Pothi Kirtan = Beadbi
Balpreet Singh · 28 Mar 2008
I have been thinking about this post for some time but feel it's necessary. My intention isn't to insult anyone or hurt anyone's feelings but just ask that you think about the issue.
When we place a pothi on the vaja and do kirtan, we are doing a serious beadbi of the pothi.
First, sujaan Gursikhs know that when reading Gurbani outloud either for example at Sri Akhand Paath Sahib, it is important to cover the mouth to ensure that spit does not fall on Gurbani. But during keertan, covering the mouth is impossible and the chances of spitting are much higher. We are doing the massive beadbi of spitting on the pothi.
The second is that the vaja moves about and the Pothi resting on the vaja is also shaken about and has often been seen to fall. This is not the proper place to put a Pothi. The other problem is also that the angs of the Pothi are not stable and so some veers and bhains go further by putting pens, glasses cases and other objects on top of the pothi.
A third issue is that vaja/jori are not "suchaa" items. They are not clean. When we handle a pothi, we wash our hands for respect. But when the pothi is on the vaja, we are using our unwashed hands to turn angs or hold it in place.
Bhai Sahib Atma Singh (Panjokhara Sahib) a very close companion of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, was a very strong opponent of pothi-kirtan.
Beyond the respect of the Pothi issue, kanthagar (memorized) kirtan is the real maryada. The time a Singh/Kaur takes to memorize and reflect on the shabad is reflected in how that shabad is sung and the impact it has on the sangat.
If kanthagar kirtan is not possible for some reason, then at the very least, please do parkash of the Pothi on the side of the vaja where respect and maryada can be maintained.
Although Gursikhs do kirtan to earn the blessings and khushi of Guru Sahib, by placing Gurbani pothi on the vaja, we are putting ourselves in the position of in fact being guilty of doing beadbi of Gurbani.
Once again, my intention is not to insult anyone only to encourage veers and bhain jees to reflect on the issue.
Re: Pothi Kirtan = Beadbi
kulbir singh · 28 Mar 2008
Balpreet Singh has raised very important point about pothi satkaar. With the exception of Akhand Kirtani Jatha, all Raagis and kirtaniyas in Panth do kanth kirtan i.e. kirtan from memory. I have never seen Srinagar walay or other Panthic kirtaniyaas doing kirtan by placing pothi on the vaaja. Why should Jatha have to do so?
A kirtaniya can concentrate on the shabad better if he or she has the shabad memorized. If the kirtaniya is going to be worried about looking up each pankiti from the pothi placed on the vaaja, how is he or she going to concentrate.
Veer ‘hsingh’ jeeo, the issue of Gurbani Satkaar is not a trivial, petty or pointless issue. The Satkaar of Gurbani is an important issue for Gursikhs and even if the kirtaniya does not feel that placing pothi on vaaja and unwittingly spiting on it brings dishonour and disrespect to the Gurbani pothi, still he or she should consider the feelings of Gursikhs sitting in darbar. Gursikhs are pained to see the rough handling of pothi by kirtaniyas. No one washes their hands before handling the pothi. After playing vaaja or tabla, how can they start handling pothi, without washing hands?
The best thing, as Balpreet Singh pointed out is to do kanth kirtan. Bhai Sahib Atma Singh jee Panjokhra Sahib waalay spent the last two decades trying to get the pothi away from Vaaja but alas, Jatha did not listen to him. Many other Gursikhs voiced their concerns but no one listened. Guru Sahib bhali karan.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Pothi Kirtan = Beadbi
khalistan_zindabaad · 01 Apr 2008
I remember Shaheed bhai amrik singh jees singhnee telling us that she had to learn about 100 shabads off by hart b4 sant kartaar singh ji allowed her to do kirtan. . .taksal maryada is of kanth bani also. . .an excellent point raised
Re: Pothi Kirtan = Beadbi
Harinder Singh · 03 Apr 2008
<< I think Quoting refrences of Gurbani into some "website" is as same as writing on a page . u may not know where the "server" is located?? the harddisk where the quoted sentence is going may be made up of plastic in china and may be placed at a location where some adjacent drive or address location contain some pronographic or vikaar content.
Also whn we write our comments on internet the cable used for transmitting the information is "same" tht contain pronography, drugs/ and many more information may travel simultaneously. THIS WAY THIS IS ALSO A BIG BEADBI >>>>>
Isnt all this data digitally encoded(bits, 10101100.....). Its only some displaly device like monitor thats decodes this digital data into graphical data(symbols, letters, urraa, airraaa etc...). I dont think there is much beadbi, yes at the time we are using a displace device for reading or writing gurbani, that device shud be respected.
At the server, the gurbani files are stored in the form of digital data on a magnetic surface(disc), we use a brower client to access that digital data and its the monitor in front of us that changes that data into graphics,text.
When it comes to paper, we are writing gurmukhi letters and not 1100111....
when we are using electonics, the display device shud be respected, and when we are using paper, any paper on which gurbani is written(even a single tukk) shud be respected. AND POTHI SHUD BE RESPECTED. if the jatha kirtaniyaas are ready to spend so much energy in doing waheguru waheguru waheguru..... waheguru waheguru waheguru during kirtan, they shud be also be ready to spend some energy in either memorizing gurbani or respecting pothi during kirtan.
May be a person with clean and washed hands shud sit besides the kirtanniyaaa and shud find the current shabad thats being sung for the kirtanniyaa and the kirtanniyaa shud only use his eyes(and at the same time take one hand off from the vajja and cover his mouth with hazooriaa) and read from the pothi.
Re: Pothi Kirtan = Beadbi
Harinder Singh · 04 Apr 2008
<<< veer hrinder singh ji i agree tht binary codes are used but other contents are also converted into binary form and whn both are travelling simultanously it is BEADBI only.
Ok take example of ur television tht is used for watching both bollywood, or other content also the same is used to watch ETC for GurBANI AND MUKHWAK this is also beadbi.>>>>
I agree that in a wire, binary code(that will decode into gurbani by a display device) and binary codes(that will decode into vikaar) are simulataniously travelling, but its not beadbi because its same as a gursikh travelling in an aeroplane and sitting beside some vikaari manmukh insaan.
But yes, when these digital codes are being decoded by the display device(TV, monitor), the display device shud be respected at that time and at that time no other vikaar activity shud be watched or seen.