Forum
Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
kulbir singh · 23 Jul 2008
Ashtam Balbira - Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib de Avtar Purab dee 'Maaha Maah Mumaarkhi'.
Today on 7 Sawan (July 23) Sikh sangats around the world are celebrating a great event in the spiritual world – the Avatar Purab of Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee. Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee was the great grandson of Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee and because of this, Siri Guru jee had following relationship with other Guru Sahibaan and Sahibzadas:
1) Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee was a grandson of Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee. Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee was son of Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee and thus brother of father of Siri Guru Har Rai Sahib jee – Baba Gurditta jee. This is why before leaving for Sachkhand, Siri Guru jee said that the next Guru is his Baba in Bakala (town). In short form he said – Baba Bakale – which meant that the next Guru is his Baba (Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee) who resides in Bakala town.
2) Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee was a nephew of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee.
3) Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee was a cousin of 4 Sahibzadas of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaj.
Siri Guru jee was only 5 Earth years old when he was chosen to be the Guru by his father and Guru – Siri Guru Har Rai Sahib jee. It is written in our history that all three siblings namely Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee, Baba Ram Rai jee and their sister Bibi Roop Kaur possessed great natural beauty. They were very beautiful. Siri Guru jee’s beauty was greatly enhanced by being Guru. The jyot of Guruship shone on his face. Whoever looked at Siri Guru jee could not taken his eyes away.
Siri Guru jee was a pooran Brahmgyani from the time of his avatar like his great great Grandfather – Siri Guru Arjun Sahib jee. This is why, at the tender age of 5, Siri Guru jee became the 8th Guru of Sikhs. Earth years don’t matter in spiritual wisdom. Age is not a factor in spiritual knowledge or Brahmgyaan. Siri Guru Amardas jee became the Guru at the age of 73 and on the other extreme Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee became the Guru at the age of 5. The same jyot of Guruship pervailed in both Guru Sahibaan and both were equal in status and possessed equal amount of Brahmgyaan. The body was not the Guru but the jyot was and is the Guru.
Many doubted that a 5 year old person cannot be the Guru and cannot possess the required spiritual knowledge to deliver sinners.
An incident involving doubting Siri Guru jee because of his age occurred at Panjokhra Sahib, where Siri Guru jee arrived on his way to Delhi. There was a Pandit who inquired from a Sikh as to who had arrived in the small town of Panjokhra. The Sikh replied by saying that Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee, the 8th master had arrived. This pandit was very proud of his knowledge of Vedas and Shastras. He was in the habit of debating and defeating scholars on the might of his knowledge. He took offense at the name of Siri Guru jee. He was a worshipper of Siri Krishna of Brindabana and he did not like the fact that Siri Guru jee’s name was longer than his deity. He addressed the Sikh as follows:
“ਜੇ ਸਾਰਥ ਇਹ ਨਾਮ ਧਰਾਵਹੁ।
ਕਰਿ ਗੀਤਾ ਕੇ ਅਰਥ ਸੁਨਾਵਹੁ।
ਨਾਹਿ ਤਾ ਕੂਰ ਕਹਨਿ ਇਨ ਕੇਰੋ।
ਹਮ ਨਹਿ ਮਾਨਹਿਂ ਕਹਿਬੋ ਤੇਰੋ।15।
(Equal to whom (Siri Krishna) they (Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee) have kept their name, then let them (Siri Guru jee) do translation of Geeta (written by Siri Krishna). If he can’t do these meanings, then go tell him that I don’t accept him as the Guru).
Hearing this the Sikh replied to the Brahmin as follows:
ਸੁਨਤਿ ਸਿਖ ਕਹਿ, “ਰਹੁ ਤੂੰ ਖਰੋ”।
ਮੈਂ ਆਬਿ ਜਾਇ ਬੂਝਿਬੋ ਕਰੋਂ।
(The Sikh said, you stay standing here. I will go and deliver your message to Guru Sahib).
The Sikh hurried to the darbar of Siri Guru jee and after matha-tek told Satguru jee the whole conversation he had with the Pandit. The sangat was hearing and some in Sangat were upset after hearing of the pandit's arrogance.
Because of the tender age of Siri Guru jee, many were placing doubts in the minds of sangat. Siri Guru jee wanted to prove that age is not a factor in attaining spiritual wisdom (Brahmgyaan). The Sikh with great humility and hope beseeched, “ਖਰੋ ਅਹੈ, ਕਿਮ ਕਹੌਂ ਬੁਝਾਈ। (He is standing waiting, what should I tell him).
Jaanee-Jaan (All knowing) Siri Guru jee said to the Sikh that this pandit is a very proud person who is full of Hankaar (pride, ego). He debates like a great fool and considers himself to be very wise. He is very far from the path of meeting Prabhu (Vaheguru). The sorrow of separation from Prabhu and haume are big dukhs that only Guru Nanak Dev jee can eliminate. The diseased and the suffering person has to take the word of Guru and place it in his heart. Then alone the dukh can go.
After pausing for a moment, Siri Guru jee with mercy and grace in their eyes, said:
ਸੋ ਇਸ ਕੋ ਦੁਖ ਹਤਹਿਂ, ਬੁਲਾਵਹੁ।
ਸਿਖ ਉਪਕਾਰ ਕਰਤਿ, ਬਿਦਤਾਵਹੁ।
(ਉਸ ਦਾ ਦੁਖ ਦੂਰ ਕਰੀਏ, ਉਸ ਨੂੰ ਬੁਲਾਵੋ। ਤੁਸੀਂ ਕਿਹਾ ਕਰਦੇ ਹੋ ਕਿ ਸਿਖ ਉਪਕਾਰ ਕਰਦੇ ਹਨ, ਸੋ ਤੁਹਾਡਾ ਬਚਨ ਪੂਰਾ ਕਰੀਏ). Let us eliminate his sorrow, call him. You say this all the time that Sikhs are compassionate and benevolent. So let’s fulfill your bachan.
The Sikh went back to the pandit and asked him to come to the darbar of Siri Guru jee. The pandit came to the Darbar of Siri Guru jee with hankaar (pride) and sat near Siri Guru jee. Siri Guru jee addressed him as follows:
ਪਿਖਿ ਬੋਲੇ ਸੋਢੀ ਕੁਲ ਟੀਕਾ।
ਕਹੁ ਦਿਜਬਰ, ਕਯਾ ਬੂਝਯੋ ਚਹੈਂ।
ਬਿਦਤ ਬਤਾਵਹੁ ਜਿਮ ਚਿਤ ਅਹੈ।
(On seeing the pandit arrive, the prince of Sodhi clan said, O Dijbar, what is it that you want answered? Say out that which is in your mind.)
The pandit said:
ਦਿਜ ਤਬਿ ਕਹਯੋ, ਕ੍ਰਿਸ਼ਨ ਅਵਤਾਰ।
ਰਿਦੇ ਜਿਨਹੁਂ ਕੇ ਗਯਾਨ ਉਦਾਰ।
ਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਗਯਾਨ ਮਯ ਗੀਤਾ ਕੀਨਸਿ।
ਜਿਹ ਪਠਿ ਸੁਨਿ ਕੈ ਲੇ ਸਭਿ ਚੀਨਸਿ।25।
Then the pandit said, “Krishna Avatar was great and in the heart of Siri Krishna immense spiritual wisdom had dawned. Using this Brahmgyaan, he uttered the Bhagwad Geeta. Hearing the paath of Geeta, one can realize everything.
