Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 09 Apr 2008
When the gurgaddii was passed, the successor became Satguru.
But at a time there can only be 1 Satguru jee. So does this mean that previous Satguru Jee dint remain Satguru after the passing of Gurgaddi ??
So that means that Guru and Satguru are 2 different hasstiis ?
like bhai lehnnaa was a sikh
Guru Angad dev were Satguru
and after Guru Amardaas were made Satguru, Guru Angad Dev Jee remained Guru ?
if the above is right, we can have Guru and Satguru jee at the same time.
So, may be we can call Granth Sahib as Satguru Granth SAhib.
and Dasam Granth as Guru Dasam Granth Sahib.
Re: Guru or Satguru
Khalsaspirit · 09 Apr 2008
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Harinder Singh jio,
Quote "So, may be we can call Granth Sahib as Satguru Granth SAhib.
and Dasam Granth as Guru Dasam Granth Sahib."
ਅਸੀਂ ਗੁਰੂ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਨਾਲੋਂ ਜਿਆਦਾ ਸਿਆਣੇ ਬਣਨ ਦੀ ਕੋਸ਼ਿਸ ਨਾ ਹੀ ਕਰੀਏ ਇਸੇ ਵਿਚ ਹੀ ਸਾਡੀ ਸਭ ਦੀ ਭਲਾਈ ਹੈ।
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 09 Apr 2008
thats true,
A sarovar was found and constructed called amrit sarovar and a temple of Akal purakh(harimandir) was constructed for the parkash of Adi Granth( no gurgaddi at this time). Adi Granth contained bani of first 5 paatshaaahs and it was given ENORMOUS respect, I feel Dasam Granth(not sure if the entire banis in Dasam Granth are the same as Dasam Granth in 1720's 1730's) shud be given GREAT respect.
now is the questin of jyot in granths, well how many of us have seen our own jyot, hahaha and we talk about jyot of Satguru/Akal Purakh. I personally feel even a pothi or gutka contains jyot. Greater the bani stronger the jyot. No one is equal to Sri SATGURU Granth Sahib Jee Maharaaj but Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Jee does contain very powerful jyot and needs great respect.
Khalsaspirit jeeo i know gurmantar is very powerful and u r doing good kamayeee par Satguru jee da khel Satguru hee jande nee.
TERA ANT NAA PARAVARIYAAA
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 09 Apr 2008
<< parkash means they are wearing robes and have chaur over them, you cant do parkash of a granth, only of Guroo. )
so what happened in 1604 when Sri Adi Granth Sahib Jee were parkashed in a specially made harimandir in the centre of an amrit sarovar. acoording to ur logic, Sri Adi Granth was just a granth, so what was all this happening in 1604(104 years before gurgaddi ceremony)?
<< saying that there is a Satguroo and a Guroo, well if one is a Satguroo, other is a false Guroo, so Guroo and Satguroo title are held by the same person.>>
Thats a very sad statment.
lets say Guru Angad Dev jee got gurgaddi at time t and became Satguru.
At time (t+1), what happened to Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee Maharaaj Jee, you would not even call Him(roop of akaal purakh) Guru ? uffff............
Bhai gurbani, granth, gurgaddi ih sab gallan apne vass diyan nahin.
TERA ANT NA PAARAAVARIYAA
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 10 Apr 2008
veer noone is equal Sri SATGURU Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj. At Sri Harimandir SAhib(its the house of akal purakh), only Sri Satguru Granth Sahib is parkashed.
Granth I feel means a COMPILED large text on PAPER
For sikhs, Granth means a COMPILED large 'amrit ocean of pavitarr gurmukhi script' on PAPER by SATGURU JEE.
By the above defination, 'Aad Granth Sahib' was a Granth.
'Dasam Granth Sahib', well i feel its a compilation of Granths and pothis(pothis of Sri Jaap Sahib or even Sri Akal Ustatt).
Now, who did this compilation ?
If Bhai Mani Singh Jee did it, I feel 'Dasam Granth Sahib' shud be called 'Dasam Pita Jee ke granths and pothis' and if it was compiled by Dashmesh Pita(a poster on this thread has mentioned that it existed before 1708 and was present at the conference), it shud be called 'Dasam Pita Ka Granth'.
Infact, I feel FOR SIKHS to call suraj prakash or pracheen panth prakash or any other book as GRANTH is BEADBI, its same as calling some sikh hargobind singh or angaddev singh or harraisingh.
GRANTH IS A SACRED WORD OF THE SIKHS.
Now how many granths did Satguru jee compile ?? hahaha, thats the key question.
how many pothis(example pothis of first 4 Paatshaahs) are not a part of Granth ???
so from the above, I will invent the theory:
all Granths(and even pothis and gutkas) can(in fact SHUD) be parkashed by sikhs.
'Aad Granth' was a Granth no doubt.
Reseach shud be done whether 'Dasam Granth' is a Granth or a collection of Granths and pothis.
P.S: sikhs shud make the names of Guru SAhibaan SACRED. Words like Nanak, Angaddev, Amardaas, Ramdaas, Arjundev,Hargobind, Harrai,Harkrishan, Gobindrai(as well as Gobind) and Granth ARE SACRED WORDS and sikhs shud not use these words for naming persons, books, shops, schools, colleges etc.
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 10 Apr 2008
just to add some more thoughts.
The location and architecture, infact EVERYTHING linked to Harimandir, Sri Amritsar Sahib(i will also include the other 4 sarovars as well as I feel they are going to merge in the amritsar one day) sri Akal takhat is DIVINE and is related to the divine creation of Sachkhand and Karam khand.
Even the semantics of the names of these creations is Divine. Infact semantics of all the words coming from the Lotus mouth of Satguru Jee like degh, kirpan, keski, dastaar and so many other words is special and ALSO CONVEYS MESSAGES.
here is what i understand according to my avastha(which isnt tht great, hahahaha)
harimandir == sachkhand
bridge == bridge connecting karam khand and sachkhand
darshan deoori= karam khandians doing darshan of sachkhandians and god.
region around darshan deori= karam khand
akal takht = takhat of god(known by the name akal) in karam khand.The second part of the present version of 'Dasam Granth' which is called Akal Ustatt has some connection with this region. Infact many nihungs feel that this composition belongs to 6th Paatshah(we cant do research or debate about it as its purely karam khandian's business)
TERA ANT NA PARAVARRIYAAA
TUNHEEE TUNHEEE TUNHEEEE TUNHEEE TUNHEEE
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harcharan Singh · 10 Apr 2008
Bhai Manni Singh Ji's letter and Mata Sundri Ji's hukumnama prove that Bhai Manni Singh Ji complied Sri Dasam Granth Sahib.
Therefore in my opinion, it does not make sense that a Dasam Bir dated before 1708 exists.
There are many historical records of parkash of both Granth sahibs (18th and 19thc).
I also have a copy of a painting of both Granths at Darbar Sahib during mid 1800's, will try and dig it out.
From what I know, Sri Dasam Granth Sahib was removed once SGPC took control.
The early Panth/Shaheeds like Bhai Mehtab Singh Ji were all involved in the establishment of Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Ji as one volume. It was the the early Panth (18thc) that decided to do parkaash of Dasam Bani.
Nobody is saying Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is not Guru, nor disagreeing with Guru Gobind Singh Ji's hukum. It's simply a matter of Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Khalsa giving Dasam Pita's bani full satkaar - as it is Gur-Bani.
At the end of the day it's a non-issue. Dual (or even triple) Parkaash tradition has survived through today amongst the oldest samprada Budda Daal, so it's not a matter of returning to the old tradition or sticking to the SGPC established tradition, both traditions exist today.
It's easier to accept this and maintain harmonyrather than expounding our own mat over the Khalsa/Shaheeds of yestertear for something we can't change in any case.
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 10 Apr 2008
I agree calling DAsam Granth as Guru Dasam Granth will be manmatt as it never got gurgaddi. BUT JOINT parkash of Guru Granth Sahib Jee and Dasam Granth at TAKHTS is something thats making me think deep.
I feel construction of Amritsar SAhib, Harmandir Sahib, compilation and Parkash of Aad Granth in Harmandir Sahib and then construction of Akal Takhat is the most important part of sikh history.
AAD God lived in SACHKHAND.(AAD Granth,Jap Ji Sahib was parkashed in HARMANDIR). AAD God decides to start a play and create juggs and became JUGAAD God(Jap Ji Sahib + JAAP Sahib). He creates a Bridge and a Darshani deori and creates Karam khand and other khands brahamands etc. The Jugaad God takes the roop of AKAAL and constructs a fort in Karam Khand.( AKAL TAKHT outside darshani deorii). And his BACHITAAR NATAK starts. In this natak, CHANDI having CHARITARR is created. Demons and gods are created. Play of maya(wars, kaam, deceit,greed,anger) starts. In this play of maya, GYAN PRABODH is needed.CHAUBEES AVATAAR and other avataars are sent.SHASTAR NAAM MALA is created. KHALSA with MAHIMA is created. CHARITROPAKHIYAAN is created to help Khalsa and finaly BENTI CHAUPAI(by the author).
Its all in a sequence.
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 10 Apr 2008
Aad God(jap) = Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj jee sitting in Harmandir Sahib.
Jugaad God(jap + jaap)= Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaaj + Dasam Granth sitting in Akal Takht Sahib.
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 10 Apr 2008
pyare veer jeeooo
<< There are many historical records of parkash of both Granth sahibs (18th and 19thc). >>
veer jeoo, can u guide me where to get a hold of these records. I want records of 18th century.
<< I also have a copy of a painting of both Granths at Darbar Sahib during mid 1800's, will try and dig it out>>>>
PLEASE. I BEG FOR IT.
your daas
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harcharan Singh · 10 Apr 2008
Harinder Singh, e-mail me, I will e-mail you the picture.
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 11 Apr 2008
email is hidden.
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harcharan Singh · 11 Apr 2008
Now unhidden.
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 11 Apr 2008
<< also, my nimaan bentee is that you should not continue in this habit of labelling siree guroo granth sahib jee as 'aad granth'...they are aad, jugaaad and forever amar siree guroo grabth sahib jee.>>
when did i do this labelling ??
<< AAD Granth,Jap Ji Sahib was parkashed in HARMANDIR>>
Whats wrong with this ?
Aad Granth got parkashed in 1604.
Sri Guru Granth Sahib is MY LIVING Guru as well, It is a NIMAANI BENTI u shud be sure before writing the stuff that u wrote.
Re: Guru or Satguru
Harinder Singh · 15 Apr 2008
Guru Granth Sahib is
Satguru
POORAN in Itself
LIVING
Gall Khatam
all the best