Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 18 Aug 2008

I listened to the last part of discussion with Sant Jagjit Singh Harkhowal, posted by SunSingh. He asked the following question to Sant jee: - some people think when this jev get bedah mukht avastha or merge with vahiguroo even then atma of this jev have some kind of paichaan? First of all, it won't be out of place to mention that excellent questions were asked and good vichaar came out of it. Sant jee responded very patiently and in detail. This is the kind of discussion that gursikhs should carry out when meeting. Sant jee's response to the above question was that what any person subscribing to the Advaita Vedanta would have given. I will, if necessary, post exact wording at a later time since I don't have the recording available to me at this time. His response to the question was that once the jeev merges with Vaheguru, it loses it's identity forever. Then the Singh who was asking the questions asked a very intelligent question. He said, what about instances when Mahapurakhs who have left their body and gone to Sachkhand, come to give darshan to their beloved ones who are still on Earth. At this Sant jee responded by saying that it's not those Mahapurakhs who come but Vaheguru who takes on their form and comes to fulfill the wishes of the jigiasoo on Earth. This was shocking for me since it was totally against the philosophy of Gurmat. This is basically Advaita Vedanta that was being preached by Sant jee. Here are some of the questions that arise from this vichaar: 1) If it was only Brahm all along (and not jeev and Brahm), then how did Brahm falter in the first place and got entangled in the illusion of Maya? We know that Brahm is infallible and cannot make a mistake. Then how did it make this mistake of falling for maya in the original instance? If we believe in some form of Duvaite (there are many schools of thought within Duvait) then we don't have to explain this since it is the jeev that might have faltered in the first place and not Brahm. 2) If we were to believe the above stated theory of Sant jee, it would mean that our Guru Sahibaan don't exist any longer. They have lost their identities and are now merged in Vaheguru. So what's the point of praying to them? Why not do ardaas before Vaheguru only? Think about it. If our Guru Sahibaan had been anihilated (May God forgive me for using this language) as stated by Sant jee in the above vichaar, then Gurbani would not have contained pankitis invoking Guru Sahibaan. What's the point of saying 'Gur Raamdaas Rakho Sharnaayee' if Siri Guru Raamdaas jee does not exist any longer and only Vaheguru exists? 3) Gurmat talks about Sad-jeevan (everlasting life) and sad-jeevan in full bliss. One cannot have bliss if one loses surti i.e. identity or consciousness. If jeev gets merged in Vaheguru in such way as Advaita Vedanta suggests, then this jeev cannot be in Anand since in order to enjoy Anand, one has to have an identity. Without consciousness one cannot have anand. 4) What's the point of doing bhagti if you are to get anihilated i.e. destroyed. To me this seems like a suicide. Why would someone do it? 5) This definition of salvation is against what all other mahapurakhs have described. Sikh salvation is entry into Sachkhand or Begumpura. This Sachkhand as per description given by Gurbani and Gursikhs who have reached there is not such that is without Bhagats. It is full of Bhagats who reside there enjoying everlasting life and bliss. 6) If we believe that above stated idea of the ultimate spiritual avastha, then such pankitis as 'Bhagat Terai Mann Bhaavde, Dar sohan Keerat Gaavde|| (9th pauri of Siri Asa kee veer) would be rendered meaningless. How can you have bhagats singing keerat of Vaheguru at his Dar, when they have merged in him and no longer have identities. Please explain this. Vedant has many theories within itself but Advait definitely is not close to Gursikhi. Below is a post I wrote on this subject some time ago. It presents thoughts of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh describing the ultimate abode of a Gursikh and how Bhagats reside in the next world: [quote] Translated from page 71-72 of 'SachKhand Darshan' by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee: Bhagat Ravidaas jee in love (Shabad: Beghampura Shehar ko nayo on ang 345 of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee) gives Sach Khand the name of Beghumpura i.e. the place where there is no sorrow (Be-Gham-pura) because in Beghampura there is no sorrow, worry, anxiety and nor is there any tax as in this mortal world. There is no worldly riches and wealth there. There is no fear of sin and nor there is regression and degeneration of mind there. Bhagat jee is saying that they have attained a very great dwelling-place where there is always happiness. Governments or kings in this land don't change like worldly governments and kings. Kingdom of Vaheguru always stays eternal. This city of Beghampura is very densely populated and very prosperous too. Since Beghampura is the place where Vaheguru resides (in his pure form) this dwelling is just as famous as Vaheguru himself. In this city, Bhagats loaded with the wealth of Naam and accepted by Vaheguru reside and they are fully knowledgeable of the secrets of the palace of Vaheguru. They can enjoy the bliss of this palace as they please i.e. there is no stopping to them. If they will, they can come back to this world (Earth) at their will as per the Gurbani hukam 'Gurmukh aaye jaaye nisung'. In this dwelling of Sach Khand one realises what real freedom is. Bhagat jee declares that only those ones who reside in Sach Khand are his friends. Only their friendship can last in the mortal world and the Sach Khand world. *********Translation over********** Above Bhai Sahib jee has clearly stated that Bhagats are very much alive and not decimated in Sach Khand. They are not only alive but at will they can come to this world or go anywhere they want. There is total freedom to them. They can go anywhere unhindered. If we read the article, 'Akal Purakh dee Dargaah' in Andithee Duniya, we get clear understanding that Bhagats do in fact reside in the next world and they don't lose their identity. I will herein give few quotations from Bhai Sahib's books to prove this point: Andithee Duniya quotations are from Edition 6, 1990. 1) Page 96 of Andithee Duniya: In the dargaah of Vaheguru (Har Dargaah andar), reside millions and billions of servants or bhagats of Vaheguru, who reside with Vaheguru in such manner that they don't lose sight of him even for one moment. This unseen and unreachable (for mortal beings) world exists totally away from the sight of the worldly people of this world (our world – Earth). This world of Nirankaar or Vaheguru is much more densely and prosperously populated than the mortal world. Exact Punjabi quote is: Ih duniya (Sach Khand) aisee hee ghugg vasdee hai jaise ke drishtmaan duniya (physical world i.e. mortal world); sagon uh vadere ghugg vasdee hai. Yatha Gurvaak (refer to the Gurbani Hukam below). KOT MEHAL JA KAE DARBARE || NIMAKH NIMAKH VASAI TIN NAALAY || 2) Page 96 of Andithee Duniya SOOKH MEHAL JA KE OOCH DUYAARAY || TAA MEH VAASEH BHAGAT PYAARAY || (Ang 739) Billions and Billions of khoohaniyaan i.e. regiments of Bhagats reside in the eternal and true Sachkhandee Darbaar of Vaheguru. By the kirpa of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj ones who have collected the true wealth of Naam took this wealth with them to Sach Khand. Khoohani means a regiment that contains x number of soldiers, infantry, elephants, horses etc. Bhai Sahib used the world khoohani to describe the colonies of Bhagats there. 3) Page 88 of Andithee Duniya The existence of the dargaah (darbaar) of Vaheguru is such a notion that a gursikh must have faith in and it is pure Gurmat to do so. According to Gurmat there is Nirankaar's Khand i.e. Sach Khand and there is the Darbaar of Vaheguru too. Yathaa Gurvaak: NIRANKAAR KAI DESH JAAHE, TAAN SUKH LAHEH MAHAL || The happiness-giving palace and the land of Vaheguru Nirankaar is surely there in the next world. O Gursikho, believe this truth without any doubt. There are many more examples I can give from Bhai Sahib's books that will prove beyond doubt that the Bhagats don't die in the next world or don't cease to exist; and not only do they exist but they stay in full bliss. The bhagats have full freedom and at their will can come to this mortal world of ours as well. "Gurmukh aaye jaaye nisung" is the pankiti that Bhai Sahib has quoted to prove this. I personally was having hard time swallowing some of the assertions by my veers and bhains that stated that Singhs like Baba Deep Singh jee and Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee had decimated into Vaheguru. Verily, they are still alive and at their will can come to this world. Bhai Sahib also writes that since there is no maaiya in Sach Khand, Bhagats don't have to do any effort to do bhagtee there because their surtee just does not go out of Naam and Sifat Salaah. What a great world this is. Oh! May we become citizens of this world.[/quote] Daas has a lot of respect for Sant Jagjit Singh jee Harkhowal. I bow my head to his Nirmal Khalsa Rehit and possession of so much Brahm Vidya. This daas has very limited knowledge of Gurmat and based on this meagre knowledge is seeking the above stated clarification. Please don't take any offense. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harcharan Singh · 18 Aug 2008

Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, One question - I respect the approach you have taken above i.e. giving respect to Sant Ji yet questioning their opinion respectfully etc, you have done this as though you are willing to open mindedly debate - implying there is a possibilty that you may change your opinion if a good arguement is put forward. I am just interested to know, in all honesty, would you (and have you) ever disagreed with a theory or opinion of Bhai Randhir Singh Ji - i.e. you are implying that Sant Ji could be wrong (with all duerespect of course) but would you agree the same could also be true for Bhai Randhir Singh Ji. I apologise if this seems off topic, but I feel any vichaar/discussion is a complete waste of time if participants are already predisposed to a certain opinion and are unlikely to ever disagree with or change their inherited thought (via their role model) - as this would put them at odds with their sangat/jathaa. I hope you will understand why I am bringing up this point. Dhanvaad.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 18 Aug 2008

[quote] I am just interested to know, in all honesty, would you (and have you) ever disagreed with a theory or opinion of Bhai Randhir Singh Ji - i.e. you are implying that Sant Ji could be wrong (with all duerespect of course) but would you agree the same could also be true for Bhai Randhir Singh Ji.[/quote] This question does not have any relevance with this topic. This topic is not about agreeing or disagreeing with Sant jee or Bhai Sahib. This topic is about whether Gurmat agrees with Advaita Vedanta. It does not matter if I have ever disagreed with Bhai Sahib or not. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

khalistan_zindabaad · 18 Aug 2008

Harcharan Singh Has a valid question, Bhai Sahib jee answer it please, and if so on what topics. Its about gurmat or your version of gurmat agreeing/disagreeing with baba jees veechar...

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 18 Aug 2008

Veer Khalistan-zindabad jeeo, [quote] Harcharan Singh Has a valid question, Bhai Sahib jee answer it please, and if so on what topics. Its about gurmat or your version of gurmat agreeing/disagreeing with baba jees veechar...[/quote] I shouldn't have to answer this question. It's a personal question and not related to the topic. But I will say this much that out of all books I have read and all authors I have read, Bhai Sahib and his books in my opinion are the best Gurmat philosophy literature available to us, after Bhai Gurdas jee and Bhai Nandlal jee. For some it may be Sant Gurbachan Singh jee's katha of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee available to us. For others it could be discourses of Sant Rarewale and yet others may like Panth Parkash of Giani Gian Singh or Sooraj Parkash Granth. I respect them all. I have been influenced to some degree by all. The pankiti "Abhul Guru Kartar" applies to all includings Sants and Bhai Sahib jee. Only Guru and Kartar are exempt from making a mistake. As for Gurmat or my version of Gurmat, I am not sure what you are trying to say. We have Gurbani and let Gurbani decide what Gurmat is. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

xzik101 · 18 Aug 2008

This is a very good topic of discussion Kulbir Singh Jee. I'm glad you have started this. Harcharan Singh Ji and Khalistan Zindabad Ji, the topic of this discussion is whether or not Advaid Vedant is in line with Gurmat not what Kulbir Singh jee's personal beleifs are. Why not address the topic at hand instead of deviating from the topic? Who cares what Kulbir Singh's personal views are because that's got nothing to do with the topic.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

N30 S!NGH · 18 Aug 2008

I ll post my thoughts on this topic whenever vahiguroo allows me some free time from changing my son diapers..lol just an general comment regarding sant ji. Sant ji is very loving gurmukh, any question you ask them, they will answer any question even if it may seem questioning their beleifs or further doing constructive debate..i by kirpa of vahiguroo asked these questions above after bhai kulbir singh ji constructive debated posted long time ago in old tapoban forum between bhai kulbir singh ji, avidya and J Singh..sant ji already left for india but they usually come to toronto every year, when they do come next year. Please swing by ask him any questions, make sure you record them and post it on the web so others can take laha as well.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

xzik101 · 18 Aug 2008

It's interesting to note that during the Bhagti movement, all the Bhagti cults which arose during the Ramanandi Shakhaa(which includes Ravidas, Kabir, NamDev etc), Gaudiyaa mat followed either Vashisht Dvait or Dvait. Non followed Advait. Then why would Sikhi which also arose during the Bhagti movement and is very similar to the other condemporary Bhagti cults take a 90 degree turn and follow Advait Vedant? If the Atma no longer has any Vajood after being merged with Akal Purkh, then that would imply that the Gurus have also merged and thus no longer exist. But then the question arises, who are we invoking when doing Ardas to Guru jee? since Guru jee no longer exists? Can Guru Nanak Dev jee no longer give us his blessings since he no longer exists? All the great Brahmgianis and GurSikhs who have had darshan of the Gurus, who did they see if Guru Jee no longer exists? After all, if the Gurus and Brahmgianis who have merged with Vaheguru no longer exist, then why do people still have their darshan? To me it seems, Advait Vedant is not compatible with Gurmat. They are to distinct philosophies.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Matheen · 18 Aug 2008

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Personally, Dass sees no conflict between what is being called 'Advait Vedanta' and 'Gurmat'. This is something I read on sikhawareness forum: "we have our own form of advaita (a term used repeatedly by Guru Maharaj in Akal Ustat and Gyan Prabodh). This is an old discussion, there is masses written on this so please search past discussions. Please show me one shabad that says Atma is anything different from Parmatma. Aham Brahamasmi (I am that) = So ham (I am Him) = same term used in shabad by Guru Nanak Dev ji twice (ANg.60 and.599)." Repeatedly Guru Ji tells us that bhagat and Akaal are one e.g. "Har, Har Jan, Doee Ek Hai"; "Tu Tu Karta, Tu Hoa"; and many other times as well. Bhai Gurdas Ji also helps us understand this. Gurbani also tells us directly and indirectly that Guru Sahib was/is Waheguru in physical form. I disagree with Veer Kulbir Singh Ji when you write that "5) This definition of salvation is against what all other mahapurakhs have described..." If you read the personal experiences of pooran Mahapursh and their Bhagti of putting Guru Ji's teachings into practice,(e.g. the personal diary of Sant Isher Singh Ji , Rarewale, was recently put on the internet), this is exactly what Sachkhand is and furthermore, we don't need to wait until after death to reach there. Our Guru Sahib existed, exist and will always exist. They are still with us in Sargun saroop of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Dass is pressed for time but will try to write more later. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Sunsingh · 19 Aug 2008

Kulbir Singh ji, in a past post on this subject you wrote: "My question is, is Vedant according to Gurmat? Is Advaitvaad preached by Vedant, according to Gurmat? Vedant in my opinion is opposed to Prema-Bhagti because they don't believe in a God separate from the Jeev and consider jeev to be God (Aham Brahmasiya) but as far as I know, Gurmat is all about Prema-bhagti. Aham-Brahmasiya is not according to Gurmat. Tu Tu karta Tu hooya (not mai hooya), mujh meh raha na hoo. In other words, Mai became tum but not tum becoming mai as is the case in Vedant. There is no doubt that Vedant is a great philosophy and it worked very well to tackle Buddhism's atheism but it is far from the Gurmat philosophy of Vaheguru and jeev. It would be interesting to know Sant jee's or their companions' views on Vedant and Gurmat." -Before we discuss whether advait is inline with Gurmat, we must agree upon what advait is. I was reading posts from Sikhawareness, and somebody posted: "in Gurmat very simply; maya = 3 gunas, everything is of 3 gunas inc mind, Atma is not touched by 3 gunas = Parmatma (described as 'advaita'). Its that simple!" He also described the need for vedant: "Why the need for Vedant? Because Gurbani explicitly talks of the four fold antahkaran, the 4 avasthas, kaivalya mukhti, etc. When the Guru talks of the four states, what do you derive from that? How then do you interpret references to the 'body' being unveiled by the Guru? Which body? When he talks of the 'fourth' state in Sidh Gosht, what does that mean? What is the nature of jivan mukt? What are the forms of praman or valid knowledge for Gurmat? What about the guns? What is meant by going beyond the three gunas? How? What is meant when bhai Gurdas Ji talks of vasna? What is the real meaning of the term? What is the nature of the 'unseeing seeing'? etc, etc. This is where Vedant comes in. It is used to explain the basic structural model of human consciousness, its components and its interactions in Gurmat. From that you will notice other bits of Gurbani which before you read over mindlessly, now they ring out with new meaning. It is also used to explain the subtlest aspects of the highest experiences (not necessarily the initial process of rising vivek). How else can you explain the existence of the study of Vedant for the last 400 years of Sikh history by gursikhs (recall Bhai Gurdas studied in Kashi and is using Vedantic concepts in his Kabits) or Kavi Sukhdev's 'Adhyatam Prakash'?" Looking at Kulbir Singh ji's points above: 1) If it was only Brahm all along (and not jeev and Brahm), then how did Brahm falter in the first place and got entangled in the illusion of Maya? We know that Brahm is infallible and cannot make a mistake. Then how did it make this mistake of falling for maya in the original instance? If we believe in some form of Duvaite (there are many schools of thought within Duvait) then we don't have to explain this since it is the jeev that might have faltered in the first place and not Brahm. -"Dvaita Vaad is about as far as you could get in terms of Vedant from Gurmat! It holds firmly to three real and seperate realities, Jiv, Ishvar and Jagat. Within them are five real differences, between jiva and matter, Jiv and vishnu, etc, etc. It is described as the extreme realist form, perhaps more like Nyaya (which some Madhavas built on). There is no maya in Dvaita vaad! Ishvar is entirely sargun as sargun Vishnu in dvaita vaad! Jiv is dependent but not of the same thing as Ishvar...whereas in Gurmat the two are repeatedly described as being one and the same. the metaphors used in Gurbani all stem from advaitavad, e.g. moon reflecting in water, the two birds in one tree, rope and the snake, water and the pot, wave and the ocean, seed and the fruit, etc, etc. " -TSingh 2) If we were to believe the above stated theory of Sant jee, it would mean that our Guru Sahibaan don't exist any longer. They have lost their identities and are now merged in Vaheguru. So what's the point of praying to them? Why not do ardaas before Vaheguru only? Think about it. If our Guru Sahibaan had been anihilated (May God forgive me for using this language) as stated by Sant jee in the above vichaar, then Gurbani would not have contained pankitis invoking Guru Sahibaan. What's the point of saying 'Gur Raamdaas Rakho Sharnaayee' if Siri Guru Raamdaas jee does not exist any longer and only Vaheguru exists? -Guru is Waheguru himself according to Gurbani (ang 442, 1142). So the same Guru existed before taking avtar of Guru Nanak, and the same Guru exists now after the Guru left his sareer. 3) Gurmat talks about Sad-jeevan (everlasting life) and sad-jeevan in full bliss. One cannot have bliss if one loses surti i.e. identity or consciousness. If jeev gets merged in Vaheguru in such way as Advaita Vedanta suggests, then this jeev cannot be in Anand since in order to enjoy Anand, one has to have an identity. Without consciousness one cannot have anand. & 4) What's the point of doing bhagti if you are to get anihilated i.e. destroyed. To me this seems like a suicide. Why would someone do it? -I think what sant ji was saying is that the the sense of being separate (which is created by ego) is abolished, it does not mean consciousness is destroyed. In Bachittar Natak, Guru ji refers to his state before taking Avtar. He wrote that he became one with God. Gurbani also states that the soul bride becomes one with God, merges with God(ang 737 - http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=KeertanPage&K=737&L=6; Ang 1107 http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=KeertanPage&K=1107&L=7). Our dhristi (vision) sees falsely b/c of our haumai, for this reason we see ourselves as being apart from waheguru when in reality we are really one with waheguru. This is why Gurbani states that we are separated from God by a veil thinner than the wing of a butterfly; there is no physical barrier actually keeping us apart from God, but the barrier of ego which makes us think we are separate. ਹਉ ਹਉ ਭੀਤਿ ਭਇਓ ਹੈ ਬੀਚੋ; ਸੁਨਤ ਦੇਸਿ ਨਿਕਟਾਇਓ ॥ The wall of pride and ego intervenes between me and Him. He is heard to be close by in the country. ਭਾਂਭੀਰੀ ਕੇ ਪਾਤ ਪਰਦੋ; ਬਿਨੁ ਪੇਖੇ ਦੂਰਾਇਓ ॥੩॥ Between me and the Lord is the fine curtain like the wings of a butter-fly but seeing Him not, I deem Him distant. -(Ang 624) 5) This definition of salvation is against what all other mahapurakhs have described. Sikh salvation is entry into Sachkhand or Begumpura. This Sachkhand as per description given by Gurbani and Gursikhs who have reached there is not such that is without Bhagats. It is full of Bhagats who reside there enjoying everlasting life and bliss. -Sachkhand is an avastha, one who is jeevanmukt is at the avastha of bhramgian, they are in sachkhand. Begampura also refers to this avastha. It also exists as a place, I believe, for after the bhramgyani leaves the sareer. No sant who has had darshan of sachkhand actually writes that it is any different as far as I know. 6) If we believe that above stated idea of the ultimate spiritual avastha, then such pankitis as 'Bhagat Terai Mann Bhaavde, Dar sohan Keerat Gaavde|| (9th pauri of Siri Asa kee veer) would be rendered meaningless. How can you have bhagats singing keerat of Vaheguru at his Dar, when they have merged in him and no longer have identities. Please explain this. -explained above. Hope that clarifies things. btw, for the sake of full disclosure, most of the questions with sant ji were not asked by myself, but by another.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 19 Aug 2008

Sunsingh jeeo, [quote] "Why the need for Vedant? Because Gurbani explicitly talks of the four fold antahkaran, the 4 avasthas, kaivalya mukhti, etc. When the Guru talks of the four states, what do you derive from that? [/quote] I am assuming you are talking about the 3 states of maya namely Rajo, Sato and Tamo. The fourth one i.e. Turiya or Chauthapad is the state beyong maya and Gursikh stays in this avastha. But staying in this avastha does not mean that a Gursikh is staying without the deity Vaheguru or has become the deity himself. This avastha according to Gurmat is the avastha in which a Gursikh is Majzoob (merged) in the Preet of Dib-Lateefi Charan Kamal of Vaheguru jee. In this avastha, the Gursikh is totally one with Vaheguru and so much so that to the normal eye, the two are indistinguishable but this does not mean that a Gursikh has lost identity. The Gursikh in this avastha is totally in bliss and to be in bliss or to enjoy bliss, one has to retain identity and consciousness. [quote] This is where Vedant comes in. It is used to explain the basic structural model of human consciousness, its components and its interactions in Gurmat. From that you will notice other bits of Gurbani which before you read over mindlessly, now they ring out with new meaning. It is also used to explain the subtlest aspects of the highest experiences (not necessarily the initial process of rising vivek). How else can you explain the existence of the study of Vedant for the last 400 years of Sikh history by gursikhs (recall Bhai Gurdas studied in Kashi and is using Vedantic concepts in his Kabits) or Kavi Sukhdev's 'Adhyatam Prakash'?" [/quote] What I can understand from the above paragraph is that Gurmat has nothing new to offer to the world and it is merely giving to the world what is already given by founders or Advaita Vedanta. Gurmat has been reduced to a Samprada of the Hindu Dharma and this is what so many pseudo-scholars want. From what I have studied, Gurmat is neither fully agreeable to Advaita nor Dvaita and it's many schools of thought. Gurmat is unique. Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee did not merely offer old wine in a new bottle. There is no doubt that Siri Guru jee and Gurmat has been in working in all four Yugs but the ultimate reality offered by Gurmat has always been beyond the comprehension of Vedas or Vedant. [quote] -"Dvaita Vaad is about as far as you could get in terms of Vedant from Gurmat! It holds firmly to three real and seperate realities, Jiv, Ishvar and Jagat. Within them are five real differences, between jiva and matter, Jiv and vishnu, etc, etc. It is described as the extreme realist form, perhaps more like Nyaya (which some Madhavas built on). There is no maya in Dvaita vaad! Ishvar is entirely sargun as sargun Vishnu in dvaita vaad! Jiv is dependent but not of the same thing as Ishvar...whereas in Gurmat the two are repeatedly described as being one and the same. the metaphors used in Gurbani all stem from advaitavad, e.g. moon reflecting in water, the two birds in one tree, rope and the snake, water and the pot, wave and the ocean, seed and the fruit, etc, etc. " -TSingh [/quote] I have never felt or said that Gurmat is fully in agreement with Dvaita. I don't think Gurmat agrees with the Dvaita of Madhvacharay and its five eternal differences because if we were to agree to the five eternal differences described by Madhvacharya, then we will also agree that Jada i.e. Prakriti i.e. Maya i.e. this world is eternal just as Ishwar is. Gurbani has made it clear that Drishtmaan hai sagal mithena. This world is not eternal. In this respect it seems Gurmat is closer to Advaita. On the other hand, it seems that Gurmat preaches that jeev is eternal and in this respect it is closer to Dvaita. Below is a shabad to backup this claim: ਗੋਂਡ ਮਹਲਾ 5 ॥ ਅਚਰਜ ਕਥਾ ਮਹਾ ਅਨੂਪ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਾਤਮਾ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਕਾ ਰੂਪੁ ॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਬੂਢਾ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਬਾਲਾ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਸੁ ਦੂਖੁ ਨਹੀ ਜਮ ਜਾਲਾ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਬਿਨਸੈ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਜਾਇ ॥ ਆਦਿ ਜੁਗਾਦੀ ਰਹਿਆ ਸਮਾਇ ॥1॥ ਨਾ ਇਸੁ ਉਸਨੁ ਨਹੀ ਇਸੁ ਸੀਤੁ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਸੁ ਦੁਸਮਨੁ ਨਾ ਇਸੁ ਮੀਤੁ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਸੁ ਹਰਖੁ ਨਹੀ ਇਸੁ ਸੋਗੁ ॥ ਸਭੁ ਕਿਛੁ ਇਸ ਕਾ ਇਹੁ ਕਰਨੈ ਜੋਗੁ ॥2॥ ਨਾ ਇਸੁ ਬਾਪੁ ਨਹੀ ਇਸੁ ਮਾਇਆ ॥ ਇਹੁ ਅਪਰੰਪਰੁ ਹੋਤਾ ਆਇਆ ॥ ਪਾਪ ਪੁੰਨ ਕਾ ਇਸੁ ਲੇਪੁ ਨ ਲਾਗੈ ॥ ਘਟ ਘਟ ਅੰਤਰਿ ਸਦ ਹੀ ਜਾਗੈ ॥3॥ Look at the following pankiti: ਪ੍ਰਾਤਮਾ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਕਾ ਰੂਪੁ ॥ Please notice that it's Praatam and not Parmatma (Parm + Aatma = Vaheguru). Pratma on the other hand means Aatma. ਨਾ ਇਸੁ ਬਾਪੁ ਨਹੀ ਇਸੁ ਮਾਇਆ ॥ ਇਹੁ ਅਪਰੰਪਰੁ ਹੋਤਾ ਆਇਆ ॥ These pankitis prove beyond doubt that the jeev has always been there. The above shabad talks about the nature of Jeev when in it's purest form. The purest form of the jeev is Aatma. In this form, the mann (mind) of the Atma is Atma-roop i.e. Jyot-roop as opposed to being coloured in the colour of maya. There is another shabad in Raag Gaund, by Siri Kabir jee, that tells us the characteristics of Atma: ਗੋਂਡ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਮਾਨਸੁ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਦੇਉ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਜਤੀ ਕਹਾਵੈ ਸੇਉ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਜੋਗੀ ਨਾ ਅਵਧੂਤਾ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਸੁ ਮਾਇ ਨ ਕਾਹੂ ਪੂਤਾ ॥1॥ ਇਆ ਮੰਦਰ ਮਹਿ ਕੌਨ ਬਸਾਈ ॥ ਤਾ ਕਾ ਅੰਤੁ ਨ ਕੋਊ ਪਾਈ ॥1॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਗਿਰਹੀ ਨਾ ਓਦਾਸੀ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਰਾਜ ਨ ਭੀਖ ਮੰਗਾਸੀ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਸੁ ਪਿੰਡੁ ਨ ਰਕਤੂ ਰਾਤੀ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਬ੍ਰਹਮਨੁ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਖਾਤੀ ॥2॥ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਤਪਾ ਕਹਾਵੈ ਸੇਖੁ ॥ ਨਾ ਇਹੁ ਜੀਵੈ ਨ ਮਰਤਾ ਦੇਖੁ ॥ ਇਸੁ ਮਰਤੇ ਕਉ ਜੇ ਕੋਊ ਰੋਵੈ ॥ ਜੋ ਰੋਵੈ ਸੋਈ ਪਤਿ ਖੋਵੈ ॥3॥ ਗੁਰ ਪ੍ਰਸਾਦਿ ਮੈ ਡਗਰੋ ਪਾਇਆ ॥ ਜੀਵਨ ਮਰਨੁ ਦੋਊ ਮਿਟਵਾਇਆ ॥ ਕਹੁ ਕਬੀਰ ਇਹੁ ਰਾਮ ਕੀ ਅੰਸੁ ॥ ਜਸ ਕਾਗਦ ਪਰ ਮਿਟੈ ਨ ਮੰਸੁ ॥4॥2॥5॥ The last pankiti makes it clear that just like ink cannot be removed from paper, same way the jeev cannot be destroyed. It's eternal. The Jeev and Ishwar are merged in such way that there is no duality. No conflicting thoughts. In the mann of the jeev resides Ishwar and this way the mann of Jeev becomes Ishwar. Mann of the jeev has same divine avastha that Ishwar has. No one can distinguish them. They are one. This way there is Vaheguru alone because there is no duality, no conflicting thoughts arising from the minds of jeev and Ishwar. But the jeev still has consciousness because to enjoy everlasting bliss, one has to have consciousness. Perhaps a good term to describe this is Chataniya Mahaprabhu's term - Achintya Abhedabhed i.e. the Jeev and Ishwar are Abhed (one) and also different but this situation is such that it is unfathomable to mortal beings i.e. it's achintya. But then Gurmat does not agree with other aspects of Achintya Abhedabhed including Everlasting Gokal, Radharani etc. [quote] 2) If we were to believe the above stated theory of Sant jee, it would mean that our Guru Sahibaan don't exist any longer. They have lost their identities and are now merged in Vaheguru. So what's the point of praying to them? Why not do ardaas before Vaheguru only? Think about it. If our Guru Sahibaan had been anihilated (May God forgive me for using this language) as stated by Sant jee in the above vichaar, then Gurbani would not have contained pankitis invoking Guru Sahibaan. What's the point of saying 'Gur Raamdaas Rakho Sharnaayee' if Siri Guru Raamdaas jee does not exist any longer and only Vaheguru exists? -Guru is Waheguru himself according to Gurbani (ang 442, 1142). So the same Guru existed before taking avtar of Guru Nanak, and the same Guru exists now after the Guru left his sareer. [/quote] Veer jeeo, I am not talking about Sareer of Siri Guru Sahibaan but their existence. What Sant jee said was that Mahapurakhs who merge in Vaheguru lose their identities and this would mean that Guru Sahibaan too have lost their identities and no longer have separate identity to whom we may pray. This means that the pankitis like I quote above i.e. 'Gur Raamdaas Rakho Sharnaayee' are meaningless today. We have to believe that our Guru Sahibaan are one with Vaheguru just as they were, when they were with body, and also retain a separate identity in Sachkhand. They listen to our pleas today just as they did when they had human body. [quote] 3) Gurmat talks about Sad-jeevan (everlasting life) and sad-jeevan in full bliss. One cannot have bliss if one loses surti i.e. identity or consciousness. If jeev gets merged in Vaheguru in such way as Advaita Vedanta suggests, then this jeev cannot be in Anand since in order to enjoy Anand, one has to have an identity. Without consciousness one cannot have anand. & 4) What's the point of doing bhagti if you are to get anihilated i.e. destroyed. To me this seems like a suicide. Why would someone do it? -I think what sant ji was saying is that the the sense of being separate (which is created by ego) is abolished, it does not mean consciousness is destroyed. In Bachittar Natak, Guru ji refers to his state before taking Avtar. He wrote that he became one with God. Gurbani also states that the soul bride becomes one with God, merges with God[/quote] If this is what they are saying as you write above, then I totally agree with them. And what a beautiful example you have given. Siri Guru Dasmesh jee clearly states in Bachitter Natak that he became one with Vaheguru, yet it is seen that Vaheguru jee gives them order to go to Earth and revive Dharma. This is a Wonderful example that clearly shows what this daas has been insisting for so long. Even though Siri Dasmesh jee was already one with Vaheguru jee yet they retained their identity and consciousness and this is why all those questions and answers take place between Vaheguru jee jee and Dasmesh jee. In the end, Siri Dasmesh jee bow their head before Vaheguru jee and agree to come to Earth to revive Dharma. This proves that Jeev and Ishwar both exist even though they become one. [quote]5) This definition of salvation is against what all other mahapurakhs have described. Sikh salvation is entry into Sachkhand or Begumpura. This Sachkhand as per description given by Gurbani and Gursikhs who have reached there is not such that is without Bhagats. It is full of Bhagats who reside there enjoying everlasting life and bliss. -Sachkhand is an avastha, one who is jeevanmukt is at the avastha of bhramgian, they are in sachkhand. Begampura also refers to this avastha. It also exists as a place, I believe, for after the bhramgyani leaves the sareer. No sant who has had darshan of sachkhand actually writes that it is any different as far as I know. [/quote] Since you agree that Sachkhand is a dwelling where all approved Bhagats reside after they leave this body, I have nothing more to say. My only issue is that Advaita Vedant is being presented as a Gurmat philosophy by many Sikh scholars. It is grave injustice to Gurmat to do so. Gurmat is unique and I have seen that it does not fit in any schools of thoughts offered by Advaita, Vishesh Advaita or Dvaita schools of thought. Gurmat is unique. It's got similarities in some aspects with many schools but it has a unique philosophy of being that is sanctioned directly by Vaheguru himself. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 19 Aug 2008

Gurfateh Advait means no second.As Akal only exists and rests are nothing but Akal so Advait is in conformity with Gurmat but we have devotion facter,facter of himbleness which is absent in Advaitism before Gurmat came. Haumai Vada Rog Hai Daru Bhi is Mai(correct das if wrong lines are writan).

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Aadsach · 19 Aug 2008

Harcharan Singh Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, > > One question - I respect the approach you have > taken above i.e. giving respect to Sant Ji yet > questioning their opinion respectfully etc, you > have done this as though you are willing to open > mindedly debate - implying there is a possibilty > that you may change your opinion if a good > arguement is put forward. > > I am just interested to know, in all honesty, > would you (and have you) ever disagreed with a > theory or opinion of Bhai Randhir Singh Ji - i.e. > you are implying that Sant Ji could be wrong (with > all duerespect of course) but would you agree the > same could also be true for Bhai Randhir Singh > Ji. > > I apologise if this seems off topic, but I feel > any vichaar/discussion is a complete waste of time > if participants are already predisposed to a > certain opinion and are unlikely to ever disagree > with or change their inherited thought (via their > role model) - as this would put them at odds with > their sangat/jathaa. > > I hope you will understand why I am bringing up > this point. > > Dhanvaad. I completly agree with veer ji above, could not have been put more honestly. Please, please, please can we refrain from this attitude of always trying find fault in anothers but never in those from in "our" jatha. Just my humble benti, im sorry if this offends any veer or bhenji but dass certainly found this thread very disturbing, bhull chak mafi, Forever the dust of your charen

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

xzik101 · 19 Aug 2008

AadSach Jee, We all respect and honour Harkowalwalay Sant regardless of ones personal group affiliation. No one is saying anything against Sant Jee which one might find "disturbing", if anything, Sant Jee has been shown utmost respect. I think that Kulbir Singh Jee started this thread to just discuss whether or not Gurmat is Advait as alot of people have now begun to think that Advaidvaad is Gurmat. Kulbir Singh has made some valid points on this topic using Gurbani and only Gurbani. I think we can we also discuss this topic using the standard of Gurbani it would be more productive for this discussion as many people like me can learn alot about Gurmat in the process. For those of us who may not have access to alot of books, it's only from such discussions that we can learn alot about various philosophies.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Sunsingh · 19 Aug 2008

kulbir singh Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > 3) Gurmat talks about Sad-jeevan (everlasting > life) and sad-jeevan in full bliss. One cannot > have bliss if one loses surti i.e. identity or > consciousness. If jeev gets merged in Vaheguru in > such way as Advaita Vedanta suggests, then this > jeev cannot be in Anand since in order to enjoy > Anand, one has to have an identity. Without > consciousness one cannot have anand. & 4) What's > the point of doing bhagti if you are to get > anihilated i.e. destroyed. To me this seems like a > suicide. Why would someone do it? > > -I think what sant ji was saying is that the the > sense of being separate (which is created by ego) > is abolished, it does not mean consciousness is > destroyed. In Bachittar Natak, Guru ji refers to > his state before taking Avtar. He wrote that he > became one with God. Gurbani also states that the > soul bride becomes one with God, merges with God > > If this is what they are saying as you write > above, then I totally agree with them. And what a > beautiful example you have given. Siri Guru > Dasmesh jee clearly states in Bachitter Natak that > he became one with Vaheguru, yet it is seen that > Vaheguru jee gives them order to go to Earth and > revive Dharma. This is a Wonderful example that > clearly shows what this daas has been insisting > for so long. Even though Siri Dasmesh jee was > already one with Vaheguru jee yet they retained > their identity and consciousness and this is why > all those questions and answers take place between > Vaheguru jee jee and Dasmesh jee. In the end, Siri > Dasmesh jee bow their head before Vaheguru jee and > agree to come to Earth to revive Dharma. This > proves that Jeev and Ishwar both exist even though > they become one. > It seems we are both in agreement with Baba ji than. When he is talking about loss of identity, I think this metaphor may clarify: A glass of water has a separate identity from the ocean. But when dumped into the ocean the water loses it's separate identity (shape of glass) and becomes one with the ocean. But the water that existed in the glass now still remains in existence in the ocean, it is not destroyed, But it now has lost the identity given from the glass. yet it is the same water (atma). kulbir singh Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > My only issue is that Advaita Vedant is being > presented as a Gurmat philosophy by many Sikh > scholars. It is grave injustice to Gurmat to do > so. Gurmat is unique and I have seen that it does > not fit in any schools of thoughts offered by > Advaita, Vishesh Advaita or Dvaita schools of > thought. Gurmat is unique. It's got similarities > in some aspects with many schools but it has a > unique philosophy of being that is sanctioned > directly by Vaheguru himself. In answering a question on Advaid Vedant baba ji answers we must become rahit from duality, which is achieved only through gurprasad. By having knowledge alone people may get hauamai, so prema bhagti is required. So we see in this manner how advait vedant fits into Gurmat. See the beginning of part 5 for more on this.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

singh05 · 20 Aug 2008

what is the difference between Jeev and Ishwar?