ਤਿਨ ਨਾਮਨ ਤੇ ਤੁਮ ਅਧਿਕਾਯੋ।
ਸ੍ਰੀ ਹਰਿਕ੍ਰਿਸ਼ਨ ਨਾਮ ਰਖਾਯੋ।
ਪੁਨ ਗੁਰ ਗਾਦੀ ਪਰ ਥਿਤ ਅਹੋ।
ਗੁਰੂ ਨਾਮ ਅਪਨੋ ਜਗ ਲਹੋ।26।
You (O Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee) have named yourself even greater than Siri Krishna i.e. the name “Harkrishan” is longer than “Krishna”. On top of this, you have placed yourself on the seat of the Gurus and made it famous in the world that you are the Guru.
ਗੀਤਾ ਬਿਖੈ ਪ੍ਰਸ਼ਨ ਬਡ ਮੇਰੇ।
ਉਤਰ ਦੇਹੁ, ਤੁਮ ਸੁਨੇ ਬਡੇਰੇ।
ਜੋ ਸ੍ਰੀ ਕ੍ਰਿਸ਼ਨ ਬਨਾਵਨਿ ਕੀਨਿ।
ਅਰਥ ਦੇਹੋ ਜੋ ਲੇਵੌਂ ਚੀਨ।27।
ਸਾਰਥ ਜਾਨੌ ਨਾਮ ਤੁਮਾਰੋ।
ਨਾਂਹਿ ਤ ਨੀਕੇ ਨਹੀਂ ਨਿਹਾਰੋ।
Regarding Siri Krishna’s Geeta, I have big questions, many questions. Answer me, I have heard from your Sikhs that you are great. If you are able to answer the questions that I will ask from Sri Krishna’s Geeta, I will consider you to be worthy of your name (Harkrishna); otherwise, I will not see you as good and pious.
ਸ੍ਰੀ ਹਰਿਕ੍ਰਿਸ਼ਨ ਸੁਨਤਿ ਬਚ ਕਹਯੋ।
ਬਾਦੀ ਬਿਪ੍ਰ ਜਾਤਿ ਕੋ ਲਹਯੋ।
ਜੇ ਕਰ ਹਮ ਤੁਝਿ ਅਰਥ ਸੁਨਾਵਹਿਂ।
ਤਊ ਕਲਪਨਾ ਅਨਿਕ ਉਠਾਵਹਿਂ।
ਧਨੀ ਪੁਰਖ ਇਹ ਭਾਗ ਬਲੀ ਹੈ।
ਕਿਨਹੁਂ ਪਢਾਏ ਪਾਠ ਭਲੀ ਹੈ।29
Hearing the pandit, Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee said, “It’s the habit of Bipars (pandits) to have doubt on everything. If I successfully do the meanings of Geeta, you will raise the doubt by saying that since I am from a rich and resourceful family, I must have learned the meanings from scholars.
ਪ੍ਰਥਮ ਪਠੀ ਹੁਇ ਗੀ ਕਿਸ ਪਾਸ।
ਇਮ ਜਾਨਹਿਂ, ਨਹਿਂ ਹੁਇ ਬਿਸਵਾਸ।
ਯਾਂ ਤੇ ਪ੍ਰਥਮ ਕਾਰ ਇਮ ਕੀਜੈ।
ਆਪ ਨਗਰ ਮਹਿਂ ਜਾਇ ਪਿਖੀਜੈ।30।
You will say that I must have learned the meanings from someone. This way you will stay faithless i.e. you will not get faith. Therefore, the first thing you should do is that go to your town and look for someone.
ਜੋ ਅਪਠਤਿ ਹੁਇ ਮੂਢ ਬਿਸਾਲਾ।
ਤਿਹ ਬੁਲਾਇ ਆਨਹੁ ਇਸ ਕਾਲਾ।
ਸੋ ਉਤਰ ਦੈ ਹੈ ਤੁਝ ਚਾਹਤਿ।
ਜਿਨ ਬੂਝਨਿ ਹਿਤ ਨੀਤ ਉਮਾਹਤਿ।31।
Someone who is a “Moodh Bisaala” i.e. Big fool, very ignorant person and call him to our Darbar right away. Whatever your questions are about Geeta, he will answer them for you.
ਸੁਨਿ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਕੋ ਬਾਕ ਰਸੀਲਾ।
ਬਿਪੂ ਭਣੋ ਮਦ ਤੇ ਕੁਛ ਢਲਿਾ।
ਗਯੋ ਨਗਰ ਮਹਿ ਧਵਿਰ ਹੇਰਾ।
ਘਰ ਘਰ ਨਿਤ ਜਲ ਢੋਇ ਘਨੇਰਾ।32।
Hearing the nectarous bachans of Satguru jee, the pride in the pandit subsided a bit. He went to the town and looked for the most foolish person, house to house.
Finally he found a person who he thought was ideal for the situation. The person was a deaf and dumb, totally uneducated and very poor. Mahakavi Santokh Singh jee writes about him as follows:
ਮਹਾਂ ਮੂਢ ਬੋਲਬਿ ਨਹਿਂ ਜਾਨੈ।
ਪੇਟ ਭਰਨਿ ਲੌ ਕਾਰਜ ਠਾਨੈ।
ਕਾਰੋ ਬਰਨ ਬਸਤ੍ਰ ਤਨ ਫਾਰੇ।
ਜਿਨ ਪਢਤੇ ਨਰ ਨਹੀਂ ਨਿਹਾਰੇ।33।
He was very big fool who could not speak. To fill his stomach he did meagre jobs. His skin colour was totally black, and clothes on him were torn. Let alone he getting any education, he had not even seen anyone study. This is how ignorant he was.
He was brought over to the Darbar of Siri Guru jee. The pandit was very happy thinking that Jheevar (the foolish person) would never be able to speak, let alone do any translations of Geeta. Siri Guru jee right away caught the thought of the pandit and glanced at the jheevar with “Shubh Disht” (Eye of grace) and with smile on his face said to the jheevar:
ਮੁਖਿ ਮੁਸਕਾਵਤਿ ਬਾਕ ਬਖਾਨਾ।
ਬਿਪ੍ਰ ਮਨੋਰਥ ਜਿਮ ਉਰ ਠਾਨਾ।37।
ਸੋ ਤੈਂ ਬੂਝਨਿ ਕਰਿ ਕੈ ਅਬਿ ਹੂੰ।
ਸ਼ੰਕਤਿ ਕੋ ਉਤਰ ਦਿਹੁ ਸਭਿ ਹੂੰ।
(With smiling face, Siri Guru jee uttered the bachans to the foolish jheevar. As per the wish of the pandit, you will realize all knowledge needed, and respond to all questions of the pandit.)
When Satguru jee uttered these Vaaks (words) and placed his chhadee (stick) on the forehead of the jheevar all divine knowledge dwelled in the heart of the foolish jheevar. The first thing that happened was that face of the jheevar started reflecting the inner knowledge he had attained. He face started shining. He was then able to speak.
The pandit asked the most difficult salok from Geeta to be translated. The Jheevar, spontaneously gave the most exalted translation of the salok. Such was the translation that the pandit had never heard of such words before. He was wonder-struck. He could not believe his ears. He asked couple of more questions but then was too wonder-struck to say anything else. Then at that time, his good karma from previous birth sprouted. His pride was overtaken by immense humility. His hand folded. He moved forward and prostrated before Siri Guru jee. With extreme humility he pleaded:
ਬੋਲਯੋ, ਮਹਿਮਾ ਲਖੀ ਅਨੂਪ।
ਸ੍ਰੀ ਹਰਿਕ੍ਰਿਸ਼ਨ ਸੁ ਕ੍ਰਿਸ਼ਨ ਸਰੂਪ।
ਭੇਦ ਨ ਫੁਰਤਿ ਮੋਹਿ ਮਨ ਮਾਂਹੀ।
ਵਹੀ ਜੋਤਿ ਤੁਮ ਹੋ ਅਨ ਨਾਂਹੀ।
ਭਵਸਾਗਰ ਤੇ ਮੋਹਿ ਉਧਾਰਹੁ।
ਧਾਰਹੁ ਕਰੁਨਾ ਬਿਰਦ ਸੰਭਾਰਹੁ।
(He said, I have realized that your greatness is unmatched. You O Siri Guru Harkishan are Siri Krishna for me. I have no doubt about it. You are the same jyot. Deliver me from this ocean of world. Have mercy on me.)
Siri Guru jee accepted his plea and gave him Naam Gurmantra there and then. Siri Guru jee accepted him as his Sikh. As per Mahakavi Santokh Singh jee, he was given Charan Pahul and initiated as a Sikh there and then.
What a great story this is. This story echoes hukams of Gurbani like:
ਕਰਿ ਹੁਕਮੁ ਮਸਤਕਿ ਹਥੁ ਧਰਿ ਵਿਚਹੁ ਮਾਰਿ ਕਢੀਆ ਬੁਰਿਆਈਆ ॥
ਸਹਿ ਤੁਠੈ ਨਉ ਨਿਧਿ ਪਾਈਆ ॥18॥
ਅਤੇ
ਸਿਰੀ ਗੁਰੂ ਸਾਹਿਬੁ ਸਭ ਊਪਰਿ ॥
ਕਰੀ ਕ੍ਰਿਪਾ ਸਤਜੁਗਿ ਜਿਨਿ ਧ੍ਰੂ ਪਰਿ ॥
ਸ੍ਰੀ ਪ੍ਰਹਲਾਦ ਭਗਤ ਉਧਰੀਅੰ ॥
ਹਸœ ਕਮਲ ਮਾਥੇ ਪਰ ਧਰੀਅੰ ॥
When Guru Sahib places their divine hand on our forehead, only then one can realize Vaheguru and only then the hardwork of japping Naam, doing paath and keeping rehit is accepted.
We think that Chhajoo Jheevar was very foolish but are we any less foolish than him? What's the point of having knowledge of this world when we don't have the knowledge or the gyaan that is relevant in the next world? It's like possessing a trillion dollars in Zimbawe's money and feeling proud of it. A 100 billion dollars of Zimbawe's currency can buy you only one loaf of bread. So what is this trillion dollars going to do for us in Canada? Nothing. Same way, one may have all the knowledge of physics, chemistry, accounting, mathematics, biology, genetics and what not but if one does not have Brahmgyaan i.e. the divine spiritual knowledge of Vaheguru, then all the worldly knowledge is a waste. It's going to be rendered useless in the next world. Even in this world, what's the point of having gyaan when that gyaan does not enable or prompt us to japp Naam and meet Vaheguru. Until we attain Gurmat-Gyaan, and until we eliminate the Durmat from within through Gurmat of Guru Sahib, we are just as foolish as Chajjoo Jheevar was prior to meeting Guru Sahib.
May Parm-Kirpaaloo, Param-Dyaaloo, Satguru Sache Paatshaah – Ashtam-Balbira – Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee have mercy on us and place their lotus hand on our forehead, so that the ignorance may be eliminated from our hearts and replaced with divine knowledge of Vaheguru jee.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
... · 25 Jul 2008
vaheguroo
BUMP!!!
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Harcharan Singh · 25 Jul 2008
Thank you veer Kulbir ji, that was a wonderful tribute.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Anonymous User · 27 Jul 2008
slightly confused here
the version i grew up with was that Guru Harikrishan was walking through the devotees in a place and a pandit was standing by a tree and made remarks about people worshipping a mere child. then a poor illiterate devotee rushed foward to respond to the pandit. he inivited the pandit to test his knowledge as a devotee of the 'mere child'. the pandit did and was astonished by the responses the devotee gave.
i dont know if this is the same story. anyone else heard this version?
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
kulbir singh · 28 Jul 2008
Navjot jee,
----------
the version i grew up with was that Guru Harikrishan was walking through the devotees in a place and a pandit was standing by a tree and made remarks about people worshipping a mere child. then a poor illiterate devotee rushed foward to respond to the pandit. he inivited the pandit to test his knowledge as a devotee of the 'mere child'. the pandit did and was astonished by the responses the devotee gave.
----------
The above story is based on Sooraj Parkash Granth by Kavi Santok Singh. If you go to the Gurdwara Sahib itself, there too, I believe, the above stated version of this saakhi is written. I have never heard or read the version that you have stated.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
gurmantar · 03 Aug 2008
...VAHEGURU...DHAN SAT GURU SAHIB SRI GURU HARKRISHAN SAHIB JI!!!
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Outwardly · 07 Aug 2008
WOW! What a relevant Sakhi!!
A quick question, however:
-----------------
ਕਰਿ ਹੁਕਮੁ ਮਸਤਕਿ ਹਥੁ ਧਰਿ ਵਿਚਹੁ ਮਾਰਿ ਕਢੀਆ ਬੁਰਿਆਈਆ ॥
ਸਹਿ ਤੁਠੈ ਨਉ ਨਿਧਿ ਪਾਈਆ ॥18॥
-----------------
Should ਸਹਿ be pronounced as "Sheh" (Persian for Master) and should there be nasal sound on end?
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
kulbir singh · 07 Aug 2008
[quote]
-----------------
ਕਰਿ ਹੁਕਮੁ ਮਸਤਕਿ ਹਥੁ ਧਰਿ ਵਿਚਹੁ ਮਾਰਿ ਕਢੀਆ ਬੁਰਿਆਈਆ ॥
ਸਹਿ ਤੁਠੈ ਨਉ ਨਿਧਿ ਪਾਈਆ ॥18॥
-----------------
Should ਸਹਿ be pronounced as "Sheh" (Persian for Master) and should there be nasal sound on end?
[/quote]
The pronunciation of ਸਹਿ should be like shah. It should not be a long shaah but a very short shah just like ਦਰਗਹ, ਪਨਹ, ਅਲਹ should not be pronounced like dargeh, paneh and Alleh but as Dargah, Panah and Allah. If you listen to kirtan by Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara jee, you will notice that he pronounces Dargah (not dargeh). There is no such word as Alleh. The word is Allah and it should be prnounced as such. Most Persian words ending with a he are pronounced as Kanna but again it depends on the accent of Persian too. I have referred to Pakistan Farsi scholar, who holds a Masters in Farsi - Mohammad Yusaf, a Bazurg in our neighbourhood, and he confirmed this below stated rule with me.
These words (Dargah, Panah, Shah etc.) are Persian words and normally are written with a Alif (kanna) before he (haaha) but in poetry to keep the poetic metre in control, many times are written without the Alif (kanna). In such cases the uchaaran is still like a kanna and haaha but it is a very quick one and a short one. These Persian words have been written in Gurbani using same spellings as Persian. To pronounce these words like Hindi/Sanskrit is does not seem to be correct. The rules for pronouncing Indian words and Persian words are not same especially when it involves 'haaha'.
Please refer to Gurbani Uchaaran book written by Bhai Dhanna Singh for more details.
Rest, I am aware of different schools of thought when it comes to Gurbani uchaaran and don't wish to debate which is the best. I have just given my personal viewpoint on Gurbani uchaaran.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Khalsaspirit · 07 Aug 2008
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Bhai kulbir Singh jio,
Thanks for information on ਦਰਗਹ, ਪਨਹ, ਅਲਹ. Interestingly, past weekend we had discussion on some ucharans and these three words came into light. We were three sareer ਸਰੀਰ who were discussing. Although as usual majority rules we ended up pronouncing as written but the other argument was same as you explained and the Singh who was holding that argument (with added light kanna before hahha) also referred to Bhai Joginder Singh Ji Talwara's ucharan for those words because he some time did the company of Bhai Sahib but on the other hand we were on the stance to pronounce those as written so we two were on one side and majority ruled but your explanation realized us how majority could be wrong.
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Anonymous User · 20 Aug 2008
these words ਦਰਗਹ, ਪਨਹ, ਅਲਹ may have originated from Persian but they are not persian words they are panjabi words. they are entirely valid in that respect in the pronunciation given. It is panjabi being spoken here not farsi.
e.g.
kagaz is persian/urdu. Kagad is panjabi.
likewise desh is hindi. des is panjabi.
people educated in urdu instruction schools last century decided that urdu pronunciation must be correct and disregard native panjabi, most obviously be inventing sounds like 'shasha' and 'zazza' that were never panjabi sounds. they have attacked the beauty of the language.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
kulbir singh · 20 Aug 2008
Navjot,
But in Punjabi too the pronunciation of these words (ਦਰਗਹ, ਪਨਹ, ਅਲਹ ) is as suggested by this daas in the previous post.
[quote]people educated in urdu instruction schools last century decided that urdu pronunciation must be correct and disregard native panjabi, most obviously be inventing sounds like 'shasha' and 'zazza' that were never panjabi sounds. they have attacked the beauty of the language.[/quote]
First of all, we need to realize that it's not Punjabi language we are speaking when reciting Gurbani. Secondly, who says that there was no shasha sound in Punjabi. Do Punjabis say sabad instead of shabad or saanti instead of shaanti?
Kulbir Singh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
xzik101 · 20 Aug 2008
Navjot Singh jee, I don't know if you come from Bihar or Punjab, because I know that in Bihar they pronounce words with Shasha as Sassa. But in Punjab I know that they pronounce most words with Shasha. I don't know any Punjabi who pronounces "Bangladesh" as "Bangladess", or any Punjabi Sikh who pronounces Guru Har Krishan Sahib Jee as "Guru HarKrissan Sahib Jee". I know Biharis pronounce words like this, but not Punjabis, especially those who speak the standard Punjabi of Taksali Boli.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Khalsaspirit · 20 Aug 2008
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Navjot jio,
ਕ੍ਰਿਪਾ ਕੀਜੀਏ ਆਪ ਸਾਂਤੀ (saanti) ਹੀ ਬਨਾਏ ਰੱਖੇਂ।
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Anonymous User · 20 Aug 2008
kulbir singh i should have picked up the example of 'sahi' (or as you say 'shah') that you used.
we are not speaking panjabi when reading Gurbani? well I agree if by that you mean modern panjabi. But I suppose there are some other dialects there from Bhagats from different states. but i personally would contend that these had all been 'transferred' into panjabi sounds.
the script is the base or essense of the language. it is the sounds that make up the language. the letters of its alphabet represent its own range of sounds. if the sound is not in the script then does it exist in the language?
there was never any letter for 'sh' in Gurmukhi like there is in Hindi. Pairee bindee Sassa is a modern invention. Likewise with Zay or the Farsi letter for 'Z'. If the sound is not in the script how can it be in the language? especially in Gurmukhi look how we have specific letters for the different 'T', 'D' or 'N' sounds. We differentiate between Babba and Bhabba but no corresponding shasha for sassa exists. why?
what modern panjabis say doesnt count because it has been adulterated by hindi/urdu.
Im not a linguist but im ready to bet some good money that the old panjabis DID say sabad and not shabad. the exception perhaps would be panjabi pandits who studied Sanskrit and used the Devanagari script.
and no xzikh101 i am not from Bihar but the Bihar point is interesting. Biharis generally tend to be poorer and also less Hindi-speaking influence, so perhaps they havent been influenced by modern pronunciation. I dont know what their language is like but since panjabi is very similar in diction and vocabularly to hindi/urdi im not surprised this influence is stronger in panjabi. Likewise if I go to a majore Bihari city am I going to hear their language or Hindi/Urdu like I hear/would expect to hear in Chandigarh or Lahore respectively?
Akal forgive my errors
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Atma Singh · 20 Aug 2008
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ
veer/bhain navjot jee,
pls do a search for threads in this and the old forum - this issue has been covered many times.
i personally find it hard to accept that siree guroo nanak sahib jee who conversed with many muslim holy men and we are told via janam sakhees was 'taught' by a local muslim scholar regarding qu'ranic philosophy as a child, would ever pronounce allah as allho or shabad as sabad.
why would maharaaj jee for some unknown reason decide to ignore sh and z sounds event though at the time of the mughals, there would have been so many words in common and state-usage which feature these sounds? the only explanation is that like many alphabets the world over, letters can and do have more than one sound.
furthermore, proof that one letter can have more than one sound approach abounds in gurbaaNee - we need not look to the validity of pairee bindeeaa(n) regarding sassa, jajja, phapha, khakha and gagga to understand this.
for example, 'prubh' which features the letter phabbha at the end yet it is featured as a strong B sound. when at the beginning of a word, phabbha has the more usual and 'official' soft sound i.e. 'bhagat' - here it sounds like a soft pappa.
however, despite my personal views, i would never dare to say that doing the ucharan of the word shabad as sabad, or for that matter vice-versa, would mean someone is doing shudh/ashudh paath. this is because maharaaj jee alone knows which pathee is really doing shudh or ashudh paath.
it is a BIG THING to say someone is doing ashudh paath when it comes to factors such as pairee bindee alphabets, haha at the end of words, tippees etc.
it is down to every individual to do ardaas to maharaaj jee for the daan of shudh paath and to hope that their ardaas is worthy of being answered.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Anonymous User · 21 Aug 2008
ssa
hello Atma Singh. I must say that to me it seems that you speak very sincerely in your post which i aprreciate.
i would say that Guru Nanak would use the language of the person being spoken to. If speaking in Persian or Arabic or rektha no doubt he would says Allah. But when speaking panjabi why wouldnt he speak panjabi? Your objection, to me, is basically based on a personal prejudice against Panjabi being 'wrong' or uneducated-man's basha. Guru Nanak did not merely talk to muslim holy men. Is it okay for me to assume that he spoke to everyday people? People who only knew panjabi. Like I am suggesting saying 'sabad' is not wrong or invalid, it is panjabi.
i have heard Bengali/Bangla speakers says Krishno (or even what sounds like Krisno) rather than Krishna. Is their way wrong? They have such a strong Vaishnava tradition, how can anyone tell them their pronunciation is wrong? Those Bengalis wont accept it. They never heeded Hindi over their own accent.
i do not find your example about letters having dual sounds very convincing; Because I do pronounce Bhagat with the given B sound and not as a 'soft p' as you suggest. e.g. I say 'Bh'agti not Phagti. Likewise this is what I hear around me. I hear people say 'Bh'agat Singh not 'P'agat Singh! Just to give some context I grew up around panjabi speakers from villages who did not have much formal education, so were not taught hindi vocabularly. Alternatively panjabi accents do vary from region to region, but to say that 'Bh' is ever like 'p' is still unconvincing.
i am certainly not advising anyone on what 'shudh' paath is either.
all im saying is that over past 100 or 200 years so much has been invented, altered, lost or hidden or changed in our sikhi tradition due to often well-meaning but misguided influence. panjabi was deemed as illiterate chatter needed to be 'corrected' by hindi rather than a pure self-existing language valid in its own right. this is why people may find it inconceivable that sabad is not shabad. they think to say sabad makes you sound uneducated.
What I am saying about panjabi accent and panjabi version of words is so obvious yet few people realise.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
xzik101 · 21 Aug 2008
Navjot SIngh Jee, I don't think we should confuse colloquial language with the standard written language.
Every area has its own slangs and colloquial language. For example, I don't write English the way I speak English. I use many English slangs and words which are colloquial, but if I write them the way I speak, then my written English would be incorrect. No matter where you come from in the world and regardless of how you speak English, the written English is always the same all over the world.
Similarly, no matter which area in Punjab one might come from whether it is Majha Malwa or Doaba, but their written Punjabi is almost always identical, which is called Taksali Boli. When we speak Punjabi, we use many of our regional dialects, slangs which we never use in written Punjabi language because written language is always more refined and should never be confused with colloquial spoken language.
Even within Punjab we have many different dialects which pronouse words differently, but the written language is always the same Punjabi. Guru Nanak Dev Jee was from Nankana Sahib, and I have met Pakistani who are from Nankana Sahib, when they speak Punjabi they always pronouse Zaza and Shasha, which leads me to believe that if people from the area of Nankana Sahib pronouse these sounds, then it’s likely that Guru Nanak Dev Jee also pronounced these sounds.
In Gurmukhi Sasa has dual sounds which should not be confused with the Punjabi Sasa which only has one sound i.e. the sound of “s”. Depending on the word,it can be pronounced as “SSS” or “SSHH” just as many English words have dual sounds depending on the words. For example, the letter “C” can sound like an “s” if you write “Cell” but it can also sound like a “k” if you write “Call”. Same letter but with two different sounds. Similarly Sasa and Jaja have dual sounds in Gurmukhi depending on the word it’s used in. Many people confuse Punjab with Gurmukhi and make the mistake of applying the rules of Punjabi to Gurmukhi. We need to differenciate the two because they are not the same.
In modern Punjab, to make it less confusing schollors have added the bindi to some words which prior to that innovation had dual sounds. If you read some Punjab literature from before this linguistic innovation such as Shah Mohammad's Jangnama letters like Sassa and Jajja were used without the bindi, but after that innovation they now have bindi. After the linguistic innovation of bindi, in the Punjabi language Sassa and Jajja stoped having dual sounds as it did prior to this innovation. Since this innovation many people for the last 100 years or so have stopped using dual sound for even Gurmukhi when reading Gurbani as they once did because they now apply the rules of Punjabi language to the rules of Gurmukhi.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Atma Singh · 21 Aug 2008
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ
veer/bhain navjot jee,
"i would say that Guru Nanak would use the language of the person being spoken to. If speaking in Persian or Arabic or rektha no doubt he would says Allah".
maharaaj jee may deliver their updesh to an individual but it holds true and is meant for all humanity at all times - if you wish, i can prove that gurbaaNee backs-up this viewpoint very firmly.
so the question is, how will you decide when doing paath if maharaaj jee is saying allaho or allah? will you decide this upon the basis of who you think they are addressing?
from memory (i could be wrong), even when it is without an aunkharD and there is just a haha at the end, many still say alleh. did siree guroo nanak sahib jee never address muslims to whom They would have done uchaaran of the word as allah according to your own opinion above? please think about this point carefully before responding.
"i do not find your example about letters having dual sounds very convincing; Because I do pronounce Bhagat with the given B sound and not as a 'soft p' as you suggest. e.g. I say 'Bh'agti not Phagti. Likewise this is what I hear around me. I hear people say 'Bh'agat Singh not 'P'agat Singh! Just to give some context I grew up around panjabi speakers from villages who did not have much formal education, so were not taught hindi vocabularly. Alternatively panjabi accents do vary from region to region, but to say that 'Bh' is ever like 'p' is still unconvincing".
veer jee, please tell me if you pronounce the beginning of the word dharam and the end of the word yudh as the same sound (i think they have the same letter? lol). if you do, i promise i will investigate more as perhaps it is the way i do ucharan which is wrong. anyhow, i am sure veer kulbir singh jee will have many better examples for your consideration compared to the ones i have put forward.
also, i do not consider those that say 'allho' or 'sabad' as un-educated. that is an unfair assumption of your's.
veer/bhain xzil101 jee
your points are very interesting but i just wanted to humbly point-out one error. regarding:
"No matter where you come from in the world and regardless of how you speak English, the written English is always the same all over the world".
veer jee, this is incorrect - written english is not the same all over the world. for instance, americans spell 'civilisation' as 'civilization'. the letter 's' has for a long time been equivalent to a 'z' sound in english however americans have decided to place a 'z' where the english would have placed a 's' to get a 'z' sound in their americanised version of english. the word 'criticise' is also often spelt by them as 'criticize'.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Harcharan Singh · 22 Aug 2008
Sorry to go off topic, but just out of interested, do Canadians use real English or the AmericaniZed version?
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Anonymous User · 22 Aug 2008
ssa
hello xzik101,
The alphabet IS the language, regardless of dialects within the language. You wont hear Chinese sounds in English because though sounds arent part of the English alphabet/pronunciation system. It is very simple. How can we in our panjabi script have two 'R' sounds (one of which, if i am not mistaken, is unique to panjabi and does not occur in Hindi or Urdu), yet only one 'S'. So I still hold that there was never any Shasha or Zazza in Panjabi language. this talk of colloquial differences is essentially a digression.
I think it would be helpful if we kept to indian languages when citing examples. world languages are two varied. it is ridiculous to compare english and panjabi.
Do you know that there are two ways of pronouncing the Name Shiva? Shiva and Siva. Im not sure here but I think Siva is the Sanskrit way or saying it.
It is not correct to infer Guru Nanaks pronunciation on what muslims today from Nankana speak. Pakistanis have a heavy leaning to Urdu. Its in all likelyhood that they were speaking Urdu-tinged panjabi. Nanakana is not remote, no doubt the schools there are Urdu instruction schools.
There is no Gurmukhi without Panjabi. How on earth can you seperate the two? Unless to say MODERN panjabi and Gurmukhi are not the same, which is exactly what I am saying. If you do try and seperate the two then where do the rules of Gurmukhi pronunciation come from? Purely from the script- this is the only spund answer. Again this means there is no Shasha. What are others using as a term of reference if not the script (i.e. say what you see)? Their own personal language and biases? I,e, it must be shabad not sabad because this is how we pronounce these days? is this a sound approach?
Its a simple point. Gurmukhi has a set number of sounds/letters. Each letter represents a sound. we have four 'd' and four 't' sounds, four 'n' (five if you count the bindi) sounds and even two 'r' sounds! yet you are telling me the Sassa has a dual purpose? There are no 'dual' sounds in pure panjabi. You gave the example 'cell' this spelling probably represents the original pronunication of the word, from Latin or wherever it came from. Even here you can see that the English speakers converted into their language.
These modern 'scholars' came out of Urdu instruction schools. They wanted to use Hindi and Urdu vocabulary in their writting. Because they wanted to mobilise panjabi script for political use. This is modern panjabi. I say it is the reverse of what you wrote in your last paragraph. It is people using this modern panjabi with its recently invented notions of correct pronunciation that are saying there is shashas there because old pronunications sound foreign to them. Another example is the introduction of english grammar signs into modern panjabi. Old panjabi never had commas or question marks. I have paath pothis where the printer has inserted commas into text. Isnt this an outrage? Infact pad ched was created out of emulation of English- putting gaps between words. Old readers never needed those gaps but modern ones depend on them!
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Anonymous User · 22 Aug 2008
Atma singh
you first paragraph is confusing. I am not debating universality of what is written in paath. where did that come from? You are talking about muslim holymen. This point refers back to you.
"so the question is, how will you decide when doing paath if maharaaj jee is saying allaho or allah? will you decide this upon the basis of who you think they are addressing?"
no i will decide the pronunciation according to what is WRITTEN, as per the letters used to form the words.
what 'many' say is not an accurate way of deciding anything. if it says Allahu I will pronounce it like that. Imagining what Guru Nanak might have said to whoever- I do not see the need or relevance of this. Nor do I understand this fixation on muslim holy men (which is abit of a theme on this site). Above the limitations of ones own understanding- which might be wrong or right- we have what is written. Muslims themselves say Allah-hu-Akbar. What is wrong with Allahu. Perhaps it is a grammatical way of saying 'Allah hu' (Allah Is)- e.g. affirming Gods existance, as opposed to writting Allah which is the pure Noun.
Again are we worried that by accepting the pronunciation as written, though it may be different from how others say it, we feel we are saying that Guru Nanak was illiterate? because we regard others so highly above ourselves? Well he traveled quite abit and it was Gurus own choice to write in Gurmukhi script (rather than Shahmukhi). you object to this accusation Atma Singh but then tell me what other reason is there for this doubt over pronunciation?
I do indeed pronounce 'dh'ram and yu'dh' with the same sounds. it is indeed the same sound. I can prove this- just join the two words- "yudh-dharam' and say 'yudharam'. tell me if the sound is not the same? the confusion is arising because 'dharam' is pronounced with a downard tone on the 'a' sound that comes after 'dh'. but the 'dh' is the same in both words. experiment for yourselves and tell me if i am wrong.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
kulbir singh · 22 Aug 2008
Navjot jee,
You have written repeatedly that in Punjabi there is only one sound for one alhpabet but you forget that Gurmukhi script of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is not there to accomodate only Punjabi language. It contains words from Sanskrit, Farsi, Arabic, Sindhi, Punjabi, Marathi and many other languages. There are almost pure Farsi shabads in Gurbani. The alphabets are limited i.e. only 35 but sounds are more. Please ponder upon the following shabad from Tilang Raag:
ਯਕ ਅਰਜ ਗੁਫਤਮ ਪੇਸਿ ਤੋ ਦਰ ਗੋਸ ਕੁਨ ਕਰਤਾਰ ॥
ਹਕਾ ਕਬੀਰ ਕਰੀਮ ਤੂ ਬੇਐਬ ਪਰਵਦਗਾਰ ॥1॥
ਦੁਨੀਆ ਮੁਕਾਮੇ ਫਾਨੀ ਤਹਕੀਕ ਦਿਲ ਦਾਨੀ ॥
ਮਮ ਸਰ ਮੂਇ ਅਜਰਾਈਲ ਗਿਰਫਤਹ ਦਿਲ ਹੇਚਿ ਨ ਦਾਨੀ ॥1॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥
ਜਨ ਪਿਸਰ ਪਦਰ ਬਿਰਾਦਰਾਂ ਕਸ ਨੇਸ ਦਸਤੰਗੀਰ ॥
ਆਖਿਰ ਬਿਅਫਤਮ ਕਸ ਨ ਦਾਰਦ ਚੂੰ ਸਵਦ ਤਕਬੀਰ ॥2॥
ਸਬ ਰੋਜ ਗਸਤਮ ਦਰ ਹਵਾ ਕਰਦੇਮ ਬਦੀ ਖਿਆਲ ॥
ਗਾਹੇ ਨ ਨੇਕੀ ਕਾਰ ਕਰਦਮ ਮਮ ੲˆØੀ ਚਿਨੀ ਅਹਵਾਲ ॥3॥
ਬਦਬਖਤ ਹਮ ਚੁ ਬਖੀਲ ਗਾਫਿਲ ਬੇਨਜਰ ਬੇਬਾਕ ॥
ਨਾਨਕ ਬੁਗੋਯਦ ਜਨੁ ਤੁਰਾ ਤੇਰੇ ਚਾਕਰਾਂ ਪਾ ਖਾਕ ॥4॥1॥
This shabad was uttered by Siri Guru jee for a Persian person. In this shabad, Siri Guru jee has spoken predominently Farsi. The pronounciation also must have been naturally Farsi. I can't see why Guru Sahib would insist in speaking impure Farsi by speaking Z as J and Sh and S and Kh like Punjabi instead of Farsi Khe. Note the following about this shabad:
1) ਅਰਜ is pronounced as Arz and not as Arj. ਪੇਸਿ is pronounced as Pesh and not as Pes. This Farsi shabad written in Gurmukhi proves that the albhabet 'ਜ' has sound of both J and Z. Same way the 'ਸ' has the sound of both S and Sh. Furthermore, the 'ਫ' in ਗੁਫਤਮ is pronounced as 'F' and not as 'Ph' as in Punjabi.
2) ਜਨ in the para after Rahao, means woman and should be pronounced as Zan and not as Jan. Jan is a masculine gender noun in Punjabi and it means servant but Zan means woman in Farsi. Over here the pronounciation is Zan. and this way the alphabet 'ਜ' in olden days had the sound of both z and j.
3) ਸਬ in 3rd para should be pronounced as Shab and not as Sab. Shab means evening in Farsi and Sab means everything.
I could go through the whole shabad and list more examples but if you are not going to be convinced with above stated three examples, three more examples will not convince you either.
It is wrong to judge and read Punjabi through the lenses of Punjabi and Punjabi too of rural area. Gurmukhi is not Punjabi. Gurmukhi is Sant-Bhaasha that contains from many languages. To insist that should read Gurbani like rural area Punjabi is totally absurd.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
xzik101 · 22 Aug 2008
Until recently Dasam Granth did not have bindis in it. But they do now especially for the farsi words. Many banis like Zafar nama which were originally written in the Persian script but later written in the Gurmukhi script did not have bindi in it simply because during the olden times people knew where to add bindis. Today many people confuse Punjabi rules with Gurmukhi as a result we no longer have knowledge of where and when to pronounce Zaza and Shasha to farsi words, and now people have started adding bindis in Dasam Granth because they think that Punjabi and language of Gurbani are the same. I've seen many people wrongly pronounce the famous words of Guru Gobind Singh Jee in Zafarnama when he said:
"When all other methods fail, it is proper to hold the sword in hand"
the right way of saying it is:
Chu kar az hama helte dar guzasht|| halal ast burdan b shamshir dast||
the wrong way of saying it is:
Chu kar aj hama helte dar gujast|| hala ast burdan b samsir dast||
Unfortunately, most people I hear say it the wrong way. Gurbani is Sant Bhasha or Sant Boli, I don't know why people call it Punjabi. In Punjabi we say Dhi and Dha but in Gurbani it is Ki and Ka.
Even when we say Fateh we say:
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
We don't say
Waheguru Ji dha khalsa, Waheguru Ji dhi Fateh.
Let’s not confuse Punjabi with Sant Bhasha, they are not the same.
Also, even in Punjabi, I don't know where you got this whole thing about Punjabis not pronouncing Zaza and Shasha. Rural (pendu) Punjabi is not considered the standard refined Punjabi language. Punjabi Taksali boli is a refined language which does in fact use Zaza and Shasha sounds. Pick up any Punjabi book about the 1971 war, and there you will see that they pronounce those words by writing "Bangladesh" and "Niazi", not Bangladess and Niaji. Every Lahori I've met pronounces the Z and Sh sounds which is where Guru Nanak Dev Jee came from.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Khalsaspirit · 22 Aug 2008
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
Although the original topic was different but just like to add one more thing to add, according to Bhai Sahib Bhai Joginder Singh ji Talwara they have seen puratan hand written saroops that where 'Sh' sound is required scribers bended the right leg of Sassa to denote the 'Sh' sound. Number of times we mentioned this before and mention again that we are very convinced by the research done Bhai Sahib for which he spent almost four decades of his life. His recommendations which also include hand writing of Saroops in future not printing should be implemented right way. We can tell you for sure that if Panth decides to apply his recommendations and findings today we all will be on right track of Gurbani word Standardization, Ucharan and no more several Arths of one word. His all research leads to most Gurbani errors/mistakes free available to entire Panth. This implementation should be Panth’s urgent goal than any other task.
This year is 300th year of Guru Ship of Guru Granth Sahib, what a sad situation we have in Sikh masses that we do not even have standard Gurbani available yet, its Ucharan and Arths. WHAT A SHAME. What is point of celebrating 300th tercentennial year if we are not paying any tribute to Guru Sahib. Do we think that huge gatherings for celebrations will pay that tribute????? We hope this crisis will be over sooner than later but only depends upon Sikh masses not just a single Jatha or few Vidvaans.
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Anonymous User · 22 Aug 2008
ssa
1. I only used rural panjabi as a tangent point that it is NOT SO MUCH influenced by MODERN TRENDS. i did NOT say todays rural panjabi= panjabi used in Guru Granth. Probably I should stop using the word panjabi to describe Guru Granths language in sofar as how different modern panjabi is but traditional panjabi is the closest language to it that I know of.
And there is no such thing as 'Sant Basha', used in the sense that there was a specific language of this name.
2. "according to Bhai Sahib Bhai Joginder Singh ji Talwara they have seen..." as interesting as this sounds saying that someone saw something is not helpful to us. We need to see the primary evidence for ourselves. We can not accept hearsay.
3. Kulbir Singh
"It contains words..." it does not mean these words have not been made into Panjabi. words are imported into languages. Just like all indian languages have converted Sanskrit words into their native sounds.
naturally with the 'Farsi worship' that goes on around here you decided to chose Farsi type-language sloaks from all these languages.
"In this shabad, Siri Guru jee has spoken predominently Farsi." Predominately Farsi or completely Farsi? Because the follow on point ("The pronounciation also must have been naturally Farsi") only applies if it is completely Farsi. If it is not completely Farsi what is it? Some sort of mullah basha perhaps.
'Impure' Farsi? To have spoken Farsi in Panjab with a Panjabi accent would be impure? Not that I am going to speculate on what Guru Nanak did. I do not see how using ones own imagination can be a guiding principle here because people can imagine all kinds of things.
The jump from Arz to Arj is not that big. just like the jump from desh to des is not so imcomprehensable. Same with every other example you gave. Even with Jan. In the context it would be clear what was meant.
by the way should we even be refering to that language as Farsi? Wasnt the Persian back then called Pahlavi?
4. I AM NOT putting up this stuff as advice on how to read or pronounce paath. Im not a linguist or very knowledgable person and im wearing my thoughts/reasoning on my sleeve here. If people can see obvious flaws in my reasoning then all the better for everyone else.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
kulbir singh · 22 Aug 2008
Navjot jee,
I don't know what you are trying to say above. You obviously have different ideas about Gurbani paath. In another thread you had mentioned that you don't believe in placing bishraams while doing paath. We believe in bishraams and also in vishesh dhunis for certain alphabets while doing paath. We could be wrong and don't claim any authority on Gurbani paath. We are doing paath as we have been taught by Gursikhs in santhiya.
There are many schools of thought on Gurbani uchaaran. Your school of thought that does not believe in bishraams while doing paath and also insists on doing paath of Gurbani as a Rural Punjabi would, is a new addition to already numerous schools of Gurbani uchaaran.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Anonymous User · 23 Aug 2008
what i adovocate is simple appraoch; speak what is written as it is written. nothing more.
i wonder if there is an existing ucharan school that agrees with me.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Matheen · 23 Aug 2008
navjot Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> what i adovocate is simple appraoch; speak what
> is written as it is written. nothing more.
>
-------------------------------------------------------
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa!
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
Veer Ji, there are no commas in Gurmukhi, so it is important to know where to pause (vishraam). Pausing in the wrong place can change the meaning of a sentence.
Some words are written one way but pronounced differently, even in English. For example: 'Christ' is pronounced 'kriste' etc etc. Where we know the correct pronunciation, this should be used. It is still important to memorise Gurbani as it is written, though, so we can keep the original form intact in the future.
The oldest schools in Sikhi date back to Guru Ji's time and have preserved Guru Ji's teachings for us, IMHO.
Back to the original topic: the version posted by Bhai Sahib appears in historic texts and is correct. Some modern, faithless preachers don't believe that Guru Ji had any Shakti so they change stories to fit their beliefs.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Khalsaspirit · 27 Aug 2008
Waheguru ji ak kahlsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Matheen jio,
Quote "there are no commas in Gurmukhi, so it is important to know where to pause (vishraam). Pausing in the wrong place can change the meaning of a sentence."
You are right here.
navjot jio,
Please ponder upon this simple Pankiti and see how important is short pauses and Bishrams are:
ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਨ ਆਵੈ ਜਾਵੈ ॥ Panna 1040
Guru Mehar karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
kulbir singh · 28 Aug 2008
What a beautiful example you have given Khalsaspirit jeeo. If one places a bishraam after 'ਨ ' of this pankiti - ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਨ ਆਵੈ ਜਾਵੈ ॥ - only then the correct meaning can be derived. The correct meaning is - without Guru there is no mukti, and one comes and goes (i.e. takes birth and dies).
If you place a bishraam after ਮੁਕਤਿ , then the meaning would be that without Guru one gets mukti and one does not come and go i.e. does not take birth and dies. What a disaster of meanings it would be. So correct bishraams are important.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Khalsaspirit · 28 Aug 2008
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕਾ ਖਾਲਸਾ
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕੀ ਫਤਿਹ॥
ਭਾਈ ਕੁਲਬੀਰ ਸਿੰਘ ਜੀਉ,
ਗੁਰਬਾਣੀ ਦੇ ਅਥਾਹ ਸਮੁੰਦਰ ਵਿਚ ਗੁਰੂ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਨੇ ਐਸੇ ਐਸੇ ਹੀਰੇ ਮੋਤੀ ਜਵਾਹਰ ਤੇ ਬੇਅੰਤ ਲਾਲ ਰੱਖੇ ਹੋਏ ਨੇ ਕਿ ਕਿਸੇ ਇਕ ਤੇ ਵੀ ਨਿਗਾਹ ਪੈ ਜਾਵੇ ਤਾਂ ਐਸੇ ਨਦਰੋਂ ਨਿਹਾਲ ਜੋ ਜਾਈਦਾ ਕਿ ਬਸ ਪੁਛੋ ਹੀ ਨਾ। ਕਿੰਨੀ ਖੂਬਸੂਰਤੀ ਗੁਰੂ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਜੀ ਨੇ ਇਸ ਪਕਤੀ ਵਿਚ ਭਰ ਦਿਤੀ ਹੈ ਕਿ ਸਿਰਫ ਇਕ ਅੱਖਰ ਹੀ ਉਹ ਵੀ ਕਿਸੇ ਲਗ ਮਾਤਰ ਤੋ ਮੁਕਤ ਐਸੀ ਖੇਡ ਵਰਤਾ ਰਿਹਾ ਹੈ ਕਿ ਇਸ ਦੇ ਹੇਰ ਫੇਰ ਕਰਨ ਤੇ ਗੁਰੂ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਦੀ ਮਹਾਨ ਵਡਿਆਈ (ਮੁਕਤ ਕਰਨ ਦੀ) ਨੂੰ ਛਿਨ ਵਿਚ ਹੀ ਘੋਰ ਅਵੱਗਿਆ ਵਿਚ ਬਦਲ ਕੇ ਰੱਖ ਦਿੰਦਾ ਹੈ। ਇਥੇ "ਨ" ਅੱਖਰ ਦੇ ਹੱਥ ਵਿਚ ਕਿੰਨੀ ਤਾਕਤ ਹੈ। ਗੁਰਬਾਣੀ ਤਾਂਹੀਉ ਤਾਂ ਅਗਾਧ ਬੋਧ ਅਖਵਾਂਉਦੀ ਹੈ।
ਗੂਰੂ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਆਪ ਹੀ ਮਿਹਰ ਕਰਨ ਅਗਾਂਹ ਤੋਂ ਸ਼ੁੱਧ ਤੇ ਸ਼ਪੱਸ਼ਟ ਪਾਠ ਕਰਨ ਦੀ ਜਾਂਚ ਬਖਸ਼ਣ ਜੀ।
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕਾ ਖਾਲਸਾ
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕੀ ਫਤਿਹ॥
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Atma Singh · 28 Aug 2008
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ
khalsa jeeo,
let's first have darshan of the panktee as revealed:
ਬਿਨੁਗੁਰਮੁਕਤਿਨਆਵੈਜਾਵੈ
now, how about following way of doing bishraam - is it possible according to viyakaraN?
ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ , ਮੁਕਤਿ ਨ ਆਵੈ ; ਜਾਵੈ
i.e. without the satguroo , mukhti cannot be received/will not arrive ; the person will have to leave i.e. without realising that 'gobind milan kee eh tereee bariaa'.
sometimes i think it helps to do paath of the panktees both before and after panktees such as this, if applicable. sometimes, the rhythm they follow with their bishraams can help us feel more informed when doing bishraams of panktees such as this.
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Khalsaspirit · 28 Aug 2008
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Bhai Atama Singh jio,
As we explained above Gurbani has all the jewels needed for Jagasu. We will try to decipher your situation by Gurbani only. We do not know Gurbani viyakaran yet but we have bharosa on Guru Sahib that they answered every thing when we asked. Your assumption of bishram ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ , ਮੁਕਤਿ ਨ ਆਵੈ ; ਜਾਵੈ is not right. The reason is if we consider that "mukhti cannot be received/will not arrive" then ਜਾਵੈ alone do not tell anything means "leave to where?" ਭਾਵ ਕਿਥੇ ਨੂੰ ਜਾਵੈ?. So correct pause is ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਨ, ਆਵੈ ਜਾਵੈ ॥
How a beginner or learner would know where to place right bishraam. We think either we should have santhyia from a Shudh Paathi Singh/Singhni or if do not have time or those circumstances for santhiya then Start a Sehaj Paath with a Ardass asking Guru Sahib to lead us for Shudh paath. We have bharosa that Guru Sahib will lead you, send someone to you or you will meet to a GurSikh who will be familiar with Gurbani Paath but key thing is Sehaj Paath and Gurbani Abhiyaas.
Now by reading following Pantkitis which came before, not just once or twice but thrice, after reading those your automatic bishraam will be ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਨ, ਆਵੈ ਜਾਵੈ ॥
ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਨ ਕੋਊ ਪਾਵੈ ਮਨਿ ਵੇਖਹੁ ਕਰਿ ਬੀਚਾਰੀ ॥੨॥ Panna ੪੯੫
ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਨ ਪਾਈਐ ਭਾਈ ॥੪॥੫॥੭॥ Panna ੮੬੪
ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਨ ਹੋਈਐ ਮੀਤਾ ॥ Panna ੧੦੧੯
Bhai Atma Singh ji other key thing we would like to share with you whether you like it or not please ponder upon (if not done so) the quiz we posted about couple of months ago under "Dedicated to Guru Grant Sahib.." topic. This is our belief whoever started to pay close attention to laga matra Guru Sahib surely do more kirpa. As explained in other topic by Bhai Kulbir Singh jee about Bhai sahib Randhir Singh jee that how Bhai Sahib's surti got stuck on same word at three places in a dutuki having three different meaning just because of Lagamatra, which ended up with their scholarly work as GURBANI DIYAN LAGAMATRA(N) DI VILAKHANTA.
This year is Guru Sahib's tercentennial year we encourage every Guru ka Sikh to have their own Sehaj Paath (if not done before), every one should have complete Darshan of Guru Sahib.
Bhul Chook di maafi,
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Anonymous User · 29 Aug 2008
no no no!
such a SHORT sloak. sloaks by their nature are short. why do you think that it needs a bishram? the meaning is clear if you read it as it is.
cant you see what you are saying? that adding a bishram changes the meaning. which is EXACTLY why you shouldnt do it.
why dont you read it aloud and see for yourself.
I say that Gurbani sloaks need to be read as they are to completion to be understand. by inserting a bishram you are not only doing something unnecessary
but you are misleading yourself and others.
if we have humility then we do not need to satisfy ourselves that we understand what is Written, we can accept it when we do not understand rather than playing with bishraams etc
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Khalsaspirit · 01 Sep 2008
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
navjot jio,
Help yourself! Your thought of having FREE STYLE Gurbani Ucharan would not be supported by any school of thought exists today. May be you can open up new one having express Ucharan of Gurbani without any short pauses or Bishrams but before opening up that school please ponder upon this pankiti which we also posted in another topic too from sri Anand Sahib:
ਅੰਗੀਕਾਰੁ ਓਹੁ ਕਰੇ ਤੇਰਾ ਕਾਰਜ ਸਭਿ ਸਵਾਰਣਾ ॥
If you are a Amritdhari Singh then you read this pankiti twice a day minimun which means 365x2=730 times a year. Now if we follow your free style Gurbani Ucharan then no matter its loud or soft your ucharan for ਅੰਗੀਕਾਰੁ ਓਹੁ would be together as ਅੰਗੀਕਾਰੋ leaving a complete word ਓਹੁ or eaten up a word ਜਾਂ ਇੰਝ ਕਹਿ ਲਈਏ ਨਿਗਲ ਗਿਆ but if you have a short pause after ਅੰਗੀਕਾਰੁ then this ਓਹੁ word will be kept in the uncharan and right meanings will come out. By doing express reading you are not only changing the meaning but also eating or missing a complete word. Hence it is very imporatnt to read Gurbani carefully with bishrams where they are required THE MOST. ਸੋ ਦੋਏ ਕਰ ਜੋੜ ਬੇਨਤੀ ਹੈ ਜੀ ਕਿ ਆਪਣਾ ਹਠ ਛੱਡੋ ਨਹੀਂ ਤਾਂ ਇਹ ਹਠ ਰਾਹੇ ਤਾਂ ਦੂਰ ਦੀ ਗੱਲ ਪਰ ਕੁਰਾਹੇ ਜ਼ਰੂਰ ਪਾ ਸਕਦਾ ਹੈ।
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ki khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib and the Haughty Pandit
Anonymous User · 02 Sep 2008
khalsaspirit
no. what you suggest seems absurd to me. i would pronounce all the sounds that are written. so for me it would be 'angeekaarU ohU'. The 'Oh' or 'OOh' sound of Oora is distinct from the 'Uck' sound of the aunkar. this wouldnt be difficult to read in Lareedar format, as I would read it letter by letter.