Re: Professional
Harcharan Singh · 15 Jun 2008
Of course full time kirtani should be paid a living wage.
This has always been the case, Rababi tradition which was only abolished by SGPC, existed form the time of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, these were full time Muslim kirtani who's sole life purpose it was to sing Sat-Guru's bachan.
You don't need to look further than the one of the last true great kirtanis who did over 70 years worth of nishkaam seva at Darbaar Sahib - Adhan Shaahi Mahapursh Baba Shaam Singh Ji Seva Panthi.
Their life was dedicated to performing the most beautiful kirtan in Sat-Guru's hazuri keeping full kirtan maryada including using Guru Arjun Dev Ji's gifted Saranda.
Whatever living wage is agreed, the key is that you do the kirtan for your Guru (and as per Guru's hukum) and therefore always in shardaa, nimrata and prem.
No difference to Gyaani's who look after the Gurdwarai, it's a full time seva, and you and they live in grihisht, so have to feed your family.
http://www.sewapanthi.org/htmls/mahapursh_bhaishaamsingh.html
Re: Professional
Anonymous User · 16 Jun 2008
its probably good because once you have set wage you will not be motivated by money any more. you can take singing as seva to prabh without worrying about paying bills. however then you might get distracted by other things such as personal prestige.
but its not going to be easy job is it? alot of raags to learn.
Re: Professional
Anonymous User · 22 Jun 2008
hi
sorry i cant help thinking you are misusing the word nishkaam. a work cam still be nishkaam is someone is being paid for it. being paid or not is irrelevant it a work being nishkaam. nishkaam refers to the action itself with disinterest in the consequences.
how can you say that nishkaam and seva are different?
so even if someone is doing seva kirtan (without pay) - if they revel in the attention or act like its their personal concert and enjoy it like that- how can it be called seva?
state of mind is the point.
Re: Professional
singh_bling · 24 Jun 2008
hmmm