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 20 Aug 2008

ssa waste fo time discussing things you cannot possible know about. these things your talk of are just your imagination. its all man- mal (dirt of mind). reading books written by speculators (people who dont know anything about anything- just interpreting what others have said) is all kachi bani- will just lead you into stupidity. likewise with studying all these philosophies- you will just land yourself in a pitt. its all superficial knowledge. one thing though people appear to thing sachkhand is a kind of heaven where people reside. Japuji says it clearly in one line (paraphrase) 'sach khand vasai nirankar'. In Sach Khand resides That-Without-Form. how then can this be a place where forms of personalities are waling around? We cannot even conceive of Nirankar (That Without Form) because the mind itself depends on forms. Formlessness is inconceivable, so what we imagine it to be can never be it. and that is all the mind can do- imagine and project things. who is this person they have interviewed? what is his experience? is he jeevan-mukt? otherwise why is anything he says to be accepted on any level? is he just repeating what he has read or heard else where? i mean no disrespect.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

N30 S!NGH · 20 Aug 2008

Gurfateh Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji, Looking at previous extreme long debates/discussion between you, Jsingh and avidya. There is not much to debate on this topic, both sides are pretty much covered premi who are khoji can read upon this previous thread from old archives titled "Condition of Bhagats in the Darbar of Vaheguru" and decide it themselves, i m writing a post to further clarify stance of mindset who beleives vajood is indeed lost when this jev leaves the body and attains bedah mukht avastha. Based on my discussion with gurmukhs (sant jagjit singh ji harkhowale, gyani gurdev singh ji) on this topic...this what i have gathered soo far. - Gurbani is sometimes very direct like an arrow..sometimes updesh in gurbani has ishara/ramaza and its indirect. It's open to your interpretation based on your surti and avastha. Gurbani agam agad bodh is above than vikayaran cannot be bound by vikayaran. When sri guru harkrishan maharaj did kirpa on gunga(mute) person to break ahankar of pandit by getting gunga do antriv arths of bhagvad gita, which vikayaran he was taught? That was bhagvad gita, We are talking about sri guru granth sahib ji which is shrimoni of all, moorat of agam agad bodh. - Gurbani updesh is meant for three categories/avastha of people- Kanisht, Madham , Utam. - Gurbani updesh is not meant for one avastha or one category type of people. For eg- Updesh given to paapi that he/she will have to go narak/chaurasi lakh joun, take bari of naam to across this worldy ocean, updesh given to madham to further elevate themselves from maya and do more naam abhyaas to get rom rom avastha, message for bhramgyanis are ekta wale shabad. - Both great panthic figures agree when jevan mukht avastha wale leaves his body person attains bedah mukht avastha, this jev totally merges into Vahiguroo. You may call this annihilation which is quite frankly an "insult" to nirgun roop of vahiguroo because you are not merging into nothingness or shuniya, you are merging into nirgun parbhram vahiguroo which is sarab vyapay which gurbani mentions in many places- jaap sahib, japji, sukhmani, akal ustat, gyan probodh. However, as sant ji said on a same token when i asked him- how come premis do get darshan of previous mahapursh who have left their body, his answer aligns with gurmat. Vahiguroo is both nirgun and sargun, based on sharda of premis and based on their pictorial imagination of mahapursh, vahiguroo transcendent its attributes into sargun saroop and give them darshan. - Then question here comes down in gurbani there are many places which we have read gurbani talks about how there is place- begumpura, baikhunt and there are gurmukhs resides there who are also jevan mukht and there is also autiobiography of sri guru gobind singh ji maharaj came in to benefit man kind. All above are direct relations with avtar theory in sikhi/sharda of based on their pictorial imagination of mahapursh, state of avastha, along with those choosen ones are sent by paratma or given task/ chooses one are in baikhunt/begumpura. Choosen ones before becoming choosen ones also get merged with vahiguroo looses their vajood and then vahiguroo himself transcendent, its attributes into sargun saroop and give its sargun saroop to do certain task, hakum whether hakum is to transcendent into this earth as different forms of avtar(different kala) based on different needs or hakum is to transcendent into sukhsham sirar and reside into baikhunt/begumpura meditate on its own naam. It his leela as gurbani says: sachkhand vase nirankar kar kar vekhe nadar nihal ||. i have a question to ask, why sikhi has to be black and white dharam?. People may make sikhi black and white but they cannot make divine law black and white. Above gurmukh pyares advised me - its not wise to do khandan of sachkhand/baikhunt being realms where choosen gurmukhs resides nor its wise to do khandan of beleif in sikhi that there is total merge/milaap in vahiguroo where one's vajood is lost. Both beleifs are correct and are equally supported by gurbani. Gurbani supports meta reality and does not have one reality in context of sachkhand because gurbani updesh based on person surti, varies from person surti to surti. In bedah mukht avastha there is no such thing as higher or lower surti. It has everything to do with how you perceive vahiguroo/guru sahiban. Bhai Randhir Singh ji gave their interpretation of sachkhand as realm how they preceive guru sahiban backed up with gurbani. Sant Isher singh ji rara sahib, hoti mardan, harkhowale, reru sahib bhramgyanis gave their interpertation of sachkhand as avastha, there is total merge/milaap in vahiguroo where one's vajood is destroyed and lost which is also backed up with gurbani. The problem is human nature, its our human fitrat that if one way is right, other way has to be wrong. Gurbani is immune from this human fitrat. Gurbani supports meta reality based on individuality surti/experiences/perception and how gurbani giving updesh to three state of mind. In layman terms, black person may perceive angel of death(jamdoot) as black, white person may preceive angel of death as white, brown person may preceive angel of death as brown. Usually human fitrat is only one could be right answer and thats the way it is, so here starts arguing, i m right you are wrong, no he is black, no he is white, no he is brown then when they die, they all see angel of death as what they perceived and felt really pity on their silliness why they fighting for among themselves. Divine laws is not bound to right or wrong but perception of jaiagaso/shardlu. Here are few of many references from gurbani , belows which also supports total merges theory without presence of any individualistic vajood. 1. Sri Akaal Ustat ਜੈਸੇ ਏਕ ਆਗ ਤੇ ਕਨੂਕਾ ਕੋਟਿ ਆਗ ਉਠੈ ਨਿਆਰੇ ਨਿਆਰੇ ਹੁਇ ਕੈ ਫੇਰਿ ਆਗ ਮੈ ਮਿਲਾਹਿਂਗੇ ॥ जैसे एक आग ते कनूका कोटि आग उठै निआरे निआरे हुइ कै फेरि आग मै मिलाहिंगे ॥ Just as millions of sparks are created from the fire; although they are different entities, they merge in the same fire. ਜੈਸੇ ਏਕ ਧੂਰਿ ਤੇ ਅਨੇਕ ਧੂਰਿ ਪੂਰਤ ਹੈ ਧੂਰਿ ਕੇ ਕਨੂਕਾ ਫੇਰ ਧੂਰਿ ਹਿ ਸਮਾਹਿਂਗੇ जैसे एक धूरि ते अनेक धूरि पूरत है धूरि के कनूका फेर धूरि हि समाहिंगे Just as from of waves are created on the surface of the big rivers and all the waves are called water. ਜੈਸੇ ਏਕ ਨਦ ਤੇ ਤੰਰਗ ਕੋਟਿ ਉਪਜਤ ਹੈਂ ਪਾਨਿ ਕੇ ਤਰੰਗ ਸਬੈ ਪਾਨਿ ਹੀ ਕਹਾਹਿਂਗੇ ॥ जैसे एक नद ते तंरग कोटि उपजत हैं पानि के तरंग सबै पानि ही कहाहिंगे ॥ Similarly the animate and inanimate objects come out of the Supreme Lord; having been created from the same Lord, they merge in the same Lord. 17.87. 2. Jiu Jal Mahi Jalu Aai Khatana Jaisey Jal Mein Jal Aa Milta Hai Tiu Joti Sangi Joti Samana Usi Tarah Vahiguroo Jyoti Mein Jyoti Milti Hai Miti Gaey Gavan Paaey Bisraam Aana Jaana Mit Jaata Hai, Aaraam Paa Leta Hai Nanak Prabh Kay Sad Kurbaan Hey Nanak! Prabhu Ke Sada Kurbaan Jaata Hoo 3. Soraj Kiran Milli Jal ka Jaal hoya Raam Joti Jot Rali Sampuran thiya Raam || 4. atma paratma iko kare antar ki dubta antar maraie || 5. santan ki mehima kavan vakhanou agad bodh kuch ant na janoo | 6. brahm deesay brahm suniai ek ek vakhaaniai Aatm pusaaraa karanahaaraa prabh binaa jaaniai || 7. nirgun thae sargun dhrisattaaran 8. ਉਦਕ ਸਮੁੰਦ ਸਲਲ ਕੀ ਸਾਖਿਆ ਨਦੀ ਤਰੰਗ ਸਮਾਵਹਿਗੇ ॥ oudhak samundh salal kee sakhia nadhee tharang samavehigae || Like drops of water in the water of the ocean, and like waves in the stream, I merge in the Lord. ਸੁੰਨਹਿ ਸੁੰਨੁ ਮਿਲਿਆ ਸਮਦਰਸੀ ਪਵਨ ਰੂਪ ਹੋਇ ਜਾਵਹਿਗੇ ॥੧॥ sunnehi sunn milia samadharasee pavan roop hoe javehigae ||1|| Merging my being into the Absolute Being of God, I have become impartial and transparent, like the air. ||1|| ਬਹੁਰਿ ਹਮ ਕਾਹੇ ਆਵਹਿਗੇ ॥ bahur ham kahae avehigae || Why should I come into the world again? ਆਵਨ ਜਾਨਾ ਹੁਕਮੁ ਤਿਸੈ ਕਾ ਹੁਕਮੈ ਬੁਝਿ ਸਮਾਵਹਿਗੇ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ avan jana hukam thisai ka hukamai bujh samavehigae ||1|| rehao || Coming and going is by the Hukam of His Command; realizing His Hukam, I shall merge in Him. ||1||Pause|| 9. Ram Kabir Ik Paie Hai Koi Sakaie Paichanaie.. 10. Kabir Jis Maran Jagat daraie mera man anand, maran hai paie poora parmanand || Kabir ji talks about after leaving the body, he will receive poora parmanand, one may question which poora parmanand he is talking about? that poora paramanad is merging with vahiguroo and loosing its existence. One may question why bhagat kabir ji talks about poora parmanand when he is about to lost his vajood/consciousness that feel parmanand after leaving his own body ?? Because kabir ji referring to poora parmanand to vahiguroo ji himself since he realized that there is nothing besides vahiguroo ji... Vahiguroo ji is poora parmanand, vahiguroo ji is sarabvyapak and continue his own lela via daiv shakti. Gurfateh Ji.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harcharan Singh · 20 Aug 2008

Excellent post Veer N30 Singh Ji.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 21 Aug 2008

Veer N3O jeeo, [quote] - Gurbani is sometimes very direct like an arrow..sometimes updesh in gurbani has ishara/ramaza and its indirect. It's open to your interpretation based on your surti and avastha. [/quote] I agree that Gurbani is sometimes Ramzee and also that Gurbani contains updesh for all levels of spirituality. [quote] Gurbani agam agad bodh is above than vikayaran cannot be bound by vikayaran. [/quote] Here I am finding it hard to agree. This is because of my study of Gurbani viyakaran. There is a viyakaran for Gurbani. I have a feeling that you misunderstand the term viyakaran. You can't have a language or a script without viyakaran. Every language has nouns, verbs, pronouns, adjectives etc and Gurbani too contains all these. It's just the way pronouns, verbs, nouns, singular nouns, plural nouns are presented in Gurbani, that is unique. A singular noun will have certain spellings and a plural noun will have it's own rules. These rules of viyakaran have been applied consistently throughout Gurbani. If you could spare some time, I can prove to you how Gurbani has a viyakaran. No one can doubt it. Having a viyakaran does not mean that Gurbani has been bound in it. This is a wrong way of looking at it. I would say that more perfect a language or a script is, more perfect it's viyakaran would be. Gurbani is the most exalted Katha in the world and its viyakaran too is. [quote] When sri guru harkrishan maharaj did kirpa on gunga(mute) person to break ahankar of pandit by getting gunga do antriv arths of bhagvad gita, which vikayaran he was taught? [/quote] Siri Guru jee opened the doors of wisdom (including Sanskrit viyakaran) when they did kirpa on this person who did arth of Srimad Bhagwat Gita. I doubt the jheevar did arths opposite to the viyakaran of Sanskrit. [quote] - Both great panthic figures agree when jevan mukht avastha wale leaves his body person attains bedah mukht avastha, this jev totally merges into Vahiguroo. You may call this annihilation which is quite frankly an "insult" to nirgun roop of vahiguroo because you are not merging into nothingness or shuniya, you are merging into nirgun parbhram vahiguroo which is sarab vyapay which gurbani mentions in many places- jaap sahib, japji, sukhmani, akal ustat, gyan probodh. [/quote] I have no qualms over merging into Vaheguru. We all agree that the merger takes place but where we differ is if this merger annihilates the jeev. I have given Gurbani parmaans to prove that jeev is abinaashi. Furthermore, the example of Siri Dasmesh jee is so perfect to prove this point. Siri Guru jee clearly states that he and Vaheguru become one from two but then when the need occurred, Vaheguru jee asked Siri Dasmesh jee to go to world to uphold Dharma. This proves that even though they had become one, still Siri Dasmesh jee kept his consciousness and identity. This proves that becoming one in Gurmat does not equal annihilation of the Jeev as is the case in Advaita. In Advaita, they don't really believe in Brahman being separate from Jeev. Furthermore they even believe that Jeev is Brahman and not the other way around. This theory is totally against Gurmat, in my humble opinion. [quote] However, as sant ji said on a same token when i asked him- how come premis do get darshan of previous mahapursh who have left their body, his answer aligns with gurmat. Vahiguroo is both nirgun and sargun, based on sharda of premis and based on their pictorial imagination of mahapursh, vahiguroo transcendent its attributes into sargun saroop and give them darshan. [/quote] Again there is misunderstanding when it comes to Nirgun and Sargun. According to Gurmat, Vaheguru is not Nirgun in the sense that he has no attributes as is the case with Advaita. Nirgun in Gurmat simply means that he does not have attributes of Trai-Guni Maya. But in any case, Nirgun Vaheguru of Sikhs has attributes. He is loving; he is Nirbhau; He is Nirvair; He is Bhagat-vachhul; He is Dukhbhanjan. The word 'Akal Moorat' in Mool Mantra is a very important term. The word Moorat proves that though he is Nirgun but still he has a Moorat that is comprehensible to his Bhagats. Many of our Gursikh veers interpret Nirgun in the same way as Advaita interprets i.e. that he is an impersonal God without any feelings. This is not true. Now coming to what you have written above and what Sant jee said about Vaheguru taking form of Mahapurakhs and giving darshan to seekers on Earth. Pray, tell me why would Vaheguru jee do this, when the Mahapurakh who have become one with im are still in existence. If Siri Dasmesh jee kept his identity and when time can he was sent to Earth, why not the same treatment with other Mahapurakhs? Why do we think that they have been annihilated and now Vaheguru has to take on their form to go to Earth? This goes against the philosophy of Gurmat which is proven by Siri Dasmesh jee's incident. [quote] - Then question here comes down in gurbani there are many places which we have read gurbani talks about how there is place- begumpura, baikhunt and there are gurmukhs resides there who are also jevan mukht and there is also autiobiography of sri guru gobind singh ji maharaj came in to benefit man kind. All above are direct relations with avtar theory in sikhi/sharda of based on their pictorial imagination of mahapursh, state of avastha, along with those choosen ones are sent by paratma or given task/ chooses one are in baikhunt/begumpura. Choosen ones before becoming choosen ones also get merged with vahiguroo looses their vajood and then vahiguroo himself transcendent, its attributes into sargun saroop and give its sargun saroop to do certain task, hakum whether hakum is to transcendent into this earth as different forms of avtar(different kala) based on different needs or hakum is to transcendent into sukhsham sirar and reside into baikhunt/begumpura meditate on its own naam. It his leela as gurbani says: sachkhand vase nirankar kar kar vekhe nadar nihal ||. [/quote] All that is written in the above quote is not sanctioned by Gurbani. In essense what you are saying is that first Mahapurakhs merge in Vaheguru and loose vajood. Where does it say in Gurbani that they lose consciousness or vajood. Merging is fine and we all agree with it but Gurbani does not say that they jeev looses consciousness and identity. Quite to the contrary, Siri Dasmesh jee's incident of becoming one with Vaheguru and then being sent to world proves that even after being one with Vaheguru, he retained his identity. This I would say is the case of Achintiya Abhedabhed i.e. Ishvar and Jeev being one and two at the same time. This is Achintiya because it cannot be fathomed by us. [quote] i have a question to ask, why sikhi has to be black and white dharam?. People may make sikhi black and white but they cannot make divine law black and white. [/quote] We may not know all the rules but I think Gurmat is Achal i.e. same through the ages. If a certain thing is a sin, it's a sin. Period. Naam is good. It's good. Period. In this sense Gurmat is Black and White. The path of spirituality that Gurmat preaches is one and not several. There is only one Vaheguru and one path to Vaheguru. Gurmat does not acknowledge any other path. Please show me through Gurbani where it recognizes any other path, other than Naam maarag of Gurmat. There is only one Satguru and there is only one Vaheguru. Same way there is only one Gurmat Naam that can take one to Vaheguru. This seems quite Black and white to me. Gurmat is not Rang-Birangi. Gurmat is not such that Dastaar vee theek hai te bodi vee theek hai. Gurmat is not like keeping kesh is okay too and cutting them is okay too. Gurmat is not like not doing 4 bajjar kurehits is okay and doing them is okay too. Where is the flexibility? Gurmat is Black and White. You are either in Gurmat or you are not in it. [quote] Bhai Randhir Singh ji gave their interpretation of sachkhand as realm how they preceive guru sahiban backed up with gurbani. Sant Isher singh ji rara sahib, hoti mardan, harkhowale, reru sahib bhramgyanis gave their interpertation of sachkhand as avastha, there is total merge/milaap in vahiguroo where one's vajood is destroyed and lost which is also backed up with gurbani. [/quote] I don't think Gurbani sanctions both of these ideas. Gurbani does say of merging and does say of being one with Vaheguru but the example of Siri Dasmesh jee proves beyond doubt that being one does not mean annihilation of the jeev. A friend of mine who is with Rara Sahib samprada narrated to me a very interesting story. He said that Jathedar Baba jee (Baba Mahinder Singh jee) told his close companions that many times Baba jee has gone to Sachkhand but everytime he goes there, 'Vadde Maharaaj' (Sant Ishar Singh Rarewale) orders him to go back as it's not his time to come yet. This proves that according to RaraSahib Samprada too Sachkhand is a dwelling of Bhagats. Similarly reading Baba Jawala Singh Harkhowal's jeevan, I recall reading about Sachkhand and how bhagat live there. The very fact that it's Sach-Khand and not Sach-Avastha proves that Sachkhand is a place albiet not like Earth i.e. it's beyond the trai-Guni Maaya. [quote] Divine laws is not bound to right or wrong but perception of jaiagaso/shardlu. [/quote] This in my opinion is a very misleading quote. Divine laws are absolute Truth and therefore not subject to change depending on one's avastha or shardha. Worldly laws of maya are objective truth and change according to one's avastha but the divine laws are as divine and truth as their creator Vaheguru. Vaheguru is a personality that does not change according to our perception. Vaheguru is Vaheguru and his nature, his personality is not changeable. Same way his laws are Sach that are not subject to change depending on one's avastha or shardha, unless there is a provision in them for change. I speak with all honesty that my intention is not to change anyone's views about the science of being. It was just to bring forth the Gurmat point of view, as I see it. I don't claim to know the absolute truth and what I have written is just based on my understanding of things. I know one thing for sure. I don't want the merger that will annihilate me. I want Sad-jeevan that Guru Sahib has promised numerous times in Gurbani. If you, N3O jeeo, want the merger that will destroy your vajood, then I can't say anything. It's your choice. Remember one thing. You will get what you want. ਸਾਈ ਵਸਤੁ ਪਰਾਪਤਿ ਹੋਈ ਜਿਸੁ ਸਿਉ ਲਾਇਆ ਹੇਤੁ ॥ Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Atma Singh · 21 Aug 2008

ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ khalsa jeeo, this is all very interesting. i noticed veer kulbir singh jee wrote the following: "This I would say is the case of Achintiya Abhedabhed i.e. Ishvar and Jeev being one and two at the same time. This is Achintiya because it cannot be fathomed by us". please see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment even wordly scientists have agreed that light can 'physically' be present in two places at one time. whether this has any relevance re: actual relationship between Ishvar (Paratma) and Jeev (Atma) beats me but it's an interesting fact to consider! :-)

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Khalsaspirit · 21 Aug 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Bhai Kulbir Singh jio, Excellent tat vichaar in accordance to Gurmat. We do not understand why some people wants the Gurmat to be gray not black and white. Why they are so scare from black and white and straight forward Gurmat? Why they wanted to spread gray area all over? Guru Nanak Dev ji's Sikhi is crystal clear and transparent. No place to foggy philosophies here. Quote "Gurmat is not such that Dastaar vee theek hai te bodi vee theek hai." That says all. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harcharan Singh · 21 Aug 2008

Khalsa Ji, Bhai Gurdas Ji - says: "ਜਹਾ ਤੇ ਉਪਜਿਆ ਫਿਰਿ ਤਹਾ ਸਮਾਵੈ ॥੪੯॥੧॥ " Is this therefore black and white also? ""Gurmat is not such that Dastaar vee theek hai te bodi vee theek hai." Please expand on this, I always thought Gurmat was for the universal benefit of mankind....?

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 21 Aug 2008

Veer Harcharan Singh jeeo, [quote] Bhai Gurdas Ji - says: "ਜਹਾ ਤੇ ਉਪਜਿਆ ਫਿਰਿ ਤਹਾ ਸਮਾਵੈ ॥੪੯॥੧॥ " Is this therefore black and white also? [/quote] Please read my posts carefully. I have stated before and say this again that merger is there between jeev and Ishvar. I just don't believe this merger annihilates the jeev i.e. takes away his consciousness. The example of Siri Dasmesh jee is perfect in this regard. Please read my previous post for details. [quote] ""Gurmat is not such that Dastaar vee theek hai te bodi vee theek hai." Please expand on this, I always thought Gurmat was for the universal benefit of mankind....?[/quote] Gurmat is for the whole world and is open to all but this does not mean that Gurmat also agrees with notions of all religions. Keep unshorn hair and maintaining a dastaar on the head is Gurmat. One who wants to adopt Gurmat, will have to adopt this principle also. You can't be one keeping bodi (shikha) and then also want to adopt Gurmat. Think of it. What is Tatt-Gurmat i.e. the essence of Gurmat? Clearly it is the daat of Naam. What do we need to do before we can get Naam? We need to come in rehit prescribed by Gurmat. Today if one wants to get Gurmat Naam from Punj Pyaare, one has to first come in Rehit i.e. wear all 5 kakaars, wear Gurmukhi baana, promise to stay away from 4 bajjar kurehits. Then only one is admitted into the Amrit Sinchaar Mandal and given Naam. So, even though Naam is the main thing in Gurmat and rehit is a small thing but still this rehit part of Gurmat is indispensible. You can't give it up. Remember Siri Guru jee in Siri Jap jee Sahib makes it clear that bhagti cannot be done without adopting Gurmat Shubh Gunn - ਵਿਣੁ ਗੁਣ ਕੀਤੇ ਭਗਤਿ ਨ ਹੋਇ ॥ Gurmat is for all but this does not mean, Gurmat should be altered to accomodate tobacco smoking faqirs, or beef eating Muslims and Christians. It does not mean that these sins of Faqirs and Beef-eaters are accomodated in Gurmat. If these people want to see the light of Vaheguru, they will have to adopt Gurmat and adopting Gurmat means they will have to give up tobacco smoking and beef eating to begin with. Then the other hukams of Guru Sahib have to be accepted. Then one can hope to get somewhere spiritually. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Sunsingh · 21 Aug 2008

Identity implies separateness, which is caused by ego. That is the identity sant ji and N30 are discussing. So this identity (ego, "I") is gone, finished. But like in my example given above, the water from the glass continues to exist in the ocean, it is just no longer in a glass (glass being a metaphor for identity). So the jeev is not destroyed, it is just merged with Waheguru. I think all agree on this point, but have misunderstood each other. kulbir singh Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > This proves that becoming one in Gurmat does not > equal annihilation of the Jeev as is the case in > Advaita. In Advaita, they don't really believe in > Brahman being separate from Jeev. IF the jeev is one with Parmatama, than how is it possible for it to be destroyed?? The advait Baba ji discussed, which I have explained in my previous post, does not say that the jeev is destroyed. Just like in Gurmat we use the same terminology hindus use for many things in Gurbani, but it is modified for Gurmat uses. Baba ji explains this when he said that Sikhi is prema bhagti marg. kulbir singh Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- >In Advaita, they don't really believe in > Brahman being separate from Jeev. Furthermore they > even believe that Jeev is Brahman and not the > other way around. This theory is totally against > Gurmat, in my humble opinion. We have our own Gurmat version of advait. I have already posted Gurbani showing how this is fully in line with Gurmat. Please show how advait says Jeev is bhraman. Advait does not teach us to worship our own souls rather than worship God, Baba ji makes this clear in response to a question on whether we can put our dhian on our own soul to do simran (he says we can't, b/c we lack the dhristhi to understand atma and parmatma as one). This is in the very last recording. please also give a brief description of what you feel advait is, b/c reading this I think it's clear that everyone is not on the same page, and that can lead to a lot of debate about something we think someone said, that they did not actually say. Better to be sure that we all have the same understanding of just what advait is. It seems you are attacking a version of advait that is completely different from the one I have explained in previous posts. kulbir singh Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Many of our Gursikh veers interpret Nirgun in the > same way as Advaita interprets i.e. that he is an > impersonal God without any feelings. This is not > true. I assure you, this is not the case. We have a Gurmat version of advait. This is also discussed in Gurbani, where Gurbani states that atma and paramatma are separated by ego thinner than the veil of a buttefly wing. They are already the same, but jeev has ego which prevents jeev from having appropriate dhrishti to see this. That is all that adviat that baba ji is talking about is, imho. It's unimaginable and false that a scholar renowned in the entire panth for his knowledge who was student of bhramgyani Baba Jawala Singh ji would completely misunderstand even basics of Gurmat such as the Mool Mantar, which teaches about the various qualities of Waheguru. kulbir singh Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Now coming to what you have written above and what > Sant jee said about Vaheguru taking form of > Mahapurakhs and giving darshan to seekers on > Earth. Pray, tell me why would Vaheguru jee do > this, when the Mahapurakh who have become one with > im are still in existence. If Siri Dasmesh jee > kept his identity and when time can he was sent to > Earth, why not the same treatment with other > Mahapurakhs? There is no difference between God and Mahapurkh at this stage. If you go have darshan of Baba Attar Singh ji today, and tomorrow you have darshan of Baba Sham Singh ji, there is no difference. The outward body is different, the behaviour habits may also be different. This is what merger means, to become totally one. Having darshan of Baba Sham Singh ji is the same as having Darshan of Baba Attar Singh ji. i'm not saying it's equal to it, although it is, but that's not what I'm saying; I'm saying it's the exact same thing. If I go meet a pooran bhramgyani today with sharda that I'm talking to Baba Thakar Singh ji bhindrenvaley, than that is essentially who I will be talking too.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 22 Aug 2008

Sunsingh jeeo, [quote] IF the jeev is one with Parmatama, than how is it possible for it to be destroyed?? The advait Baba ji discussed, which I have explained in my previous post, does not say that the jeev is destroyed. Just like in Gurmat we use the same terminology hindus use for many things in Gurbani, but it is modified for Gurmat uses. Baba ji explains this when he said that Sikhi is prema bhagti marg. [/quote] Thanks for the clarification. As long as we don't associate Gurmat with Advaita Vedanta, I am fine with it. Gurmat is unique and nothing in the world comes even near it. To describe Gurmat through the lenses of Vedant or any other worldly philosophy is what I am against. Gurmat can be described through Gurbani, Bhai Gurdaas jee's Baani, Bhai Nandlal jee's baani and by Gursikhs who have lived Gurmat all their lives. Where does Vedant come in picture when talking about Gurmat? The root of Vedant is Vedas and these Vedas have been rejected by Guru Sahib in Gurbani, then what to talk about Vedant? There no point repeating what I have already wrote in my previous posts. Let informed Gursikhs reading this thread make up their mind after reading posts under this thread. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

N30 S!NGH · 25 Aug 2008

Gurfateh Kulbir singh ji, [quote]Here I am finding it hard to agree. This is because of my study of Gurbani viyakaran. There is a viyakaran for Gurbani. I have a feeling that you misunderstand the term viyakaran. You can't have a language or a script without viyakaran. Every language has nouns, verbs, pronouns, adjectives etc and Gurbani too contains all these. It's just the way pronouns, verbs, nouns, singular nouns, plural nouns are presented in Gurbani, that is unique. A singular noun will have certain spellings and a plural noun will have it's own rules. These rules of viyakaran have been applied consistently throughout Gurbani. If you could spare some time, I can prove to you how Gurbani has a viyakaran. No one can doubt it. Having a viyakaran does not mean that Gurbani has been bound in it. This is a wrong way of looking at it. I would say that more perfect a language or a script is, more perfect it's viyakaran would be. Gurbani is the most exalted Katha in the world and its viyakaran too is. Siri Guru jee opened the doors of wisdom (including Sanskrit viyakaran) when they did kirpa on this person who did arth of Srimad Bhagwat Gita. I doubt the jheevar did arths opposite to the viyakaran of Sanskrit. [/quote] According to my understanding, vikayaran is a grammar. Gurbani has grammar thats the way gurbani is written so that where noun, verb, adverb, adjective, pronouns could be understood if one follows rules of grammer and understand them. I have never once did khandan of vikayaran itself. I said gurbani is not bound by vikayaran because gurbani is from dhuroo. Vikayaran of gurbani is there to make us understand on a basic level but when bhramgyani interprets gurbani. He/she does not need follow rules of vikayaran since gurbani is agam agad bodh. Bhramgyani interprets gurbani via their anubhav parkash, they do antriv arths. Thats why prof sahib singh translations and sant gurbachan singh ji translations of gurbani varies..one is at basic level and other one is through anubhav parkash. Its not only that but within Bhramgyani's there is huge diversity of interpertation gurbani based on anubhav parkash, bhramgyan is same, but experiences, surti is different. According to soraj parkash granth written by bhai sahib kavi santokh singh, jheevar did antriv arths of geeta by kirpa of Guru Maharaj which broke ahankar of pandit. I would never do khandan of vikayaran. It just wouldn't make sense on socio-economic level its just doing khandan of english grammar then we wouldn't be able to convey our message properly. Nirmale are known for teaching vikayaran of gurbani both in sanskrit and arabic, thats the first thing one is taught when someone learns from nirmala vidya gurudev. [quote]I have no qualms over merging into Vaheguru. We all agree that the merger takes place but where we differ is if this merger annihilates the jeev. I have given Gurbani parmaans to prove that jeev is abinaashi. Furthermore, the example of Siri Dasmesh jee is so perfect to prove this point. Siri Guru jee clearly states that he and Vaheguru become one from two but then when the need occurred, Vaheguru jee asked Siri Dasmesh jee to go to world to uphold Dharma. This proves that even though they had become one, still Siri Dasmesh jee kept his consciousness and identity. This proves that becoming one in Gurmat does not equal annihilation of the Jeev as is the case in Advaita. In Advaita, they don't really believe in Brahman being separate from Jeev. Furthermore they even believe that Jeev is Brahman and not the other way around. This theory is totally against Gurmat, in my humble opinion. Again there is misunderstanding when it comes to Nirgun and Sargun. According to Gurmat, Vaheguru is not Nirgun in the sense that he has no attributes as is the case with Advaita. Nirgun in Gurmat simply means that he does not have attributes of Trai-Guni Maya. But in any case, Nirgun Vaheguru of Sikhs has attributes. He is loving; he is Nirbhau; He is Nirvair; He is Bhagat-vachhul; He is Dukhbhanjan. The word 'Akal Moorat' in Mool Mantra is a very important term. The word Moorat proves that though he is Nirgun but still he has a Moorat that is comprehensible to his Bhagats. Many of our Gursikh veers interpret Nirgun in the same way as Advaita interprets i.e. that he is an impersonal God without any feelings. This is not true. Now coming to what you have written above and what Sant jee said about Vaheguru taking form of Mahapurakhs and giving darshan to seekers on Earth. Pray, tell me why would Vaheguru jee do this, when the Mahapurakh who have become one with im are still in existence. If Siri Dasmesh jee kept his identity and when time can he was sent to Earth, why not the same treatment with other Mahapurakhs? Why do we think that they have been annihilated and now Vaheguru has to take on their form to go to Earth? This goes against the philosophy of Gurmat which is proven by Siri Dasmesh jee's incident. [/quote] Atma is abhinashi, jiv isnt. Jiv is made of five elements which eventually gets merged into chida akash. Atma is paratma. I have also given many quotes from gurbani which proves this ekta while loosing its existence. In my previous post, i have bought fwd concept of avtarvad in gurmat which prefectly explains sri guru gobind singh ji maharaj taking vahiguroo sargun avtar as dushat daman and as sri gobind rai. I really think we are not on the same page when we are talking about advait vedanta. I beleive you might have made few false statements along have some misconceptions when you talked about advait vedanta. I am not sure why you keep making false statements on advait vedanta since you were corrected many times before by avidya in the topic condition of bhagats in vahiguroo darbar. 1. Advait vedant don't really believe in Brahman being separate from Jeev. Furthermore they even believe that Jeev is Brahman and not the other way around. This theory is totally against Gurmat, in my humble opinion. That statement has false elements. Advait vedant beleive in bhraman separate from jevan because of this upadhi. Upadhi is keyword, once upadhi ie- antish karan(man, chit, budh, ahankar) is destroyed then there is no difference jiv atma and paratama. As gurbani says: Atam Paratama iko Karaie Antar Ki Dubta Antar Maraie || Atam Chinish Paratam soi || Atam Ras Neh Jannehi Sio Haie Khalas Dev, Prab Meh Mo Meh Tas Meh Ranchak Naeh Bhaiv || 2. According to Gurmat, Vaheguru is not Nirgun in the sense that he has no attributes as is the case with Advaita. Advait vedant beleive vahiguroo is sat, chit, anand svaroop so as gurbani as in jaap sahib- sri guru gobind singh ji said- Sada Sach da Anand Sarabang Parnasi || , Gurmat belives in nirgun is without any trai guns so as advait vedant. 3. Advait beleives vahiguroo is shuniya. That is also false statement. Advait Vedant beleives in vahiguroo is sada chit anandsaroop. Vahiguroo is not shuniya(nothiness). Shuniya is jarr(dead matter). Paratama is chaitain saroop, gurbani also beleives vahiguroo is sat chit anandsaroop has chaitanta. 4. Advait Vedant is written by adi sancharaya therefore an philosphy something to do with vedas. I think this is very important point, reason i think we are going around the circles is because we both have different meaning/understanding of advait vedant. Sant jagjit singh ji, gyani gurdev singh and other scholars of the panth beleives advait vedant is theory of atma just like how there is a theory of karma and reincarnation just like that there is theory of atma is called advait vedant. Advait vedant is written by adi sankarcharyan, he only did viakhiya of some of writings based on his interpertation. If you were listen full audio segments of sant jagjit singh ji discussing, he clearly states theory of atma/advait vedant is described by anadi anubhavi mahapursh nothing to do with hinduism. Vedant means ant of vedas, tat nichor of all the vedas. Advait (non-duality ekta between atma and paratma). Just like theory of karma, reincarnation has nothing to do with any religion in particular, these theories are adapted by eastern religions, just like theory of atma has nothing to do with any religion in particular. Just like karma, reincarnation theory exist in Gurmat, just like theory of atma also exist in Gurmat, you cannot separate it just because you might think vedant has something to do with different religion. 'Advai Alakh Purakh Abgiaamii Sabh ghat ghat ke antarjaamii' and further on; 'Bidiaa ke Bichaar ho ki Aduai avtaar ho ki suptaa ki soorati ho ki supta ki saan ho' [quote]So the word 'aduai' or 'advai' (non-duality/monism) is used repeatedly (it also arises in Gyanbodh as well if I remember correctly) in Guru Gobind Singh ji's bani to describe the attributes of Waheguru. [/quote] [quote]All that is written in the above quote is not sanctioned by Gurbani. In essense what you are saying is that first Mahapurakhs merge in Vaheguru and loose vajood. Where does it say in Gurbani that they lose consciousness or vajood. Merging is fine and we all agree with it but Gurbani does not say that they jeev looses consciousness and identity. Quite to the contrary, Siri Dasmesh jee's incident of becoming one with Vaheguru and then being sent to world proves that even after being one with Vaheguru, he retained his identity. This I would say is the case of Achintiya Abhedabhed i.e. Ishvar and Jeev being one and two at the same time. This is Achintiya because it cannot be fathomed by us. [/quote] I have to discuss this very carefully since anything which does not fit in your mindset is not gurmat. I have read your posts before you mentioned antish karan of this jev and shuksham sirar of this jev which leads me to think you acknowledge those concepts. After leaving the body gaining enlightment, jiv merges with vahiguroo which you beleive but maintains that it holds its own vajood? if thats a case that implies atma is not above from antish karan(man, chit) and sukhsam sirar which is not gurmat because gurbani talks about bhramgyan di avastha being turiya(nirvakalp samadhi=nirgun vahiguroo) before and after death, which is beyond three gunas-rajo tamo, sato, three states- jagrath, supan, sukhopat, three layers of body- asthol, sukhsam, karan. [quote]We may not know all the rules but I think Gurmat is Achal i.e. same through the ages. If a certain thing is a sin, it's a sin. Period. Naam is good. It's good. Period. In this sense Gurmat is Black and White. The path of spirituality that Gurmat preaches is one and not several. There is only one Vaheguru and one path to Vaheguru. Gurmat does not acknowledge any other path. Please show me through Gurbani where it recognizes any other path, other than Naam maarag of Gurmat. There is only one Satguru and there is only one Vaheguru. Same way there is only one Gurmat Naam that can take one to Vaheguru. This seems quite Black and white to me. Gurmat is not Rang-Birangi. Gurmat is not such that Dastaar vee theek hai te bodi vee theek hai. Gurmat is not like keeping kesh is okay too and cutting them is okay too. Gurmat is not like not doing 4 bajjar kurehits is okay and doing them is okay too. Where is the flexibility? Gurmat is Black and White. You are either in Gurmat or you are not in it. [/quote] I was strictly speaking in context of sachkhand when i mentioned why sikh has to be black and white. Not sure why you bought up other things. [quote] don't think Gurbani sanctions both of these ideas. Gurbani does say of merging and does say of being one with Vaheguru but the example of Siri Dasmesh jee proves beyond doubt that being one does not mean annihilation of the jeev. A friend of mine who is with Rara Sahib samprada narrated to me a very interesting story. He said that Jathedar Baba jee (Baba Mahinder Singh jee) told his close companions that many times Baba jee has gone to Sachkhand but everytime he goes there, 'Vadde Maharaaj' (Sant Ishar Singh Rarewale) orders him to go back as it's not his time to come yet. This proves that according to RaraSahib Samprada too Sachkhand is a dwelling of Bhagats. Similarly reading Baba Jawala Singh Harkhowal's jeevan, I recall reading about Sachkhand and how bhagat live there. The very fact that it's Sach-Khand and not Sach-Avastha proves that Sachkhand is a place albiet not like Earth i.e. it's beyond the trai-Guni Maaya. [/quote] If you have read ishvar amolak lal written by sant maharaj ji rara sahib himself you will know their take on this subject, its fully advait gurmat , fully beleives after leaving the body, bedah mukht avastha person looses its vajood. i have read that book three times, first i didnt get that much, but second and third time i have got 80% of its contents accept the sahiyara in urdu. I beleive that sakhiya is correct, there is no question about that. However there is difference between baikhunt and sachkhand...as there is a line thinner than thread difference between karam khand and sachkhand. [quote]This in my opinion is a very misleading quote. Divine laws are absolute Truth and therefore not subject to change depending on one's avastha or shardha. Worldly laws of maya are objective truth and change according to one's avastha but the divine laws are as divine and truth as their creator Vaheguru. Vaheguru is a personality that does not change according to our perception. Vaheguru is Vaheguru and his nature, his personality is not changeable. Same way his laws are Sach that are not subject to change depending on one's avastha or shardha, unless there is a provision in them for change. If you, N3O jeeo, want the merger that will destroy your vajood, then I can't say anything. It's your choice. Remember one thing. You will get what you want. ਸਾਈ ਵਸਤੁ ਪਰਾਪਤਿ ਹੋਈ ਜਿਸੁ ਸਿਉ ਲਾਇਆ ਹੇਤੁ ॥ [/quote] Divine laws in context of attaining ik-mik avastha is not bound to black and white notions, is based on individual surti. As you yourself have acknowledged - you will get what you want. I am sure if guru maharaj does kirpa on both of us in this life, our expereinces will be different based on surti, you will see dwelling in bhagats firmly thinkin they have their vajoods whereas my expereince would be opposite. I think sad jeevan is mithiya without loosing our vajood, True sad jeevan isthiti resides in nirgun paratama only, this sargun parsara is only for certain time, drama, leela of nirgun paratma. Eh Sargun Parbhram Ki Leela || [quote]I speak with all honesty that my intention is not to change anyone's views about the science of being. It was just to bring forth the Gurmat point of view, as I see it. I don't claim to know the absolute truth and what I have written is just based on my understanding of things. [/quote] Same here veer, i m not here to convince anyone preconceived views, I replied to your posts because i beleive some of stuff/concepts sant jagjit singh ji talked about were misinterperted. This is my last post on this topic, i tried my best to clarify the other side of the coin so readers can decide for themselves, as they did in other similiar thread- COndtion of bhagats in vahiguroo darbar which could be found in old tapoban archives. I have showed our discussion to gyani gurdev singh ji, he find this to be interesting discussion, he will do katha on your intial 5 points of thread. I will post it up as soon as he records his thoughts. Bhul Chuk Maph for vad kat vachans. Gurfateh Ji.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

N30 S!NGH · 25 Aug 2008

just a small correction under point 4 2nd paragraph: Advait vedant is written by adi sankarcharyan. What i meant was-Advait vedant is not[ written by adi sankarcharya

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Khalsaspirit · 25 Aug 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh N30 S!NGH jio, Sorry to say we could not completely understand your gray philosophy. The best example of “Dashmesh pita Guru Gobind Singh ji” given by Bhai Kulbir Singh Jee is more than enough to defy any old, new and coming philosophies of so called Advait Vedanta. From your posts Advait Vadant seems clearly against what Guru Sahib explained himself, hence Gurmat. So any learned GurSikh won't look further to what Guru Sahib said. ਹਾਂ ਟਾਈਮ ਪਾਸ ਕਰਨ ਲਈ ਮਨ ਦੀ ਬੁੱਧੀ ਦੁਆਰਾ ਅਨੇਕ ਫਿਲਾਸਫੀਆਂ ਘੜੀਆਂ ਜਾ ਸਕਦੀਆ ਹਨ ਜਿਨਾਂ ਤੋਂ ਆਮ ਬੰਦਾ ਤਾਂ ਪ੍ਰਭਾਵਿਤ ਕੀਤਾ ਜਾ ਸਕਦਾ ਹੈ। Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ki fateh WAheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

gsingh · 26 Aug 2008

Khalsaspirit, you, being a wise, learned gursikh, please follow your own advice and don't look further in this thread. waheguru ji ka khalsa. waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 26 Aug 2008

N3O Jeeo, [quote] According to my understanding, vikayaran is a grammar. Gurbani has grammar thats the way gurbani is written so that where noun, verb, adverb, adjective, pronouns could be understood if one follows rules of grammer and understand them. I have never once did khandan of vikayaran itself. I said gurbani is not bound by vikayaran because gurbani is from dhuroo. Vikayaran of gurbani is there to make us understand on a basic level but when bhramgyani interprets gurbani. He/she does not need follow rules of vikayaran since gurbani is agam agad bodh. Bhramgyani interprets gurbani via their anubhav parkash, they do antriv arths[/quote] I find it hard to believe that a Brahmgyani who has realized the ultimate will do such antreev arths of Gurbani that would contradict viyakaran of Gurbani. You say that when a normal person interprets Gurbani he or she uses Viyakaran but a Brahmgyani would not use viyakaran rules. Why is it so? If anything, a Brahmgyani would use superior knowledge of Gurbani Viyakaran to understand Gurbani. Just as Gurbani arths would come naturally to a Brahmgyani same way Gurbani viyakaran would come natural to him or her. Their surtee and Budhi would be tuned it to that of Guru Sahib and thus they would realize not only true meanings but also true Gurbani Viyakaran because when Guru Sahib wrote Gurbani they themselves created the unique Gurbani viyakaran so that Gurbani does not get misinterpreted. I give few examples to bring forth my point: In Siri Jap jee Sahib, the last two pankitis of 3rd pauri are as follows: ਹੁਕਮੀ ਹੁਕਮੁ ਚਲਾਏ ਰਾਹੁ ॥ ਨਾਨਕ ਵਿਗਸੈ ਵੇਪਰਵਾਹੁ ॥3॥ The meaning of the first pankiti above has been misinterpreted by all those who are devoid of Gurbani Grammar and the ones who know grammar have interpreted this correctly. The ones who have done correct meanings according to Viyakran include Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara, Giani Harbans Singh and Professor Sahib Singh. The correct meanings are: The Hukam of Hukami chalai raah. ਹੁਕਮੀ ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਦਾ ਹੁਕਮ ਦੁਨੀਆ ਦਾ ਰਾਹ ਚਲਾਉਂਦਾ ਹੈ। All those who don't know Gurbani viyakaran they have interpreted this as Hukami Vaheguru through his hukam chalai raah. None of them in their many many meanings of one pankiti that they do, could come up with this above stated meaning but the ones who know Gurbani Grammar know that you can only derive this one meaning from this pankiti that Hukam of Hukami (Not hukami through his hukam) runs the world (chalai raah). The aunkar at the end of Hukam prevents any other meaning. The above stated is the simplified meaning. Now the antreevi meanings would involve explaining what it means by Hukam and how it is Hukam and not the Hukami who runs the world. So the antreevi meanings cannot be against Viyakaran. Let's look at another pankiti that came to my mind just now. A Gursikh bhain once asked me about the following pankiti: ਮਸਤਕਿ ਭਾਗੁ ਮੈ ਪਿਰੁ ਘਰਿ ਆਇਆ ॥ ਥਿਰੁ ਸੋਹਾਗੁ ਨਾਨਕ ਜਨ ਪਾਇਆ ॥4॥2॥53॥ About the first pankiti she asked if ਮੈ ਪਿਰ ਦੇ ਘਰ ਵਿਚ ਆਇਆ ਹਾਂ ਕਿ ਪਿਰ ਮੇਰੇ ਘਰ ਵਿਚ ਆਇਆ ਹੈ। I looked at the pankiti and noticed that the word ਪਿਰੁ had an aunkad in the end. This would prevent any possibility of the meanings of I coming to the house of ਪਿਰੁ . So the correct meaning according to viyakaran can only be that ਪਿਰੁ has come to my house. The word ਮੈ is the padd-naavi visheshan of noun ਘਰਿ . The sihaari of ਘਰਿ is giving the meaning of vich (ਵਿਚ ). The above are the simplified meanings of this pankiti. As for the antreevi meanings of this pankiti, we need to explain what ghar here means and what pir (husband) here is. The ghar here is referring to the nij-ghar or hirda sej where Pir-Parmatma comes i.e. where jyot parkash occurs. One can go on explaining this more for antreevi meanings but the point I want to make is that the antreevi meanings can never go against Gurbani viyakaran. Let's look at the third pankiti I just remembered: ਲੇ ਪਖਾ ਪ੍ਰਿਅ ਝਲਉ ਪਾਏ ॥ ਭਾਗਿ ਗਏ ਪੰਚ ਦੂਤ ਲਾਵੇ ॥2॥ The outwardly meanings of this pankiti are simple. May I take a fan and fan my husband's feet. This is how Shabadaarthis have interpreted it. Professor Sahib Singh has interpreted this as 'May I stand by the feet of my husband and take fan and fan my husband'. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh too has stayed within viyakaran while interpreting this pankiti but he knew that Guru Sahib is not talking about fanning the flesh-bone feet of Guru Sahib. It seems silly to fan them. Who fans anyone's feet? The meanings that Bhai Sahib have done are within Viyakaran but they are aatmak and antreevi. He says that paaye here means the dib-lateefi Charan Kamal of Vaheguru that appear in the Naabh Kamal and Hirda area of the jigiyaasoo. May I fan them. How? By doing swaas swaas abhyaas with full surthee, is fanning those charan kamal and more you fan them, bigger and larger they become. This is also called watering and drinking the charan kamal. Now Bhai Sahib has done the meanings as per grammar but has done antreevi and correct meanings of these pankitis. The point I want to make is that to do antreevi arth of Gurbani one must also stay within Viyakaran of Gurbani. Guru Sahib intended to write Gurbani in Grammar for this reason only that no one misinterprets Gurbani [quote] According to soraj parkash granth written by bhai sahib kavi santokh singh, jheevar did antriv arths of geeta by kirpa of Guru Maharaj which broke ahankar of pandit[/quote] As I wrote earlier, doing antreevi arth does not mean that one goes against viyakaran. I am cent percent sure that if the jheevar had done meanings against Viyakaran, the pundit would have never been appeased. He got impressed because such great meanings that were perfect in all sense, he had never heard. In Sanskrit just as in Gurbani, viyakaran plays an important role in interpretion. [quote] Nirmale are known for teaching vikayaran of gurbani both in sanskrit and arabic, thats the first thing one is taught when someone learns from nirmala vidya gurudev. [/quote] I have yet to know of a Nirmala teekakaar (other than Pandit Dakha jee) who knew Gurbani viyakaran. The first Nirmala person or one with Nirmala background to understand Gurbani viyakaran was none other than Mahaan Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha. Whether you read Faridkoti teeka or teeka of Pandit Tara Singh Narotam (Another Nirmala who did steek of Bhagat Baani), you realize that they were very learned but had lost grasp of Gurbani Viyakaran. Gurbani Viyakaran was re-discovered in the 1900s by Gursikhs like Professor Sahib Singh, Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha, Professor Teja Singh and Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. This vidya had been lost in 200 years of battles of Khalsa with enemies. [quote] Atma is abhinashi, jiv isnt. Jiv is made of five elements which eventually gets merged into chida akash. Atma is paratma. I have also given many quotes from gurbani which proves this ekta while loosing its existence. [/quote] It is such an absurd thing I have heard that the jeev is made of 5 elements. Who says so? Please ponder upon the following pankiti: ਹਰਿ, ਜੀਉ ਗੁਫਾ ਅੰਦਰਿ ਰਖਿ ਕੈ, ਵਾਜਾ ਪਵਣੁ ਵਜਾਇਆ ॥ (Hari placed the Jeeo inside the body and started the process of breathing). This pankiti clearly distinguishes between the jeeo and the body. The jeeo is not made of 5 elements but the body is. So what did Vaheguru do? Place jeev made of 5 elements in the body made of 5 elements? No. The jeev is Abinaashi. And yes Atma is roop of Paarbraham Vaheguru but not Vaheguru. Please ponder upon the following pankiti: ਅਚਰਜ ਕਥਾ ਮਹਾ ਅਨੂਪ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਾਤਮਾ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਕਾ ਰੂਪੁ ॥ It clearly states the the praatma i.e. the Aatma is the roop of Paarbraham Vaheguru. This means it is the roop of it and not Paarbraham itself as Advaita Vedanta states. The very fact that Praatma and Parbraham are mentioned separately proves that they are separate, though totally united. You write that you gave many pankitis that state that the aatma loses existence in ekta with Vaheguru and I responded back giving example of Siri Dasmesh jee that ekta does not mean losing existence. Siri Dasmesh jee was very much existent even after being one with Vaheguru and this is evident from the following pankitis: ਇਹ ਬਿਧਿ ਕਰਤ ਤਪਿਸਆ ਭਯੋ ॥ ਦ੍ਵੈ ਤੇ ਏਕ ਰੂਪ ਹ੍ਵੈ ਗਯੋ ॥ Siri Guru jee is clearly stating that he became one from two. This means total unity took place. Now inspite of this union, Siri Guru jee's existence continued on. This is something you don't accept. ਚਿਤ ਨ ਭਯੋ ਹਮਰੋ ਆਵਨ ਕਹਿ ॥ ਚੁਭੀ ਰਹੀ ਸ੍ਰੁਤਿ ਪ੍ਰਭੁ ਚਰਨਨ ਮਹਿ ॥ ਜਿਉ ਤਿਉ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਹਮ ਕੋ ਸਮਝਾਯੋ ॥ ਇਮ ਕਿਹ ਕੈ ਇਹ ਲੋਕਿ ਪਠਾਯੋ ॥੫॥ The first two pankitis above make it clear that being one means the surthee of Siri Guru jee was totally in the charan kamal of Guru Sahib. This is exactly what Siri Bhagat Kabir jee has written: ਕਬੀਰ ਸੁਰਗ ਨਰਕ ਤੇ ਮੈ ਰਹਿਓ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਕੇ ਪਰਸਾਦਿ ॥ ਚਰਨ ਕਮਲ ਕੀ ਮਉਜ ਮਹਿ ਰਹਉ ਅੰਤਿ ਅਰੁ ਆਦਿ ॥120॥ Now it has been established beyond doubt that being one means to be absorbed in the Charan Kamal of Vaheguru forever and ever. It definitely does not mean annihilation of the jeev because as Siri Dasmesh jee has pointed out that the surthee (one of the components of Antishkaran) stay on even after merger. Mann too stays on because in Gurbani it is written that even Vaheguru has a mann. All this talk about antashkaran being of 5 elements is Advaita trash. According to Gurmat, in the 3rd Khand - Sharam Khand, the antishkaran of the jeev is reequipped or tuned for Sach Khand. Please ponder upon the following Pankiti for this: ਤਿਥੈ ਘੜੀਐ ਸੁਰਤਿ ਮਤਿ ਮਨਿ ਬੁਧਿ ॥ ਤਿਥੈ ਘੜੀਐ ਸੁਰਾ ਸਿਧਾ ਕੀ ਸੁਧਿ ॥36॥ There in Sharam Khand the antashkaran (surat, mann, budh etc) get re-carved or tuned for Sachkhand. [quote] In my previous post, i have bought fwd concept of avtarvad in gurmat which prefectly explains sri guru gobind singh ji maharaj taking vahiguroo sargun avtar as dushat daman and as sri gobind rai. [/quote] Siri Guru jee in his own Gurbani (quoted earlier in this post) makes it clear that Vaheguru jee sent Guru Sahib and before coming a long dialogue took place between the two. So your concept of Vaheguru coming as Avatar does not stand in front of Guru Sahib's own testimony of how they came to Earth. Was Vaheguru talking to himself or was he talking to his Bhagat Siri Dasmesh jee, who was totally united in him, but keeping his identity? [quote] 1. Advait vedant don't really believe in Brahman being separate from Jeev. Furthermore they even believe that Jeev is Brahman and not the other way around. This theory is totally against Gurmat, in my humble opinion. That statement has false elements. Advait vedant beleive in bhraman separate from jevan because of this upadhi. Upadhi is keyword, once upadhi ie- antish karan(man, chit, budh, ahankar) is destroyed then there is no difference jiv atma and paratama. As gurbani says: Atam Paratama iko Karaie Antar Ki Dubta Antar Maraie || Atam Chinish Paratam soi || Atam Ras Neh Jannehi Sio Haie Khalas Dev, Prab Meh Mo Meh Tas Meh Ranchak Naeh Bhaiv || [/quote] This is what I am saying too. They believe that after the antashkaran is destroyed, there is only Brahm but Gurbani does not support this. First of all, the mann and Surtee etc. don't die as I stated before. Secondly after falling of Aham (false ego, KuRai paal) the jeev and Vaheguru become one. Becoming one does not mean annihilation of the jeev as you state. Advaita really states that jeev realizes that he is the Brahm. This is why they call out Aham Brahmasiya. This is totally against Gurmat. Gurmat does not support this in any way. None of the pankitis you have quoted fulfill your cause. All the pankitis you quoted call for ekta of jeev and Parmatma but none says that the jeev is annihilated. The example of Siri Dasmesh jee clearly proves that being one means to get one's surtee absorbed in the Charan Kamal of Vaheguru. [quote] 2. According to Gurmat, Vaheguru is not Nirgun in the sense that he has no attributes as is the case with Advaita. Advait vedant beleive vahiguroo is sat, chit, anand svaroop so as gurbani as in jaap sahib- sri guru gobind singh ji said- Sada Sach da Anand Sarabang Parnasi || , Gurmat belives in nirgun is without any trai guns so as advait vedant. [/quote] I think you know what I am trying to say. Advaita does not believe in a Vaheguru who feels for bhagats and loves them, cares for them etc. According to Advaita he is Sat chit Anand in the sense that he is carefree of the world. Correct me on this. It also states that the world has been created out of ignorance but according to Gurbani, the world including the maya has been created by Vaheguru consciously and not as a result of some illusion or ignorance as Advaita states. This is why Vaheguru cares for this world. About his creation - he is - Vekhai Vigsai kar Vichaar|| Is this how the Brahm of Advaita too does i.e. look at his creation and be satisfied? No. The Brahm of Advaita did not even create this world. The world according to that Brahm of Advaita Vedanta is a result of illusion and not his conscious creation. Tell me with honesty, does the Brahm of Advaita have the following attributes: Santan Dukh paaye te dukhi|| Dukh paaye Saadhan ke sukhi|| Never. Impossible. That Brahm is Sada Chit Anand in his own saroop and feels not for his Bhagats. Look at the Brahm of Gurmat who feels dukh when his Bhagats feel Dukh and feels sukh when Saadhu Jan feel sukh. Is the Advaita Vedanta Brahm like this? No! [quote] 3. Advait beleives vahiguroo is shuniya. That is also false statement. Advait Vedant beleives in vahiguroo is sada chit anandsaroop. Vahiguroo is not shuniya(nothiness). Shuniya is jarr(dead matter). Paratama is chaitain saroop, gurbani also beleives vahiguroo is sat chit anandsaroop has chaitanta. [/quote] Even though I did not call the Advaita Brahm Shuniya recently but when I did quote this couple of years ago, there was a reason. The Shankracharya's interpretation of Advaita Vedanta was to counter the Buddhist concept of Shunya. But he overdid it. He is criticized for making the Brahm so out-of-world, so impersonal that he is almost like the Shunya Avastha of Buddhist. A Brahm who feels not for the world, and the world is not created by him is shunya for the bhagats. What use is there of such Brahm who is not helpful and cares not for his bhagats? So I called him similar to the Shunya avastha of Buddhists. Factually you are correct in correcting me but I have explained above why I called him Shunya. [quote] 4. Advait Vedant is written by adi sancharaya therefore an philosphy something to do with vedas. I think this is very important point, reason i think we are going around the circles is because we both have different meaning/understanding of advait vedant. Sant jagjit singh ji, gyani gurdev singh and other scholars of the panth beleives advait vedant is theory of atma just like how there is a theory of karma and reincarnation just like that there is theory of atma is called advait vedant. Advait vedant is written by adi sankarcharyan, he only did viakhiya of some of writings based on his interpertation. [/quote] This theory has its roots in Vedas. Vedas have been rejected by Guru Sahib. The what is the standing of Vedas produced Advaita or the Vedas concept of Karma and reincarnation. Gurmat Karam Philosphy is different from that of Buddhist Karma and Vedas Karma. I don't know why you are under the impression that Gurmat has adopted the Karma philosophy of Hindus or Buddhists. I think you should read Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee's monumental book on Gurmat Karam Philosophy. The Napunsak (impotent) Karam philosophy of Buddhism and Vedas has been rejected by Gurmat. I don't want open a new front on Karam philosophy here, so I will stick to the topic on hand. [quote] If you were listen full audio segments of sant jagjit singh ji discussing, he clearly states theory of atma/advait vedant is described by anadi anubhavi mahapursh nothing to do with hinduism. [/quote] What Anadi Anubhavi Mahapurash are you referring to? No one has been Anadi Anubhavi Mahapurash without the kirpa of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Those Anaadi Mahapurash who are considered to be Pitamahs of Vedant are slaves of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Please refer to the following pankitis for proof on this: ਗੁਣ ਗਾਵਹਿ ਪਾਯਾਲਿ ਭਗਤ ਨਾਗਾਦਿ ਭੁਯੰਗਮ ॥ ਮਹਾਦੇਉ ਗੁਣ ਰਵੈ ਸਦਾ ਜੋਗੀ ਜਤਿ ਜੰਗਮ ॥ ਗੁਣ ਗਾਵੈ ਮੁਨਿ ਬ੍ਹਾਸੁ ਜਿਨਿ ਬੇਦ ਬ੍ਹਾਕਰਣ ਬੀਚਾਰਿਅ ॥ ਬ੍ਰਹਮਾ ਗੁਣ ਉਚਰੈ ਜਿਨਿ ਹੁਕਮਿ ਸਭ ਸ੍ਰਿਸਟਿ ਸਵਾਰੀਅ ॥ Who's greater in Hindus than Brahma the doer of Vedas? Who's greater sage in Hindu Dharam than Ved Vyaas who did the viyakaran of Vedas and divided them into 4 parts? Who is greater than Mahadev Shiv jee, who knows ultimate dhyaan and is the master of Yoga? Well, as per the above quote from Savaiyye Mahalle Pehle ke, they all are singing praises of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Looks like in due time they realized the true Guru - Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. [quote] Vedant means ant of vedas, tat nichor of all the vedas. Advait (non-duality ekta between atma and paratma). Just like theory of karma, reincarnation has nothing to do with any religion in particular, these theories are adapted by eastern religions, just like theory of atma has nothing to do with any religion in particular. Just like karma, reincarnation theory exist in Gurmat, just like theory of atma also exist in Gurmat, you cannot separate it just because you might think vedant has something to do with different religion. [/quote] I have explained earlier that Karma, Vedant etc as explained in Hindu or Buddhist way has no place in Gurmat. According to the propenents of Advaita what did Gurmat bring to this world? It borrowed Vedant from Hindus and Karma from them as well. What is Gurmat offering to the world then? You guys are making Gurmat part of the Sanatan Dharma, for heaven's sake. While I don't have a phobia about Hindu religion like the extemists like Kala Afghana do, and I have respect and regard for these philosophies, and I think of them as most exalted thoughts after Gurmat but at the same time, I do believe that Gurmat is unique and not part of any old tradition. Gurmat of Guru Nanak Dev jee introduced to this world the true Nirgun-ism and it is the preacher of Gurmat Naam, without which no one can reach Vaheguru. Gurmat has not borrowed any concept from anyone. Gurmat is the source not borrower of knowledge. Gurmat is Vaheguru's own Dharma as per Bachiter Natak of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee. [quote] I have to discuss this very carefully since anything which does not fit in your mindset is not gurmat. I have read your posts before you mentioned antish karan of this jev and shuksham sirar of this jev which leads me to think you acknowledge those concepts. [/quote] I acknowledge these concepts but not through the lens of Advaita Vedanta. [quote] After leaving the body gaining enlightment, jiv merges with vahiguroo which you beleive but maintains that it holds its own vajood? if thats a case that implies atma is not above from antish karan(man, chit) and sukhsam sirar which is not gurmat because gurbani talks about bhramgyan di avastha being turiya(nirvakalp samadhi=nirgun vahiguroo) before and after death, which is beyond three gunas-rajo tamo, sato, three states- jagrath, supan, sukhopat, three layers of body- asthol, sukhsam, karan. [/quote] I have already explained above that the jeev gets new or refined antashkaran in the Sharam Khand. I don't know all this talk about Kaaran Sareer or whatever. This all is not written in Gurbani. I have read about it in Hindu books and it seems like Sikhs have just copied it from there. Gurbani makes it clear that Mann is jyot saroop. Please look at the following pankiti: ਮਨ ਤੂੰ ਜੋਤਿ ਸਰੂਪੁ ਹੈ ਆਪਣਾ ਮੂਲੁ ਪਛਾਣੁ ॥ ਮਨ ਹਰਿ ਜੀ ਤੇਰੈ ਨਾਲਿ ਹੈ ਗੁਰਮਤੀ ਰੰਗੁ ਮਾਣੁ ॥ First of, please tell me how and why the impersonal, carefree Brahm of Advaita Vedanta would be with the mann of the jeev, as stated in Gurbani pankiti above? Secondly, mann has been called jyot saroop. Then how can this mann not be with the jeev and Aatma when it's one with Vaheguru. Please ponder upon the following pankiti that clearly proves that Vaheguru too has Mann: ਸੇਵਕ ਸੇਵਿ ਰਹੇ ਸਚਿ ਰਾਤੇ ਜੋ ਤੇਰੈ ਮਨਿ ਭਾਣੇ ॥ ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤੁ ਨਾਮੁ ਤੇਰਾ ਸੋਈ ਗਾਵੈ ॥ ਜੋ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਤੇਰੈ ਮਨਿ ਭਾਵੈ ॥ ਤੂੰ ਸੰਤਨ ਕਾ ਸੰਤ ਤੁਮਾਰੇ ਸੰਤ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਮਨੁ ਮਾਨਾ ਜੀਉ ॥2॥ It's clear from the above stated pankitis that Vaheguru too has mann but Advaita Vedanta states to the contrary and you too mentioned that jeev too is of 5 elements. Mann is part of the jeev and is jyot saroop as stated above. As you can see, Gurmat philosophy of being is quite contrary to the one being preached by Sants through the lens of Advaita Vedanta. [quote] Divine laws in context of attaining ik-mik avastha is not bound to black and white notions, is based on individual surti. As you yourself have acknowledged - you will get what you want. I am sure if guru maharaj does kirpa on both of us in this life, our expereinces will be different based on surti, you will see dwelling in bhagats firmly thinkin they have their vajoods whereas my expereince would be opposite. I think sad jeevan is mithiya without loosing our vajood, True sad jeevan isthiti resides in nirgun paratama only, this sargun parsara is only for certain time, drama, leela of nirgun paratma. Eh Sargun Parbhram Ki Leela || [/quote] I think what you mean above was Eh Parpanch (not Sargun) Parbrahm kee Leela|| Bhul chuk dee maafi. ਸਤਿਗੁਰੁ ਤੁਮ੍ ਕਉ ਹੋਇ ਦਇਆਲਾ ਸੰਤਸੰਗਿ ਤੇਰੀ ਪ੍ਰੀਤਿ ॥ ਕਾਪੜੁ ਪਤਿ ਪਰਮੇਸਰੁ ਰਾਖੀ ਭੋਜਨੁ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਨੀਤਿ ॥2॥ Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Matheen · 26 Aug 2008

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Gurbani is all poetry, and like all poetry the true meaning lies deeper than mere grammar. Grammar is what children are taught when they first learn a language. Later, once they understand the language, they are taught 'literature' and how to interpret what they read intelligently. In Jaap Sahib, Guru Gobind Singh Ji states that Akaal Purkh is 'Anubhav Parkash' hence Gurbani, being Akaal Purkh's roop is also Anubhav Parkash. One reason for doing Abhiyaas is to become 'Anubhavi' so we can understand the deeper messages of Guru Ji's awesome poetry - 'Brahm Vichar', not a normal book. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Sunsingh · 26 Aug 2008

Normal worldly poetry cannot always be understood using grammer rules. How than can the deepest mysticism expressed through poetry be fully comprehended through mere grammer rules?

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Bijla Singh · 27 Aug 2008

If you guys are so against viyakaran and believe that deeper meanings are free from viyakaran rules then give some examples and post the meanings. I have read some deeper meanings by Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji but they do not go against viyakaran. Instead, they are best explained using viyakaran. Only after studying it one understand its true essence.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harcharan Singh · 27 Aug 2008

Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, "Gurbani Viyakaran was re-discovered in the 1900s by Gursikhs like Professor Sahib Singh, Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha, Professor Teja Singh and Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. This vidya had been lost in 200 years of battles of Khalsa with enemies." Please could provide more history/info on this, I have not come across this re-discovery story before.

Re: viayakarN - a well-written history & bibiliography

Atma Singh · 27 Aug 2008

SOURCE: http://www.panthic.org/news/132/ARTICLE/1305/2005-05-08.html (written by Anoop Singh) Section 4 - Linguistic Studies A - Gurbani Grammars Introduction From a linguistic perspective, Sri Guru Granth Sahib is an ocean of medieval Punjabi and Hindi dialect forms, and loanwords from Persian, Arabic and Sanskrit languages, as tadbhav (localized forms) and tatsam (original) terms. For a linguist who studies the history and origin of the Punjabi language, Sri Guru Granth Sahib is the primary resource. Meanwhile, our intentions are somewhat different. Being students of Gurbani, our main purpose of understanding the language is to comprehend, or at least try to comprehend Guru's Words and Teachings in a proper way. In this part of the Bibliography, we will present works dealing with the language of Sri Guru Granth Sahib. In the past century, a great number of writings on the 'Sikh Sacred Language' have been prepared; however, as still is the situation, the Sikhs at large lack the understanding of this language. Studies Before we take a look at the serious studies in the field, we may mention the two special works written by Western scholars. Dr Ernest Trumpp, a German linguist who studied Indian languages and literature, tried to translate Sri Guru Granth Sahib, publishing the incomplete translation in 1877. According to Dr Harnam Singh Shan, the author of 'Guru Granth Sahib di Koshkari', Trumpp had prepared a grammar of the Gurbani before he started on the translation. However, no such work has yet been published and if the book does exist then it is the first attempt by any writer to construct a grammar of the 'Sikh Sacred Language'. Dr Shan located a manuscript titled 'Grammar to the Adi Granth', Dr Ernest Trumpp, 1873 at the State Library Munich, stored under the reference MSS.NO.Cod.Panj.3. The second Western scholar who has written a work on what he calls the 'Sacred Language of the Sikhs' is Christopher Shackle, at the School of Oriental and African Studies, London. His books is more like the modern language learning books and gives the reader tutorials and exercises in the Gurmukhi script, besides the grammar and includes selected readings. Along with 'A Guru Nanak glossary' (1981), Shackle's books are prescribed to western students of Sikhism, who have no initial knowledge of the Punjabi language and script. The book will also be helpful for some of our readers who do not understand the difficult Punjabi used in Punjabi Vyakarans, and in many ways this is the only alternative for understanding Gurbani language, without actually learning the special terminology of the Punjabi grammarians. Among the Sikh scholars, Principal Teja Singh (1922) and Prof. Sahib Singh (1932) pioneered the field of Gurbani linguistics. The core of Principal Teja Singh's 'Shabadãtar Lagã-Matrã de Gujje Bhed' is that the importance of Gurmukhi vowels (sehari, behari, aunkar, etc) is as the tools for interpreting the Shabad-vaak. The work had immense popularity among Panthic scholars and had a great affect on the standardized printing of Sri Guru Granth Sahib by the SGPC, as the Shabadarth was normalized according to the rules found in this book. Thirty years after Teja Singh Ji, Bhai Randhir Singh Ji wrote a similar work that supported the view that vowels are in fact interpretive tools. However, there is a differentiation of thought between Bhai Randhir Singh and Principal Teja Singh. In the foreword of 'Gurbani dian Lagã-Matrã di Vilakhanta', the publisher, Giani Nahar Singh says: "The main purpose of this book is [to highlight] that Gurbani Shabads can have only one meaning. The functional placing of Lagã-Matrãs makes this clear." Meanwhile, Prof. Sahib Singh went on to produce a full-fledged grammar of Gurbani, published in 1932. Initially, sections of the Panth did not accept the Gurbani Vyakaran as an authentic grammar; however as linguistics and modern scholars saw the value of this work, Prof Sahib Singh started to be called the 'Panini of the Sikhs' (Panini being the first person to construct a Sanskrit grammar). It should be noted that the grammarians Sahib Singh and Teja Singh, and Bhai Randhir Singh agreed upon the 'one-meaning' interpretation of Gurbani. This front consisting of modern linguists and Panthic scholars stood against the traditional views that Gurbani was not written according to any grammatical rules, and that there were endless meanings that must remain oral and not be published as written commentaries. Another work from this era is 'Sri Guru Vyakaran Panchain' by Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha, published in 1945. The book is no longer published, and old copies are only available at specific Sikh Sahit libraries. The next period starts from after 1975, when new debates arise in the Panth, specially related to the correct pronunciation of Gurbani and the logical justification of the practise through the authentic grammar. The works produced in the debate would be presented in the next part of this Bibliography; however we must mention some authors who have given us new linguistic insights of Gurbani. Dr Harkeerat Singh, a famous Punjabi linguist and student of Prof. Sahib Singh prepared a work titled 'Gurbani di Bhasha te Vyakaran', published by Punjabi University, Patiala in 1997. The author says that this book is meant as a supplement to the grammar written by Prof. Sahib Singh. New linguistic discoveries had appeared in the past forty-fifty years, and some of the assumptions made by the first grammarians of Gurbani were no longer relevant. Thus, Dr Harkeerat Singh presents us a highly linguistic view on the evolution of the Gurbani language from its roots in the Prakrit, to the development of Apabhrãsha. The main focus of the book is on the sound and pronunciation, and the discussion around the specimens of Punjabi dialects and tadbhav-tatsam forms. He has also given a linguistic understanding of the Gurmukhi vowels and moved away from the views of former grammarians that vowels only appear as interpretive tools. The evolutionary theory presented says that the existence of every vowel or sign in Gurbani is reasoned in the linguistic development in the Punjab. Other scholars, such as Giani Harbans Singh 'Nirnaykar' still hold on to the grammarian thoughts of Prof. Sahib Singh, Teja Singh and Principal Harbhajan Singh, Sikh Missionary College, Amritsar. In his book 'Navin Gurbani Vyakaran' (2000), Giani Harbans Singh criticizes Harkeerat Singh, especially on his views regarding Gurbani pronunciation. A short booklet titled 'Gurbani Vyakaran de Saral Nem', published by Sikh Missionary College (Ludhiana), presents an outline of various grammatical forms found in Gurbani. Meanwhile, the greatest effort in the field of Gurbani grammar in recent years has been made by Bhai Joginder Singh Ji 'Talwara'. His 'Gurbani da Saral Vyakaran-Bodh' (two parts), published posthumously in April 2004 as volume three of 'Shri Guru Granth Sahib Bodh' forms more than 800 pages. The extensive study done by Bhai Sahib is nothing less than an encyclopedia of Gurbani language. Every thinkable aspect of the 'Sikh Sacred Language' has been commented. Gurbani language, script, sounds, morphology (as word formation), and other aspects of the grammar have been dealt with. Bhai Joginder Singh Ji says that he is not a linguist, nor a grammarian, only a devoted student of Gurbani. However, this is also the strength of his work. Keeping in mind that his readers would be normal students of Gurbani who may not know grammatical and linguist terms, he gives clear definitions and formulations before the start of every new section of the book. Interestingly, the first part of the volume has three appendixes, where the first includes a list of 465 combined-terms found in Gurbani that scholars have not yet been able to separate. The author has given the Pad-Ched of such terms according to the grammar, with meanings of each related Shabad in one column. Another appendix has a glossary of Arabic and Persian terms found in Gurbani. All this makes Bhai Joginder Singh Ji's work the nearly perfect reference grammar of Gurbani. Its easy, yet beautiful and equally systematic design and layout brings out the best in Gurmukhi and Punjabi printing. Works Cited Gurbani Vyakaran de Saral Nem. Ludhiana: Sikh Missionary College. Harbans Singh 'Nirnaykar', Giani. Navin Gurbani Vyakaran. Chandigarh: Gurmat Nirnay Bhavan, 2000. Harkeerat Singh, Dr. Gurbani di Bhasha te Vyakaran. Patiala: Punjabi University, 1997. Joginder Singh Talwara, Giani. Gurbani da Saral Vyakaran-Bodh. (2 vols). Amritsar: Singh Brothers, 2004. Kartar Singh Dakha, Pandit. Sri Guru Vyakaran Panchain. Pub. author, 1945. Randhir Singh, Bhai Sahib. Gurbani dian Lagã-Matrã di Vilakhanta. 3rd ed. Ludhiana: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Trust, 2003. Sahib Singh, Prof. Gurbani Vyakaran. Amritsar: Singh Brothers, 1932. Shackle, Christopher. An introduction to the sacred language of the Sikhs. London: School of Oriental and African Studies, 1983. Teja Singh, Principal. Shabadãtar Lagã-Matrã de Gujje Bhed. Amritsar: Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandak Committee, 1922. Trumpp, Dr Ernest. "Grammar to the Adi Granth" 1873. Manuscript located by Dr Harnam Singh Shan at State University Munich under reference number MSS.NO.Cod.Panj.3.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 27 Aug 2008

Sun Singh jeeo, [quote] Normal worldly poetry cannot always be understood using grammer rules. How than can the deepest mysticism expressed through poetry be fully comprehended through mere grammer rules?[/quote] We are not talking about worldly poetry but heavenly divine poetry - Gurbani. I agree that grammar is not the only tool that should be used to understand Gurbani but grammar is the vital tool though. You have to see the context, different meanings of the words used, and anubhav (Tazarba, personal spiritual experience) along with grammar to interpret Gurbani. All components are important and you can't violate any of them. Please tell me where did I say that you use 'mere grammar rules' only to 'fully comprehend' Gurbani? All I said was that you cannot ignore viyakaran when interpreting Gurbani. If some meanings are ignoring viyakaran and are not in agreement with viyakaran rules, then those meanings are incorrect. Matheen jeeo, [quote]Gurbani is all poetry, and like all poetry the true meaning lies deeper than mere grammar. Grammar is what children are taught when they first learn a language. Later, once they understand the language, they are taught 'literature' and how to interpret what they read intelligently. [/quote] Let us look at the analogy that you have used of teaching grammar to children and once they learn grammar they are taught to interpret intelligently. Pray tell us, when they are taught literature and when they interpret intelligently, do they ignore viyakaran rules? No. Actually what happens is that viyakaran becomes part of the being so much so that they don't have to think about viyakaran separately and they naturally and effortlessly consider viyakaran when they interpret literature. Same way, a Brahmgyani, would naturally and effortlessly employ viyakaran when interpreting Gurbani in the light of their Anubhav (spiritual experience). Please don't condemn the Gurmat principle of viyakaran to hide the weakness of your mahapurakhs. If certain Mahapurakhs did not know viyakaran, this does not mean that viyakaran should be belittled. Haath Kangan ko aarsi kya. Just study viyakaran yourself and you will know it's importance. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harcharan Singh · 27 Aug 2008

Dhanvaad Veer Atma Singh Ji, that is an informative article. But it still doesn't shed any light on Kulbir Singh Ji's quote below - I would like to see some evidence to support this claim i.e. re-discovery. ""Gurbani Viyakaran was re-discovered in the 1900s by Gursikhs like Professor Sahib Singh, Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha, Professor Teja Singh and Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. This vidya had been lost in 200 years of battles of Khalsa with enemies."

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

xzik101 · 27 Aug 2008

I think that Kulbir Singh Jee has explained everything so perfectly. Personally I find it very disturbing that one's vajood gets finished after merging with Vaheguru. Everything we read about in Gurbani talks of great everlasting Anand, but how can one experience Anand when your Vajood no longer exists? You have to be in existence to experience Anand. The testimony of Guru Gobind Singh jee in Bachitar Naatak proves beyong doubt that one does not lose Vajood after merging with Vaheguru as Advait says.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 27 Aug 2008

Veer Harcharan Singh jeeo, Gurbani viyakaran vidya had been lost in 200 years of jung-yudh that Khalsa had to go through. At the time of Guru Sahibaan, this vidya came about naturally to informed Gursikhs because they have used the same rules in their own baani e.g. Bhai Gurdaas jee. Later on it seems that Gurbani viyakaran vidya especially the use of Lag-maatra to differentiate between different words was lost. If we read Faridkoti teeka, Pandit Tara Singh Narotam's Bhagat Baani Steek or other Sampradayak teekaas, we see that while these great Gursikhs and scholars did some excellent vichaars on Gurbani and did the best based on the knowledge they had but in many cases Gurbani Viyakaran was not employed. For quite some time they continued to insist that there is no such thing as Gurbani Viyakaran and that Gurbani cannot be bound in Viyakaran but these arguments cannot stand in face of reality. When you give them few examples to prove the efficacy of Gurbani Viyakaran, they then understand. Without knowing Gurbani Viyakaran, without understanding and studying Gurbani Viyakaran, how can someone come out and say that there is no such thing as Gurbani Viyakaran or that Gurbani is not bound by it. Gurbani is not bound by some external Viyakaran but it is bound by it's own divine, unique viyakaran. Around the 1920, Gursikhs not having contact with each other discovered the simple rules of Gurbani Viyakaran. Professor Teja Singh was the first one to publish the rules of how laga-maatra change according to Gurbani Viyakaran. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee too, while he was in jail, and not aware that other Gursikhs too are being revealed Gurbani Grammar by Satguru jee, around 1920 or so, got stuck when he saw the following du-pankiti: ਮ: 5 ॥ ਆਹਰ ਸਭਿ ਕਰਦਾ ਫਿਰੈ ਆਹਰੁ ਇਕੁ ਨ ਹੋਇ ॥ ਨਾਨਕ ਜਿਤੁ ਆਹਰਿ ਜਗੁ ਉਧਰੈ ਵਿਰਲਾ ਬੂਝੈ ਕੋਇ ॥2॥ In this salok, the word aahar comes three times but the spellings are different. Bhai Sahib and his companion Bhai Kartar Singh Canadian started pondering upon this and they came up with some Grammar rules. They found out that the word Aahar in all 3 instances above had different meanings. They then started doing khoj of Gurbani based on these newly learned Gurbani principles and this way discovered Gurbani Viyakaran. Professor Teja Singh jee published an excellent pamphlet on Gurbani Viyakaran. Professor Sahib Singh, I believe too did sangat of Professor Teja Singh and learned some rules from him. In those days, SGPC declared a prize of Rupees 1000 for anyone who would come up with the best and most up to date description and explanation of Gurbani Viyakaran. Professor Sahib Singh published his book in the early 1930s and also won the prize that SGPC had offered. What a great book he published. Many wrote books after this book but this book remained unique and one of the best. In the meantime, Bhai Sahib came out of jail but all the rules that they had written were lost with Akal Chalaana of Bhai Canadian jee. Then Bhai Sahib re-wrote everything from his memory and by doing more research and this book was published too. Around this time a book by Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha was published. Pandit jee was the most learned scholar of his time but unfortunately, his books are not now readily available. I have heard that this book by Pandit Dakha jee is just great. Later on many scholars published their books but the best one to date, after Professor Sahib Singh jee's monumental book is Talwara jee's Viyakaran book published recently. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Khalsaspirit · 27 Aug 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh xzik101 jio, Agree with you. We were thinking to post that Shabad of Dasam Patshah in beginnings but bhai Kulbir Singh ji explained everything in so detail and so perfectly that we withdrawn our thinking. Dasam Patshah's Shabad is actually the eye witness of vazood. In beginning of Shabad Guru Sahib mentions that "NOW I AM TELLING MY OWN STORY OR EXPERIENCE" ਅਬ ਮੈ ਅਪਨੀ ਕਥਾ ਬਖਾਨੋ ॥ ਤਪ ਸਾਧਤ ਜਿਹ ਬਿਧਿ ਮੁਹਿ ਆਨੋ ॥ Which leaves no pico doubt about state after merger as explained in Shabad. Having this discussion and testimony of Guru Gobind Singh jee proves this ADVAIT VANDANTA is nothing but to create DVAIT (doubts) in KHALSA PANTH. This is very unfortunate that the GURU SAHIB DE HUNDYA SUNDYA (ਹੁੰਦਿਆਂ ਸੁੰਦਿਆਂ) why some of our brothers are looking for some thing else from some one else? Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Matheen · 27 Aug 2008

kulbir singh Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > > Let us look at the analogy that you have used of > teaching grammar to children and once they learn > grammar they are taught to interpret > intelligently. Pray tell us, when they are taught > literature and when they interpret intelligently, > do they ignore viyakaran rules? No. Actually what > happens is that viyakaran becomes part of the > being so much so that they don't have to think > about viyakaran separately and they naturally and > effortlessly consider viyakaran when they > interpret literature. Same way, a Brahmgyani, > would naturally and effortlessly employ viyakaran > when interpreting Gurbani in the light of their > Anubhav (spiritual experience). -------------------------------------------------------------- Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Naturally, a full-stop remains a full-stop, however, there is room for interpretation that may not always fit with the literal rules of grammar. For example, Guru Sahib uses names like 'Gobind', 'Har', 'Hari', 'Gopal' etc for 1 Waheguru. Applying strict, literal rules, one could argue that Guru Ji was referring to the Hindu deities of similar name (these usually being pronouns according to grammar), which is clearly not the case. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- > Please don't condemn the Gurmat principle of > viyakaran to hide the weakness of your > mahapurakhs. If certain Mahapurakhs did not know > viyakaran, this does not mean that viyakaran > should be belittled. Haath Kangan ko aarsi kya. > Just study viyakaran yourself and you will know > it's importance. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Veer Ji, was this directly aimed at me? With respect, how do you know who 'my Mahapurkhs' are and could you name those you feel didn't know Viyakaran? I haven't belittled it anywhere and for all you know I could have studied it in depth, - it's just not the 'be all - end all' of Gurbani Vichaar. BAck to topic, how would you interpret the following: (Ang 1375) ਕਬੀਰ ਤੂੰ ਤੂੰ ਕਰਤਾ ਤੂ ਹੂਆ ਮੁਝ ਮਹਿ ਰਹਾ ਨ ਹੂੰ ॥ kabeer thoo(n) thoo(n) karathaa thoo hooaa mujh mehi rehaa n hoo(n) || Kabeer, repeating, ""You, You"", I have become like You. Nothing of me remains in myself. ਜਬ ਆਪਾ ਪਰ ਕਾ ਮਿਟਿ ਗਇਆ ਜਤ ਦੇਖਉ ਤਤ ਤੂ ॥204॥ jab aapaa par kaa mitt gaeiaa jath dhaekho thath thoo ||204|| When the difference between myself and others is removed, then wherever I look, I see only You. ||204|| From Ang 1165: ਨਾਮੇ ਨਾਰਾਇਨ ਨਾਹੀ ਭੇਦੁ ॥28॥1॥10॥ naamae naaraaein naahee bhaedh ||28||1||10|| There is no difference between Naam Dayv and the Lord. ||28||1||10|| Kind regards, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

khalistan_zindabaad · 27 Aug 2008

Ok as per viakaran rules the pangti laak krori bandan pareh. is as laak krori band na pareh. However when listening to katha by giani thakur singh jee, he states that he personally asked sant harnaam singh jee about this pangti and which is the mukh paat, sant jee said they did benti to maharaj and satguru jee stated the first one, and said whoever wants to recite as according to there own budhi can, however maharaj stated bandan pareh... in sukhmani sahib.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 27 Aug 2008

Matheen jeeo, [quote] Naturally, a full-stop remains a full-stop, however, there is room for interpretation that may not always fit with the literal rules of grammar. For example, Guru Sahib uses names like 'Gobind', 'Har', 'Hari', 'Gopal' etc for 1 Waheguru. Applying strict, literal rules, one could argue that Guru Ji was referring to the Hindu deities of similar name (these usually being pronouns according to grammar), which is clearly not the case. [/quote] I have never said that we should take literal meanings of Gurbani. All I have been writing is that we cannot ignore Gurbani Viyakaran when interpreting Gurbani. I am not saying that other tools like Anubhav, context etc. should not be used. With respect to what you wrote above, I am in agreement with you. [quote]Veer Ji, was this directly aimed at me? With respect, how do you know who 'my Mahapurkhs' are and could you name those you feel didn't know Viyakaran?[/quote] The above was not aimed at you Matheen jeeo and this is why it was in a separate paragraph. It was aimed generally at one's who belittle Gurbani viyakaran by saying that it can be ignored by high-avastha mahapurakhs. [quote] ਕਬੀਰ ਤੂੰ ਤੂੰ ਕਰਤਾ ਤੂ ਹੂਆ ਮੁਝ ਮਹਿ ਰਹਾ ਨ ਹੂੰ ॥ kabeer thoo(n) thoo(n) karathaa thoo hooaa mujh mehi rehaa n hoo(n) || Kabeer, repeating, ""You, You"", I have become like You. Nothing of me remains in myself. ਜਬ ਆਪਾ ਪਰ ਕਾ ਮਿਟਿ ਗਇਆ ਜਤ ਦੇਖਉ ਤਤ ਤੂ ॥204॥ jab aapaa par kaa mitt gaeiaa jath dhaekho thath thoo ||204|| When the difference between myself and others is removed, then wherever I look, I see only You. ||204|| From Ang 1165: ਨਾਮੇ ਨਾਰਾਇਨ ਨਾਹੀ ਭੇਦੁ ॥28॥1॥10॥ naamae naaraaein naahee bhaedh ||28||1||10|| There is no difference between Naam Dayv and the Lord. ||28||1||10|| [/quote] Please make a note that these pankitis have been uttered by Mahapurakh Bhagats - Siri Kabir jee and Siri Bhagat Naamdev jee while they were alive in this body. In other words, they became one with Vaheguru while they were alive in this body. This proves my point that even though they were one with Vaheguru, still they retained their own identity. Please refer to my previous posts where I have suggested that in Gurmat being one with Vaheguru does not mean losing existence but means being absorbed in the charan kamal kee mauj. Now look at the pankitis above and tell me if Bhagat Kabir jee and Bhagat Naamdev jee who were one with Vaheguru when they uttered these pankitis, also did they not retain their identities too? They were one with Vaheguru and they also retain their identities. Look what Bhagat Kabir jee is saying. He is addressing Vaheguru (another proof that Bhagat jee's identity was separate even while being one with Vaheguru) and saying doing you you (japping Naam) I have become you and there is no longer hoo (ahankaar) in me now. The very fact that he is still referring to no aham in himself means he is there, alive, existent, thought united and one with Vaheguru. Who else is he communicating to? If he had become one with Vaheguru and ceased to exist, then why is he telling Vaheguru that he has lost his ego i.e. aham? Or is it Vaheguru talking to himself? It's clear that Bhagat Kabir jee and Bhagat Naamdev jee in the above stated shabads are one with Vaheguru, so much so that there is no difference to the visible eye, yet, Bhagat Sahibaan have retained their identities. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Matheen · 27 Aug 2008

Kulbir Singh wrote: >Bhagat Kabir jee and Bhagat Naamdev jee who were one with Vaheguru when they >uttered these pankitis, also did they not retain their identities too? They were >one with Vaheguru and they also retain their identities. ---------------------------------------------- If they have become 1 with Waheguru, then what is their identity since they are one and not two? i.e. Kabir Ji is saying there is no difference between his true self and Waheguru ==> in effect, Kabir Ji at this point is identifying himself as Atma, which is same as Parmatma, according to Gurbani. IMHO, this is the case with every human being, but we haven't realised it due to maya, haumai etc. This is what 'becoming' one with Akaal is - realisation of the truth that your true self, your true roop is one with Waheguru. This cannot be thought of as annihilation or ceasing to exist. (By realisation I don't mean acknowledgement of the situation but that it really happened and they experienced it). It is the natural conclusion to Bhagti - Shabad Guru takes the surti up to the Atma and when it gets there we realise who we really are. Anyway, there is no point in talking about jeevan mukti when I can't even wake up at Amritvela!! If we all concentrate on our Abhiyaas and doing what Guru ji has asked us to, Guru Ji will take care of the rest. We are trying to describe something we haven't experienced (I speak for myself) and until we reach these high Avasthas, there is no point arguing over details.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Sunsingh · 27 Aug 2008

kulbir singh Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Please make a note that these pankitis have been > uttered by Mahapurakh Bhagats - Siri Kabir jee and > Siri Bhagat Naamdev jee while they were alive in > this body. In other words, they became one with > Vaheguru while they were alive in this body. This > proves my point that even though they were one > with Vaheguru, still they retained their own > identity. Please refer to my previous posts where > I have suggested that in Gurmat being one with > Vaheguru does not mean losing existence but means > being absorbed in the charan kamal kee mauj. Now > look at the pankitis above and tell me if Bhagat > Kabir jee and Bhagat Naamdev jee who were one with > Vaheguru when they uttered these pankitis, also > did they not retain their identities too? They > were one with Vaheguru and they also retain their > identities. > > Look what Bhagat Kabir jee is saying. He is > addressing Vaheguru (another proof that Bhagat > jee's identity was separate even while being one > with Vaheguru) and saying doing you you (japping > Naam) I have become you and there is no longer hoo > (ahankaar) in me now. The very fact that he is > still referring to no aham in himself means he is > there, alive, existent, thought united and one > with Vaheguru. Who else is he communicating to? If > he had become one with Vaheguru and ceased to > exist, then why is he telling Vaheguru that he has > lost his ego i.e. aham? Or is it Vaheguru talking > to himself? > > It's clear that Bhagat Kabir jee and Bhagat > Naamdev jee in the above stated shabads are one > with Vaheguru, so much so that there is no > difference to the visible eye, yet, Bhagat > Sahibaan have retained their identities. > > Kulbir Singh This is exactly what I wrote that sant ji stated in his talk. Why do you keep insisting that he said otherwise? The identity (ego) is erased. Never did he say that the soul is destroyed.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Matheen · 27 Aug 2008

Forget to add this to my last post. This shabad makes it all clear for me. rwgu soriT bwxI Bgq rivdws jI kI raag sorat(h) baanee bhagath ravidhaas jee kee Raag Sorat'h, The Word Of Devotee Ravi Daas Jee: <> siqgur pRswid ] ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: jb hm hoqy qb qU nwhI Ab qUhI mY nwhI ] jab ham hothae thab thoo naahee ab thoohee mai naahee || When I am, then You are not. Now that You are, I am not. Anl Agm jYsy lhir mie EdiD jl kyvl jl mWhI ]1] anal agam jaisae lehar mae oudhadhh jal kaeval jal maa(n)hee ||1|| The wind may raise up huge waves in the vast ocean, but they are just water in water. ||1|| mwDvy ikAw khIAY BRmu AYsw ] maadhhavae kiaa keheeai bhram aisaa || O Lord, what can I say about such an illusion? jYsw mwnIAY hoie n qYsw ]1] rhwau ] jaisaa maaneeai hoe n thaisaa ||1|| rehaao || Things are not as they seem. ||1||Pause|| nrpiq eyku isMGwsin soieAw supny BieAw iBKwrI ] narapath eaek si(n)ghaasan soeiaa supanae bhaeiaa bhikhaaree || It is like the king, who falls asleep upon his throne, and dreams that he is a beggar. ACq rwj ibCurq duKu pwieAw so giq BeI hmwrI ]2] ashhath raaj bishhurath dhukh paaeiaa so gath bhee hamaaree ||2|| His kingdom is intact, but separated from it, he suffers in sorrow. Such is my own condition. ||2|| rwj BuieAMg pRsMg jYsy hih Ab kCu mrmu jnwieAw ] raaj bhueia(n)g prasa(n)g jaisae hehi ab kashh maram janaaeiaa || Like the story of the rope mistaken for a snake, the mystery has now been explained to me. Aink ktk jYsy BUil pry Ab khqy khnu n AwieAw ]3] anik kattak jaisae bhool parae ab kehathae kehan n aaeiaa ||3|| Like the many bracelets, which I mistakenly thought were gold; now, I do not say what I said then. ||3|| srby eyku AnykY suAwmI sB Gt BuogvY soeI ] sarabae eaek anaekai suaamee sabh ghatt bhuogavai soee || The One Lord is pervading the many forms; He enjoys Himself in all hearts. kih rivdws hwQ pY nyrY shjy hoie su hoeI ]4]1] kehi ravidhaas haathh pai naerai sehajae hoe s hoee ||4||1|| Says Ravi Daas, the Lord is nearer than our own hands and feet. Whatever will be, will be. ||4||1||

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Atma Singh · 28 Aug 2008

ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ dear veer/bhain matheen jee, you wrote: "It is the natural conclusion to Bhagti - Shabad Guru takes the surti up to the Atma and when it gets there we realise who we really are". my understanding, based completely upon my limited understanding of gurbaaNee and the writings of gurmukhs, NOT personal experience (despite what my name suggests! lol), is that the stage where one perceives Self (Atma) is not the same stage whereupon one perceives Paratma (Universal Self/Atma). this is apparent even in the level of Parkaash/Vigaas one perceives. if Atma is one light bulb, Paratma is infinite shining suns. however apparently, once someone has perceived Atma, they are not very far off from realising Paratma...it is a major milestone on the path of Gurmat/Naam Marag/Prembhagtee. my current understanding is that perhaps some who realise Atma become stuck at that stage believeing that this is darshan of vaheguroo i.e. they think 'i am vaheguroo (the concept of Sohang). my belief is that the thin veil of ego would still remain and therefore this is actually very far off from true Vaheguroo Darshan/Milaap/Ik Mik Avastha.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Aadsach · 28 Aug 2008

xzik101 wrote: We all respect and honour Harkowalwalay Sant regardless of ones personal group affiliation. No one is saying anything against Sant Jee which one might find "disturbing", if anything, Sant Jee has been shown utmost respect. I think that Kulbir Singh Jee started this thread to just discuss whether or not Gurmat is Advait as alot of people have now begun to think that Advaidvaad is Gurmat. Kulbir Singh has made some valid points on this topic using Gurbani and only Gurbani. I respect that Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji has used Gurbani and Gurmat and is very knowledgable and mahaan compared to my maha paapi-self. The reason i found this thread disturbing was because NEVER would i question Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh ji, similarly, i find it incredibily DISGUSTING that someone is questioning Sant Baba Jagjit Singh ji. We should listen to their veechar and paarchar with pyaar and not try to compare it with another. I agree with Matheen veer ji that we are trying to describe something we haven't experienced is sumwhat useless. Im sorry if none of this makes sense and is going off-topic. hir jip jIAry CutIAY gurmuiK cInY Awpu ]3] har jap jeearae shhutteeai guramukh cheenai aap.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Sunsingh · 29 Aug 2008

The atma in sachkhand merges with Waheguru. The atma is made of the same stuff as parmatma. Like a drop of water merging in the ocean. The H2O molecules in that drop intermixes with the H2O molecules in the ocean. It does not retain the shape of the drop, yet at the same time, the water in the drop is not destroyed. Gurbani truthfully states that the atma enjoys bliss in sachkhand. This is Waheguru in bliss contemplating Himself. It does not mean an existence as a separate being. ਆਪਿ ਉਪਾਏ ਆਪਿ ਖਪਾਏ ॥ ਆਪੇ ਸਿਰਿ ਸਿਰਿ ਧੰਧੈ ਲਾਏ ॥ ਆਪੇ ਵੀਚਾਰੀ ਗੁਣਕਾਰੀ ਆਪੇ ਮਾਰਗਿ ਲਾਈ ਹੇ ॥੨॥ You Yourself create, and You Yourself destroy. You yourself link each and every person to their tasks. You contemplate Yourself, You Yourself make us worthy; You Yourself place us on the Path. ||2|| (ang 1020) ਆਪੇ ਜਗਤੁ ਉਪਾਇ ਕੈ ਕੁਦਰਤਿ ਕਰੇ ਵੀਚਾਰ ॥ He Himself created the world; He contemplates His Creative Omnipotence. (ang 1280) (http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=KeertanPage&K=1280&L=19) The above proves beyond doubt that Waheguru contemplates on Himself. This is the only explanation that seems to reconcile the Gurbani that explicitly states that atma and parmata merge with the Gurbani stating that the bhagats are in bliss in sachkhand. When a bhramgyani contemplates on Waheguru, that is Waheguru contemplating Himself as a bhramgyani is one with Waheguru. For example, when Baba Gurbachan Singh ji looked at someone, that is Waheguru looking at someone through the body labelled Gurbachan Singh. there is no difference.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 30 Aug 2008

this is interesting because i often see people interpret 'haumai' as meaning only vanity or superificial ego. and the views expressed here king of explain why, whereas to me it has always obviously refered to the very centre of self-existance ('aap'- Guru tells us to lose the self- aap gavaieaa). the very 'I am' has to go to see God. to be fair to advaita vedanta, it skind of a fashion these days and alot of people have thrown in their own opinions- people who dont really know about these things. someone said that in advaita the Brahman doesnt care about his bhagats. but the Advaitins say the world is illusitory, so that explains why. the key of all suffering is belief that the self is real. also they say that the experience, experienced and experiencer are One and not seperate. that One is Brahman. this isnt an indifferant God. I read in paath once Guru Nanak says no-one is born (ajati). this would sound very familiar to an Advaitin. and i know we have alot sufi fans here. so how would you reconcile this with their talk of 'fana-al-fana'?

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

N30 S!NGH · 04 Sep 2008

Bhai Sahib Kulbir singh, sorry for the delay in replying to your post, been really busy with gristh jevaan. I hope this post will bring tat khalsa parchar as khalsa spirit like to call it :) [quote] I find it hard to believe that a Brahmgyani who has realized the ultimate will do such antreev arths of Gurbani that would contradict viyakaran of Gurbani. You say that when a normal person interprets Gurbani he or she uses Viyakaran but a Brahmgyani would not use viyakaran rules. Why is it so? If anything, a Brahmgyani would use superior knowledge of Gurbani Viyakaran to understand Gurbani. Just as Gurbani arths would come naturally to a Brahmgyani same way Gurbani viyakaran would come natural to him or her. Their surtee and Budhi would be tuned it to that of Guru Sahib and thus they would realize not only true meanings but also true Gurbani Viyakaran because when Guru Sahib wrote Gurbani they themselves created the unique Gurbani viyakaran so that Gurbani does not get misinterpreted. I give few examples to bring forth my point: [/quote] Veer kulbir singh, i never mentioned words like "contradict vikayaran of gurbani" "against vikayaran" . I beleive they are very strong words which does not do justice to describe my stance. There are three reasons i said Anubhavi arths are not bound by viakyaran (refering to teekakars who have done arths using vikayaran kausuti) 1) Gurbani vikayaran is a tool which is used to simplify dhur ki bani into bhav arths, Gurbani vikayaran is sampooran in itself but there are differences of opnions of scholars who claim authority over gurbani vikayaran, people who have used certain standarized vikayaran rules in gurbani yet couldn't fully standardized gurbani vikayaran sidhant, there are still loads of work needs to be done as article suggests above because there are vikayaran niyam(rules) made by scholars where scholars like prof sahib singh and others tried to apply it consistently in gurbani and failed. During this failure, sampardai arths/uthanka comes into play are equally valid because its coming from seena-basina tradition going all the way to bhai mani singh taksal. For eg- In academic missionary circle- prof sahib singh's teeka - Gurbani Darpan is considered somewhat authority to translate/interpret gurbani. Prof sahib singh teeka its far from perfect, has lot of mistakes in them( thats fine because he mentioned in his preface that my work is just tip of the iceberg). Please read Prof sher singh who is language vigyani in punjab university found his translations somewhat shallow and also check Dr Harkarit Singh view on vikayaran niyam..book is called- gurbani basha and vikayaran he bought some interesting analysis on vikaayaran rules translations of sri guru granth sahib ji and found one vikayaran sidhant/niyam(rules) cannot be applied consistently, here are couple of examples of many, in his analysis on vikayaran he writes. - vikaayaran niyam explained by prof sahib singh does not apply to some parts in bhagat bani because some parts in bhagata bani rachna is written in marathi basha in sri guru granth sahib ji, because each language has their own grammar, also sidhant of vikayaran prof sahib used in japj sahib, same sidhant of vikayaran couldn't apply in rehras sahib consistently. There are even diversity within vikayaran interpertation of gurbani as article suggests. - On different ocassion, sant gurbachan singh ji mentioned how yet again vikayaran niyam which was applied in certain shabad cannot be applied consistently in other shabads. Here is the audio recording of sri guru granth sahib ji katha by sant gurbachan singh ji: please fwd it to 17:00 minutes. http://www.gurmatveechar.org/audio/katha/01_Puratan_Katha/Sant_Gurbachan_Singh_%28Bhindran_wale%29/Guru_Granth_Sahib_Larivaar_Katha/Volume_04_Ang_0250-0346/16-Sant.Gurbachan.Singh--Raag.Gourhi--Ang.264.%28Sukhmani.Sahib%29.mp3 [quote]If you guys are so against viyakaran and believe that deeper meanings are free from viyakaran rules then give some examples and post the meanings. I have read some deeper meanings by Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji but they do not go against viyakaran. Instead, they are best explained using viyakaran. Only after studying it one understand its true essence. [/quote] Sant gurbachan singh ji did antriv arths via samparda seena-basina tradition done by mahapursh in taksal who were anubhavi coming striaght from bhai mani singh ji. He is not against vikayaran totally but he did found as stated above in audio katha of sri guru granth sahib done by him that he finds certain vikayaran niyam(rules) not consistent or accurate thats where sampardai arths and uthanka arths comes in handy. Now question as of why i said anubhav arths of gurbani are not bound by vikayaran rules...not just antriv arths but uthanka of certain shabad is not bound by vikayaran either. I will give you three examples- - Sikhi sidhant was challenged by RSS type people who were challenging Vahiguroo cannot be Gurmantar. At that point nirmale baba isher singh kalyug wale bought fwd 500 antriv arths of Vahiguroo mantar. Now tell me which vikayaran sidhant/rules he used when he bought fwd 500 arths of vahiguroo mantar? Sant jagjit singh said, arths are fully antriv in nature and if you were to do arths of vahiguroo in vikayaran you can go far 10 at the max. - If we go by gurbani vikayaran we will not be able to do uthanka of certain shabad since certain shabads are directly linked with events involving our Guru Sahiban and bhagats..as some people who are premis of vikayaran of gurbani beleive that there can be one interpertation of gurbani. - This is very important point, please try to understand this. When this jev gets bhramgyan, their surti merges into nirankar, same nirankar dhur ki bani comes from. When bhramgyani does interpertation of gurbani via their anubhav bhramgyan they don't need to follow 1st step use vikayaran to get arths of certain tuk or shabad because they already realize the tat nichor(essence) of that certain shabad, tuk. They give out tat nichor of shabad or tuk which naturally will not contradict Gurbani vikayaran sidhant set by Guru Sahib himself not dunavi punjabi vikayaran. Gurbani vikayaran is still yet to be fully discovered. As vikayaran niyam(rules) set by scholars of the panth still not sampooran itself or accurate as the article pointed out along with sant gurbachan singh ji pointed out. [quote]It is such an absurd thing I have heard that the jeev is made of 5 elements. Who says so? Please ponder upon the following pankiti: har jeo gofa andar rakh kai, vaja pavan vajaya || (Hari placed the Jeeo inside the body and started the process of breathing). This pankiti clearly distinguishes between the jeeo and the body. The jeeo is not made of 5 elements but the body is. So what did Vaheguru do? Place jeev made of 5 elements in the body made of 5 elements? No. The jeev is Abinaashi. [/quote] I admit i choose poor choice of words here, i meant to say body is made out of five elements but jev is in the body. Jiv atma is abnashi in essence but since antish karan doesn't recnognize its true self, until then this consciouness doesn't merge with super conscouness and become abhinashi. [quote]And yes Atma is roop of Paarbraham Vaheguru but not Vaheguru. Please ponder upon the following pankiti: Acharcj Katha Maha Anoop Paratma parbhram ka roop It clearly states the the praatma i.e. the Aatma is the roop of Paarbraham Vaheguru. This means it is the roop of it and not Paarbraham itself as Advaita Vedanta states. The very fact that Paraatma and Parbraham are mentioned separately proves that they are separate, though totally united. [/quote] Here we go again, all this already been addressed by J Singh in the following link from old tapoban forum : http://www.gurmarag.net/SikhAwareness/Text/Condition_of_Bhagats_in_the_darbar.htm After reading the debate one can easily fetch your views were same 3 years ago, same now, same will be after you realize your body as this is directly related to your surti based on your own understanding of gurbani. I have read discussion between jsingh and yourself three times.. its my all time favorite, that discussion touches finest of finest sidhant in gurmat. Everyone who is reading this discussion should definitely read that discussion before as well. The above pankiti still does not fullfill your main cause..because that panktii is meant for certain state or surti as i mentioned earlier gurbani are meant different state of minds.. you cannot make a rule if gurbani is giving updesh to paapi, jaiagaso, same updesh is also given to bhramgyani. Here is shabad where gurbani giving explaining avastha of gurmukh/bhramgyani. In this shabad two separate entities- joti(atma), surti(individual consciousness) merges into jot and surat: Joti jot millaie surati surat sanjog || Clear distincation is made how joti(atma) and individual surti after getting bhramgyan merges with Param Jot and Param Surat no other than vahiguroo himself. What happened to the individual surti in this shabad? It merged into super consciouness nirgun roop which is sat chit anandsvaroop. Here is another one Pavanaie Mein Pavan Samaaiya Joti Mein Jot Ral Jaiya || Here is another one: ਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਦੀਸੈ ਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਸੁਣੀਐ ਏਕੁ ਏਕੁ ਵਖਾਣੀਐ ॥ breham dheesai breham suneeai eaek eaek vakhaaneeai || ਆਤਮ ਪਸਾਰਾ ਕਰਣਹਾਰਾ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਬਿਨਾ ਨਹੀ ਜਾਣੀਐ ॥ aatham pasaaraa karanehaaraa prabh binaa nehee jaaneeai || [quote]You write that you gave many pankitis that state that the aatma loses existence in ekta with Vaheguru and I responded back giving example of Siri Dasmesh jee that ekta does not mean losing existence. Siri Dasmesh jee was very much existent even after being one with Vaheguru and this is evident from the following pankitis...Siri Guru jee is clearly stating that he became one from two. This means total unity took place. Now inspite of this union, Siri Guru jee's existence continued on. This is something you don't accept. Siri Guru jee in his own Gurbani (quoted earlier in this post) makes it clear that Vaheguru jee sent Guru Sahib and before coming a long dialogue took place between the two. So your concept of Vaheguru coming as Avatar does not stand in front of Guru Sahib's own testimony of how they came to Earth. Was Vaheguru talking to himself or was he talking to his Bhagat Siri Dasmesh jee, who was totally united in him, but keeping his identity? Eh Badh Karat Tapasya Bhaiye || Dvaie Taie Ek Roop ho gaye Chit na bhaie hamraie aavan keh Chobi rahi surat prabh charnan meh Joi taoi prab ham kai smjhaie Em kahi kaae eh lok pataye || This is exactly what Siri Bhagat Kabir jee has written: Kabir swarag narak taie me rahio satgur kaie gurparsa Charan kamal ki mauj mein raho ant aur aad. [/quote] I am just suprised it didnt even occur to you even for one second that is quite possible that this deliverance might have taken place in sri guru gobind singh ji previous earthly life as dushat daman avtar at hemkunt. Even If we go with your opnion on this that guru ji was given deliverance in spiritual world which you should said it implies guru ji had seperate vajood, conscinouness then how do you explain narsingh avtar(half lion and half man) who came to kill harnakash and save parlhad. Was narsingh avtar before arrival was chilling in sachkhand as well holding onto his vajood and surti. Was he also doing naam simran same where in the sachkhand? [quote]Now it has been established beyond doubt that being one means to be absorbed in the Charan Kamal of Vaheguru forever and ever. It definitely does not mean annihilation of the jeev because as Siri Dasmesh jee has pointed out that the surthee (one of the components of Antishkaran) stay on even after merger. Mann too stays on because in Gurbani it is written that even Vaheguru has a mann. All this talk about antashkaran being of 5 elements is Advaita trash. According to Gurmat, in the 3rd Khand - Sharam Khand, the antishkaran of the jeev is reequipped or tuned for Sach Khand. Please ponder upon the following Pankiti for this: Tithaie Gharaie Surat Mat Man Budh Tithaie Gharaie Sora Sidha Ki Sudh || There in Sharam Khand the antashkaran (surat, mann, budh etc) get re-carved or tuned for Sachkhand. [/quote] Nothing is been established here mate, thats your surti based on your own understanding of gurbani. As guru sahib mentioned in chaupi sahib, jinni buddhi vahiguroo valu milli hai, uhni buddhi dwara bandai di sochni aa or here is an classic tuk which explains whichever surat: jehri surat tahi rahe jai || Calling antish karan as advaita trash just shows how frustrated you are with theory of atma totally residing in gurmat. That you went to call advaita(oneness with bhram/vahiguroo) as trash in intoxication of your hindu phobia, you just fell in a same dandal which kala afghana has fell on this matter [quote]This is what I am saying too. They believe that after the antashkaran is destroyed, there is only Brahm but Gurbani does not support this. First of all, the mann and Surtee etc. don't die as I stated before. Secondly after falling of Aham (false ego, KuRai paal) the jeev and Vaheguru become one. Becoming one does not mean annihilation of the jeev as you state. Advaita really states that jeev realizes that he is the Brahm. This is why they call out Aham Brahmasiya. This is totally against Gurmat. Gurmat does not support this in any way. [/quote] As sant jagjit singh ji says prem bhagti marg and gyan of your self marg totally parvan in sikhi..as far as gurbani sidhant is concerned because gurbani there are many quotes of prem/variaag and many quotes of ekta wale shabad. As jaigaso we should do vairaag, prema bhagti but for bhramgyanis there is no paun there is no paap, as bhagat kabir ji after attaining bhramgyan he said: sohang so jaa ko hai jaap || jaa ko lipath n hoe pu(n)n ar paap ||6|| ang- 1162 [quote] None of the pankitis you have quoted fulfill your cause. All the pankitis you quoted call for ekta of jeev and Parmatma but none says that the jeev is annihilated. The example of Siri Dasmesh jee clearly proves that being one means to get one's surtee absorbed in the Charan Kamal of Vaheguru. [/quote] I really don't think i have energy like J singh who had veechar on this topic with you for 20 straight days tried from all different angles to show you thats your preception of sachkhand, will remain your preception based on your surti. But thats not rule for everyone. You have proven nothing before nothing now that there is one premanent divine law that each jiv who have got bhramgyan holds on to its vajood. If maharaj does equal kirpa on both of us when we leave our body, you will be there with your vajood(surti, consciouness) along with countless others who have same belief as yourself in sachkhand (place as you call it) because thats what your surti is attuned towards. But i will not be there mate so you won't be able to tease me ..hehe. I will be merged with that parmanand roop nirgun sarabvypak vahiguroo because thats what i wish for, call it annihilation, sucide, nothingness whatever you wish based on your own understanding. If you call loosing one vajood and merging completly with vahiguroo is an sucide, annahliation, merging into nothiness what you will do when Vahiguroo decides to merge all his parpanch akar/sargun parsara into itself? what would you call when vahiguroo decides to merge all his parpanch ? sucide..? You will also have to merge in to same energy and loose your vajood, consicouness, indentity which you call annihilation where would your vajood be then? Here are few shabads to ponder upon on the topic of destruction and creation of all pasara including physical and spiritual realms how one day all the pasara akara, asthohol, sukhsham, traie gun will all perish. This shabad talks both about spiritual and physical realms: ਇੰਦ੍ਰ ਪੁਰੀ ਮਹਿ ਸਰਪਰ ਮਰਣਾ ॥ eindhr puree mehi sarapar maranaa || In the Realm of Indra, death is sure and certain. 8 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਪੁਰੀ ਨਿਹਚਲੁ ਨਹੀ ਰਹਣਾ ॥ breham puree nihachal nehee rehanaa || The Realm of Brahma shall not remain permanent. 8 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਸਿਵ ਪੁਰੀ ਕਾ ਹੋਇਗਾ ਕਾਲਾ ॥ siv puree kaa hoeigaa kaalaa || The Realm of Shiva shall also perish. 9 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਤ੍ਰੈ ਗੁਣ ਮਾਇਆ ਬਿਨਸਿ ਬਿਤਾਲਾ ॥੨॥ thrai gun maaeiaa binas bithaalaa ||2|| The three dispositions, Maya and the demons shall vanish. ||2|| 9 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਗਿਰਿ ਤਰ ਧਰਣਿ ਗਗਨ ਅਰੁ ਤਾਰੇ ॥ gir thar dhharan gagan ar thaarae || The mountains, the trees, the earth, the sky and the stars; 9 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਰਵਿ ਸਸਿ ਪਵਣੁ ਪਾਵਕੁ ਨੀਰਾਰੇ ॥ rav sas pavan paavak neeraarae || the sun, the moon, the wind, water and fire; 10 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਦਿਨਸੁ ਰੈਣਿ ਬਰਤ ਅਰੁ ਭੇਦਾ ॥ dhinas rain barath ar bhaedhaa || day and night, fasting days and their determination; 10 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਸਾਸਤ ਸਿੰਮ੍ਰਿਤਿ ਬਿਨਸਹਿਗੇ ਬੇਦਾ ॥੩॥ saasath sinmrith binasehigae baedhaa ||3|| the Shaastras, the Simritees and the Vedas shall pass away. ||3|| 10 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਤੀਰਥ ਦੇਵ ਦੇਹੁਰਾ ਪੋਥੀ ॥ theerathh dhaev dhaehuraa pothhee || The sacred shrines of pilgrimage, gods, temples and holy books; 11 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਮਾਲਾ ਤਿਲਕੁ ਸੋਚ ਪਾਕ ਹੋਤੀ ॥ maalaa thilak soch paak hothee || rosaries, ceremonial tilak marks on the forehead, meditative people, the pure, and the performers of burnt offerings; 11 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਧੋਤੀ ਡੰਡਉਤਿ ਪਰਸਾਦਨ ਭੋਗਾ ॥ dhhothee ddanddouth parasaadhan bhogaa || wearing loin cloths, bowing in reverence and the enjoyment of sacred foods 11 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਗਵਨੁ ਕਰੈਗੋ ਸਗਲੋ ਲੋਗਾ ॥੪॥ gavan karaigo sagalo logaa ||4|| - all these, and all people, shall pass away. ||4|| 12 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਜਾਤਿ ਵਰਨ ਤੁਰਕ ਅਰੁ ਹਿੰਦੂ ॥ jaath varan thurak ar hindhoo || Social classes, races, Muslims and Hindus; 12 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਪਸੁ ਪੰਖੀ ਅਨਿਕ ਜੋਨਿ ਜਿੰਦੂ ॥ pas pankhee anik jon jindhoo || beasts, birds and the many varieties of beings and creatures; 12 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਸਗਲ ਪਾਸਾਰੁ ਦੀਸੈ ਪਾਸਾਰਾ ॥ sagal paasaar dheesai paasaaraa || the entire world and the visible universe 12 Gaurhee Guru Arjan Dev ਬਿਨਸਿ ਜਾਇਗੋ ਸਗਲ ਆਕਾਰਾ ॥੫॥ binas jaaeigo sagal aakaaraa ||5|| - all forms of existence shall pass away. ||5|| Here is 2nd shabad on this topic: ਸਾਗਰ ਮਹਿ ਬੂੰਦ ਬੂੰਦ ਮਹਿ ਸਾਗਰੁ ਕਵਣੁ ਬੁਝੈ ਬਿਧਿ ਜਾਣੈ ॥ saagar mehi boondh boondh mehi saagar kavan bujhai bidhh jaanai || The drop is in the ocean, and the ocean is in the drop. Who understands, and knows this? 18 Raamkalee Guru Nanak Dev ਉਤਭੁਜ ਚਲਤ ਆਪਿ ਕਰਿ ਚੀਨੈ ਆਪੇ ਤਤੁ ਪਛਾਣੈ ॥੧॥ outhabhuj chalath aap kar cheenai aapae thath pashhaanai ||1|| He Himself creates the wondrous play of the world. He Himself contemplates it, and understands its true essence. ||1|| Here is another one: ਜਿਸ ਤੇ ਉਪਜਿਆ ਤਿਸੁ ਮਾਹਿ ਸਮਾਨਾ ॥ jis thae oupajiaa this maahi samaanaa || Here is the last one, this one is very important to read and its quite poetic, guru maharaj ji talks about parsara of this akaar: Bazigar Jasie Baazi Paie Nana Roop Bhek Dekhlaie Sang Utar Thaimo Pasara Tab Ikaie Ikankara || Kavan Roop Dristio Binasio Kaithe Gayoo Oh Kath Dhayo || Jal Tai Utaie Anakh Taranga Kanakh bhookaie Bahu ranga Bij Bij Dekho Bahu Parkara Phul Pakaie Taie Ikankara || Sahet Gatava Mein Ek Akash Ghat Footaie Ohi Pargas || [quote]think you know what I am trying to say. Advaita does not believe in a Vaheguru who feels for bhagats and loves them, cares for them etc. According to Advaita he is Sat chit Anand in the sense that he is carefree of the world. Correct me on this. It also states that the world has been created out of ignorance but according to Gurbani, the world including the maya has been created by Vaheguru consciously and not as a result of some illusion or ignorance as Advaita states. This is why Vaheguru cares for this world. About his creation - he is - Vekhai Vigsai kar Vichaar|| Is this how the Brahm of Advaita too does i.e. look at his creation and be satisfied? No. The Brahm of Advaita did not even create this world. The world according to that Brahm of Advaita Vedanta is a result of illusion and not his conscious creation. Tell me with honesty, does the Brahm of Advaita have the following attributes: Santan Dukh paaye te dukhi|| Dukh paaye Saadhan ke sukhi|| Never. Impossible. That Brahm is Sada Chit Anand in his own saroop and feels not for his Bhagats. Look at the Brahm of Gurmat who feels dukh when his Bhagats feel Dukh and feels sukh when Saadhu Jan feel sukh. Is the Advaita Vedanta Brahm like this? No! [/quote] Advaita is theory of atma ekta with paratama. Therefore, they have only mentioned attributes of vahiguroo which relates to this atma being sat chit anand saroop. I agree advaita does not mention attributes to do with emotions as it gyan marg. But because of that, you cannot say advaita theory is not parvan in Gurmat. Sant jagjit singh ji as sun singh quote again beleives in the Gurmat - sikhi prema marg and gyan marg both are parvan, for starters is prema bhagti but for bhramgyani according to their surtee/perception they could carry with this same prem bhavna or they could say, sing out all aloud from gurbani- sohang so jai jaap , ja ko paun, there is no paap or paun for them, they are above karams and reason its not recommended for jaigaso because they can become more ahankari with jap. This gurmat sidhant - prema bhagti/gyan marg is beleived by all samparda- nirmale, sevapanthis, taksal. [quote]This theory has its roots in Vedas. Vedas have been rejected by Guru Sahib. The what is the standing of Vedas produced Advaita or the Vedas concept of Karma and reincarnation. Gurmat Karam Philosphy is different from that of Buddhist Karma and Vedas Karma. I don't know why you are under the impression that Gurmat has adopted the Karma philosophy of Hindus or Buddhists. I think you should read Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee's monumental book on Gurmat Karam Philosophy. The Napunsak (impotent) Karam philosophy of Buddhism and Vedas has been rejected by Gurmat. I don't want open a new front on Karam philosophy here, so I will stick to the topic on hand. [/quote] I never said theory of karma has orgins of hinduism. i said theory of karam is shared by eastern religions with few differences within them. I also don't want to open a new front on karam philosphy here as well, if you wish to discuss further kindly open up another topic as well. [quote]What Anadi Anubhavi Mahapurash are you referring to? No one has been Anadi Anubhavi Mahapurash without the kirpa of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Those Anaadi Mahapurash who are considered to be Pitamahs of Vedant are slaves of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Please refer to the following pankitis for proof on this: Who's greater in Hindus than Brahma the doer of Vedas? Who's greater sage in Hindu Dharam than Ved Vyaas who did the viyakaran of Vedas and divided them into 4 parts? Who is greater than Mahadev Shiv jee, who knows ultimate dhyaan and is the master of Yoga? Well, as per the above quote from Savaiyye Mahalle Pehle ke, they all are singing praises of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Looks like in due time they realized the true Guru - Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. [/quote] Why don't you ask sant jagjit singh ji harkhowale when he comes to toronto next time on which anubhavi mahapursh he is referring to?? You are more than welcome to discuss this with sant jagjit singh ji. I have already discuss it with your student- bijla singh in quite detail on sikhsangat forum. I have no desire to beat the dead horse. [quote]I have explained earlier that Karma, Vedant etc as explained in Hindu or Buddhist way has no place in Gurmat. According to the propenents of Advaita what did Gurmat bring to this world? It borrowed Vedant from Hindus and Karma from them as well. What is Gurmat offering to the world then? You guys are making Gurmat part of the Sanatan Dharma, for heaven's sake. While I don't have a phobia about Hindu religion like the extemists like Kala Afghana do, and I have respect and regard for these philosophies but at the same time, and I think of them as most exalted thoughts after Gurmat but I do believe that Gurmat is unique and not part of any old tradition. Gurmat of Guru Nanak Dev jee introduced to this world the true Nirgun-ism and it is the preacher of Gurmat Naam, without which no one can reach Vaheguru. Gurmat has not borrowed any concept from anyone. Gurmat is the source not borrower of knowledge. Gurmat is Vaheguru's own Dharma as per Bachiter Natak of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee [/quote] You see all your questions were already asked by myself and other singhs, sant ji answered them quite clearly. During the interview i even played devil's advocate and asked him all these questions, if you are not satisifed with the answers..no worries..when he comes next time you can meet him and request him to go deep. [quote]I acknowledge these concepts but not through the lens of Advaita Vedanta. ... have already explained above that the jeev gets new or refined antashkaran in the Sharam Khand. I don't know all this talk about Kaaran Sareer or whatever. This all is not written in Gurbani. I have read about it in Hindu books and it seems like Sikhs have just copied it from there. Gurbani makes it clear that Mann is jyot saroop. Please look at the following pankiti: First of, please tell me how and why the impersonal, carefree Brahm of Advaita Vedanta would be with the mann of the jeev, as stated in Gurbani pankiti above? Secondly, mann has been called jyot saroop. Then how can this mann not be with the jeev and Aatma when it's one with Vaheguru. Please ponder upon the following pankiti that clearly proves that Vaheguru too has Mann: It's clear from the above stated pankitis that Vaheguru too has mann but Advaita Vedanta states to the contrary and you too mentioned that jeev too is of 5 elements. Mann is part of the jeev and is jyot saroop as stated above. As you can see, Gurmat philosophy of being is quite contrary to the one being preached by Sants through the lens of Advaita Vedanta. [/quote] You may not know all this talk about karan sareer as you said but karan sareer is third layer of the body. Gurbani talks about first, two layer It's absurd to reject three layer of the body but acknowledge first two. In fact gurbani may not mention karan sirar directly but it mentions jagrath, saupan, sukhopat, these three avasthas are directly linked with three layers of body, panj kosh. Now going to gurbani quote you provided, its excellent quote, explains it all by shabads like jot saroop, mool painchan. Man tu jot saroop hai apna mool paichain || Advaita beleives avidya has diseased mind(mann) which in its orginal form was unman, guru maharaj giving updesh to mind with avidya - o ignorant mind, you are infact jot saroop...because of avidya you don't realize it but in fact you are jot saroop, recnognize yourself. To back it up all claim above on man which has antish karan and made out of five elements cannot be jot saroop and how vahiguroo cannot have mann but unman(atam chaitanta) here are tuks, once antish karan is gone and man becomes unman then only they can taste their own atma/paratma. As gurbani mentions describing state of bhramgyanis: Man asaadh sadhai jan koe Man maraie bin bhagat na hoi || ਇਹੁ ਮਨੁ ਪੰਚ ਤਤ ਕੋ ਜੀਉ ॥ eihu man panch tat ko jeeo || This mind is the life of the five elements. ਇਹੁ ਮਨੁ ਲੇ ਜਉ ਉਨਮਨਿ ਰਹੈ ॥ eihu man lae jo ounaman rehai || When this mind is channeled, and guided to enlightenment, ਉਨਮਨਿ ਮਨੂਆ ਸੁੰਨਿ ਸਮਾਨਾ ਦੁਬਿਧਾ ਦੁਰਮਤਿ ਭਾਗੀ ॥ ounaman manooaa sunn samaanaa dhubidhhaa dhuramath bhaagee || The disturbed mind has been absorbed in the Lord; duality and evil-mindedness have run away. 2 Gaurhee Saint Kabir ਕਹੁ ਕਬੀਰ ਅਨਭਉ ਇਕੁ ਦੇਖਿਆ ਰਾਮ ਨਾਮਿ ਲਿਵ ਲਾਗੀ ॥੪॥੨॥੪੬॥ kahu kabeer anabho eik dhaekhiaa raam naam liv laagee ||4||2||46|| ਜਗੁ ਜੀਤਉ ਗੁਰ ਦੁਆਰਿ ਖੇਲਹਿ ਸਮਤ ਸਾਰਿ ਰਥੁ ਉਨਮਨਿ ਲਿਵ ਰਾਖਿ ਨਿਰੰਕਾਰਿ ॥ ag jeetho gur dhuaar khaelehi samath saar rathh ounaman liv raakh nirankaar || [quote]I think what you mean above was Eh Parpanch (not Sargun) Parbrahm kee Leela|| [/quote] I am sorry about the quote above, i wasnt sure if gurbani calls it parpanch or sargun saroop. After little bit of research i couldnt find it so it was best not to write gurbani mentions this - sargun parbhram kee laal since i wasnt sure, i just wrote the line hoping someone would correct me and you did..thanks much.! To all the readers who are reading this vichar, here are some final thoughts on this topic: - I admit my knowledge in vikayaran is not very great but i m learning. I acknowledge its importantance. However, i also acknowledge based on reading book by looking at agam agadh bodh of gurbani, vikayaran(rules) niyam are made for gurbani are not accurate thats where sampardai's paramparik arths comes in gives valid interpertation of gurbani. - As you can see from previous discussion especially the one i posted from tapoban forum titled - Condition of bhagats in Vahiguroo darbar, some of the points were bought up again which were adressed by jsingh already. However, i m glad that kulbir singh bought fwd up those points in this discussion because that lead me to do more khoj on this, during this khoj i came across with some stunning gurbani quotes above which totally debunks the "one rule theory that all bhramgyanis have their own vajood(indentity), individualstic conscinesss when they leave their body". It is even clearer after reading beautiful gurbani quotes that gurbani supports meta reality, based on your surti. - From previous debates, few stuff were not answered by jsingh as why there is need for second merge when they already attained bhramgyan in this earth. After some khoj, this is where i disagree a bit with jsingh. There are quotes likes zeeman zaaman kai bhikaie samast ek jot hai na ghat na bhat hai na ghat bat hot hai || and other quotes above which proves that gurmukh bhramgyanis are fully merged with nirankar, all bhramgyani does tyaag their chola(body) this upadi, thats it, there is no second merge they are already merged with vahiguroo while living in this body, after bhramgyan there man has became unman, antish karans (karama di bhand) is destroyed, they are above karam (paap na paun) as explained in gurbani quote above by bhagat kabir ji. - I too have provided have gurbani quotes to back up most of veechar i shared in this discussion. At the end of day, I m in no way to convince kulbir singh and other preconceived loyality to their group mindset. I have no intentions making people beleif on total merge theory where vajood being lost with gurbani quotes explaining destruction. Kulbir singh beleifs/stance same 3 years ago, same now, same will even after giving up his body because thats his surti there is no problem there as gurbani mentions it clear. However,when one tries to imply that all the bhramgyanis have their vajood(indentity), conscicouness when they leave this body thats where one's view contradicts in gurbani as gurbani supports meta reality and have given updesh to based on person's surti. its a long post, i didn't proof read it properly. Bhul Chuk Maaphi for any mistakes in gurbani or if i said any koraie bachans. VahiguroojikakhalsaVahiguroojikifateh!

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Bijla Singh · 04 Sep 2008

You did not post any aarths to which viyakaran cannot be applied. Every language has viyakaran and viyakaran in Gurbani is applicable all the time. Your poor understanding of viyakaran unables you to realize this fact. Whether Shabads are written in context, metaphors etc viyakaran will always apply because no language is written without grammar. If scholars have not understood viyakaran completely then it is not the fault of viyakaran. It is like saying Gurbani has not been understood 100% by anyone so Gurbani is not valid or false. This is very foolish. Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji is correct when he says "Lakh Kror bandhan will go away by doing japp of Naam" but these meanings do not apply to the panktis in Sukhmani Sahib because the word ਬੰਧੁਨ does not appear in Gurbani. Do a search and study the difference between ਬੰਧਨ and ਬੰਧੁ ਨ. Here viyakaran is very helpful in understanding what Gurbani really means. I do not believe Gurbani is limited to one meaning only but I also believe viyakran will always apply even to antreev meanings. "I have already discuss it with your student- bijla singh in quite detail on sikhsangat forum" Please don't make foolish assumptions without any proof. My teacher is Guru Sahib because I obey Guru Sahib only, and to clear my doubts I ask gursikhs, refer to teekas and other books. I also listen to katha done by Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji to understand wide range of approaches to Gurbani. I would be narrow minded if I only wished to learn only one side and not other thoughts on Gurbani. I ask questions on this forum because some people here are more qualified to answer what Bhai Sahib has written than anyone else on other forums. I will leave rest of your points to be answered by kulbir singh, if he wishes.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 05 Sep 2008

Veer N3O Singh jeeo, I will respond to your post soon but I could not help respond to your comment about Bijla Singh being my chela. Here is what you wrote: [quote] I have already discuss it with your student- bijla singh in quite detail on sikhsangat forum[/quote] 1) First of all, what gave you the impression that I am in the business of making chelas? If I myself can live the life of chela of Guru Sahib, I would be immensely satisfied. People whom I socialize with and talk to on regular basis can be counted on my fingers. I am not a public person, nor I have a social circle. From home I go to work and from work to home. On the weekend the only destination for me to visit is Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib. That's it. I don't have a third destination to go. No stores, no parks, no theates, no bazaars, no restaurants, no other public places, no nothing. Where would I find poor Bijla Singh to make my chela? 2) I don't even know who Veer Bijla Singh is. I have never met him and I believe had only one or two email conversations with him, about a couple of Gurbani pankitis. The comment was unfair to both of us. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

N30 S!NGH · 05 Sep 2008

Gurfateh Kulbir singh ji, Accept my humblest apologies for assumption made by me above which i shouldn't have done. will look fwd to your reply and response back if there is anything new to discuss. Gurfateh Ji.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Atma Singh · 05 Sep 2008

ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ Khalsa Jeeo, just before the final Mundavnee (i.e. before Salok Mehla 5) appears the last Dohra of Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee blessed upon us by Siree Guroo Tegh Bahadur Sahib Jee, The King of Shaheeds. please bear in mind that immediately before this Dohra, the Salok that features ends with the following du-panktee: ਜੋ ਉਪਜਿਓ ਸੋ ਬਿਨਸਿ ਹੈ ਪਰੋ ਆਜੁ ਕੈ ਕਾਲਿ ॥ jo oupajiou so binas hai paro aaj kai kaal || WHATEVER HAS BEEN CREATED SHA'LL BE DESTROYED; everyone shall perish, today or tomorrow. ਨਾਨਕ ਹਰਿ ਗੁਨ ਗਾਇ ਲੇ ਛਾਡਿ ਸਗਲ ਜੰਜਾਲ ॥52॥ naanak har gun gaae lae shhaadd sagal ja(n)jaal ||52|| O Nanak, sing the Glorious Praises of the Lord, and give up all other entanglements. ||52|| the Dohra continues with this theme (instability/non-permanence of all creation, importance of merging with Vaheguroo) and expands upon it. please contemplate the following panktee which appears within this final Dohra: ਨਾਮੁ ਰਹਿਓ ਸਾਧੂ ਰਹਿਓ ਰਹਿਓ ਗੁਰੁ ਗੋਬਿੰਦੁ ॥ naam rehiou saadhhoo rehiou rehiou gur gobi(n)dh || The Naam remains; the Gurmukhs remain; the Guru, the Lord of the Universe, remains. ਕਹੁ ਨਾਨਕ ਇਹ ਜਗਤ ਮੈ ਕਿਨ ਜਪਿਓ ਗੁਰ ਮੰਤੁ ॥56॥ kahu naanak eih jagath mai kin japiou gur ma(n)th ||56|| Says Nanak, how rare are those who chant the Guru's Mantra in this world. ||56|| (ang 1429) therefore, however we wish to interpret this or understand it, we must all accept that three inseperable entities have been described as 'remaining' post-destruction of the visible universe. this clearly suggests that these entities can be distinguished to some sort of extent. these entities are Vaheguroo, Guroo and Sadhoos (Gurmukhs-Bhagats). in effect they are all actually One. it has recently kept popping into my mind for various reasons that the word Gurmukh has been used in GurbaaNee, in various forms, to refer to all three of these entities...however, the above tells us that upon some sort of level these are identifiable as three. veer kulbir singh jee, perhaps you could discuss this panktee in the light of viyakarN as there may be different ways to interpret it. questions/conclusions that jump to mind are: - naam refers to gurmantar here; naam here is a singular noun, in both the first and second part of this du-panktee. this highlights the vast gulf between kirtam naam and gurmat naam. kirtam naam are man-made words, albeit the purest words man has ever conjured-up, which helps him get very close to Vaheguroo. however, these will bedstroyed when the universe immerses back into where it came from, Vaheguroo. at that point only Naam, Gur-Mant, will remain. we know that this Naam is Self-Created and Self-Existent...beyond spoken words, it is Vaheguroo's Presence and Self-Expressed Kalaa. Gursikhs really do a disservice to Maharaaj Jee by trying to lump Gurmant (Gurmat Naam) with Kirtam Naam...i suppose this is His Bhana so who am i to complain :-) - it could be argued that the term sadhoo may not be a plural term; that it is singular and refers to Siree Guroo Sahib Jee - i personally think it is plural and that it therefore refers to Gurmukh-Bhagats; perhaps we don't even need viyakarN to prove this. the preceding du-panktee to this one is: ਸੰਗ ਸਖਾ ਸਭਿ ਤਜਿ ਗਏ ਕੋਊ ਨ ਨਿਬਹਿਓ ਸਾਥਿ ॥ sa(n)g sakhaa sabh thaj geae kooo n nibehiou saathh || My associates and companions have all deserted me; no one remains with me. ਕਹੁ ਨਾਨਕ ਇਹ ਬਿਪਤਿ ਮੈ ਟੇਕ ਏਕ ਰਘੁਨਾਥ ॥55॥ kahu naanak eih bipath mai ttaek eaek raghunaathh ||55|| Says Nanak, in this tragedy, the Lord alone is my Support. ||55|| therefore, it is obvious that these immortal and stable Gurmukh-Bhagats, the Rangle Sajjan that will stand with us here in Lok and there in Par-Lok, are being referred to in contrast to our temporary and unstable worldy non-Gurmukh associates. what can we learn form all this? perhaps the most most important thing to note is that the drop returns to The Ocean; no-one is arguing against this. but that doesn't mean that the drop has forever disappeared. it is now One with The Ocean and has access to the vast greatness of The Ocean...but Vaheguroo is no ordinary Ocean... that drop is still discernible - it has not been destroyed by joining The Ocean - it has simply been made greater by becoming part of something which is the greatest. perhaps this is why the stage where one realises Aatmaa is different to that stage when one realises Par-Aatmaa...the former is definitely the lower of the two stages. even if Sadhoo did refer to Siree Guroo Sahib Jee, as some may argue, it would still prove that when Milaap with Par-Aaatmaa occurs, individual Aatmaas have their own existence. - gur gobind - both are nouns. perhaps only Vaheguroo is being referred to here via a compound term - gur-gobond. however, one could argue that Gur refers to Siree Guroo Sahib Jee whilst Gobind refers to Vaheguroo. regardless, They are one and The Same so no matter. or perhaps Maharaaj Jee is referring to Themself within the term Sadhoo? veer kulbir singh jee, any viyakarN thoughts here? - by saying: kahu naanak eih jagath mai kin japiou gur ma(n)th...Maharaaj Jee is effectively telling us that only those rare few will realise this reality, that only The Gurmukh (Vaheguroo, Guroo, Gursikhs) will remain, who truly jap Gur-Mant and are Gur-Mant. it is for the Gursikh Gurmukh to do Milaap before dissolution and come to know The Truth regarding that which exists beyond all dissolution - the first to have no need to do Milaap as that is a given. Gurmukh-Vaheguroo is The Primal and Gurmukh-Guroo is Vaheguroo's Witness since Creation. this is because in order to Self-Reveal within Created Creation, and not to rely on hearsay, Vaheguroo manifested and Self-Revealed on earth as Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee - Bhai Gurdaas Jee (and Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh via his tract 'Is Worship of Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee Idol Worship?) helps us inderstand that only Vaheguroo can reveal themselves as Vaheguroo to us - no-one lese has the capability as all revealed Dharam and thoughts are Kachee knoweldge and hearsay. this is the job of Guroo and this is why Guroo had to be, and is, Vaheguroo Themself. Gurmukh-Bhagat is They who realise that their Aatmaa is Vaheguroo/Guroo which can ONLY as occur as a result of becoming direct Bhagats of Vaheguroo through Guroo who is Vaheguroo. - veer kulbir singh jee, how would you do bishraams of this panktee - the word kin has left me in a bit of doubt. i'm thinking it can only be one of two ways: kahu naanak , eih jagath mai kin ; japiou gur ma(n)th ||56|| or... kahu naanak , eih jagath mai ; kin japiou gur ma(n)th ||56||

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harjas Kaur · 08 Sep 2008

[quote]As long as we don't associate Gurmat with Advaita Vedanta, I am fine with it. Gurmat is unique and nothing in the world comes even near it. To describe Gurmat through the lenses of Vedant or any other worldly philosophy is what I am against. Gurmat can be described through Gurbani, Bhai Gurdaas jee's Baani, Bhai Nandlal jee's baani and by Gursikhs who have lived Gurmat all their lives. Where does Vedant come in picture when talking about Gurmat? The root of Vedant is Vedas and these Vedas have been rejected by Guru Sahib in Gurbani, then what to talk about Vedant?[/quote] Where does Gurbani reject the Vedas? Gurbani clarifies that Vedas cannot give you Mukti, but also that Vedas are wonderful and teach us the mukti comes from Naam jap. Moreover, Bhai Gurdas Ji was a Sanskrit scholar. His vaaran talks about Vedas, stories from Ramayan and Bhagavad-Gita and even things from Shiva Sutras like kechari mudra. Where do you get Advaita as a philosoiphy has no impact whatsoever on Gurbani? Much of Gurbani contains references to Gaudiya Vaishnavism in Naams of the Sarguna, why not the Achint abedabeda of Vaishnavism as well, which Gurbani seems to support in the very concept of niragun-sargun as well as Dvaita and Advaita philosophies of the multiplicity being the One, and the All-pervading? Since Sikhism is rooted within Indic culture and context, and this terminology and these philosophies are really not anything new... unique yes, but not new, why would Advaita per se, not be Gurmat? Why would Vaishnavism not be Gurmat? After all doesn't vaaran of Bhai Gurdas Ji say the Vaheguru Gurmantra is V= Vasudeyv, Vishnu, H = Hari Krishna, G = Gobinda, R= Raam? If this is not Vaishnav Naams of God but some new unique "Sikh Panth" formulation which really translates as nirguna Eko Braman, we know that can't be true since no one can name the nirguna. Nirguna is beyond language and concepts of mind and hence requires Turiya consciousness of dasm duar which is opened to perceive the darshan of Vaheguru without kalpas in nirbikalpa samadhi. Not only that but other pauris of Gurbani clearly praise the Das Avataaras and Vishnu as the Supreme Lord, and so this must be sargun saroop of nirguna. If any philosophy comes closest to matching Gurbani I see that as being Gaudiya Vaishnavism. So it makes perfect sense for Gurbani to deiscuss both Dvaita personal bhakti relationship with sarguna, as well as merging or mukti acknowledging all that exists is only He. Why would this be anti-Gurmat when it is clearly discussed in Gurbani and has definite and traceable relationship to bhagti Vaishnavism of the time? ~bhul chak maaf karni ji

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harcharan Singh · 08 Sep 2008

"all revealed Dharam and thoughts are Kachee knoweldge and hearsay" With all due respect Atma Singh Veerji, I think this statement is a little extreme. How can Dharam be both revealed and Kachaa? Bhai Gurdas Ji says: ਬੇਦ ਕਤੇਬ ਭੁਲਾਇ ਕੈ ਮੋਹੇ ਲਾਲਚ ਦੁਨੀ ਸੈਤਾਣੇ । He clearly says that by forgetting the Bayd and K'teb - the followers have been incticed into greed by Satan. Does this by default not imply the Bayd and K'teb are therefore guides of truth? Why would Guru Arjun Dev Ji say: ਕੁਰਾਣੁ ਕਤੇਬ ਦਿਲ ਮਾਹਿ ਕਮਾਹੀ ॥ Why would Bhagat Kabir Ji say: ਬੇਦ ਕਤੇਬ ਕਹਹੁ ਮਤ ਝੂਠੇ ਝੂਠਾ ਜੋ ਨ ਬਿਚਾਰੈ ॥ I am not quoting these tuks out of context - I am aware the shabds talk about hypocrisy of the followers - but that is a different subject. Guru Nanak Dev Ji says: ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਨਾਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਵੇਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਰਹਿਆ ਸਮਾਈ ॥ Guru Arjun Dev Ji says: ਸਾਸਤ ਸਿੰਮ੍ਰਿਤਿ ਬੇਦ ਬੀਚਾਰੇ ਮਹਾ ਪੁਰਖਨ ਇਉ ਕਹਿਆ ॥ ਬਿਨੁ ਹਰਿ ਭਜਨ ਨਾਹੀ ਨਿਸਤਾਰਾ ਸੂਖੁ ਨ ਕਿਨਹੂੰ ਲਹਿਆ ॥੧॥ Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji says: ਬੇਦ ਪੁਰਾਨ ਪੜੇ ਕੋ ਇਹ ਗੁਨ ਸਿਮਰੇ ਹਰਿ ਕੋ ਨਾਮਾ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ And ਬੇਦ ਪੁਰਾਨ ਜਾਸ ਗੁਨ ਗਾਵਤ ਤਾ ਕੋ ਨਾਮੁ ਹੀਐ ਮੋ ਧਰੁ ਰੇ ॥ Does the following quote from the bible sound like hearsay: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God."

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harjas Kaur · 09 Sep 2008

Admin Note: Harjas Kaur, please use lower case, when using the 'quote' function. Otherwise it will not work and the admin had to manually fix the 'quote' notation in this post of yours [quote]this clearly suggests that these entities can be distinguished to some sort of extent. these entities are Vaheguroo, Guroo and Sadhoos (Gurmukhs-Bhagats). in effect they are all actually One. it has recently kept popping into my mind for various reasons that the word Gurmukh has been used in GurbaaNee, in various forms, to refer to all three of these entities...however, the above tells us that upon some sort of level these are identifiable as three.[/quote] Why would the Oneness of the All-pervading be limited to only these three categories, Vaheguroo, Guroo and Gurmukhs-bhagats? Doesn't Gurbani say otherwise? ਜਹ ਦੇਖਾ ਤਹ ਰਵਿ ਰਹੇ ਸਿਵ ਸਕਤੀ ਕਾ ਮੇਲੁ ॥ jeh dhaekhaa theh rav rehae siv sakathee kaa mael || Wherever I look, I see the Lord pervading there, in the union of Shiva and Shakti, of consciousness and matter. ~SGGS Ji p. 21 ਵਰਨ ਰੂਪ ਵਰਤਹਿ ਸਭ ਤੇਰੇ ॥ varan roop varathehi sabh thaerae || In all colors and forms, You are pervading. ~SGGS Ji p. 120 ਘਟਿ ਘਟਿ ਏਕੁ ਵਰਤਦਾ ਜਲਿ ਥਲਿ ਮਹੀਅਲਿ ਪੂਰੇ ॥੪॥ ghatt ghatt eaek varathadhaa jal thhal meheeal poorae ||4|| In each and every heart, the One Lord is pervading. He is totally permeating the water, the land, and the sky. ||4|| ਪਾਪ ਬਿਨਾਸਨੁ ਸੇਵਿਆ ਪਵਿਤ੍ਰ ਸੰਤਨ ਕੀ ਧੂਰੇ ॥੫॥ paap binaasan saeviaa pavithr santhan kee dhhoorae ||5|| I serve the Destroyer of sin, and I am sanctified by the dust of the feet of the Saints. ||5|| ~SGGS Ji p. 133 ਉਲਟਿਓ ਕਮਲੁ ਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਬੀਚਾਰਿ ॥ oulattiou kamal breham beechaar || The inverted heart-lotus has been turned upright, through reflective meditation on God. ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤ ਧਾਰ ਗਗਨਿ ਦਸ ਦੁਆਰਿ ॥ anmrith dhhaar gagan dhas dhuaar || From the Sky of the Tenth Gate, the Ambrosial Nectar trickles down. ਤ੍ਰਿਭਵਣੁ ਬੇਧਿਆ ਆਪਿ ਮੁਰਾਰਿ ॥੧॥ thribhavan baedhhiaa aap muraar ||1|| The Lord Himself is pervading the three worlds. ||1|| ~SGGS Ji p. 153 ਸਭੁ ਕੀਤਾ ਤੇਰਾ ਵਰਤਦਾ ਤੂੰ ਅੰਤਰਜਾਮੀ ॥ sabh keethaa thaeraa varathadhaa thoon antharajaamee || You made them all; You are all-pervading. You are the Inner-knower, the Searcher of hearts. ਹਮ ਜੰਤ ਵਿਚਾਰੇ ਕਿਆ ਕਰਹ ਸਭੁ ਖੇਲੁ ਤੁਮ ਸੁਆਮੀ ॥ ham janth vichaarae kiaa kareh sabh khael thum suaamee || What can these wretched creatures do? This whole drama is Yours, O Lord and Master. ~SGGS Ji p. 167 ਸੁਰਗ ਪਇਆਲ ਮਿਰਤ ਭੂਅ ਮੰਡਲ ਸਰਬ ਸਮਾਨੋ ਏਕੈ ਓਹੀ ॥ surag paeiaal mirath bhooa manddal sarab samaano eaekai ouhee || In the heavenly paradise, in the nether regions of the underworld, on the planet earth and throughout the galaxies, the One Lord is pervading everywhere. ਸਿਵ ਸਿਵ ਕਰਤ ਸਗਲ ਕਰ ਜੋਰਹਿ ਸਰਬ ਮਇਆ ਠਾਕੁਰ ਤੇਰੀ ਦੋਹੀ ॥੧॥ siv siv karath sagal kar jorehi sarab maeiaa thaakur thaeree dhohee ||1|| Everyone calls upon You with their palms pressed together, saying, ""Shiva, Shiva"". O Merciful Lord and Master, everyone cries out for Your Help. ||1|| ~SGGS Ji p. 207 ਉਆ ਕਾ ਅੰਤੁ ਨ ਕਾਹੂ ਪਾਇਆ ॥ ouaa kaa anth n kaahoo paaeiaa || No one has ever found His limit. ਕੀਟ ਹਸਤਿ ਮਹਿ ਪੂਰ ਸਮਾਨੇ ॥ keett hasath mehi poor samaanae || In the ant and in the elephant, He is totally pervading. ~SGGS Ji p. 252 ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਨਾਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਵੇਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਰਹਿਆ ਸਮਾਈ ॥ guramukh naadhan guramukh vaedhan guramukh rehiaa samaaee || The Guru's Word is the Sound-current of the Naad; the Guru's Word is the Wisdom of the Vedas; the Guru's Word is all-pervading. ਗੁਰੁ ਈਸਰੁ ਗੁਰੁ ਗੋਰਖੁ ਬਰਮਾ ਗੁਰੁ ਪਾਰਬਤੀ ਮਾਈ ॥ gur eesar gur gorakh baramaa gur paarabathee maaee || The Guru is Shiva, the Guru is Vishnu and Brahma; the Guru is Paarvati and Lakhshmi. ~SGGS Ji p. 2 ਕਿਰਪਾ ਕਰਿ ਕੈ ਆਪਣੀ ਆਪੇ ਲਏ ਸਮਾਇ ਜੀਉ ॥੨੧॥ kirapaa kar kai aapanee aapae leae samaae jeeo ||21|| Showering His Mercy, He has blended me into Himself. ||21|| ਗੋਪੀ ਨੈ ਗੋਆਲੀਆ ॥ gopee nai goaaleeaa || You are the Gopis, the milk-maids of Krishna; You are the sacred river Jamunaa; You are Krishna, the herdsman. ਤੁਧੁ ਆਪੇ ਗੋਇ ਉਠਾਲੀਆ ॥ thudhh aapae goe outhaaleeaa || You Yourself support the world. ~SGGS Ji p. 73 And in clear praise of sargun saroop of Hari Krishna Gurbani says: ਆਪੇ ਗੋਪੀ ਕਾਨੁ ਹੈ ਪਿਆਰਾ ਬਨਿ ਆਪੇ ਗਊ ਚਰਾਹਾ ॥ aapae gopee kaan hai piaaraa ban aapae goo charaahaa || The Beloved Himself is the milk-maid and Krishna; He Himself herds the cows in the woods. ਆਪੇ ਸਾਵਲ ਸੁੰਦਰਾ ਪਿਆਰਾ ਆਪੇ ਵੰਸੁ ਵਜਾਹਾ ॥ aapae saaval sundharaa piaaraa aapae vans vajaahaa || The Beloved Himself is the blue-skinned, handsome one; He Himself plays on His flute. ਕੁਵਲੀਆ ਪੀੜੁ ਆਪਿ ਮਰਾਇਦਾ ਪਿਆਰਾ ਕਰਿ ਬਾਲਕ ਰੂਪਿ ਪਚਾਹਾ ॥੨॥ kuvaleeaa peerr aap maraaeidhaa piaaraa kar baalak roop pachaahaa ||2|| The Beloved Himself took the form of a child, and destroyed Kuwalia-peer, the mad elephant. ||2|| ਆਪਿ ਅਖਾੜਾ ਪਾਇਦਾ ਪਿਆਰਾ ਕਰਿ ਵੇਖੈ ਆਪਿ ਚੋਜਾਹਾ ॥ aap akhaarraa paaeidhaa piaaraa kar vaekhai aap chojaahaa || The Beloved Himself sets the stage; He performs the plays, and He Himself watches them. ਕਰਿ ਬਾਲਕ ਰੂਪ ਉਪਾਇਦਾ ਪਿਆਰਾ ਚੰਡੂਰੁ ਕੰਸੁ ਕੇਸੁ ਮਾਰਾਹਾ ॥ kar baalak roop oupaaeidhaa piaaraa chanddoor kans kaes maaraahaa || The Beloved Himself assumed the form of the child, and killed the demons Chandoor, Kansa and Kaysee. ਆਪੇ ਹੀ ਬਲੁ ਆਪਿ ਹੈ ਪਿਆਰਾ ਬਲੁ ਭੰਨੈ ਮੂਰਖ ਮੁਗਧਾਹਾ ॥੩॥ aapae hee bal aap hai piaaraa bal bhannai moorakh mugadhhaahaa ||3|| The Beloved Himself, by Himself, is the embodiment of power; He shatters the power of the fools and idiots. ||3|| ਸਭੁ ਆਪੇ ਜਗਤੁ ਉਪਾਇਦਾ ਪਿਆਰਾ ਵਸਿ ਆਪੇ ਜੁਗਤਿ ਹਥਾਹਾ ॥ sabh aapae jagath oupaaeidhaa piaaraa vas aapae jugath hathhaahaa || The Beloved Himself created the whole world. In His hands He holds the power of the ages. ~SGGS Ji p. 606 ~Bhul chak maaf

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Atma Singh · 09 Sep 2008

ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ veer harcharan singh jee, firstly, we must all have faith that if GurbaaNee/Bhai Gurdaas Jee's Vaaraa(n) seem self-contradictory, the misunderstanding is ALWAYS with us and we must do further GurbaaNee and Naam Abhiyaas to rectify our understanding. bhai gurdaas jee also says the following elsewhere: ਅਪੜਿ ਕੋਇ ਨ ਹੰਘਈ ਸੁਣਿ ਸੁਣਿ ਆਖਣ ਆਖਿ ਸੁਣਾਈ॥ ਸਤਿਗੁਰੁ ਮੂਰਤਿ ਪਰਗਟੀ ਆਈ ॥੫॥ None can reach Him, ALL TALK about Him is on the basis of HEARSAY. That Lord has become MANIFEST in the form of the True Guru.(5) also: ਨਿਰੰਕਾਰੁ ਆਕਾਰੁ ਕਰਿ ਜੋਤਿ ਸਰੂਪੁ ਅਨੂਪ ਦਿਖਾਇਆ॥ ਵੇਦ ਕਤੇਬ ਅਗੋਚਰਾ ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਗੁਰ ਸਬਦੁ ਸੁਣਾਇਆ॥ ਚਾਰਿ ਵਰਨ ਚਾਰਿ ਮਜਹਬਾ ਚਰਣ ਕਵਲ ਸਰਣਾਗਤਿ ਆਇਆ॥ ਪਾਰਸਿ ਪਰਸਿ ਅਪਰਸ ਜਗਿ ਅਸਟਧਾਤੁ ਇਕੁ ਧਾਤੁ ਕਰਾਇਆ॥ The formless Lord has been beholden in the form of the light (in Guru Nanak and other Gurus). The Gurus recited Word-Guru as Vaheguru who is BEYOND the Vedas and Katebas (the Semitic scriptures). Therefore all the four varnas and all four Semitic religions have sought the shelter of the lotus feet of the Guru. When the Gurus in the form of Philosopher’s stone touched them, that alloy of eight metal changed into ONE METAL (Gold in the form of Sikhism). also: ਬੇਦ ਗਿਰੰਥ ਗੁਰ ਹਟਿ ਹੈ ਜਿਸੁ ਲਗਿ ਭਵਜਲ ਪਾਰਿ ਉਤਾਰਾ॥ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਬਾਝੁ ਨ ਬੁਝੀਐ ਜਿਚਰੁ ਧਰੇ ਨ ਪ੍ਰਭੁ ਅਵਤਾਰਾ॥ From that knowledge of the Vedas which gets man across the world ocean even the knowledgeable people get away. So long God DOES NOT DESCEND on earth in the form of True Guru, no mystery can be UNDERSTOOD. from the above it is crystal clear that: - Vaheguroo who is Unapproachable and Inaccessible cannot be 'reached' no matter how much anyone has tried in the past or will try in the future. - Therefore, Vaheguroo could only be known, and directly 'reach us', if They were to become Pargat (manifest) upon earth. - Satguroo Sahib Jee is Vaheguroo's Pargat Presence upon earth. - Before Satguroo Sahib Jee, all spiritual knowledge was and still is hearsay i.e. kachee/half-baked. it may be useful (just as Kachee rotee will still give you some nutrition) but it is not the Tat i.e. quintessence. Bhagat Kabeer Sahib Jee says: ਕਹਤ ਕਬੀਰ ਭਲੇ ਅਸਵਾਰਾ || ਬੇਦ ਕਤੇਬ ਤੇ ਰਹਹਿ ਨਿਰਾਰਾ ॥3॥31॥ Says Kabeer, those who remain detached from the Vedas, the Koran and the Bible are the best riders. ||3||31|| when we read the whole Shabad, we realise that Bhagat Sahib Jee is telling us that Prem-Bhagtee is the only way to realise Vaheguroo. Vaheguroo cannot be received nor experienced through adherence to these scriptures which are actually devoid of Prem-Bhagtee Philosophy (i.e. Gurmat) and it's implications. incidentally, Bhagat Sahib is perhaps the most critical out of all the Mehls/Bhagat Sahibs re: other scriptures. so, the big question is: are there INHERENT CONTRADICTIONS within GurbaaNee/Gurmat or not? this is where Jeevan-less scholars/Vidhvaans become unstuck due to their intellectual and dry experience-less/faithless mis-interpretations..nonetheless, they have to quickly pander to their own 'quick-fix' Vichaaraa(n) in order to save face - they tell themselves: "Oh my mind, don't leave me! I need you to show the world that I understand!". in this way they chase after their ego and get more and more stuck in the swamp of duality where faith is nowhere to be found. but it is this situation also where Gurmukh Bhagats become free of all doubt and become content with the truth due to personal experience and Guroo-Blessed Intuitive and Spontaneous Sojhee - their mind is firmly told: "leave me - you have no place here! Gurmat rules here". they avoid duality and beg for Sojhee from Maharaaj Jee alone, leaving all their assumptions and presumptions behind. we must all come directly to Siree Guroo Sahib Jee and put in the effort if we are truly to start doing Vichaar of Gurmat/GurbaaNee. it is then that the overall 'Gurmat Context', within which we naturally come to understand the Pankteeaa(n) you have highlighted, becomes apparent and ultimately, the key to really understanding just Who and What Siree Guroo Sahib Jee really is. the more GurbaaNee and Naam Abhiyaas, the greater GurbaaNee-based knowledge we will receive. i personally have yet to come across one Panktee which contradicts the notion that without Siree Satguroo Sahib Jee one can attain Milaap with Vaheguroo. why? because the Kasvatee (touch-stone of truth) being used is GurbaaNee and i must CONTINUOUSLY apply all my limited interpretations regarding GurbaaNee back against this Kasvatee, on an ongoing basis. through Maharaaj Jee's Kirpa, my doubts on this path have been and continue to be removed in this way. ਵਾਹੁ ਵਾਹੁ ਬਾਣੀ ਨਿਰੰਕਾਰ ਹੈ ਤਿਸੁ ਜੇਵਡੁ ਅਵਰੁ ਨ ਕੋਇ ॥ ਵਾਹੁ ਵਾਹੁ ਅਗਮ ਅਥਾਹੁ ਹੈ ਵਾਹੁ ਵਾਹੁ ਸਚਾ ਸੋਇ ॥ Wondrous! Wondrous! is the BaaNee, the Word, it is Nirankaar (Formless Vaheguroo). There is no other as great as BaaNee/Nirankaar. Wondrous! Wondrous! Vaheguroo is unfathomable and inaccessible. Wondrous! Wondrous! is the True One. my interpretation regarding this Du-Panktee is: - GurbaaNee, the Pothee which is 'Parmeshar Ka Thaan' (the place where the Universal Vaheguroo resides'), is Nirankaar (Formless Vaheguroo)...because only GurbaaNee qualifies as Akath dee Katha (Explanation regarding the Unexplainable) - because it explains and lets us immerse within the Self-Revealed Guns (attributes/qualities) of Nirankaar. - These Attributes are One and the Same - the Formless can only be known via Their Attributes; therefore GurbaaNee is the Manifest Nirankaar...the seemingly impossible happening has happened with the advent of Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee - the Pargat Guroo-Jyot Form of Vaheguroo and now the Eternal Existence of Siree Guroo Granth Sahib Jee. - They who are ਅਗਮ ਅਥਾਹੁ (Un-realisable, Un-reachable), Vaheguroo, the Mysterious One, They have reached out to us in the Form of Manifest Eternal Truth - Shabad Guroo. Truth is and always has been the Form of Nirankaar Vaheguroo and always will be. This True One is Truly ਵਾਹੁ!!! veer jee, it would be silly for me to continue and offer my opinion, which is a result of trying to assimilate GurbaaNee in my own way. ਆਦਿਸਚੁਜੁਗਾਦਿਸਚੁ ॥ ਹੈਭੀਸਚੁਨਾਨਕਹੋਸੀਭੀਸਚੁ ॥੧॥ The Truth before time, The Truth when time began The Truth Here and Now; Nanak, The Truth Eternally.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Atma Singh · 09 Sep 2008

bhain jee harjas kaur jee, you wrote: "Why would the Oneness of the All-pervading be limited to only these three categories, Vaheguroo, Guroo and Gurmukhs-bhagats?" it is not limited to these three - i simply believe that after dissolution of the Universe, the All-Pervading Singular Vaheguroo will be expressed through these three alone. there will be no material creation. i accept that Vaheguroo/Naam is all pervasive - one of the Gur-shabads you quoted throws more light upon your own question: ਉਲਟਿਓ ਕਮਲੁ ਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਬੀਚਾਰਿ || oulattiou kamal breham beechaar || The inverted heart-lotus has been turned upright, through reflective meditation on God. ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤ ਧਾਰ ਗਗਨਿ ਦਸ ਦੁਆਰਿ || anmrith dhhaar gagan dhas dhuaar || From the Sky of the Tenth Gate, the Ambrosial Nectar trickles down. ਤ੍ਰਿਭਵਣੁ ਬੇਧਿਆ ਆਪਿ ਮੁਰਾਰਿ ॥੧॥ thribhavan baedhhiaa aap muraar ||1|| The Lord Himself is pervading the three worlds. ||1|| ~SGGS Ji p. 153 only the Gurmukh-Bhagats via Gurmukh-Vaheguroo/Guroo/Naam have the tools needed to experience Vaheguroo face-to-face in the most quintessential sense - they have the human body and they are blessed directly by Vaheguroo. no-one denies that Vaheguroo has acted through all things, all people at all times - GurbaaNee confirms this over and over again. many of the Gur-Shabads you have blessed upon us reiterate this. however, please bear in mind that Bhagats such as Brahma never realised Vaheguroo. Brahmas and millions of others must approach Siree Guroo Sahib Jee in manifest form to receive Amrit Naam. whether this can occur through the Spiritual Sareer of Maharaaj Jee or whether they must be reborn as humans to be given Amrit Naam, i personally don't know either way. also, when some people worship Shiva or Krishna, even if they do not realise it, they are worshipping Vaheguroo to some extent because Vaheguroo is the power behind all of these Dev/Devteeaa(n). On the other hand, those who worship Vaheguroo and call Him via Kirtam Naam (Brahma, Krishna, Allah etc.) are simply singing the praises of Vaheguroo, knowing full well that they are addressing Vaheguroo who has expressed Their Great Glory through all forms...yet is not limited to any. for example, you blessed us with the following Gur-Pankteeaa(n): ਕਿਰਪਾ ਕਰਿ ਕੈ ਆਪਣੀ ਆਪੇ ਲਏ ਸਮਾਇ ਜੀਉ ॥੨੧॥ kirapaa kar kai aapanee aapae leae samaae jeeo ||21|| Showering His Mercy, He has blended me into Himself. ||21|| ਗੋਪੀ ਨੈ ਗੋਆਲੀਆ ॥ gopee nai goaaleeaa || You are the Gopis, the milk-maids of Krishna; You are the sacred river Jamunaa; You are Krishna, the herdsman. ਤੁਧੁ ਆਪੇ ਗੋਇ ਉਠਾਲੀਆ ॥ thudhh aapae goe outhaaleeaa || You Yourself support the world. here, Vaheguroo is being described as every beautiful form, the One who is served as well as the One who serves. this reminds me of the following Panktee from Rehraas Sahib: "har aaape thakur , har aapae sevak jee ; kiaa nanak jant vichara" Vaheguroo works through all things/all entities at all times. again, you presented the following: ਆਪੇ ਹੀ ਬਲੁ ਆਪਿ ਹੈ ਪਿਆਰਾ ਬਲੁ ਭੰਨੈ ਮੂਰਖ ਮੁਗਧਾਹਾ ॥੩॥ aapae hee bal aap hai piaaraa bal bhannai moorakh mugadhhaahaa ||3|| The Beloved Himself, by Himself, is the embodiment of power; He shatters the power of the fools and idiots. ||3|| ਸਭੁ ਆਪੇ ਜਗਤੁ ਉਪਾਇਦਾ ਪਿਆਰਾ ਵਸਿ ਆਪੇ ਜੁਗਤਿ ਹਥਾਹਾ ॥ sabh aapae jagath oupaaeidhaa piaaraa vas aapae jugath hathhaahaa || The Beloved Himself created the whole world. In His hands He holds the power of the ages. the ਵਸਿ belongs to Vaheguroo and is exercised by Vaheguroo. the three qualities, Rajo, Tamo and Sato pervades the whole creation which includes all Devtae and Devteeaa(n). beieve it or not, many of them were affected by lust and other 'human-frailties' - GurbaaNee attests to this. the truth is that the frailties are not human in origin; they are the product of ego, which is caused by a lack of understanding re: Maya which then overpowers us through the 5 Chor. if we do further Khoj of this Shabad, we will realise that attention is being focused upon Nirankaar Vaheguroo which is alone worthy of worship. Brahmas, Shivas etc. were established/created by Vaheguroo, as were all others. you quoted: ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਨਾਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਵੇਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਰਹਿਆ ਸਮਾਈ || ਗੁਰੁ ਈਸਰੁ ਗੁਰੁ ਗੋਰਖੁ ਬਰਮਾ ਗੁਰੁ ਪਾਰਬਤੀ ਮਾਈ || let's go further and quote more: ਜੇ ਹਉ ਜਾਣਾ ਆਖਾ ਨਾਹੀ ਕਹਣਾ ਕਥਨੁ ਨ ਜਾਈ ॥ ਗੁਰਾ ਇਕ ਦੇਹਿ ਬੁਝਾਈ ॥ ਸਭਨਾ ਜੀਆ ਕਾ ਇਕੁ ਦਾਤਾ ਸੋ ਮੈ ਵਿਸਰਿ ਨ ਜਾਈ ॥੫॥ Even knowing God, I CANNOT DESCRIBE HIM; He cannot be described in words. The Guru has given me this one understanding: there is ONLY THE ONE, the Giver of all souls. May I never forget Him! ||5|| There is One Nirankaar who has embodied Himself via Sargun form through all of creation. This Sargun Form will one day be destroyed as GurbaaNee highlights. Then there will be Nirgun Nirankaar Roop Vaheguroo alone. Brahma etc. can all be described as they are finite created beings - the creation can be described. Howerver, the Infinite Creator, The Embodiment of All Power who wields All Power, can They be described. We can't decribe Them...so what's the enxty best thing - Mahraaj Jee tells us to simply remember Them. This is the whole point of Naam Japna. Ps - GurbaaNee is unknowable - that truly goes without saying.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harcharan Singh · 09 Sep 2008

With all due respect Veer Ji, you have not addressed any of the tuks I quoted. I didn't mention any contradiction - questioning someone elses avaasta does not resolve what appears to you, as seeming contradiction. I regularly hear a lot of talk about Bani being black and white and simple to understand via the role of viakaran - please do kirpa and explain how each of the tuks I have quoted does not negate the view that in all ages before Guru Nanak Dev Ji - there was adharma and that all previous truths, semetic and snaatn - are were kache in their original form (I am not talking about their present narrow minded, God-monopolising, shariat/ritual obsessed followers - which is the road our people are sadly also following today - and which is what Gurbani actually criticises IMHO).

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 09 Sep 2008

Veer Harcharan Singh jeeo, Below is the vichaar of Gurbani pankitis you quoted, based on my meagre understanding of Gurbani. [quote] With all due respect Atma Singh Veerji, I think this statement is a little extreme. How can Dharam be both revealed and Kachaa? Bhai Gurdas Ji says: ਬੇਦ ਕਤੇਬ ਭੁਲਾਇ ਕੈ ਮੋਹੇ ਲਾਲਚ ਦੁਨੀ ਸੈਤਾਣੇ । [/quote] Majority Dharams, at least the main ones do talk about good and bad karma. They from time to time have tried to instill morality in people who followed them. For this reason, Siri Guru jee has written in Gurbani as that Simrities and Shasters do vichaar of good and bad karma but they don't contain the true essence of Dharma: ਸਿਮ੍ਰਿਤਿ ਸਾਸਤ੍ਰ ਪੁੰਨ ਪਾਪ ਬੀਚਾਰਦੇ ਤਤੈ ਸਾਰ ਨ ਜਾਣੀ ॥ What is that Tatt Vastoo i.e. the Dharma that Shasters don't talk about? It's the Naam that they don't contain and for this reason, though they offer excellent moral and philosophical advice and lead to the seekers they are unable to provide with the Tatt-Vastoo Naam. [quote] He clearly says that by forgetting the Bayd and K'teb - the followers have been incticed into greed by Satan. Does this by default not imply the Bayd and K'teb are therefore guides of truth? [/quote] As explained above, they are not the guides of truth and nor Gurbani anywhere says that they are guides of truth. Truth in Gurbani means Vaheguru himself. Yes these religious books are guides of morality (that changes from time to time and region to region) and do vichaar of Paap and Punn. If one is to follow them truly, one would at least be classified as following Satoguni but one would still be part of maya. These shasters keep one in maya and don't know about state beyond maya. [quote] Why would Guru Arjun Dev Ji say: ਕੁਰਾਣੁ ਕਤੇਬ ਦਿਲ ਮਾਹਿ ਕਮਾਹੀ ॥ [/quote] This does not mean that one should do kamaayee of Kuran and Kateyb but it means that if one does kamaayee of Naam, within oneself, this is Kuran and Kateyd for one. This pankiti is similar to Siri Jap jee Sahib pankiti where Guru Sahib says that for us Guru is Ishar, Guru alone is Brahma and Guru is Bishan and Parbati maayee as well. To do kamaayee of Naam in our dil is Kuran and Kateb for us. [quote] Why would Bhagat Kabir Ji say: ਬੇਦ ਕਤੇਬ ਕਹਹੁ ਮਤ ਝੂਠੇ ਝੂਠਾ ਜੋ ਨ ਬਿਚਾਰੈ ॥ I am not quoting these tuks out of context - I am aware the shabds talk about hypocrisy of the followers - but that is a different subject. [/quote] This actually means that call (ਕਹਹੁ ) the matts (religions) of Bed and Kateb false because that is false that does not do vichaar (sachee Naam dee vichaar). These Vedas and Katebas don't do vichaar of Sat Naam. Matt means don't but matt also means Dharam or religion just as it means in the third pankiti of first pauri of Sudha Savaiye that we do everyday as nitnem. Why call them false? This is explained in the next pankiti i.e. on one hand they say that Allah Khuda is in all, then in then in the same book they tell you ways to kill a chicken. These self-contradictory religions are false. [quote] Guru Nanak Dev Ji says: ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਨਾਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਵੇਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਰਹਿਆ ਸਮਾਈ ॥ [/quote] Gurmukh (Vaheguru - Mukhi Guru, Greatest Guru) is the divine celestial Naad (music, anhad shabad) that pervades the whole universe, Gurmukh is the divine knowledge (Ved means Gyaan or knowledge) and Gurmukh himself is present everywhere i.e. “Rahiya Samaayee”. [quote] Guru Arjun Dev Ji says: ਸਾਸਤ ਸਿੰਮ੍ਰਿਤਿ ਬੇਦ ਬੀਚਾਰੇ ਮਹਾ ਪੁਰਖਨ ਇਉ ਕਹਿਆ ॥ ਬਿਨੁ ਹਰਿ ਭਜਨ ਨਾਹੀ ਨਿਸਤਾਰਾ ਸੂਖੁ ਨ ਕਿਨਹੂੰ ਲਹਿਆ ॥੧॥ [/quote] This pankiti again is often misinterpreted. Mahapurakh Guru Sahib have said that no matter how many Shaster, Simritees and Vedas one may do vichaar on but without Harbhajan i.e. reciting Naam, one cannot get delivered and no one has found happiness without Naam. [quote] Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji says: ਬੇਦ ਪੁਰਾਨ ਪੜੇ ਕੋ ਇਹ ਗੁਨ ਸਿਮਰੇ ਹਰਿ ਕੋ ਨਾਮਾ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ [/quote] As written in one of my posts recently, this pankiti means that the use of reading Vedas and Puranas is only if one recites Naam Hari. [quote] ਬੇਦ ਪੁਰਾਨ ਜਾਸ ਗੁਨ ਗਾਵਤ ਤਾ ਕੋ ਨਾਮੁ ਹੀਐ ਮੋ ਧਰੁ ਰੇ ॥ [/quote] For us Vedas Puranas is singing Jaas (jass, praises) of Vaheguru and keeping Naam in our hearts. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Atma Singh · 09 Sep 2008

ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ Veer Harcharan Singh Jee, the following Choupee can be found in Bachitar Natak - Siree Dasam Granth Sahib. Verses 20 - 28 are especially relevant. Please note how the actual scriptures, prophets and gods are being criticised by Dasmesh Pita Jee and not just the followers and their interpretations. if this doesn't convince you then i think we will have to agree to disagree. i sincerely respect you views - there is nothing with brothers disagreeing with one another. i personally like doing Sangat with people who have different views to me - it's far too easy to get on with people who think exactly like you do...the real test of Ekta and Panthic Piyaar is to have Love with those Gursikhs who think differently to you. i think this is why it is a good thing that different Jathebandeeaa(n) exist...everything Vaheguroo does is so Beautiful... -------------------------------------------- ਚੌਪਈ ॥ ਜਬ ਪਹਿਲੇ ਹਮ ਸ੍ਰਿਸਟਿ ਬਨਾਈ ॥ ਦਈਤ ਰਚੇ ਦੁਸਟ ਦੁਖਦਾਈ ॥ ਤੇ ਭੁਜ ਬਲ ਬਵਰੇ ਹੈੂੁ ਗਏ ॥ ਪੂਜਤ ਪਰਮ ਪੁਰਖ ਰਹਿ ਗਏ ॥ 6॥ ਤੇ ਹਮ ਤਮਕਿ ਤਨਕ ਮੋ ਖਾਪੇ ॥ ਤਿਨ ਕੀ ਠਉਰ ਦੇਵਤਾ ਥਾਪੇ ॥ ਤੇ ਭੀ ਬਲਿ ਪੂਜਾ ਉਰਝਾਏ ॥ ਆਪਨ ਹੀ ਪਰਮੇਸਰ ਕਹਾਏ ॥7॥ ਮਹਾਦੇਵ ਅਚੁੱਤ ਕਹਾਯੋ ॥ ਬਿਸਨ ਆਪ ਹੀ ਕੋ ਠਹਿਰਾਯੋ ॥ ਬ੍ਰਹਮਾ ਆਪ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਬਖਾਨਾ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਕੋ ਪ੍ਰਭੂ ਨ ਕਿਨਹੂੰ ਜਾਨਾ ॥ 8॥ ਤਬ ਸਾਖੀ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਅਸਟ ਬਨਾਏ ॥ ਸਾਖ ਨਮਿਤ ਦੇਬੇ ਠਹਿਰਾਏ ॥ ਤੇ ਕਹੈ ਕਰੋ ਹਮਾਰੀ ਪੂਜਾ ॥ ਹਮ ਬਿਨ ਅਵਰੁ ਨ ਠਾਕੁਰੁ ਦੂਜਾ ॥ 9॥ ਪਰਮ ਤੱਤ ਕੋ ਜਿਨ ਨ ਪਛਾਨਾ ॥ ਤਿਨ ਕਰਿ ਈਸਰ ਤਿਨ ਕਹੁ ਮਾਨਾ ॥ ਕੇਤੇ ਸੂਰ ਚੰਦ ਕਹੁ ਮਾਨੈ ॥ ਅਗਨਿ ਹੋਤ੍ਰ ਕਈ ਪਵਨ ਪ੍ਰਮਾਨੈ ॥ 10॥ ਕਿਨਹੂੰ ਪ੍ਰਭੁ ਪਾਹਨ ਪਹਿਚਾਨਾ ॥ ਨ੍ਹਾਤ ਕਿਤੇ ਜਲ ਕਰਤ ਬਿਧਾਨਾ ॥ ਕੇਤਕ ਕਰਮ ਕਰਤ ਡਰਪਾਨਾ ॥ ਧਰਮ ਰਾਜ ਕੋ ਧਰਮ ਪਛਾਨਾ ॥ 11॥ ਜੋ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਸਾਖ ਨਮਿਤ ਠਹਿਰਾਏ ॥ ਤੇ ਹਿਆਂ ਆਇ ਪ੍ਰਭੂ ਕਹਵਾਏ ॥ ਤਾ ਕੀ ਬਾਤ ਬਿਸਰ ਜਾਤੀ ਭੀ ॥ ਅਪਨੀ ਅਪਨੀ ਪਰਤ ਸੋਭ ਭੀ ॥ 12॥ ਜਬ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਕੋ ਨ ਤਿਨੈ ਪਹਿਚਾਨਾ ॥ ਤਬ ਹਰਿ ਇਨ ਮਨੁਛਨ ਠਹਿਰਾਨਾ ॥ ਤੇ ਭੀ ਬਸਿ ਮਮਤਾ ਹੁਇ ਗਏ ॥ ਪਰਮੇਸਰ ਪਾਹਨ ਠਹਿਰਏ ॥ 13॥ ਤਬ ਹਰਿ ਸਿੱਧ ਸਾਧ ਠਹਿਰਾਏ ॥ ਤਿਨ ਭੀ ਪਰਮ ਪੁਰਖ ਨਹੀ ਪਾਏ ॥ ਜੇ ਕੋਈ ਹੋਤ ਭਯੋ ਜਗਿ ਸਿਆਨਾ ॥ ਤਿਨ ਤਿਨ ਅਪਨੋ ਪੰਥੁ ਚਲਾਨਾ ॥ 14॥ ਪਰਮ ਪੁਰਖ ਕਿਨਹੂੰ ਨਹ ਪਾਯੋ ॥ ਬੈਰ ਬਾਦ ਅਹੰਕਾਰ ਬਢਾਯੋ ॥ ਪੇਡ ਪਾਤ ਆਪਨ ਤੇ ਜਲੈ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਕੈ ਪੰਥ ਨ ਕੋਊ ਚਲੈ ॥ 15॥ ਜਿਨਿ ਜਿਨਿ ਤਨਿਕ ਸਿੱਧ ਕੋ ਪਾਯੋ ॥ ਤਿਨ ਤਿਨ ਅਪਨਾ ਰਾਹੁ ਚਲਾਯੋ ॥ ਪਰਮੇਸਰ ਨ ਕਿਨਹੂੰ ਪਹਿਚਾਨਾ ॥ ਮਮ ਉਚਾਰਤੇ ਭਯੋ ਦਿਵਾਨਾ ॥ 16॥ ਪਰਮ ਤੱਤ ਕਿਨਹੂੰ ਨ ਪਛਾਨਾ ॥ ਆਪ ਆਪ ਭੀਤਰਿ ਉਰਝਾਨਾ ॥ ਤਬ ਜੇ ਜੇ ਰਿਖਰਾਜ ਬਨਾਏ ॥ ਤਿਨ ਆਪਨ ਪੁਨ ਸਿੰਮ੍ਰਿਤ ਚਲਾਏ ॥ 17॥ ਜੇ ਸਿੰਮ੍ਰਿਤਨ ਕੇ ਭਏ ਅਨੁਰਾਗੀ ॥ ਤਿਨਿ ਤਿਨਿ ਕ੍ਰਿਆ ਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਕੀ ਤਿਆਗੀ ॥ ਜਿਨ ਮਨ ਹਰਿ ਚਰਨਨ ਠਹਿਰਾਯੋ ॥ ਸੋ ਸਿੰਮ੍ਰਿਤਨ ਕੇ ਰਾਹ ਨ ਆਯੋ ॥ 18॥ ਬ੍ਰਹਮਾ ਚਾਰ ਹੀ ਬੇਦ ਬਨਾਏ ॥ ਸਰਬ ਲੋਕ ਤਿਹ ਕਰਮ ਚਲਾਏ ॥ ਜਿਨ ਕੀ ਲਿਵ ਹਰਿ ਚਰਨਨ ਲਾਗੀ ॥ ਤੇ ਬੇਦਨ ਤੇ ਭਏ ਤਿਆਗੀ ॥ 19॥ ਜਿਨ ਮਤ ਬੇਦ ਕਤੇਬਨ ਤਿਆਗੀ ॥ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਕੇ ਭਏ ਅਨੁਰਾਗੀ ॥ ਤਿਨ ਕੇ ਗੂੜ ਮੱਤ ਜੇ ਚਲਹੀ ॥ ਭਾਂਤਿ ਅਨੇਕ ਦੁਖਨ ਸੋ ਦਲਹੀ ॥ 20॥ ਜੇ ਜੇ ਸਹਿਤ ਜਾਤਨ ਸੰਦੇਹਿ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਕੋ ਸੰਗਿ ਨ ਛੋਡਤ ਨੇਹ ॥ ਤੇ ਤੇ ਪਰਮ ਪੁਰੀ ਕਹ ਜਾਹੀ ॥ ਤਿਨ ਹਰਿ ਸਿਉ ਅੰਤਰੁ ਕਛੁ ਨਾਹੀਂ ॥ 21॥ ਜੇ ਜੇ ਜੀਯ ਜਾਤਨ ਤੇ ਡਰੈ ॥ ਪਰਮ ਪ੍ਰਰਖ ਤਜਿ ਤਿਨ ਮਗ ਪਰੈ ॥ ਤੇ ਤੇ ਨਰਕ ਕੁੰਡ ਮੋ ਪਰਹੀ ॥ ਬਾਰ ਬਾਰ ਜਗ ਮੋ ਬਪੁ ਧਰਹੀ ॥ 22॥ ਤਬ ਹਰਿ ਬਹੁਰ ਦੱਤ ਉਪਜਾਇਓ ॥ ਤਿਨ ਭੀ ਅਪਨਾ ਪੰਥੁ ਚਲਾਇਓ ॥ ਕਰ ਮੋ ਨਖ ਸਿਰ ਜਟਾਂ ਸਵਾਰੀ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਕੀ ਕ੍ਰਿਆ ਨ ਕਛੂ ਬਿਚਾਰੀ ॥ 23॥ ਪੁਨਿ ਹਰਿ ਗੋਰਖ ਕੌ ਉਪਰਾਜਾ ॥ ਸਿੱਖ ਕਰੇ ਤਿਨਹੂੰ ਬਡ ਰਾਜਾ ॥ ਸ੍ਰਵਨ ਫਾਰਿ ਮੁਦ੍ਰਾ ਦੁਐ ਡਾਰੀ ॥ ਹਰਿ ਕੀ ਪ੍ਰੀਤ ਰੀਤਿ ਨ ਬਿਚਾਰੀ ॥ 24॥ ਪੁਨਿ ਹਰਿ ਰਾਮਾਨੰਦ ਕੋ ਕਰਾ ॥ ਭੇਸ ਬੈਰਾਗੀ ਕੋ ਜਿਨ ਧਰਾ ॥ ਕੰਠੀ ਕੰਠਿ ਕਾਠ ਕੀ ਡਾਰੀ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਕੀ ਕ੍ਰਿਆ ਨ ਕਛੂ ਬਿਚਾਰੀ ॥ 25॥ ਕੰਠੀ ਕੰਠਿ ਕਾਠ ਕੀ ਡਾਰੀ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਕੀ ਕ੍ਰਿਆ ਨ ਕਛੂ ਬਿਚਾਰੀ ॥ 25॥ ਮਹਾਦੀਨ ਤਬ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਉਪਰਾਜਾ ॥ ਅਰਬ ਦੇਸ ਕੋ ਕੀਨੋ ਰਾਜਾ ॥ 26॥ ਤਿਨ ਭੀ ਏਕ ਪੰਥ ਉਪਰਾਜਾ ॥ ਲਿੰਗ ਬਿਨਾ ਕੀਨੇ ਸਭ ਰਾਜਾ ॥ ਸਭ ਤੇ ਅਪਨਾ ਨਾਮੁ ਜਪਾਯੋ ॥ ਸਤਿ ਨਾਮੁ ਕਾਹੂੰ ਨ ਦ੍ਰਿੜਾਯੋ ॥27॥ ਸਭ ਅਪਨੀ ਅਪਨੀ ਉਰਝਾਨਾ ॥ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਕਾਹੂ ਨ ਪਛਾਨਾ ॥ ਤਪ ਸਾਧਤ ਹਰਿ ਮੋਹਿ ਬੁਲਾਯੋ ॥ ਇਮ ਕਹਿ ਕੈ ਇਹ ਲੋਕ ਪਠਾਯੋ ॥ 28॥ ਅਕਾਲ ਪ੍ਰਰਖ ਬਾਚ ॥ chaapee | jab pehilae ham srisatt banaaee | dheeth rachae dhusatt dhukhadhaaee | thae bhuj bal bavarae haioo geae | poojath param purakh rehi geae | 6| thae ham thamak thanak mo khaapae | thin kee thour dhaevathaa thaapae | thae bhee bal poojaa ourajhaaeae | aapan hee paramaesar kehaaeae |7| mehaadhaev achuth kehaayo | bisan aap hee ko thehiraayo | brehamaa aap paarabreham bakhaanaa | prabh ko prabhoo n kinehoon jaanaa | 8| thab saakhee prabh asatt banaaeae | saakh namith dhaebae thehiraaeae | thae kehai karo hamaaree poojaa | ham bin avar n thaakur dhoojaa | 9| param thaath ko jin n pashaanaa | thin kar eesar thin kahu maanaa | kaethae soor chandh kahu maanai | agan hothr kee pavan pramaanai | 10| kinehoon prabh paahan pehichaanaa | naath kithae jal karath bidhaanaa | kaethak karam karath ddarapaanaa | dharam raaj ko dharam pashaanaa | 11| jo prabh saakh namith thehiraaeae | thae hiaa aae prabhoo kehavaaeae | thaa kee baath bisar jaathee bhee | apanee apanee parath sobh bhee | 12| jab prabh ko n thinai pehichaanaa | thab har ein manushan thehiraanaa | thae bhee bas mamathaa hue geae | paramaesar paahan thehireae | 13| thab har sdh saadh thehiraaeae | thin bhee param purakh nehee paaeae | jae koee hoth bhayo jag siaanaa | thin thin apano panth chalaanaa | 14| param purakh kinehoon neh paayo | bair baadh ahankaar bataayo | paedd paath aapan thae jalai | prabh kai panth n kooo chalai | 15| jin jin thanik sdh ko paayo | thin thin apanaa raahu chalaayo | paramaesar n kinehoon pehichaanaa | mam ouchaarathae bhayo dhivaanaa | 16| param thaath kinehoon n pashaanaa | aap aap bheethar ourajhaanaa | thab jae jae rikharaaj banaaeae | thin aapan pun sinmrith chalaaeae | 17| jae sinmrithan kae bheae anuraagee | thin thin kriaa breham kee thiaagee | jin man har charanan thehiraayo | so sinmrithan kae raah n aayo | 18| brehamaa chaar hee baedh banaaeae | sarab lok thih karam chalaaeae | jin kee liv har charanan laagee | thae baedhan thae bheae thiaagee | 19| jin math baedh kathaeban thiaagee | paarabreham kae bheae anuraagee | thin kae goorr maath jae chalehee | bhaath anaek dhukhan so dhalehee | 20| jae jae sehith jaathan sandhaehi | prabh ko sang n shoddath naeh | thae thae param puree keh jaahee | thin har sio anthar kash naahee | 21| jae jae jeey jaathan thae ddarai | param prarakh thaj thin mag parai | thae thae narak kanudd mo parehee | baar baar jag mo bap dharehee | 22| thab har bahur dhaath oupajaaeiou | thin bhee apanaa panth chalaaeiou | kar mo nakh sir jattaa savaaree | prabh kee kriaa n kashoo bichaaree | 23| pun har gorakh ka ouparaajaa | skh karae thinehoon badd raajaa | sravan faar mudhraa dhuai ddaaree | har kee preeth reeth n bichaaree | 24| pun har raamaanandh ko karaa | bhaes bairaagee ko jin dharaa | kanthee kanth kaath kee ddaaree | prabh kee kriaa n kashoo bichaaree | 25| kanthee kanth kaath kee ddaaree | prabh kee kriaa n kashoo bichaaree | 25| mehaadheen thab prabh ouparaajaa | arab dhaes ko keeno raajaa | 26| thin bhee eaek panth ouparaajaa | ling binaa keenae sabh raajaa | sabh thae apanaa naam japaayo | sath naam kaahoon n dhrirraayo |27| sabh apanee apanee ourajhaanaa | paarabreham kaahoo n pashaanaa | thap saadhath har mohi bulaayo | eim kehi kai eih lok pathaayo | 28| akaal prarakh baach | Chaupai "When I created this Universe in the beginning. At first, I produced the wicked and troublesome demons Who ran amok due to the might of their arms; And abandoned the worship of the Supreme Purusha (i.e. me).(6) Flushed with anger, I destroyed those demons in a little while; And created the gods in their place. They (the gods) too got involved in the worship of animal sacrifice and offerings of grains. And called themselves as the Supreme Lord.(7) Shiva called himself as Infallible (immortal). Vishnu ascertained himself to be the Supreme Lord. Brahma too designated himself to be the Transcendent One. None of them could comprehend the real Lord (i.e. me) as the Supreme Lord.(8) (God said)-Then the Lord (I) established eight gods as witnesses called Sakhi (earth, the pole star, moon, sun, fire, wind, dawn and lustre). These Sakhi gods were appointed to bear witness according to the actions of the people. They said to the people, "Worship us only. There is no other God except ourselves."(9) They, who did not recognize the Supreme Spirit (God), Accepted these witness gods as the Lord. Many started to worship the sun and the moon. Many worshipped the sacrificial fire and the wind.(10) Several persons accepted the stone (idols) as the Lord. Several others considered it auspicious to take a bath according to some fixed rules. Innumerable people practised ceremonial acts and became afraid. Some others considered Dharam Raj (King of justice for the dead) as their God.(11) The celestial beings, who were appointed by the Lord as testifiers, When they came here, they called themselves as the Supreme Soul. They forgot even the directive of God. And they became eager to become glorious.(12) When they did not comprehend the Lord, Then the Lord created human beings. They too were dominated by infatuation and self- interest, And installed stone statues in place of the Lord.(13) Then the Immortal Lord established the accomplished ascetics and the saints. They too were unsuccessful in realizing the Supreme Lord. They, who happened to be shrewd in the world, Set up their individual creeds.(14) None could realize the Supreme Lord. On the contrary, they spread enmity, conflict and ego. Just as the tree is ablaze with the fire of its leaves, rubbing each other. (The populace was burning by the fire of spite, enmity and ego.) But none followed the highway of the Lord.(15) They, who attained a little spiritual power, Started their individual faiths. And none recognized the Supreme Lord. Rather such people became mad with ego.(16) Nobody understood the essence of the spiritual knowledge. They were entrapped by their own self-conceit. Then I created patriarchal sages (like Manu). Later on they introduced their own Simrities.(17) Those, who became votaries of the Simrities, They discarded God-oriented activity. Those, who implanted the holy feet of the Lord in their mind, They never followed the way of the Simrities.(18) Brahma composed only four Vedas. All the people followed the ceremonial and religious rituals contained in the Vedas. Those (fortunate) persons, who implanted the holy feet of the Lord in their mind, Abandoned the path and the teachings, contained in the Vedas.(19) Those, who DISCARDED the creed of the VEDAS (the Hindu scriptures) and also the faiths of the KATEBAS (Scriptures of Jews, Mohammedans and Christians), They became the adorers of the Transcendent One. Those, who follow the profound creed of the Lord, Obliterate various types of their sufferings.(20) They, who endure torments on their bodies, And do not break off their affection with the Lord, All of them go to the abode of the Lord, And there is no difference between the Lord and them.(21) They who are afraid of hardships. And TURN AWAY FROM THE SUPREME SOUL and follow the creeds of the Vedas and Semitic Scriptures; All of them fall into the inferno of hell; And take births again and again in the world.(22) Thereafter the Lord created Dattatreya (An incarnation-Son of Atri and Ansuya). He, too, started his own sect. He let long nails grow on the hands and kept matted hair on the head. He, too, did not contemplate a plan for devotional love with the Lord.(23) Then the Lord brought forth Gorakh Nath (Preceptor of ear split Yogis). He made great kings his disciples. He split (pierced) the ears and put into ear-rings in each ear, But he, too, did not reflect on any means of the devotional love with the Lord.(24) Then the Lord made Rama Nand (an apostle of ascetics), Who adopted the garb of a Bairagi (a Vaishnava ascetic). He wore a wooden necklace round his neck, And did not consider a way to realize the Lord.(25) repeated and missing line. Correct definition= Whosoever the leading Purushas (personages) were created by the Lord. They all introduced their own creeds. Then the Lord created Mahadin (Prophet Mohammed), And made him the Emperor of the Arabian Peninsula. (26) He, too, created a path (Islam-religion), And made all the kings remove the foreskin of their phalluses (for circumcision). He induced all and sundry to recite his name, And DID NOT INSTILL THE TRUE ETERNAL NAME of the Lord in any one.(27) All (the religious Preceptors) got entangled in their own dogmas. No one comprehended the Transcendent One. I was absorbed in His austere meditation when the Lord called me. Having uttered the following words, He sent me to this world.(28) The Immortal Lord (Purusha) spoke:

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harcharan Singh · 09 Sep 2008

Veer Atma Singh Ji, The section of the Bachitar Natak you have quoted in my humble opinion - refers to the followers and representatives of these holy men - rather than the holy men themselves. I am not disputing the fact that the followers of these Margs lost the plot (in general) and that Sikhi is the supremem and pure light in Kalijug - but Vaheguru - who is Aad Sach, Jugaad Sach - has always been revealing his truth - in all ages. This is why Ramanand Ji is also mentioned here - even though they are a Bhagat. Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji, ਬੇਦ ਪੁਰਾਨ ਪੜੇ ਕੋ ਇਹ ਗੁਨ ਸਿਮਰੇ ਹਰਿ ਕੋ ਨਾਮਾ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ "As written in one of my posts recently, this pankiti means that the use of reading Vedas and Puranas is only if one recites Naam Hari." Veer Ji, just taking this one tuk as an example - my point here has been to negate the comment about all other granths being hearsay - why would Guru Maharaj even mention them in a postive light if they were hearsay? Why would they still be of use if one recites naam? Even if prior granths were more moralistic rather than esoteric, it does not mean they were not divine. That Gurbani exists in it's pure unadulterated form and is pristine does not relegate prior divine wisdom to hearsay. I know your view already veer Kulbir Singh Ji, so this question was not intended for you but rather for Veer Atma Singh Ji - whose use of language I am questioning.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Atma Singh · 10 Sep 2008

ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ Veer Harcharan Singh Jee, you wrote: "in my humble opinion - [the Chaupee Sahib quoted] refers to the FOLLOWERS AND REPRESENTATIVES of these holy men - rather than the holy men THEMSELVES" pls pay particular attention to the following: ਤਿਨ ਭੀ ਏਕ ਪੰਥ ਉਪਰਾਜਾ ॥ ਲਿੰਗ ਬਿਨਾ ਕੀਨੇ ਸਭ ਰਾਜਾ ॥ ਸਭ ਤੇ ਅਪਨਾ ਨਾਮੁ ਜਪਾਯੋ ॥ ਸਤਿ ਨਾਮੁ ਕਾਹੂੰ ਨ ਦ੍ਰਿੜਾਯੋ ॥27॥ ਸਭ ਅਪਨੀ ਅਪਨੀ ਉਰਝਾਨਾ ॥ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਕਾਹੂ ਨ ਪਛਾਨਾ ॥ ਤਪ ਸਾਧਤ ਹਰਿ ਮੋਹਿ ਬੁਲਾਯੋ ॥ ਇਮ ਕਹਿ ਕੈ ਇਹ ਲੋਕ ਪਠਾਯੋ ॥28॥ ਅਕਾਲ ਪ੍ਰਰਖ ਬਾਚ ॥ He, too, [Prophet Muhammad Sahib] created a path [Islam], And made all the kings remove the foreskins [circumcision]. He induced all and sundry to RECITE HIS NAME, And DID NOT INSTILL SAT-NAAM [VAHEGUROO GURMANTAR] in any one.(27) ALL THE RELIGIOUS PRECEPTORS GOT ENTANGLED IN THEIR OWN DOGMAS No one comprehended the Transcendent One. I was absorbed in His austere meditation when the Lord called me. Having uttered the following words, He sent me to this world.(28) the above clearly and undeniably refers to The Prophet and describes where and why he went wrong - it definitely DOES NOT mention followers and representatives. frankly, you are denying what is staring you in the face Veer Jee. please read the original language if you distrust the translation (i have edited it to try and make things clearer) the salient points are: - The Prophet created Islam; therefore, it was not a directly revealed path form Vaheguroo. - Therefore, he did not instill Gurmantar i.e. do Dhrir of Naam in anyone as this was not his duty nor a duty given to him. - Without Naam, there can be no Perfect Dharam. Therefore, the web that was weaved as by all other Spiritual preceptors, got tangled and hence we have all these dogmas, superstitious beliefs e.g. if a dog walks in front of a Muslim while he is praying, he becomes unclean. - As such, Islam glorifies The Prophet who was not the manifest Guroo-Jyot of Vaheguroo. For instance a Muslim must verbalise blessings regarding The Prophet more so than when blessing any other humans. Also The Prophet has always had certain rights which his followers don't i.e. no. of wives allowed. you wrote: "this question was not intended for you but rather for Veer Atma Singh Ji - whose use of language I am questioning" prior granths are useful and i am sure that they can take someone far but you will be unable to find one Panktee in the whole of GurbaaNee which will prove that anyone got Milaap with Vaheguroo through Kamayee of any of these Granths. i sincerely believe that i have already used Pankteeaa(n) to prove that these Granths are ultimately ignored by Prem-Bhagats. Veer Jee, i really don't know what you mean when you say you are 'questioning' my 'use of language'. it is Bhai Gurdaas Jee who has referred to all other 'spiritual knowledge' as hearsay i.e. not directly revealed by Vaheguroo. this is the key difference between Gurmat and all other Dharams. yes - all that has ever been thought, spoken, written and done has been done by Vaheguroo. i believe that in this sense, Vaheguroo has been the inspiration behind all Dharam...even these 'hearsay' Dharams have lots to offer if followers follow them sincerely. For instance, Bed are called 'pure words' by Mahraaj Jee (i.e. in Sukhmanee Sahib for instance i think - 'shud aakh(i)r') but being pure words does not make them Nirankaar's Self-Revealed BaaNee...they can help people get closer to Vaheguroo but ultimately, 'Bin Satguroo [Vaheguroo whose Revealed Roop is GurbaaNee/Gurmantar/Vaheguroo] Kinaai Na Paiaa'. Please read Bhai Gurdaas Jee's Vaaraa(n) - they will really convince you of what is being said here and you will never feel the need to debate this again. veer jee, this will be my last post - it is not my purpose in life to convince you about anything and i think we have both made all the points we need to make. readers will have to look at what we have both been saying and decide for themselves what makes sense and has or has not been proved. if i have come across as bullish at any point, maafee mangdae Veer Jee. i sometimes talk/write too bluntly - i assure you, well i at least like to think, that in person i am not nearly so blunt or bullish. hopefully one day i will have your Darshan. dhanvaad. ps - am looking forward to listening to you doing Raag Keertan.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harcharan Singh · 10 Sep 2008

Pyare Veer Atma Singh Ji, No need to apologise, your posts have politnes, humility and open-mindedness in them - if anything, I admire you for that. Bhai Gurdaas ji's quote - this IMHO refers to those who talk about dharma rather than practice it - or even those who are obsessed with the words rather than the practice (simran - which exists in all Margs). I do not agree with the hearsay translation - it translates more to talking. In any case this point has run it's course. More interestingly, I would like to know why you think Bhagat Ramanand Ji has been mentioned in the bani you have quoted as one of the failed spiritual leaders - this does not reconcile with the acceptance of Bhagat Ji and his bani in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 10 Sep 2008

Veer N3O jeeo, Good to hear from you. ਦੇਰ ਆਏ ਦਰੁਸਤ ਆਏ I think we don’t realize the seriousness of calling Gurmat or thinking that Gurmat subscribes to Advaita Vedanta. The implications of subscribing to Advaita are very severe and this is why many great thinkers of India have already rejected Advaita. These thinkers include Ramanujacharya, Vallabhacharya, Nimbarkacharya and Chaitanya etc. They have proven or they claim to have proved beyond doubt that the Advaita Vedanta is not in accordance with Brahm Sutras, or Vedas, or Upanishads. Everyone in India has rejected Advaita but our own Sikh philosophers especially those associated with Nirmalas are preaching that Gurmat and Advaita are same or that Gurmat is in accordance with Advaita. It’s surprising that all these above mentioned scholars and Acharyas including the great Shankracharya, his Guru’s Guru Gaudapada claim to derive their philosophies from Brahmsutras and Upanishads yet, they are so different from each other and contrary to each other. Anyone who has done even mediocre research of Gurmat and if such person reads about Advaita Vedanta, her or she can never think even in dream that Advaita is in accordance with Gurmat. Here are some points to ponder upon: 1) Advaita ultimately believes that there is only one existence and that is Brahman. This Brahman is not Vaheguru but the self of jeev i.e. Aatma. The self or Aatma or Brahman due to it’s habit of creating maya or playing with it has forgotten that it is Brahman. This is severely in contrast with Gurmat that first of all the Karta Vaheguru never is led astray as is the case with Advaita’s Brahm. Secondly, Vaheguru is not jeev and jeev is not Vaheguru but are two separate entities and the jeev is totally of and dependant on Vaheguru. 2) Advaita’s philosophy on creation of the world is very strange. According to them Brahman the ultimate nirgun God has nothing to do with creation. The world has not been created but is an illusion that the world has been created just like one thinks of rope to be a snake in darkness. They also go forward saying that Atma is Brahman. Then how did Atma that’s Brahman, fall into the illusion of creation? In Gurmat, the creation is a conscious work by Vaheguru. 3) The status of Vaheguru in Advaita is that Ishwar is assumed to be God only for the sake of it but in reality there is no other existence beyond Atma. There is no merger of Atma and Vaheguru but the realization that Atma is Vaheguru. In Gurmat clearly there is Vaheguru and the jeev and merger in Gurmat means that the jeev’s surthee is one with Vaheguru. 4) There is no such thing as Prema Bhagti in Advaita because the Advaitin thinks that he or she is Brahman. They just have to realize this through intense mental cultivation. No room for Prema Bhagti because for Prema Bhagti one needs a wordhipper and the deity. In Gurmat, prema bhagti is the key to meeting with Vaheguru. Vaheguru is the deity and Jeev is the worshipper. The difference is very clear. There are much more to write and I will write about that in due time but this much is enough for this post. [quote] Veer kulbir singh, i never mentioned words like "contradict vikayaran of gurbani" "against vikayaran" . I beleive they are very strong words which does not do justice to describe my stance. [/quote] This is what you wrote in your previous post: [i]He/she does not need follow rules of vikayaran since gurbani is agam agad bodh. Bhramgyani interprets gurbani via their anubhav parkash, they do antriv arths.[/i] From the above I understood that when a brahmgyani does arth of Gurbani, they may over-rule viyakaran rules and my understanding is that if anything, the arths done by a Brahmgyani would actually make the utmost use of Gurbani viyakaran because after all the viyakaran of Gurbani has come from Guru Sahib and not a man made thing. I agree that a Brahmgyani may not have to actively and consciously employ Gurbani viyakaran but the meanings done by a Brahmgyani would naturally not go against viyakaran. Just as an advanced novelist when writing novel does not have to actively employ English grammar but it comes naturally to him or her. Same is the situation when a Mahapurakh does meanings of Gurbani. Rest of the stuff that you have written about viyakaran not being consistent etc. is not really true. The scholars like Professor Sahib, Talwara jee and Giani Harbans Singh know of the exceptions and have written about them in their books. At many places, the spelling mistakes in the printed Birs play a role in our perception that viyakaran rules are inconsistent. [quote] In academic missionary circle- prof sahib singh's teeka - Gurbani Darpan is considered somewhat authority to translate/interpret gurbani. Prof sahib singh teeka its far from perfect, has lot of mistakes in them( thats fine because he mentioned in his preface that my work is just tip of the iceberg).[/quote] No one can do a perfect steek of Gurbani. I believe Giani Harbans Singh has done excellent steek of Gurbani, fully based on viyakaran. The thing I have noticed about Giani jee is that where ever he could, he has tried to do the traditional arth of Gurbani. Only at places where the sampradayak arth contradicted viyakaran, he has done arth according to viyakaran. Talwara jee has been pretty good as well. Even though these great scholars have done arths according to Viyakaran, the antreevi arth don’t match. This is perfectly fine. What is required is to not go against Gurbani viyakaran when doing arth. Doing creative arth does not mean that one should go against viyakaran. This is all I am saying. [quote]- vikaayaran niyam explained by prof sahib singh does not apply to some parts in bhagat bani because some parts in bhagata bani rachna is written in marathi basha in sri guru granth sahib ji, because each language has their own grammar, also sidhant of vikayaran prof sahib used in japj sahib, same sidhant of vikayaran couldn't apply in rehras sahib consistently. There are even diversity within vikayaran interpertation of gurbani as article suggests.[/quote] I can’t take this as prima facie. I agree that certain words may be used as singular in some language and plural in other. The word ‘hum’ is mostly used as a pronoun for plural noun but sometimes it’s used as a pronoun for singular noun too. This does not mean that viyakaran has been violated. We are not using some standard Punjabi or Hindi here. There are many dialects and languages employed in Gurbani. The main rules of viyakaran that come in handy while doing arth vichaar are the rules of ankand and mukta ending nouns. These lag-maatree rules that change according to saroop of the nouns is what really comes in handy when interpreting Gurbani. These rules are pretty much consistent in Gurbani and all exceptions to these rules are also pretty much recorded. I don’t see the merit in Harkirat Singh in criticizing viyakaran or finding faults in it. He himself in my opinion is more of a Bhasha Vigiyani than master of Viyakaran. In the recent past, pure viyakaran works are of Talwara jee and Giani Harbans Singh. In any case, this topic does not belong to this thread and should be discussed separately. [quote] Now question as of why i said anubhav arths of gurbani are not bound by vikayaran rules...not just antriv arths but uthanka of certain shabad is not bound by vikayaran either. I will give you three examples- - Sikhi sidhant was challenged by RSS type people who were challenging Vahiguroo cannot be Gurmantar. At that point nirmale baba isher singh kalyug wale bought fwd 500 antriv arths of Vahiguroo mantar. Now tell me which vikayaran sidhant/rules he used when he bought fwd 500 arths of vahiguroo mantar? Sant jagjit singh said, arths are fully antriv in nature and if you were to do arths of vahiguroo in vikayaran you can go far 10 at the max. [/quote] In case 490 arths that Baba Ishar Singh jee did were against grammar, then we are just going to invite mockery from RSS, if they happen to bring up this point. One can do 1000 arths but if these arths are just creation of one’s imagination and if we are unable to satisfy scholars of other faiths, then in my opinion, it does injustice to the Sikhi cause. Who are the RSS to challenge that Vaheguru cannot be a mantra? And why are we trying to prove that Vaheguru mantra is truly a gurmantra using vedic rules. They can’t judge Sikhi mantra according to their rules. For them Khodsa Mantra (16 maatra mantra) may be the best or the 12 Maatra (Om Bhagvate Vasudevaia) could be the ultimate but we just don’t care. Vaheguru mantra need not be explained to them. The answer to them should be that the ultimate jaapaks of Khodsa Mantra and 12 maatra mantras had to become chelas of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. As the matter of fact, the Gurmantra should just not be discussed or mentioned to Aanmattees and Manmukhs. This mantra is the mantra to japp and there is no need to understand it or worry about how many maatras it has. This is the beej mantra of Khalsa and this is the Maha Mantra and the ultimate mantra. No mantra can come even close to this mantra. [quote] - If we go by gurbani vikayaran we will not be able to do uthanka of certain shabad since certain shabads are directly linked with events involving our Guru Sahiban and bhagats..as some people who are premis of vikayaran of gurbani beleive that there can be one interpertation of gurbani. [/quote] It’s not true that if we go by Gurbani viyakaran we can’t do uthaanka of shabads. Many shabads are a result of Guru Sahib’s interaction with different people and we should use uthaanka to understand shabads better, so far as it does not violate viyakaran. [quote] - This is very important point, please try to understand this. When this jev gets bhramgyan, their surti merges into nirankar, same nirankar dhur ki bani comes from. When bhramgyani does interpertation of gurbani via their anubhav bhramgyan they don't need to follow 1st step use vikayaran to get arths of certain tuk or shabad because they already realize the tat nichor(essence) of that certain shabad, tuk. They give out tat nichor of shabad or tuk which naturally will not contradict Gurbani vikayaran sidhant set by Guru Sahib himself not dunavi punjabi vikayaran. Gurbani vikayaran is still yet to be fully discovered. As vikayaran niyam(rules) set by scholars of the panth still not sampooran itself or accurate as the article pointed out along with sant gurbachan singh ji pointed out. [/quote] Agreed. [quote] I admit i choose poor choice of words here, i meant to say body is made out of five elements but jev is in the body. Jiv atma is abnashi in essence but since antish karan doesn't recnognize its true self, until then this consciouness doesn't merge with super conscouness and become abhinashi. [/quote] theek hai jee. . [quote] Here is shabad where gurbani giving explaining avastha of gurmukh/bhramgyani. In this shabad two separate entities- joti(atma), surti(individual consciousness) merges into jot and surat: Joti jot millaie surati surat sanjog || Clear distincation is made how joti(atma) and individual surti after getting bhramgyan merges with Param Jot and Param Surat no other than vahiguroo himself. What happened to the individual surti in this shabad? It merged into super consciouness nirgun roop which is sat chit anandsvaroop. [/quote] In this pankiti the word ‘sanjog’ has been used when talking about surat. I don’t know how you have interpreted this to mean that the individual surat has merged into the Param-surat of Vaheguru and lost itself. As the matter of fact it talks about sanjog i.e. milaap of the suratee of individual with that of Vaheguru. This means both have become one. How they have become one. Let me give you a worldly example. When we say ਸਾਡੀ ਸੋਚ ਇਕ ਹੈ it does not mean that my thinking and my friend’s thinking have merged and now there is only one thinking in existence. Same way sanjog or milaap of surat with Param surat and Jyot with Param Jyot does not mean that one of them ceases to exist. Please listen to Sun Singh who has agreed in principle that the individual does not cease to exist. We both agree that the milaap or a merger takes place but we differ about the fate of individual Aatma. I am saying that it continues to retain identity (because this is the only way it can enjoy everlasting bliss) and you are insisting that the soul just ceases to exist. This Advaita Vedanta philosophy I cannot digest. Later in the article I will write more about Advaita and Gurmat. [quote] Here is another one Pavanaie Mein Pavan Samaaiya Joti Mein Jot Ral Jaiya || Here is another one: ਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਦੀਸੈ ਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਸੁਣੀਐ ਏਕੁ ਏਕੁ ਵਖਾਣੀਐ ॥ breham dheesai breham suneeai eaek eaek vakhaaneeai || ਆਤਮ ਪਸਾਰਾ ਕਰਣਹਾਰਾ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਬਿਨਾ ਨਹੀ ਜਾਣੀਐ ॥ aatham pasaaraa karanehaaraa prabh binaa nehee jaaneeai || [/quote] You are trying to convert the converted. I already agree and have been insisting that the jeev is totally merged in Vaheguru so much so that to the ordinary eye, there is no difference. But this does not mean that the jeev does not exist anymore. The example of Siri Dasmesh jee perfectly explains that being one means that one’s surthee is absorbed in Charan Kamal of Vaheguru. Siri Guru jee themselves have written about this. What more proof do we need. Pavan meh Pavan gets merged and jyot gets merged in jyot but why does it have to mean that one has now ceased to exist? What happened to Gurbani’s promise of Sadd-Jeevan and everlasting bliss? How will the jeev enjoy bliss if the jeev no longer exists? To enjoy the bliss one has to exist. No one answers this question. If you say that Vaheguru will enjoy the bliss, then my answer is that he is already enjoying the bliss. Then are we doing all this bhagti for Vaheguru to enjoy more bliss? Can we really increase or decrease his bliss? [quote] I am just suprised it didnt even occur to you even for one second that is quite possible that this deliverance might have taken place in sri guru gobind singh ji previous earthly life as dushat daman avtar at hemkunt. Even If we go with your opnion on this that guru ji was given deliverance in spiritual world which you should said it implies guru ji had seperate vajood, conscinouness then how do you explain narsingh avtar(half lion and half man) who came to kill harnakash and save parlhad. Was narsingh avtar before arrival was chilling in sachkhand as well holding onto his vajood and surti. Was he also doing naam simran same where in the sachkhand? [/quote] It does not matter if Siri Dasmesh jee was in Sachkhand or somewhere else. The fact of the matter is that Siri Guru jee became one with Vaheguru. Once you are one, you are one. It does not matter whether you are in Sachkhand or on Earth. By the way, I think Siri Guru jee is talking about their avastha in Sachkhand because they refer to this world as “maat lok”. If they had been at Maat Lok already, they would not have referred to this world as Maatlok. Regarding your question about Narsingh, I don’t think he came from Sachkhand, nor did any other of the 24 avatars came from Sachkhand. The most elevated of all 24 avatars is Siri Krishna and he is not from Sachkhand but from Baikunth. The avatars came to the world as per hukam and then they were used by Guru-jyoti (as per Bhattan de savaiye) to do some tasks in this world. So, Narsingh was not chilling at Sachkhand but must have been hanging out in Baikunth, which I believe lies in Gyaan Khand. [quote] Quote: ""Now it has been established beyond doubt that being one means to be absorbed in the Charan Kamal of Vaheguru forever and ever. It definitely does not mean annihilation of the jeev because as Siri Dasmesh jee has pointed out that the surthee (one of the components of Antishkaran) stay on even after merger. Mann too stays on because in Gurbani it is written that even Vaheguru has a mann. All this talk about antashkaran being of 5 elements is Advaita trash. According to Gurmat, in the 3rd Khand - Sharam Khand, the antishkaran of the jeev is reequipped or tuned for Sach Khand. Please ponder upon the following Pankiti for this: Tithaie Gharaie Surat Mat Man Budh Tithaie Gharaie Sora Sidha Ki Sudh || There in Sharam Khand the antashkaran (surat, mann, budh etc) get re-carved or tuned for Sachkhand."" Nothing is been established here mate, thats your surti based on your own understanding of gurbani. As guru sahib mentioned in chaupi sahib, jinni buddhi vahiguroo valu milli hai, uhni buddhi dwara bandai di sochni aa or here is an classic tuk which explains whichever surat: jehri surat tahi rahe jai || Calling antish karan as advaita trash just shows how frustrated you are with theory of atma totally residing in gurmat. That you went to call advaita(oneness with bhram/vahiguroo) as trash in intoxication of your hindu phobia, you just fell in a same dandal which kala afghana has fell on this matter [/quote] What I have written is that to call the antashkaran made of 5 elements is totally an absurd thing. If it’s not trash then what else is it? As I wrote before I don’t have Hindu phobia but I certainly have a problem when someone tries to say that Gurmat is same as Advaita Vedanta. Advaita is a flawed philosophy that majority of Hindus have rejected as well including Madhva, Ramanujacharya, Nimburkacharya, Vallabhacharya, Chaitaniya, and other Vaishnav Acharyas. So, if I don’t agree with Advaita Vedanta, it does not make me diseased by Hindu Phobia. You say that nothing is established but pray tell me how you explain Siri Dasmesh jee’s incident that totally destroys your Advaita argument that Atma loses identity. Mere Veer, you have only one way out. Like Kala Afghana, you will have to reject Dasam Granth. But if you do accept this saakhi of Siri Dasmesh jee as truth, then you will have to admit that being one with Vaheguru means to be absorbed in the Charan Kamal of Vaheguru and that jeev does not cease to exist after merger in Vaheguru. [quote] If you call loosing one vajood and merging completly with vahiguroo is an sucide, annahliation, merging into nothiness what you will do when Vahiguroo decides to merge all his parpanch akar/sargun parsara into itself? what would you call when vahiguroo decides to merge all his parpanch ? sucide..? You will also have to merge in to same energy and loose your vajood, consicouness, indentity which you call annihilation where would your vajood be then? Here are few shabads to ponder upon on the topic of destruction and creation of all pasara including physical and spiritual realms how one day all the pasara akara, asthohol, sukhsham, traie gun will all perish. This shabad talks both about spiritual and physical realms: [/quote] Merging of jeevs who have not reached Vaheguru at the time of Pralya is not same as merging of Bhagats in Vaheguru. There has to be a difference and there is a difference. I think they stay dormant and when the next time world is created, they start where they were at the time of Pralya. The shabad that you quoted does not say that spiritual realms like Karam Khand and Sachkhand can perish. The very name of Sachkhand tells us that it’s an eternal khand. “Sach” means eternal. So this khand does not perish ever. [quote] Bazigar Jasie Baazi Paie Nana Roop Bhek Dekhlaie Sang Utar Thaimo Pasara Tab Ikaie Ikankara || Kavan Roop Dristio Binasio Kaithe Gayoo Oh Kath Dhayo || Jal Tai Utaie Anakh Taranga Kanakh bhookaie Bahu ranga Bij Bij Dekho Bahu Parkara Phul Pakaie Taie Ikankara || Sahet Gatava Mein Ek Akash Ghat Footaie Ohi Pargas || [/quote] This shabad too does not tell me that the jeev is annihilated after merger with Vaheguru. This shabad talks about the physical world and I already agree that the physical world and whatever we can see will perish. [quote] Advaita is theory of atma ekta with paratama. Therefore, they have only mentioned attributes of vahiguroo which relates to this atma being sat chit anand saroop. I agree advaita does not mention attributes to do with emotions as it gyan marg. But because of that, you cannot say advaita theory is not parvan in Gurmat. [/quote] You are mistaken when you say that Advaita is a theory of ekta of Atma with Parmatma. In fact, Advaita is the discovery of the jeev, that jeev in fact is Parmatma i.e. Atma is Parmatma. This is why they start calling out Aham Brahmasiya. The fact of the matter is that Vaheguru can neither decrease or increase. If we were to accept your notion that Atma merges in Vaheguru and loses identity, then we will have to admit that Parmatma has increased and this is very contrary to Siri Dasmesh jee’s Bachan that ‘na baadh hai na ghaat hai not baadh ghaat hoth hai||. I will be very honest in telling you that in my opinion as far as philosophy of mind is concerned and as far as reaching high levels of mental capabilities and understandings is concerned, Shankracharya and his Guru’s Guru – Gaudapada were probably in par with the great Shakyamuni – Siddhartha Buddha. Nothing less. Buddha was right up there as far as cultivating the mind and understanding the mind is concerned. I respect them for their genius minds and what they have written. What Shankracharya wrote at the age of 12, we can’t even write in 7 lives (unless we are blessed with Raam Naam Parkash). When you read Shankracharya’s or Gaudapada’s or Buddha’s works, you are shaken and you are shocked and you have to read again and again to understand what they are saying but despite all this, the path of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee is much superior and totally distinct from these great philosophers and theologians. I am thinking of writing a detailed research paper on this. Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee’s path is not about philosophies or mental exercises but is divine path straight from Vaheguru. No one has understood Vaheguru more than Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee who in fact is the Guru-form of Vaheguru. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh writes a very interesting account in one of his books. He writes that when the jeev discovers and beholds its Aatma, it gets great bliss. At this stage, many Mahatmas think that they have realized Vaheguru because of the Parkash they see. They start saying that they are Brahm i.e. God. Bhai Sahib writes further that discovering oneself and beholding Aatma is not beholding Vaheguru. In Jail Chithiaan it’s written that before having darshan of Vaheguru, Bhai Sahib got darshan of his Aatma. He was in bliss then but he continued his journey to Vaheguru. One’s who get stuck at discovery Aatma, get stuck there and don’t get darshan of Vaheguru. They think they have found Vaheguru in Aatma. This is what seems to have happened to a number of Sikh Mahapurakhs. Advaita too stops just here. Advaita thinks that discovering oneself is discovering Vaheguru and that there is no Vaheguru beyond one’s Aatma. It's Guru Sahib who has shown the world that beyond Aatma there is Parmatma. [quote] Sant jagjit singh ji as sun singh quote again beleives in the Gurmat - sikhi prema marg and gyan marg both are parvan, for starters is prema bhagti but for bhramgyani according to their surtee/perception they could carry with this same prem bhavna or they could say, sing out all aloud from gurbani- sohang so jai jaap , ja ko paun, there is no paap or paun for them, they are above karams and reason its not recommended for jaigaso because they can become more ahankari with jap. This gurmat sidhant - prema bhagti/gyan marg is beleived by all samparda- nirmale, sevapanthis, taksal. [/quote] There is only one Maarag in Sikhi and that is Prem Bhagti. This mental Gyaan Maarag is the way of Advaita Vedanta who in turn have learned this from Shakyamuni Buddha and the disciples of Buddha like Nagarjana. What Gyaan can you have by mental exercise? The gyaan that Gurmat preaches is the Gyaan that comes as the result of engaging in Prema Bhagti of Naam and then when one becomes cognizant of Vaheguru, divine Gyaan comes. This is the gyaan Gurmat talks about. There is no such thing as two maarags in Gurmat one being Gyaan and the other being Prema Bhagti. The only maarag in Gurmat is Prema Bhagti of Naam. Gyaan is the result or fruit of this Prema Bhagti and not some bogus mental realization that I am Brahm or I am this or I am that. Such mental realizations bring a lot of shakti but not Tatt-Gyaan that Gurmat is talking about. [quote] Why don't you ask sant jagjit singh ji harkhowale when he comes to toronto next time on which anubhavi mahapursh he is referring to?? You are more than welcome to discuss this with sant jagjit singh ji [/quote] About 18-19 years ago, I had darshan of Sant Jagjit Singh jee at Malton Gurdwara. I went to see them at the place of his stay and we had some bachan bilaas. He may not remember me at that time. In those days, I was always looking for someone to show me the way to Vaheguru. I asked them the same thing and they instructed me to do 25 Siri Jap jee Sahibs for 6 months and then come back to them. I didn’t think I could do that many paaths and after that I never got to see them again. Many years later, I realized how correct they were and how wrong I was. What to talk about 25 paaths, one has to do much more paath than that to cleanse one’s inside and on top of so much Gurbani paath, one has to engage in Naam Abhyaas all the time and especially at Amrti Vela. I can’t see myself debating with them at any time. They are senior to me and I am much junior to them in all sense. [quote] Man tu jot saroop hai apna mool paichain || Advaita beleives avidya has diseased mind(mann) which in its orginal form was unman, guru maharaj giving updesh to mind with avidya - o ignorant mind, you are infact jot saroop...because of avidya you don't realize it but in fact you are jot saroop, recnognize yourself. [/quote] But you guys believe that Kaaran Sareer or the purest form does not even have Antashkaran including Mind. But here Siri Guru jee is clearly saying that Mann i.e. mind is Jyot Saroop. This contradicts the Advaita philosophy that does not recognize anything other than the Aatma, not even Vaheguru. They say that Aatma is Brahman and there is no antashkaran. [quote] To back it up all claim above on man which has antish karan and made out of five elements cannot be jot saroop and how vahiguroo cannot have mann but unman(atam chaitanta) here are tuks, once antish karan is gone and man becomes unman then only they can taste their own atma/paratma. [/quote] I already have quoted in my previous posts that Vaheguru has a mann. And mann being jyot saroop proves beyond doubt that mann cannot be destroyed and stays with the jeev all the time. [quote] As gurbani mentions describing state of bhramgyanis: Man asaadh sadhai jan koe Man maraie bin bhagat na hoi || [/quote] Mann da maarna means to bring mind under control. Please look at the following pankiti: ਮੁਰਦਾ ਹੋਇ ਮੁਰੀਦ ਨ ਗਲੀਂ ਹੋਵਣਾ॥ Being murda (dead) means to obey all hukams. Same way for the mind to die means for it to die towards the world i.e. to not find pleasures in mind and to obey hukams of Guru Sahib. It does not mean that mind has died in the sense of ceasing to exist. In the end, I agree with your vichaar that we cannot convince each other and nor should we try to convert the other. For me this debate (vichaar, not Vaad) was very fruitful as it prompted me to think more profoundly about the notions I am subscribing to now. It prompted me to read more about Advaita and other philosophies and this in turn increased respect and awe I already hold for the great thinkers of India. I am now more resolved than ever before that Gurmat is indeed different and unique from existing philosophies of India and of course the world. I will be writing a writeup on this in the near future. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Atma Singh · 10 Sep 2008

veer hjarcharans ingh jee, you wrote: "More interestingly, I would like to know why you think Bhagat Ramanand Ji has been mentioned in the bani you have quoted as one of the failed spiritual leaders - this does not reconcile with the acceptance of Bhagat Ji and his bani in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji". the only thoughts i have worth sharing are that this could be referring to Bhagat Ramanand Sahib Jee at an earlier stage of his spiritual journey i.e. before he became a Prem-Bhagat and disciple of Siree Satguroo Sahib Jee. or it could be referring to a different person altogether although i think this is doubtful given how well-known Bhagat Sahib Jee was. veer kulbir singh jee - can you answer this. i don't have any further knowledge to offer any kind of opinion regarding this interesting question.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

xzik101 · 10 Sep 2008

As always, a really amazing post Kulbir SIngh Jee.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Bijla Singh · 11 Sep 2008

Bhagat Ramanand Ji went against his own guru and advocated Rama bhagtee. He had to come in the sharan of Guru Nanak Dev Ji upon which he became blessed with Naam and got muktee. Many of the other bhagats also followed his suit and got naam from Guru Sahib. As Guru Sahib says in Bachittar Natak, no one preached "Satnaam", the gurmantra. Hence, all failed and so did their own ways. When Bhagat Ji got naam, he sang a Shabad praising Guru Sahib which is included in Guru Granth Sahib. I doubt it is a different Ramanand but it could be since his name comes before Mohammad. So it could be that this Ramanand lived before Mohammad was born. It could also mean that Guru Sahib first listed Hindu ways and their leaders and then Islam which came in India later.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harjas Kaur · 11 Sep 2008

[quote][i][color=brown]1) Advaita ultimately believes that there is only one existence and that is Brahman. This Brahman is not Vaheguru but the self of jeev i.e. Aatma. The self or Aatma or Brahman due to it’s habit of creating maya or playing with it has forgotten that it is Brahman. This is severely in contrast with Gurmat that first of all the Karta Vaheguru never is led astray as is the case with Advaita’s Brahm. Secondly, Vaheguru is not jeev and jeev is not Vaheguru but are two separate entities and the jeev is totally of and dependant on Vaheguru.[color][/i][/quote] This is incorrect. The Advaitin believes that he is not the jeevatma, but the Real Self s that which is all-pervading within, the Paramatman. Hence, the Advaitin does not believe in his identity as being based on the false ego-identity self at all, but in the underlying core Reality. [i][color=green]ਜੋ ਕਿਛੁ ਹੋਆ ਸੁ ਤੇਰਾ ਭਾਣਾ ॥ jo kishh hoaa s thaeraa bhaanaa || Whatever happens is by the Pleasure of Your Will. ਜੋ ਇਵ ਬੂਝੈ ਸੁ ਸਹਜਿ ਸਮਾਣਾ ॥੩॥ jo eiv boojhai s sehaj samaanaa ||3|| Whoever understands this, is intuitively merged in the Lord. ||3|| ਕਹਤੁ ਕਬੀਰੁ ਕਿਲਬਿਖ ਗਏ ਖੀਣਾ ॥ kehath kabeer kilabikh geae kheenaa || Says Kabeer, my sins have been obliterated. ਮਨੁ ਭਇਆ ਜਗਜੀਵਨ ਲੀਣਾ ॥੪॥੧॥ man bhaeiaa jagajeevan leenaa ||4||1|| My mind has merged into the Lord, the Life of the World. ||4||1|| ~SGGS Ji p. 1349[/i][/color] What is merged? The mind, the consciousness. How does this merger take place? By transcending the 3 states of ordinary consciousness, waking, sleeping, and dreaming. Advaita is simply telling us not to live in the consciousness of the Dream-world, which is to perceive according to modes of three gunas, maya and duality. But to recognize that all along we are not even the jeev, but the jyot. [i][color=green]2) Advaita’s philosophy on creation of the world is very strange. According to them Brahman the ultimate nirgun God has nothing to do with creation. The world has not been created but is an illusion that the world has been created just like one thinks of rope to be a snake in darkness. They also go forward saying that Atma is Brahman. Then how did Atma that’s Brahman, fall into the illusion of creation? In Gurmat, the creation is a conscious work by Vaheguru.[/i][/color] This is a material misstatement. Advaita teaches one of the four-fold qualities in a spiritual aspirant is: 1.) Nityānitya vastu viveka — The ability (viveka) to correctly discriminate between the eternal (nitya) substance (Brahman) and the substance that is transitory existence (anitya). Hence Advaita clearly acknowledges the nirgun Brahman as eternal, versus the transitory, and hence illusory nature of the sansaara of pakrti. And this can be explained by understanding past versus present. In the past, your experiences and nature were very real to you. But now that it has become "past" you recollect the memory of it as a dream. What is passing away is in it's fundamental nature only illusion. It will cease to be a real experience and become part of the dream. Advaita teaches that our consciousness perceives Reality in shadow, as if in a dream state, while that which we perceive to be Real is the true dream. Advaita is not a "weird" philosophy at all, but must be understood in context of transcending consciousness. We are not the body. We are not even the mind. We are not the ego. We are no the individual jeevatma. We are the eternal Someone, Parabrahm who is at play dreaming of being a jeeva. When we wake up, obtain mukti, become free from samskaras and obstacles that delude consciousness, samskaras, kaleshas, karam, kalpas... we the dream-being cease to exist... and realize we are the Self, the Divine Beloved, That which is... neti, neti, but beyond even description of language. This is the basis of concept of Self-realization, which is not that the individual is God, but that God has become an individual. The difference between the two (atma and Paramatma) is consciousness and clarity. In Turiya consciousness there exists no ego, no jeev, no shadow to obscure the Light. [i][color=green]3) The status of Vaheguru in Advaita is that Ishwar is assumed to be God only for the sake of it but in reality there is no other existence beyond Atma. There is no merger of Atma and Vaheguru but the realization that Atma is Vaheguru. In Gurmat clearly there is Vaheguru and the jeev and merger in Gurmat means that the jeev’s surthee is one with Vaheguru.[/i][/color] The Atma is the drop of ocean water. The Vaheguru is the ocean. The atma is the jyoti. The Vaheguru is the Paramjyoti. Advaita asks, "Is there a difference between ocean and Ocean?" "Is there a difference between light and Light?" There is no jeevatma (ego identity) which supercedes God. There is only God as true nature pervading within, a Superconscious Light hidden from perception by defilements deriving from the sansaaric world of the illusive pakrti, Maya and duality. This is transcended by merging with the Truth, Shabad, Naam, sound-current of the Naad, cleansing the inner Mirror, opening dasm duar, blossoming of sahasrara chakr, etc. The jeev's consciousness by merging, is no longer in bondage to three gunas, ego-identity and hence, no longer jeevatman, but only the Paramatma. How can you "merge" and still be a separate jeev? [i][color=green]4) There is no such thing as Prema Bhagti in Advaita because the Advaitin thinks that he or she is Brahman. They just have to realize this through intense mental cultivation. No room for Prema Bhagti because for Prema Bhagti one needs a wordhipper and the deity. In Gurmat, prema bhagti is the key to meeting with Vaheguru. Vaheguru is the deity and Jeev is the worshipper. The difference is very clear.[/i][/color][/quote] The Advaitin does not think that he or she (individual jeev egos) is God. The Advaitin believes that the God is playing the part of individual jeevs. [i][color=blue]ਚੋਜੀ ਮੇਰੇ ਗੋਵਿੰਦਾ ਚੋਜੀ ਮੇਰੇ ਪਿਆਰਿਆ ਹਰਿ ਪ੍ਰਭੁ ਮੇਰਾ ਚੋਜੀ ਜੀਉ ॥ chojee maerae govindhaa chojee maerae piaariaa har prabh maeraa chojee jeeo || Playful is my Lord of the Universe; playful is my Beloved. My Lord God is wondrous and playful. ਹਰਿ ਆਪੇ ਕਾਨ੍ਹ੍ਹੁ ਉਪਾਇਦਾ ਮੇਰੇ ਗੋਵਿਦਾ ਹਰਿ ਆਪੇ ਗੋਪੀ ਖੋਜੀ ਜੀਉ ॥ har aapae kaanha oupaaeidhaa maerae govidhaa har aapae gopee khojee jeeo || The Lord Himself created Krishna, O my Lord of the Universe; the Lord Himself is the milkmaids who seek Him. ਹਰਿ ਆਪੇ ਸਭ ਘਟ ਭੋਗਦਾ ਮੇਰੇ ਗੋਵਿੰਦਾ ਆਪੇ ਰਸੀਆ ਭੋਗੀ ਜੀਉ ॥ har aapae sabh ghatt bhogadhaa maerae govindhaa aapae raseeaa bhogee jeeo || The Lord Himself enjoys every heart, O my Lord of the Universe; He Himself is the Ravisher and the Enjoyer. ਹਰਿ ਸੁਜਾਣੁ ਨ ਭੁਲਈ ਮੇਰੇ ਗੋਵਿੰਦਾ ਆਪੇ ਸਤਿਗੁਰੁ ਜੋਗੀ ਜੀਉ ॥੧॥ har sujaan n bhulee maerae govindhaa aapae sathigur jogee jeeo ||1|| The Lord is All-knowing - He cannot be fooled, O my Lord of the Universe. He is the True Guru, the Yogi. ||1|| ਆਪੇ ਜਗਤੁ ਉਪਾਇਦਾ ਮੇਰੇ ਗੋਵਿਦਾ ਹਰਿ ਆਪਿ ਖੇਲੈ ਬਹੁ ਰੰਗੀ ਜੀਉ ॥ aapae jagath oupaaeidhaa maerae govidhaa har aap khaelai bahu rangee jeeo || He Himself created the world, O my Lord of the Universe; the Lord Himself plays in so many ways! ~SGGS Ji p. 174[/i][/color] [i]"Vaheguru is the deity and Jeev is the worshipper. The difference is very clear."[/i] Not really so clear as that veer ji. Advaita is not the philosophy of Gurbani. BUT, Gurbani clearly contains an Advaita component. The clearest philosophy of Gurbani is Achint Abedabeda, the philosophy which includes BOTH Dvaita (separate Object-subject, lover and Beloved) as well as Advaita (Everything is only the One Divine Beloved, and the world is only illusion.) [i][color=brown]ਸੰਸਾ ਇਹੁ ਸੰਸਾਰੁ ਹੈ ਸੁਤਿਆ ਰੈਣਿ ਵਿਹਾਇ ॥ sansaa eihu sansaar hai suthiaa rain vihaae || This world is an illusion; people pass their life-nights sleeping. ~SGGS Ji p. 36[/i][/color] [i][color=indigo]ਸਦਾ ਮੁਕਤੁ ਆਪੇ ਹੈ ਸਚਾ ਆਪੇ ਅਲਖੁ ਲਖਾਵਣਿਆ ॥੪॥ sadhaa mukath aapae hai sachaa aapae alakh lakhaavaniaa ||4|| The True Lord is liberated forever. The Unseen Lord causes Himself to be seen. ||4|| ਆਪੇ ਮਾਇਆ ਆਪੇ ਛਾਇਆ ॥ aapae maaeiaa aapae shhaaeiaa || He Himself is Maya, and He Himself is the Illusion. ਆਪੇ ਮੋਹੁ ਸਭੁ ਜਗਤੁ ਉਪਾਇਆ ॥ aapae mohu sabh jagath oupaaeiaa || He Himself has generated emotional attachment throughout the entire universe. ~SGGS Ji p. 125[/i][/color] [i][color=green]ਮ੍ਰਿਗ ਤ੍ਰਿਸਨਾ ਜਿਉ ਜਗ ਰਚਨਾ ਯਹ ਦੇਖਹੁ ਰਿਦੈ ਬਿਚਾਰਿ ॥ mrig thrisanaa jio jag rachanaa yeh dhaekhahu ridhai bichaar || The created world is like an illusion, a mirage - see this, and reflect upon it in your mind. ਕਹੁ ਨਾਨਕ ਭਜੁ ਰਾਮ ਨਾਮ ਨਿਤ ਜਾ ਤੇ ਹੋਤ ਉਧਾਰ ॥੨॥੨॥ kahu naanak bhaj raam naam nith jaa thae hoth oudhhaar ||2||2|| Says Nanak, vibrate forever the Name of the Lord, which shall deliver you. ||2||2|| ~SGGS Ji p. 536[/i][/color] [i][color=blue]ਆਪੇ ਪਾਰਸੁ ਆਪਿ ਧਾਤੁ ਹੈ ਆਪਿ ਕੀਤੋਨੁ ਕੰਚਨੁ ॥ aapae paaras aap dhhaath hai aap keethon kanchan || He Himself is the Philosopher's Stone, He Himself is the metal, and He Himself is transformed into gold. ਆਪੇ ਠਾਕੁਰੁ ਸੇਵਕੁ ਆਪੇ ਆਪੇ ਹੀ ਪਾਪ ਖੰਡਨੁ ॥ aapae thaakur saevak aapae aapae hee paap khanddan || He Himself is the Lord and Master, He Himself is the servant, and He Himself is the Destroyer of sins. ਆਪੇ ਸਭਿ ਘਟ ਭੋਗਵੈ ਸੁਆਮੀ ਆਪੇ ਹੀ ਸਭੁ ਅੰਜਨੁ ॥ aapae sabh ghatt bhogavai suaamee aapae hee sabh anjan || He Himself enjoys every heart; the Lord Master Himself is the basis of all illusion. ~SGGS Ji p. 552[/i][/color] [i][color=purple]ਏਕਸ ਤੇ ਦੂਜਾ ਨਾਹੀ ਕੋਇ ॥ eaekas thae dhoojaa naahee koe || Everything comes from the One and only Lord; there is no other at all. ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਬੂਝੈ ਸੋਝੀ ਹੋਇ ॥੯॥ guramukh boojhai sojhee hoe ||9|| The Gurmukh realizes this, and understands. ||9|| ~SGGS Ji p. 842[/i][/color] ~bhul chak maaf karni ji

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 11 Sep 2008

Bibi Harjas Kaur jeeo, [quote] This is incorrect. The Advaitin believes that he is not the jeevatma, but the Real Self s that which is all-pervading within, the Paramatman. Hence, the Advaitin does not believe in his identity as being based on the false ego-identity self at all, but in the underlying core Reality. [/quote] You can say it which ever way you want but the bottomline is that the Advaitins believe that there is no difference between Aatma and Brahman and that Aatma is Brahman i.e. the ultimate nirgun God. [quote] 1.) Nityānitya vastu viveka — The ability (viveka) to correctly discriminate between the eternal (nitya) substance (Brahman) and the substance that is transitory existence (anitya). Hence Advaita clearly acknowledges the nirgun Brahman as eternal, versus the transitory, and hence illusory nature of the sansaara of pakrti. And this can be explained by understanding past versus present. In the past, your experiences and nature were very real to you. But now that it has become "past" you recollect the memory of it as a dream. What is passing away is in it's fundamental nature only illusion. It will cease to be a real experience and become part of the dream. Advaita teaches that our consciousness perceives Reality in shadow, as if in a dream state, while that which we perceive to be Real is the true dream. Advaita is not a "weird" philosophy at all, but must be understood in context of transcending consciousness. We are not the body. We are not even the mind. We are not the ego. We are no the individual jeevatma. We are the eternal Someone, Parabrahm who is at play dreaming of being a jeeva. When we wake up, obtain mukti, become free from samskaras and obstacles that delude consciousness, samskaras, kaleshas, karam, kalpas... we the dream-being cease to exist... and realize we are the Self, the Divine Beloved, That which is... neti, neti, but beyond even description of language. This is the basis of concept of Self-realization, which is not that the individual is God, but that God has become an individual. The difference between the two (atma and Paramatma) is consciousness and clarity. In Turiya consciousness there exists no ego, no jeev, no shadow to obscure the Light. [/quote] But you still have not answered my question originally if there was and is only one Brahman and even now there is only one Brahman i.e. God, and that all the world, the creation, and even the jeev is illusion, then how did Brahman or God falter in the first place? How can a perfect God falter? I know you will say that Brahman still has not faltered but tell me whoever has faltered i.e. the jeev, how did it begin in the first place? All the stuff you have written above, I do understand but this does not answer my question. You write the following: [quote]We are the eternal Someone, Parabrahm who is at play dreaming of being a jeeva. When we wake up, obtain mukti, become free from samskaras and obstacles that delude consciousness, samskaras, kaleshas, karam, kalpas... [/quote] After reading Gurbani and after understanding Gurbani can you even say the above in a dream? How can you say that 'Some, Parabrahm who is at play dreaming of being a dream' and is now stuck in maya. Parabrahm is not subject to dreams and he does not dream. Vaheguru is always in a highly conscious state. [quote] The Atma is the drop of ocean water. The Vaheguru is the ocean. The atma is the jyoti. The Vaheguru is the Paramjyoti. Advaita asks, "Is there a difference between ocean and Ocean?" "Is there a difference between light and Light?" There is no jeevatma (ego identity) which supercedes God. [/quote] Your above statement about Advaita is incorrect. Advaita does not believe in Aatma as being a drop of water and Vaheguru the ocean. It believes that Aatma IS Vaheguru and not a drop. Aatma is Vaheguru. [quote] The jeev's consciousness by merging, is no longer in bondage to three gunas, ego-identity and hence, no longer jeevatman, but only the Paramatma. How can you "merge" and still be a separate jeev? [/quote] Please refer to my previous posts on this thread and look for example of Siri Dasmesh jee whereby Siri Guru jee state it very clearly that they have merged and then still kept their identity. [quote] "Vaheguru is the deity and Jeev is the worshipper. The difference is very clear." Not really so clear as that veer ji. Advaita is not the philosophy of Gurbani. BUT, Gurbani clearly contains an Advaita component. The clearest philosophy of Gurbani is Achint Abedabeda, the philosophy which includes BOTH Dvaita (separate Object-subject, lover and Beloved) as well as Advaita (Everything is only the One Divine Beloved, and the world is only illusion.) [/quote] I have already mentioned under this thread in my previous posts that Achintya Abhedabhed is closer to Gurmat than other Dualist and Non-Dualist schools as far as the relationship between Jeev and Vaheguru is concerned but there are other components of this philosophy that do not go very well with Gurmat, especially the Radha Krishna component. I am saddened to hear Bhain jeeo, that your thinking has changed so much from last time you were posting. As Veer Aatma Singh requested and advised, please stay firm in Khalsa rehit e.g. wearing Dastaar, doing Amritvela with Gurmat Naam Abhyaas and not indulging in anti-rehit stuff. Rest is your free will. Your well-wisher, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Atma Singh · 11 Sep 2008

ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ dear bhain jee harjas kaur jee, apparently, Sant Mani Singh who was previously known as Resham Singh, wrote the below where he has, i presume, talked about his experience of Milaap with Vaheguroo. it is interesting that he too seemed to believe that Milaap with Par-Aatma does not equal non-existence of Jeev-Aatma. ps - i personally am looking forward to finding out more about this Gursikh who sounds as though he led a very inspiring Tat Gurmat lifestyle and had lots of Guroo-Dee-Kirpaa. ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ ਦਾਸ, ਆਤਮਾ ਸਿੰਘ ----------------- Rayen Subaayee at Tapoban "When asked if one can dissolve with another he replied, “When you burn two lamps in a room, they meet. THE LIGHT MEETS. You can’t divide the first light from the second light. STILL THERE IS A DIFFERENCE. You can bring them close, even then their flames will remain different. The light will dissolve into each other. YOU CAN@T MELT INTO EACH-OTHER. Only your light can melt in the other – your outer aura.”

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 12 Sep 2008

am i misunderstanding or are people saying that Guru Nanak and Amrit Sanchar is the ONLY way to God, throughout eternity?

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 12 Sep 2008

"Your above statement about Advaita is incorrect. Advaita does not believe in Aatma as being a drop of water and Vaheguru the ocean. It believes that Aatma IS Vaheguru and not a drop. Aatma is Vaheguru. " But look: ਸਾਗਰ ਮਹਿ ਬੂੰਦ ਬੂੰਦ ਮਹਿ ਸਾਗਰੁ ਕਵਣੁ ਬੁਝੈ ਬਿਧਿ ਜਾਣੈ ॥ (Ang 878)

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 12 Sep 2008

Also waht advaitins are saying (i think) is to end duality (subject-object or experience experienced and experiencer): ਗੁਰਿ ਦੁਬਿਧਾ ਜਾ ਕੀ ਹੈ ਮਾਰੀ ॥ ਕਹੁ ਨਾਨਕ ਸੋ ਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਬੀਚਾਰੀ (Ang 1090) Brahma- this is the word used for Paratma by Advaitins. I do not think Advaiti is anti-Bhakti in anyway. expecially because if you look at people such as Ramana Maharshi or Nisargadatta- who were strongly associated with Advaita- as people who were Living it- they advocated Bhakti aswell as Jnana. I read an interview with Nisargadatta (its online somewhere) where he quoted sloaks by Guru Nanak to illustrate a point.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 12 Sep 2008

[quote]But look: ਸਾਗਰ ਮਹਿ ਬੂੰਦ ਬੂੰਦ ਮਹਿ ਸਾਗਰੁ ਕਵਣੁ ਬੁਝੈ ਬਿਧਿ ਜਾਣੈ ॥ (Ang 878)[/quote] Navjot, I looked at it. What are you trying to imply? This pankiti tells me that the jeev is in Vaheguru and Vaheguru is in jeev. This is not telling me that Aatma is Vaheguru and there is no Vaheguru separate or outside of Aatma, as Advaita preaches. [quote]ਗੁਰਿ ਦੁਬਿਧਾ ਜਾ ਕੀ ਹੈ ਮਾਰੀ ॥ ਕਹੁ ਨਾਨਕ ਸੋ ਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਬੀਚਾਰੀ (Ang 1090) Brahma- this is the word used for Paratma by Advaitins. [/quote] So what if this is the word used by Advaitins for Paratma? Because of this are you trying to say that Advaita becomes Gurmat or Gurmat becomes Advaita? [quote] I do not think Advaiti is anti-Bhakti in anyway. expecially because if you look at people such as Ramana Maharshi or Nisargadatta- who were strongly associated with Advaita- as people who were Living it- they advocated Bhakti aswell as Jnana. I read an interview with Nisargadatta (its online somewhere) where he quoted sloaks by Guru Nanak to illustrate a point.[/quote] I don't have anything against any philosophy in the world including Advaita. All I am saying is that stop labelling Gurmat as Advaita or saying tha Gurmat is Advaita or that Gurmat subscribes to Advaita. That's all I am saying. As far as respect and awe is concerned I have it for both Advaita and it's contributing source - Buddhist philosophy. Though Shankracharya did not make any reference to Buddhist philosophy but his Guru's Guru Gaudapada did make references of admiration to Buddha and Nagarjana. Regarding Ramana Maharishi, I have read about him and know that a lot of Westerners were his followers but I have never been impressed by him. One thing about him is that he had no Guru. I don't doubt the spiritual experiences he got but whatever the reason, I am not drawn towards him. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 12 Sep 2008

Kulbir singh I do not know how that sloak is telling you about jeev or Vahuguru since neither word is mentioned. The sloak says something lilke the drop is in the ocean and other ocean is in the drop. I didnt bring up the ocean/drop metaphor one of you lot did. I think Advaita (not sure) they say that Ishwar is a projection of the mind in its dualistic state- going beyond the duality then it is realised that there was only One all along- Atma. Doesnt it say in Gurbani that you shouldnt go outside the body looking for It? Implying look within- Atma. Strange you are comfortable when Guru uses muslim or arabic terminology, but when i point out that Advaita terminology is being used you say it isnt relevant. All I am saying is that Gurubani utilises the Advaita language too. I dont know where this jump to saying that Gurmat becomes Advaita came from, when did I imply that? When you say Guru is addressing Sufis are you saying that Islam becomes Gurmat and Gurmat becomes Islam? Why would you assume I am saying such a thing (Im not)? At most I am saying that what they say is not totally different to what Guru Granth sometimes says- or so it seems to me. Look at this: ਨਹ ਕਿਛੁ ਜਨਮੈ ਨਹ ਕਿਛੁ ਮਰੈ ॥ (Ang 281) Nor is anything born nor does anything die. Now doesnt this remind you of Gaudapada and his Ajativada? I dont know what this word Gurmat is meant to imply, I dont personally use it. I wouldnt claim anything except Gurbani to be 'Gurmat'. People are attacking Advaita (which I dont particularly ascribe to by the way) and I am merely pointing out some personal knowledge I have on the subject where I think what people are saying is inaccurate. The thing about Advaita is that its something of a religious fashion these days and alot of preachers and thinkers have taken up its banner and spread false teachings grounded in their mere thought processes. Gaudapada admired Buddha and Nagarjana? are you sure or is this what you read on wikipedia? I would be careful we know that Gurbani is often mistranslated so you can imagine what mistakes are made with a language as intricate as sanskrit, expecially when translated by westerners or modernist indians. Its a little vain I think to disregard someome from our discussion just because you personally are not 'drawn' toawrds them. I mentioned Ramana Maharshi as an a modern exponent or perhaps(?) epitome of Advaita. That is all.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 12 Sep 2008

Navjot, [quote] I do not know how that sloak is telling you about jeev or Vahuguru since neither word is mentioned. The sloak says something lilke the drop is in the ocean and other ocean is in the drop. [/quote] Salok talks about Ocean and drop. It obviously means Jeev and Vaheguru. [quote] Strange you are comfortable when Guru uses muslim or arabic terminology, but when i point out that Advaita terminology is being used you say it isnt relevant. [/quote] I am equally comfortable whether Arabic terminology is employed or Vedic. The thing to understand is Gurmat principle. Guru Sahib has taken liberty to employ a lot of old words and terminology to prove the Gurmat point. [quote] All I am saying is that Gurubani utilises the Advaita language too. I dont know where this jump to saying that Gurmat becomes Advaita came from, when did I imply that? When you say Guru is addressing Sufis are you saying that Islam becomes Gurmat and Gurmat becomes Islam? Why would you assume I am saying such a thing (Im not)? [/quote] Theek hai Bhai Galtee ho gayee. Maaf karna, if I misunderstood your point. [quote] Gaudapada admired Buddha and Nagarjana? are you sure or is this what you read on wikipedia? I would be careful we know that Gurbani is often mistranslated so you can imagine what mistakes are made with a language as intricate as sanskrit, expecially when translated by westerners or modernist indians. [/quote] I read it in either Dr Radhakrishnan's Indian Philosophy or esteemed Bengali writer, a contemporary of Dr. Radhakrishnan - Surendranath Dasgupta who wrote the monumental work, a five volumed word, 'A History of India Philosophy'. Of course, I did not read the original work of Gaudapada that's written in Sanskrit. I know for fact that Surendranath Dasgupta was one of the few writers of India philosophy who had first hand knowledge from the original source i.e. Sanskrit source. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 12 Sep 2008

"Salok talks about Ocean and drop. It obviously means Jeev and Vaheguru." one could say that it obviously means Atma and Paramatma. even to look at it your way: 'Vaheguru is in Jeev and Jeev is in Vaheguru' you are saying that Jeev and Vahrguru are one and the same substance? (Like the drop and the ocean are btoh water) Interesting. Sounds very...advaitic some (most) of these modern indian writers dont know how to translate. e.g. they translate Atma as meaning Self.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Khalsaspirit · 12 Sep 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Navjot jio, [quote]one could say that it obviously means Atma and Paramatma.[/quote] But the shabad is not letting us to derive that meaning. Please read the shabad completely. ਸਾਗਰ ਮਹਿ ਬੂੰਦ ਬੂੰਦ ਮਹਿ ਸਾਗਰੁ ਕਵਣੁ ਬੁਝੈ ਬਿਧਿ ਜਾਣੈ ॥ ਉਤਭੁਜ ਚਲਤ ਆਪਿ ਕਰਿ ਚੀਨੈ ਆਪੇ ਤਤੁ ਪਛਾਣੈ ॥੧॥ ਐਸਾ ਗਿਆਨੁ ਬੀਚਾਰੈ ਕੋਈ ॥ ਤਿਸ ਤੇ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਪਰਮ ਗਤਿ ਹੋਈ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਦਿਨ ਮਹਿ ਰੈਣਿ ਰੈਣਿ ਮਹਿ ਦਿਨੀਅਰੁ ਉਸਨ ਸੀਤ ਬਿਧਿ ਸੋਈ ॥ ਤਾ ਕੀ ਗਤਿ ਮਿਤਿ ਅਵਰੁ ਨ ਜਾਣੈ ਗੁਰ ਬਿਨੁ ਸਮਝ ਨ ਹੋਈ ॥੨॥ ਪੁਰਖ ਮਹਿ ਨਾਰਿ ਨਾਰਿ ਮਹਿ ਪੁਰਖਾ ਬੂਝਹੁ ਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਗਿਆਨੀ ॥ ਧੁਨਿ ਮਹਿ ਧਿਆਨੁ ਧਿਆਨ ਮਹਿ ਜਾਨਿਆ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਅਕਥ ਕਹਾਨੀ ॥੩॥ ਮਨ ਮਹਿ ਜੋਤਿ ਜੋਤਿ ਮਹਿ ਮਨੂਆ ਪੰਚ ਮਿਲੇ ਗੁਰ ਭਾਈ ॥ ਨਾਨਕ ਤਿਨ ਕੈ ਸਦ ਬਲਿਹਾਰੀ ਜਿਨ ਏਕ ਸਬਦਿ ਲਿਵ ਲਾਈ ॥੪॥੯॥ Especially the last tuk which means: Nanak is ever a sacrifice unto those who are entangled (by surat) in Eak Shabad (Naam). Because it is relating to jeev that is why Guru Sahib used ਤਿਨ and ਜਿਨ words. Hope that helps understanding the essence of this Shabad. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 13 Sep 2008

concentration on sabad doesnt negate what i say or even prove what you say. i already told you advaita doesnt conflict with naam bhakti. 'jin' 'tin' these are pronouns used to refer to the person who does naam bhakti. so it says- to paraphrase- Nanak is a sacrficie to that who does naam bhakti. This is called language, the kind of language you or me in duality will understand. so you have just thown in some little reasoning and run away. why dont YOU look at the whole sabad? here is Kulbir Thind's translation of the second line (I use SriGranth.org as a reference): "He Himself creates the wondrous play of the world. He Himself contemplates it, and understands its true essence. ||1|| " do you dispute this translation of the second line of the first salok? By 'He' it is referring to God/Paratma. This answers the people here who are saying how can Brahm be in ignorance about its own nature as suggested by Advaitins, It is Brahms own play. That Brahma is in ignorance itself is an illusion. Shall we continue? Aisā gi­ān bīcẖārai ko­ī. Ŧis ṯė mukaṯ param gaṯ ho­ī. Gian bichar- the way of a Jnani. To perceive things is this way- this one is liberated, the supreme state occurs in them. i think you know this but are purposely being stubborn and denying it, just out of anti-hindu bigotry. Forgive me if I am wrong. Guru ji speaks to Yogis and Jnanis aswell as Bhaktas.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 13 Sep 2008

sorry but just to add the rest of the pauri is negating opposites (or dualities). then Guru says: Ḏẖun meh ḏẖi­ān ḏẖi­ān meh jāni­ā gurmukẖ akath kahānī. so from Dhun (Naam) comes meditation and from meditation comes Jnana (Gian) of that which is Unspeakbale. right?

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 13 Sep 2008

[quote]concentration on sabad doesnt negate what i say or even prove what you say. i already told you advaita doesnt conflict with naam bhakti. 'jin' 'tin' these are pronouns used to refer to the person who does naam bhakti.[/quote] How doesn't Advaita conflict with Naam Bhagti when they don't believe in anything apart from their Aatma. The Brahman too is Aatma and the world is an illusion. How can they do prema bhagti? I mentioned it before that to do prema bhagti, one needs a worshipper and the worshippee i.e. deity. If one believe one's self or Aatma to be the ultimate reality, how can one do prema bhagti? This is why the way of Advaitins is Gyaan (I don't know why you insist on writing jnan instead of gyaan). Gurmat is all about prema bhagti of the deity Vaheguru. [quote] here is Kulbir Thind's translation of the second line (I use SriGranth.org as a reference): "He Himself creates the wondrous play of the world. He Himself contemplates it, and understands its true essence. ||1|| " do you dispute this translation of the second line of the first salok? By 'He' it is referring to God/Paratma. [/quote] Here is the pankiti I believe you are talking about above: ਉਤਭੁਜ ਚਲਤ ਆਪਿ ਕਰਿ ਚੀਨੈ ਆਪੇ ਤਤੁ ਪਛਾਣੈ ॥੧॥ He himself creates the plant world (ਉਤਭੁਜ ) and other wonders of the world, then himself recognizes (ਚੀਨੈ) (the greatness of it), then himself recognizes the essence of it. This in no way is Advaita. In the first pankiti itself Guru Sahib established that in drop is ocean and in ocean is drop. This way two entities have been recognized, thereby negating Advaita. In this pankiti, Guru Sahib is taking the thought further and saying that he being in his own creation himself is doing all wonders of the world. [quote] This answers the people here who are saying how can Brahm be in ignorance about its own nature as suggested by Advaitins, It is Brahms own play. That Brahma is in ignorance itself is an illusion. [/quote] In this pankiti, it's now shown that Vaheguru is ignorant of his rachna. It just says that he himself creates the world and recognizes the greatness of it. This is echoed in the pankitis like Vekhai Vigsai Kar Vichaar. He himself looks at his creation, does vichaar on it greatness and Vigsai i.e. is contented and happy with is. This is not advaita that believes the creation to be an act of ignorance. In Gurmat the act of creation is a conscious act of Vaheguru. [quote] Shall we continue? ਐਸਾ ਗਿਆਨੁ ਬੀਚਾਰੈ ਕੋਈ ॥ ਤਿਸ ਤੇ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਪਰਮ ਗਤਿ ਹੋਈ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ Gian bichar- the way of a Jnani. To perceive things is this way- this one is liberated, the supreme state occurs in them. [/quote] The above is your misunderstanding. Such vichaar is done by a rare person. What vichaar? That from Vaheguru one can obtain Mukti and receive the greatest spiritual position. How's this pankiti supporting Advaita? [quote]sorry but just to add the rest of the pauri is negating opposites (or dualities). then Guru says: Ḏẖun meh ḏẖi­ān ḏẖi­ān meh jāni­ā gurmukẖ akath kahānī. so from Dhun (Naam) comes meditation and from meditation comes Jnana (Gian) of that which is Unspeakbale. right?[/quote] This pankiti tells us about Gurmat Vidhi of Naam Abhyaas. The seeker has it's dhyaan (concentration) in the dhuni (of Naam) and by being in such dhyaan one realizes Vaheguru. Through Guru i.e. Gurmukh, such undescribable description is realized. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 13 Sep 2008

Jnan, Jnani, Jnana- thats the way texts concerning advaita write it. Gyana is our panjabi, I'll happily stick to this panjabi form if you want. They Believe that Atma= Brahman, it is the SAME as saying Brahman=Atma. They are synonymous. Advaitin is one worships Brahman. To the realised Advaitin (I suppose) it is Brahman who takes up the role of the unknowing Bhakta and Brahman also who takes up the role of the Ishta- it is Brahma worhsipping Brahma. You say the ocean drop mentioned in Gurbani negates advaita. But isnt it saying that the ocean and the drop are in ESSENCE the same thing? Atma=Brahma Brahma=Atma. By saying that Jeev is in Prabh and Prabh is in Jeev are you saying that Prabh is in essence Jeev? This is clearly ridiculous, as we say Prabh is Akal and Ajoni. I think this salok is saying something similar to the salok about the ocean and drop: Āṯmaʼn sarī bāsavḏaivas­y jė ko­ī jānas bẖėv. Nānak ṯā ko ḏās hai so­ī niranjan ḏėv. (Ang 1353) you ask how can advaitins do bhagti? Nisargadatta himself did Japa. Heres a quote attributed to Ramana Maharshi: "When the Japa becomes continuous, all other thoughts cease and one is in one’s real nature, which is Japa or Dhyana (meditation or contemplation). We turn our mind outwards on things of the world and are therefore not aware of our real nature being always Japa. When the conscious effort of Japa or Dhyana, as we call it, we prevent our mind from thinking of other things, then what remains is our real nature, which is Japa." "So long as you think you are name and form, you can’t escape name and form in Japa also. When you realise you are not name and form, then name and form will drop of themselves. No other effort is necessary. Japa or Dhyana will naturally and as a matter of course lead to it. What is now regarded as the means, Japa, will then be found to be the goal. Name and God are not different. This is clearly shown in the teachings of Namdev" Surely you are not so arrogant to tell Advaitins what they do and dont believe? "Gurmat is all about prema bhagti of the deity Vaheguru." to me it seems that in paath it say that it is God Itself that ultimately performs the Bhagti. Theres no actual jeev-self there to do it: "Hari Aape Thakur Hari Aape Sevaku Ji Kia Nanak Jant Vichara" (So Purakh paath) "ਆਪ ਹੀ ਪੂਜਾਰੀ ਆਪ ਹੀ ਦੇਵਾ ॥੩॥ " (Ang 803) i took outbuj to mean/be on par with kudrat. that salok doesnt use the word 'creates'- 'chalat' and 'kar' do not translate to creates. they are present tense. 'chalat' things are 'going' according to God's power and 'kar' God is 'doing' these things. to say that it translates to "Guru Sahib is taking the thought further and saying that he being in his own creation himself is doing all wonders of the world." is not correct. look at the language. 'Aapay Tatu Pachaanai' - God Itself is Beholding 'Tat'. To behold Tat is a matter of Bichar. The impression I have is that: Advaita doesnt believe creation to be an act of ignorance (like a mistake) as you suggest but it believes that the perception that there is a creation is out of ignorance. This is NOT the same thing. Like i said im not upholding Advait as the same as Gurmat. Howevr you appear to have some notion of a 'Gurmat' ideology that applies throughtout the Guru Granth. I dont believe such a thing could ever work. The Guru Granth has many contradicitions- your gurmat ideology wont stand up to all of its saloks- not only that but tells us to abandon Sianap. This comes down to the fable of the blind men and the elephant. Theres different modes of expression for Ultimate Truth. Now answer me this- do you or dont you agree with the muslim sufis talk of fana (annihilation)? I want a clear answer.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 13 Sep 2008

[quote]Howevr you appear to have some notion of a 'Gurmat' ideology that applies throughtout the Guru Granth. I dont believe such a thing could ever work. The Guru Granth has many contradicitions- your gurmat ideology wont stand up to all of its saloks[/quote] A Sikh could not have written the above. How can you say that Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee has many contradictions? First of all there are no contradictions. Secondly, if you perceive some contradictions, these are are result of your (or anyone else's) imperfect wisdom. Gurmat (Ideology of the Gurus) is just as perfect as Vaheguru himself because as per Gurbani, Gurbani is 'Dhur kee Baani' i.e. has come directly from Tatt-Gyaan saroop Vaheguru. You don't seem to have faith in Gurbani because this is why you have stated that it contains contradictions. There is no point debating with you because I am going to quote from Gurbani and you don't seem to have faith in it. If you want to do Tarka-vaad, then it's a different story. [quote]Now answer me this- do you or dont you agree with the muslim sufis talk of fana (annihilation)? I want a clear answer.[/quote] I don't believe in the fanah notion of Sufis, or Shuniya notion of Buddhist or in Aatma being Parmatma notion of Advaitins. [quote]"Gurmat is all about prema bhagti of the deity Vaheguru." to me it seems that in paath it say that it is God Itself that ultimately performs the Bhagti. Theres no actual jeev-self there to do it: "Hari Aape Thakur Hari Aape Sevaku Ji Kia Nanak Jant Vichara" (So Purakh paath) "ਆਪ ਹੀ ਪੂਜਾਰੀ ਆਪ ਹੀ ਦੇਵਾ ॥੩॥ " (Ang 803)[/quote] The above pankitis just mean that Vaheguru is pervading in all his creation including the jeevs. When the jeev gets Vaheguru-realization, he realizes that Vaheguru is all-pervading i.e. in everyone and is controlling everything. In this sense the above pankiti is stated, not in the sense that there is no Jeev and only Brahm as is the case with Advaitins. Navjot, if you are so sympathatic to Advaita, please go first convince the Madhvas to accept Advaita. Why are you forcing Advaita on us? First convince the Vaishnavs schools like Madhvas, Vallabhas, Nimbarkas and Chaitaniyas about Advaita. These Hindu schools have rejected Advaita and you are insisting it on us? They go so far as saying that Madhva who's considered to be an avatar of Pavan, was a born enemy of Shankra. The pankitis that you are quoting tell us that Vaheguru is all pervading. It tells us that inside the jeev is Vaheguru and since the jeev lives in this world and this world is in Vaheguru therefore the jeev too is in Vaheguru. These pankitis don't prove an Advaita notion of Aatma being Vaheguru and that nothing exists beside Aatma. [quote]i took outbuj to mean/be on par with kudrat. that salok doesnt use the word 'creates'- 'chalat' and 'kar' do not translate to creates. they are present tense. 'chalat' things are 'going' according to God's power and 'kar' God is 'doing' these things.[/quote] Utbhuj means creation of banaspati (the plant world) but eventually it means the whole creation. Chalat does not means things are going. You are mistaken here. You are translating this word wrongly as a verb whereas this word Chalat is a noun and it means wonders. Do some more research of this word and you will realize that many times this word is used in the meanings of wonders. As for 'kar', this actually means 'kar ke'. Please refer to translation of Viyakaran masters including Professor Sahib Singh and Giani Harbans Singh for more details. The meanings that I did are in line with theirs. [quote]you ask how can advaitins do bhagti? Nisargadatta himself did Japa. Heres a quote attributed to Ramana Maharshi: "When the Japa becomes continuous, all other thoughts cease and one is in one’s real nature, which is Japa or Dhyana (meditation or contemplation). We turn our mind outwards on things of the world and are therefore not aware of our real nature being always Japa. When the conscious effort of Japa or Dhyana, as we call it, we prevent our mind from thinking of other things, then what remains is our real nature, which is Japa." "So long as you think you are name and form, you can’t escape name and form in Japa also. When you realise you are not name and form, then name and form will drop of themselves. No other effort is necessary. Japa or Dhyana will naturally and as a matter of course lead to it. What is now regarded as the means, Japa, will then be found to be the goal. Name and God are not different. This is clearly shown in the teachings of Namdev" Surely you are not so arrogant to tell Advaitins what they do and dont believe? [/quote] Just because one is doing japa does not mean that one is doing Prema Bhagti. You must know this much. Prema Bhagti is not only about Japa but also about total submission to the Deity. The Buddhist who are silent about Vaheguru too do Japa of Mantras including the japa of 'Buddho Buddho'. Does this make their japa part of Prema Bhagti? Same way the japa that Nisargadatta did was not of a deity but of himself i.e. repeating that he is he is (I am I am). You are classifying this as Prema Bhagti? I don't have anything personal against Advaita but all I am saying is that Gurmat is Gurmat and not Advaita, Vishesh-Advaita or Duvaita. Gurmat is unique. There are similarities between Gurmat and all these schools of Advaita and Dvaita but this does not mean that Gurmat subscribes to these thoughts. [quote]You say the ocean drop mentioned in Gurbani negates advaita. But isnt it saying that the ocean and the drop are in ESSENCE the same thing? Atma=Brahma Brahma=Atma.[/quote] Your logic is strange. The drop and ocean have same chemical properties but this does not mean that the drop equals ocean. Can you sail a ship in a drop of water? No. But you can sail it in the ocean. Why are you debating a vain debate? Vaheguru and jeev dont' equal in Gurmat. Period. [quote] By saying that Jeev is in Prabh and Prabh is in Jeev are you saying that Prabh is in essence Jeev? This is clearly ridiculous, as we say Prabh is Akal and Ajoni. [/quote] It is you who is stating the ridiculous by saying that because Vaheguru is in present in the jeev, it is taking birth. This is the greatness of Vaheguru that he is in his creation but still is Naranjan i.e. without Anjan i.e. without the effect of maya. Please read Gurbani more keenly to get this understanding that Vaheguru is in his creation but Nirlayp from it as well. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 13 Sep 2008

Any ideology is manmat. produce of mind. There are different modes of expression. Apparent contradictions expose the limitations of thinking. The Zen Buddhists know the power of contradiction (or paradox, if you prefer). Gurubani is unfettered by logic. perhaps you want to believe there is an ideology so that you can build a school of thought about it, with instructions. Guru Granth isnt a ideological document. you've developed a few ideas and now all your understanding of any paath you psychologically interpret to fit these ideas. its a mental game. your are following your own interpretation rather than the paath itself. Anything that suggests elsewise you find alarming. However I actually see this attitude of mind as beneficial. Because such strong faith implies one's mind is becomeing one pointed in is devotion. What astonds me is your arrogance- telling people what a sikh could or couldnt have written, telling people what things mean etc. If God is all pervading and controlling everything, that means that everything is God. If God is pervading and controlling the Jeev completely as well as the non-Jeev then how is this different as everything is Brahm. Do you know the shabad- 'ek tu hi ek tu hi ek tu hi'? I suppose what you are saying is some kind of pantheism. That the world is materially real. Tell me this, can there be sense of being a Jeev without Haumai (I am)? Who is 'forcing' advaita on anyone? I could turn around and say why are you enforcing your Vaheguru-Jeev stuff on me and Harjas Kaur? I have only taken the defensive position in all these posts. Why are you bringing all these Hindu schools into it? What have they got to do with me as a sikh? I can see alot of similarities there that is all- look at the vocab they use like ajati, or the way they describe atma reminds me of the descriptions of Parabrahm in Gurubani before any creation occured. But im not a follower of advaita, i already said that. to me Japa in sikhi is not limited to prema bhagti. but even then if you read their writings they do not reject prema bhakti or japa on a deity. Japa by its nature is an act of devotion. For the record I agree that kathaks shouldnt be preaching advaita in Gurduaras. But then I think kathaks are a waste of space anyway.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harjas Kaur · 14 Sep 2008

[quote][color=brown]You can say it which ever way you want but the bottomline is that the Advaitins believe that there is no difference between Aatma and Brahman and that Aatma is Brahman i.e. the ultimate nirgun God.[/color][/quote] You continue to misunderstand an essential difference. Advaitins do not believe the individual JEEV, the individual ego-atman is the same as nirgun Brahman, because the nature of individuality and ego is avidya. They believe the ego-identity is an illusory quality associated with distortion of perception in the world of pakrti. But that the inner light, the inner soul quality of the individual atman, is the hidden All-Pervading One who has no second. To see a second, as separate object-identity, is immediately to perceive in duality. [quote][color=indigo]ye tv aksharam anirdesyam avyaktam paryupasate sarvatra-gam acintyam ca kuta-stham acalam dhruvam sanniyamyendriya-gramam sarvatra sama-buddhayah te prapnuvanti mam eva sarva-bhuta-hite ratah "But those who fully worship the unmanifested, that which lies beyond the perception of the senses, the all-pervading, inconceivable, unchanging, fixed and immovable -- the impersonal conception of the Absolute Truth -- by controlling the various senses and being equally disposed to everyone, such persons, engaged in the welfare of all, at last achieve Me." ~Bhagavad-gita As It Is 12.3-4[/color][/quote] Even the Bhagavad-Gita which discusses relationship between the atman and the Paramatman (Bhagavan Krishna) in terms of Dvaita, can also be construed to coincide with Advaita if you take the personal object ("at last achieve Me," as saying equally, "at last achieve Self-Realization." Because it is in changing of perception surpassing the senses, to awakening awareness of the Transcendant All-Pervading which is controlling and within all beings which leads to merging. Dvaita keeps the focus on the dual aspect of lover and Divine Beloved, whereas Advaita tries to explain what is not logical to human minds, that this Holy relationship between soul and God at a deeper level of reality has no subject, has no Object, but is only appearing so due to the misperception because of the nature of created materiality. Beyond the world of the three gunas, this misperception does not apply, because it is outside the constraints of Maya and duality. Outside of duality, there is no separation between the Creator and His creation... because at a fundamental level, there is no creation. All is appearance manifesting in the Time dimension. In infinity, time is not a reality. So these things must be perceived with a higher level of consciousness because they aren't logical to the brain. [quote][color=brown]ਤ੍ਰੈ ਗੁਣ ਮਾਇਆ ਮੋਹੁ ਹੈ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਚਉਥਾ ਪਦੁ ਪਾਇ ॥ thrai gun maaeiaa mohu hai guramukh chouthhaa padh paae || The three qualities hold people in attachment to Maya. The Gurmukh attains the fourth state of higher consciousness. ਕਰਿ ਕਿਰਪਾ ਮੇਲਾਇਅਨੁ ਹਰਿ ਨਾਮੁ ਵਸਿਆ ਮਨਿ ਆਇ ॥ kar kirapaa maelaaeian har naam vasiaa man aae || Granting His Grace, God unites us with Himself. The Name of the Lord comes to abide within the mind. ~SGGS Ji p. 30[/color][/quote] You keep saying Advaita teaches the jeev atman is the same thing as Brahman, as if to say all the petty little egos are the same thing as God. This is not so. It is a misunderstanding of the teachings. To awaken from the illusion of the separate self (ego-identity which obscures the true light of the inner atman) is to realize that the Self (Brahman) was the only Presence with Reality all along, hidden by a veil of illusion as a separate individual being (jeev atman). Shri Shankara is saying that the ultimate Reality (nirguna) is non-dual, and so can't be perceived or explained in terms of duality and separation. For one thing, nirguna is infinite, and hence outside of the Time dimension. Since the entire universe and worlds upon worlds including Brahma-loka are passing away and of transient nature, in a dimension outside of Time, they already cease to exist, and are illusory. Atman आत्मन्‍ as defined as that which is beyond identification with the transient world of passing forms, pakrti. [quote][color=purple]sa nityo nitya-sambandhah prakritis ca paraiva sa "The same jiva is eternal and is for eternity and without a beginning joined to the Supreme Lord by the tie of an eternal kinship. He is transcendental spiritual potency." ~Sri Brahma-samhita 5.21[/color][/quote] [quote][color=green]ਜਾਤਿ ਮਹਿ ਜੋਤਿ ਜੋਤਿ ਮਹਿ ਜਾਤਾ ਅਕਲ ਕਲਾ ਭਰਪੂਰਿ ਰਹਿਆ ॥ jaath mehi joth joth mehi jaathaa akal kalaa bharapoor rehiaa || Your Light is in Your creatures, and Your creatures are in Your Light; Your almighty power is pervading everywhere. ~SGGS Ji p. 469[/color][/quote] "Sarvam Khalvidam Brahma" (all this is Brahman), (Ch. Up. III. 14. 1). [quote][color=teal]Brahman is not an object, as It is Adrisya, beyond the reach of senses, mind or intellect. It is not another. It is all-full, infinite, changeless, self-existent, self-delight, self-knowledge and self-bliss. It is Svarupa, essence. It is the essence of the knower. It is the Seer (Drashta), Transcendent (Turiya) and Silent Witness (Sakshi). It is always the Witnessing Subject. It can never become an object as It is beyond the reach of the senses. Brahman is non-dual, [u]one without a second[/u]. It has no other beside It. http://www.shankaracharya.org/[/color][/quote] And Gurbani says the same: [quote][color=blue]ਦੂਜੀ ਮਾਇਆ ਜਗਤ ਚਿਤ ਵਾਸੁ ॥ dhoojee maaeiaa jagath chith vaas || The duality of Maya dwells in the consciousness of the people of the world. ਕਾਮ ਕ੍ਰੋਧ ਅਹੰਕਾਰ ਬਿਨਾਸੁ ॥੧॥ kaam krodhh ahankaar binaas ||1|| They are destroyed by sexual desire, anger and egotism. ||1|| ਦੂਜਾ ਕਉਣੁ ਕਹਾ ਨਹੀ ਕੋਈ ॥ dhoojaa koun kehaa nehee koee || Whom should I call the second, when there is only the One? ਸਭ ਮਹਿ ਏਕੁ ਨਿਰੰਜਨੁ ਸੋਈ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ sabh mehi eaek niranjan soee ||1|| rehaao || The One Immaculate Lord is pervading among all. ||1||Pause|| ਦੂਜੀ ਦੁਰਮਤਿ ਆਖੈ ਦੋਇ ॥ dhoojee dhuramath aakhai dhoe || The dual-minded evil intellect speaks of a second. ਆਵੈ ਜਾਇ ਮਰਿ ਦੂਜਾ ਹੋਇ ॥੨॥ aavai jaae mar dhoojaa hoe ||2|| One who harbors duality comes and goes and dies. ||2|| ਧਰਣਿ ਗਗਨ ਨਹ ਦੇਖਉ ਦੋਇ ॥ dhharan gagan neh dhaekho dhoe || In the earth and in the sky, I do not see any second. ਨਾਰੀ ਪੁਰਖ ਸਬਾਈ ਲੋਇ ॥੩॥ naaree purakh sabaaee loe ||3|| Among all the women and the men, His Light is shining. ||3|| ਰਵਿ ਸਸਿ ਦੇਖਉ ਦੀਪਕ ਉਜਿਆਲਾ ॥ rav sas dhaekho dheepak oujiaalaa || In the lamps of the sun and the moon, I see His Light. ਸਰਬ ਨਿਰੰਤਰਿ ਪ੍ਰੀਤਮੁ ਬਾਲਾ ॥੪॥ sarab niranthar preetham baalaa ||4|| Dwelling among all is my ever-youthful Beloved. ||4|| ਕਰਿ ਕਿਰਪਾ ਮੇਰਾ ਚਿਤੁ ਲਾਇਆ ॥ kar kirapaa maeraa chith laaeiaa || In His Mercy, He attuned my consciousness to the Lord. ਸਤਿਗੁਰਿ ਮੋ ਕਉ ਏਕੁ ਬੁਝਾਇਆ ॥੫॥ sathigur mo ko eaek bujhaaeiaa ||5|| The True Guru has led me to understand the One Lord. ||5|| ਏਕੁ ਨਿਰੰਜਨੁ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਜਾਤਾ ॥ eaek niranjan guramukh jaathaa || The Gurmukh knows the One Immaculate Lord. ਦੂਜਾ ਮਾਰਿ ਸਬਦਿ ਪਛਾਤਾ ॥੬॥ dhoojaa maar sabadh pashhaathaa ||6|| Subduing duality, one comes to realize the Word of the Shabad. ||6|| ਏਕੋ ਹੁਕਮੁ ਵਰਤੈ ਸਭ ਲੋਈ ॥ eaeko hukam varathai sabh loee || The Command of the One Lord prevails throughout all the worlds. ਏਕਸੁ ਤੇ ਸਭ ਓਪਤਿ ਹੋਈ ॥੭॥ eaekas thae sabh oupath hoee ||7|| From the One, all have arisen. ||7|| ਰਾਹ ਦੋਵੈ ਖਸਮੁ ਏਕੋ ਜਾਣੁ ॥ raah dhovai khasam eaeko jaan || There are two routes, but remember that their Lord and Master is only One. ਗੁਰ ਕੈ ਸਬਦਿ ਹੁਕਮੁ ਪਛਾਣੁ ॥੮॥ gur kai sabadh hukam pashhaan ||8|| Through the Word of the Guru's Shabad, recognize the Hukam of the Lord's Command. ||8|| ਸਗਲ ਰੂਪ ਵਰਨ ਮਨ ਮਾਹੀ ॥ sagal roop varan man maahee || He is contained in all forms, colors and minds. ਕਹੁ ਨਾਨਕ ਏਕੋ ਸਾਲਾਹੀ ॥੯॥੫॥ kahu naanak eaeko saalaahee ||9||5|| Says Nanak, praise the One Lord. ||9||5|| ~SGGS Ji p. 223[/color][/quote] [quote][color=green]ਖੋਜਤ ਖੋਜਤ ਪਾਇਆ ਡਰੁ ਕਰਿ ਮਿਲੈ ਮਿਲਾਇ ॥ khojath khojath paaeiaa ddar kar milai milaae || I searched and searched, and found God. In the Fear of God, I have been united in His Union. ਆਪੁ ਪਛਾਣੈ ਘਰਿ ਵਸੈ ਹਉਮੈ ਤ੍ਰਿਸਨਾ ਜਾਇ ॥ aap pashhaanai ghar vasai houmai thrisanaa jaae || Through self-realization, people dwell within the home of their inner being; egotism and desire depart. ਨਾਨਕ ਨਿਰਮਲ ਊਜਲੇ ਜੋ ਰਾਤੇ ਹਰਿ ਨਾਇ ॥੮॥੭॥ naanak niramal oojalae jo raathae har naae ||8||7|| O Nanak, those who are attuned to the Name of the Lord are immaculate and radiant. ||8||7|| ~SGGS Ji p. 57[/color][/quote] ~Bhul chak maaf karni ji

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harjas Kaur · 14 Sep 2008

[quote][color=brown]How doesn't Advaita conflict with Naam Bhagti when they don't believe in anything apart from their Aatma. The Brahman too is Aatma and the world is an illusion. How can they do prema bhagti? I mentioned it before that to do prema bhagti, one needs a worshipper and the worshippee i.e. deity. If one believe one's self or Aatma to be the ultimate reality, how can one do prema bhagti?[/quote][/color] Gurbani also says the world is illusion veer ji. Where did you get the notion Advaitins only believe in their own Atman and not in God? This is a ridiculous characterization. Advaitins believe that their ultimate identity is God Himself, which is a very different thing than believing their petty little ego-natures are God. Sikhs also believe this in the sense that a Gurmukh becomes merged in Vaheguru. This is by recognizing the Sanskrit definition of atman as being that uncreated aspect within living beings. So there is an aspect within created beings which is uncreated and eternal, and hence part of the Ajooni. As Sage Shankara teaches, the atman is everything that the Paramatman is... only appearing as separate (in the world of false appearances, sansaar). When the atman merges, unites with the Paramatman, or is Realized in Turiya consciousness, there is only Paramatman, because illusion of separation ceases to exist. The Atman is the same as Paramatman. Naam bhagkti is a method of obtaining Self-realization, mukti. Advaitins use Self-inquiry which you properly noted is a form of Gyana, or Jyana depending on linguistical preference. According to Guru Sahib, in Kaliyuga the japping of Naam with devotion is the safest way to cross the ocean of suffering. But we don't have to belittle the wise philosophies of Advaita to prove anything about superiority of Sikhi. Often such attitudes only show lack of understanding, tolerance and respect for other teachings, and lack of familiarity at how close they actually are to Sikhi since Sikhi is derived from all the wisdom of the Vedas according to Gurbani. [quote][color=purple]ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਨਾਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਵੇਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਰਹਿਆ ਸਮਾਈ ॥ guramukh naadhan guramukh vaedhan guramukh rehiaa samaaee || The Guru's Word is the Sound-current of the Naad; the Guru's Word is the Wisdom of the Vedas; the Guru's Word is all-pervading. ਗੁਰੁ ਈਸਰੁ ਗੁਰੁ ਗੋਰਖੁ ਬਰਮਾ ਗੁਰੁ ਪਾਰਬਤੀ ਮਾਈ ॥ gur eesar gur gorakh baramaa gur paarabathee maaee || The Guru is Shiva, the Guru is Vishnu and Brahma; the Guru is Paarvati and Lakhshmi. ~SGGS Ji p. 2[/color][/quote] [quote][color=blue]This single, unitary divinity had several aspects and names in the Upanishads, one of the most important of which is Atman, a word that originally meant "breath" or "soul" or "vital principle" (as the word "Atmen" does in German). As a cosmological principle or deity, Atman seems to be something like "universal soul" or "universal spirit." In the Brihad-Aranyaka Upanishad , Atman is explicitly called a Person that created the universe by first splitting himself into male and female halves. In the Chandogya Upanishad, this single god is called Brahman, and is "the One without a second"; this Brahman is not only the principle and creator of all there is, but is also fully present within each individual. This dual conception, Brahman and Atman, gets worked out in the following way. Brahman can be located both in the physical, external world and also in the spiritual and inner world where it is present as Atman, "universal spirit." Now every human being has an undying soul (atman) which, because of samsara, lasts through eternity from life to life; this undying atman is a microcosm of Atman, the universal spirit. By understanding yourself, by coming to know one's own soul, one then arrives at the knowledge of Atman itself; the key to understanding the nature of the one unitary principle of the universe is to see one's (undying) self as identical with that principle: "tat svam asi": That (Atman) is what you are, Svetaketu. (Chandogya Upanishad VI.8.4ff.) Here's the equation: Brahman=Atman=atman. Brahman is the totality of the universe as it is present outside of you;, Atman is the totality of the universe as it is present within you; Brahman is the totality of the world known objectively, Atman is the totality of the world known subjectively. This equation fundamentally underlies the whole of Krishna's teachings concerning dharma in the Baghavad Gita. http://www.wsu.edu/~dee/GLOSSARY/ATMAN.HTM[/color][/quote]

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 14 Sep 2008

Harjas Kaur: "since Sikhi is derived from all the wisdom of the Vedas according to Gurbani. " 'derived'? i dont think thats correct, nowhere have i heard or seen it said that sikhi is derived from Vedas. If that was so Guru Nanak would not have rejected the sacred thread ceremony. Sikhi came direct from Prabh/Vaheguru. I think sometimes Guru talks about the essence of the Vedas, or that the Vedas also state something stated.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

xzik101 · 14 Sep 2008

[quote]"since Sikhi is derived from all the wisdom of the Vedas according to Gurbani. "[/quote] Simrat Shastr Bedh sabhai bhoh bhedh kahe hum ek n janiyo We read this in our reheras Sahib every day.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

xzik101 · 14 Sep 2008

Bhehen Harjas Kaur Jee, even though the Gurus clearly say Vaheguru created Vishnu, Shiva and Brahma yet why are you still insisting that Vishnu is our IshtDev? Even Vaheguru himself says this (Akal Purkh Baach!) in Bachintr Naatak when talking to Guru Gobind Singh Jee, yet insisting on the opposite. Just because kirtam names like Ram, Krishan, Gopal, Gobind are used for Vaheguru does not mean the Guru are referring to the Avtars of Vishnu. The Gurus have also used Islamic names like Allah and Rahim for Vaheguru yet no one is saying that Sikhi subscribes to Islam. When our Tenth Master has clearly written: Kishan Bishan Kabhun na diaun Kan sune paihchan na tin son Liv lagi mohi pag in son Maha kal rakhvar hamaro Maha loh mai kinkar tharo [i] I do not worship Krishna or Vishnu, etc. I do not recognize them. I am engrossed in the loving-devotion of my Lord alone. The Lord of death, Akal, is my refuge. He saves me in all tribulations [/i] When our Guru has clearly written this, then why are you still insisting that Sikhi is a Vishnu worshiping faith? Was Guru Gobind Singh Jee unaware of Sikh philosophy when he wrote ``Kishan Bishan Kabhun na Diau``?

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

xzik101 · 14 Sep 2008

I really find it strange for people to actually think that Sikhi subscribes to Advaitism when Gurbani clearly contradicts Advait Vedanta. The sad thing is that now that it is proven that Gurbani does not agree with Advaitism, we now have Sikhs who are now openly stating that it is Gurbani which is full of contradictions! How sad state of affairs our Panth is right now that Sikhs themselves are casting doubts about uniformity of the perfect Bani of the Gurus. To some here Gurbani of Guru Nanak may by contradictory, but the Advait Vedant of Shankar Acharya is ``perfect`` despite the fact that all other major schools of Vedanta in India do not agree with Advait Vedant and have even refuted it. I think that it`s all to do with what is the current trend. I have seen these Sikh discussion forums for a long time. During the 90s I remember that it was considered very trendy to identify Gurmat with Sufism and Islam, so many Sikhs would go to any length in trying to identify with Sufism, many would start using Sufi terminology while a small minority would even make an effort to say that Sikhi IS Sufism. After Sep-11-2001 it was no longer fashionable to identify with anything Islamic. After that trend the new trend was Buddhism. For a few years many Sikhs relate Gurmat to Buddhism, and that stayed on for many years. But since the last year or so Advait Vedant has become very fashionable amongst Sikhs in discussion forums. It's the new trend (for now). Now we are saying that Sikhi subscribes to Advaitism. And where ever Gurbani contradictions Advaitism, it must be Gurbani that is at error or "contradictory", because Advaitism can never be wrong as it is "perfect".

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

scimitar · 14 Sep 2008

bed kateb na bhed lakhiyo sabh haar paray Har haath na aaio. vedas and katebas have not unravelled God's mystery; they have been wearied in their search, but have not been able to attain Him. 8.250 (35) Bed Puran haar hath chhadiyo tadap dhian na aay. 1 The vedas and the puranas failed and hence gave up all their efforts for realising Him. (711) Ik bin doosar so na chinaar, Bhanjan garhan samrath sadaa Prabh jaanat hai Kartar 1 Rahau Except one God do not accept anyone else. God is the Destroyer , the Designer, the Omnipotent and the Eternal, who is known as the Creator. Pause. Jo jeea hot det kachh tuh kar man bach karam bichar. If these stones had any life, they could have given you something. Just rely on your thoughts, words, and deeds. kaun baat pari tisai path sarthi rath koi 1 Taat maat na jaat jakaar putr potra mukand. kaun kaaj kahahingay aan devknand.2 Dev dait disaa visaa jeh keen sarab, pasaar. Kaun upmaa taun ko mukh let nam murar 3 What need had he to be the driver of Arjuns chariot? God the bestower of salvation, has neither father nor mother nor caste nor son nor grandson. What for should he have to come into the world to be known as the son of Devki? He has created gods, demons and spread them in all directions. What glory do we offer Him when we call him by the name of Murar. (711)

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Khalsaspirit · 15 Sep 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh xzik101 jio, Quote "The sad thing is that now that it is proven that Gurbani does not agree with Advaitism, we now have Sikhs who are now openly stating that it is Gurbani which is full of contradictions! How sad state of affairs our Panth is right now that Sikhs themselves are casting doubts about uniformity of the perfect Bani of the Gurus." ਬਿਲਕੁਲ ਦਰੁਸਤ ਫੁਰਮਾਇਆ ਆਪ ਜੀ ਨੇ। ਖਵਰੇ ਕਿਉਂ ਇਨ੍ਹਾਂ ਸਿੱਖਾ ਨੂੰ ਅੱਜ ਮਾਂ ਨਾਲੋ ਵੱਧ ਮਾਸੀਆਂ ਨਾਲ ਹੇਜ ਜਾਗ ਰਿਹਾ ਹੈ? ਲਗਦਾ ਹੈ ਇਹ ਸੰਤ ਭਾਸ਼ਾ ਤੋਂ ਅੱਕ ਗਏ ਹਨ ਅਤੇ ਇਨ੍ਹਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਵੇਦ ਪੁਰਾਣਾ ਦੀਆਂ ਚਟਪਟੀਆ ਗੱਲਾ ਵਿਚ ਜਿਆਦਾ ਸੁਆਦ ਆਉਣ ਲਗ ਪਿਆ ਹੈ। ਕੁੱਝ ਵੀ ਗੱਲ ਹੋਵੇ ਇਨ੍ਹਾਂ ਮੌਸਮੀ ਸਿੱਖਾ ਨੂੰ ਇਕ ਗੱਲ ਦ੍ਰਿੜ ਕਰ ਲੈਣੀ ਚਾਹੀਦੀ ਹੈ ਕਿ ਜੇਕਰ ਇਨ੍ਹਾਂ ਦੀ ਗੁਰੂ ਨਾਨਕ ਦੇ ਘਰ ਵਿਚ ਪੂਰੀ ਨਹੀ ਪਈ ਤਾਂ ਲੱਖ ਜ਼ੋਰ ਲਗਾ ਲੈਣ ਭਾਂਵੇ ਸਾਰੀ ਦੁਨੀਆਂ ਦਾ ਭ੍ਰਮਣ ਕਰ ਲੈਣ, ਕੁਲ ਦੁਨੀਆਂ ਦੇ ਬੇਦ ਸ਼ਾਸ਼ਤਰ ਪੜ ਲੈਣ ਇਨ੍ਹਾਂ ਦੀ ਪੂਰੀ ਕਿਤੋਂ ਨਹੀ ਪੈਣੀ ਅੰਤ ਨਿਬੇੜੇ ਗੁਰੂ ਘਰ ਵਿਚੋਂ ਹੀ ਹੋਣੇ ