Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

were maharaja ranjit singh and udham singh and kartar singh sikhs

were maharaja ranjit singh and udham singh and kartar singh sikhs

mandeep · 21 Apr 2008

i believe maharaja ranjit singh and udham singh and kartar singh were sikhs what are your opinions

Re: were maharaja ranjit singh and udham singh and kartar singh sikhs

mandeep · 21 Apr 2008

reason behind this thread is cause of so many people who judge sikhs who may cut their hair or eat mean, if your going to judge other sikhs and not call them sikhs then you might as well say the same about these three men but personally i believe they were sikhs, anyone who believes in what the gurus preached is a sikh as far as im concerned.

Re: were maharaja ranjit singh and udham singh and kartar singh sikhs

singhstah · 21 Apr 2008

on this issue is it really our opinion that matters or Guroo Sahib's?

Re: were maharaja ranjit singh and udham singh and kartar singh sikhs

Harinder Singh · 21 Apr 2008

dint ranjit singh do many marriages ?? but if those marriages happened with the consent of guru roop sadhsangat, then he is a sikh, otherwise he is patit. not a sikh. dont know about udham singh and kartar singh, but they were certainly brave people, god bless them.

Re: were maharaja ranjit singh and udham singh and kartar singh sikhs

scimitar · 22 Apr 2008

bani parh! simran karh! appeih pattah lag janah

Re: were maharaja ranjit singh and udham singh and kartar singh sikhs

mandeep · 22 Apr 2008

i beleive its up to guru ji to decide whose sikh whose not and not up to the people, when people try to judge others i believe its bad as drinking or cutting once hair cause now your trying to play the role of god, my personal belief is that guru ji will accept anyone as a sikh who is willing to give their life for a sikh. Harinder singh more then one marriage is against sikhi but i still believe ranjit singh was a sikh cause he woudl die for sikhi, but if one were to say he wasn't a sikh then can we say sikhs never had a homeland or empire.

Re: were maharaja ranjit singh and udham singh and kartar singh sikhs

Harinder Singh · 22 Apr 2008

i feel its better to be a brave atheist than to be a "religious" coward. BRAVERY, HONESTY are the biggest virtues and THERE IS NO DOUBT ABOUT IT.