Re: Is 99% of the Panth really doing Paath?
Daljeet Singh · 08 Oct 2007
VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh!
Thats such a wrong mentality. Its like you're saying you're not reading baanee but something else, or you're doing paap by reading from padd ched.
Sure, you should strive to learn gurbaanee in larivaar saroops, but you shouldn't say if they are reading padd ched they are not 'doing paath' from it they're not doing his sift salah or it working in their benefit, what about amrit keertan sencheeaa, does tapoban gurduaara saheb have larivaar amrit keertans for reference?
Do you think someone shouldn't even read gurbaanee if they are not reading from lareevaar, that type of kattar mentality is what takes people away. I'm sure the person who said that knows the proper vishraams, or know what sihaaree/bihaarees mean on certain words.
Naam japnaa, amrit chaknaa, rehat rakhnee jarooree aa, maryada dee pratipaalan karnee jarooree aa but don't say reading baanee one way is right and another way is wrong, you're no-one to make that statement.
Bhul chuk muaaf karnee.
VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh!
Re: Is 99% of the Panth really doing Paath?
Jagjit Singh · 08 Oct 2007
vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, I am not sure I agree with that. Paath is more than just than just separating the Gurbani.
I think making statements such as 99% of the Panth is really not doing paath, will not further understanding of the importance of larrevar saroop.
vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Is 99% of the Panth really doing Paath?
kulbir singh · 08 Oct 2007
At a personal level, I never do paath from padd-chhed Gurbani but don't extend this to others. It's not a Tapoban policy to not consider ones who do paath from padd-chhed as not doing paath.
I don't think paath from padd-chhed will have same shakti as from Laridaar saroop. This again is a personal opinion, not an official opinion of Tapoban.
Paath from Gurbani includes not only pronouncing Gurbani but also understanding it. One can do padd-chhed of Gurbani only when one understands it. When doing paath from laridaar form of Gurbani, one has to understand it and only then one can do paath. If Gurbani has already been done padd-chhed, this important part of doing paath is missed.
Rest Guru Sahib knows.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh