURAKH NA LABYEE
Re: yugas and raam
kulbir singh · 10 Mar 2008
-----------
first question is do yugas actually mean that humans have been one erarth for billions of yrs, and in reality were ntot evolving and the stuff in hindu history actually happened?
-------------
Yes, humans have been here for long time. I am not sure what Hindu history in particular you are referring to but stuff that’s mentioned in Gurbani happened for sure.
----------
and were raam, vishnu actually vaheguru as well, and then y wud dasam granth banee be so agasint worshipping raam
is it because of nirgun and sargun
and was raam same as guru nanak dev je
--------
The Gurmat stand, as per my understanding ,is that Vishnu, Brahma, Shiva, Indra etc do exist but have been created by Vaheguru. They have powers and responsibilities that they carry out. A Gursikh acknowledges the existence of these Devtas but does not worship them as per hukam of Guru Sahib. A Sikh worship only Vaheguru through the Shabad of Satguru.
Kulbir Singh
Re: yugas and raam
Anonymous User · 10 Mar 2008
"he Gurmat stand, as per my understanding ,is that Vishnu, Brahma, Shiva, Indra etc do exist but have been created by Vaheguru. They have powers and responsibilities that they carry out. A Gursikh acknowledges the existence of these Devtas but does not worship them as per hukam of Guru Sahib. A Sikh worship only Vaheguru through the Shabad of Satguru."
Well said Kulbir Singh Jee. But you stand, which is self contained, is totally different from the one taken by Atma singh where he is more interested in denigrating Hindu Gods rather than worshiping Waheguru. Had he not found those superficial abrahamic similarities in Sri gurugranth he would have rejected Sikhi iself and probably would have converted to one of those binary cults of middle east.