1984 & the 40 mukte and the Gurus!!!
ConfusedMunda · 04 Jun 2008
Fateh!
no1 has seemed to answer me so im guessing may be u can help me. It is said that
wheneva sikhs are in great trouble the gurus and the 40 mukte guard them. Even
when the Sukhmani Sahib paathh is done it is meant to protect one from any evil
spirits or evil humans. It says that the 40 mukte guard the place where the
Sukhmani Sahib ji is read with a true heart; and Guru Ji resides in all places
where patth is done. But veerji i fail to understand one thing; during the attack
on the Golden Temple, many sikhs were murdered. Many true devotees, true gursikhs
became shaheed fighting. Gursikhs were dishonored due to their religion, in their
own religious place; but how comes this happened? Why didnt the chaali mukte
prevent this from happening? Plus the Guru Granth Sahib ji has been read many
times in the Golden Temple, and im sure the Sukhmani Sahib Ji has been read many
times and many devotees prayed with a true heart. But then why were these devotees
massacred?!?! veero i don't mean to question WaheGuru or my Gurus. But i jus fail
to understand that how this had all happened and why the 40 mukte didn't prevent
this.
Veer ji, im sorry if i have said to much; i don't intend to questions Sikhi but i
just want to understand a few things more deeply. I hope you can help me.
i hope WaheGuru forgives me if i said anything out of line.
WaheGuru Ji ka Khalsa, WaheGuru Ji ki Fateh
Re: 1984 & the 40 mukte and the Gurus!!!
Anonymous User · 05 Jun 2008
well the only thing that came to mind is the saying that Guru Gobind Singh stated that if the sikhs deviated from his instructions he would withdraw his support/protection/blessing (sorry if my paraphrasing is wrong, but you all know what i am refering to right?)
i mean who fortified the Harimandra in the first place? Gurus didnt build or intend it for that purpose. those people who died in the army's siege were trapped and massacred because they couldnt leave, because of those outer confines.
we say that there are 4 entrances because all our welcome yet someone went and built huge building and enclose what was once one with its surrounding area.
Even in Guru Hargobinds time, the Akal Takht was a outdoor platform and not a fortification (or so i read, is this incorrect?)
Re: 1984 & the 40 mukte and the Gurus!!!
ConfusedMunda · 05 Jun 2008
bundha veer ji, i understand what you are saying, and shaheedian are important in our religion, but such a huge amount of people were massacred in the Harmandir Sahib and the after math was tooo horrific. so many peoploe killed at one time, wha does this mean?? that its the beginning of Khalistan?? but even if it is veer ji wen will we achieve khalistan because in india itself i dont think there have been any people who are trying to achieve a khalistan or anythink, like Bhindranwale did
i have accepeted all this massacre 2 be the way of WaheGuru and the new beginning of something, but wen will all these shaheedis actually show result veer ji
Re: 1984 & the 40 mukte and the Gurus!!!
ConfusedMunda · 05 Jun 2008
matheen thank you, i think ur comment has answered my question :-) and i accidently said tha Bhindranwale wanted Khalistan b4, i no he want to free Sikhs from this slavery and be considered equal to every1; he also said tha he is not for or against Khalistan however the if the government were willin to give it he wudnt reject it..... veer ji i am a Sikh and proud to be one and i try display that in all ways possible and all my close ones i try convincing them to take more interest in Sikhi and our Gurus. however, i feel tha i want to do more, i want to do more for my brothers and sisters in punjab i want them 2 have their equal rights. What the brave Singhs started before 1984 i want to give that journey a results now.
plz help me in telling me ways in which i can help my people in india get their equal rights and be respected. i want people of all religions to accept that sikhi isnt jus a load of crap, it is actually a very powerful and right religion. i don't want my brothers in india to be referred as "long haired hindus"!!! Veer ji i am not racist as some ppl may think i may be.... but plz help me and advise me now i can give input by achieveing this for my religion
Re: 1984 & the 40 mukte and the Gurus!!!
ConfusedMunda · 05 Jun 2008
this general brar lies!!! he said tha pilgrims were killed in cross fire when that is an absolute lie!!!! pilgrims were forced by the army 2 sit 2getha then their turbans were removed to tie up their hands and then they were shot at a point blank range!!! The army itself wouldnt let anyone out, because as soon as they saw movenment from inside they just started firing!!! its traitors like this who are holding Sikhs back! can any of my brothers or sisters tell me what people get out of betrayin their own religion, their own Gurus and their own people?!?!?!
http://www.neverforget84.com/sakhis.php?id=June-1984
go on this link 2 read an actual surviors story of what happened when Harmandir Sahib ji was attacked
Re: 1984 & the 40 mukte and the Gurus!!!
ConfusedMunda · 05 Jun 2008
hopeless, my brother so do u believe that general brar was right for attacking the Golden Temple and he has justified all of his actions in that interview?
Re: 1984 & the 40 mukte and the Gurus!!!
ConfusedMunda · 05 Jun 2008
http://www.neverforget84.com ..... go to this link, then click on Shaheeds Of Operation Bluestar & Khalistan Movement, and then click on June 1984: One Jujharoo's Account
Re: 1984 & the 40 mukte and the Gurus!!!
Bhopinder Singh · 05 Jun 2008
Navjooot
I think you have no sense of anything,well let me try and help you ,read neville maxwells book India's china war and remmember the ' which means India started the war .To this day Indians say otherwise,read how general Kaul ran also read col.Choudhary's book on that war in which he details the true character of Hindu army true to its history and heritage written by a Hindu himself.
NO danger of any seige read Lt. gen. Sinha's book .The weapons were nothing as he says compared to the Indian army ,well he says they were virtually unarmed.So much so he goes on to say they were defending their history of never letting any body go over them ,true to their history they fulfilled that,only in death will it be SO TRUE IT IS AND TRUE IT WILL BE ALWAYS
JO BOLE SO NIHAL SAT SRI AKAL
Re: 1984 & the 40 mukte and the Gurus!!!
ConfusedMunda · 06 Jun 2008
www.sikhgenocide.org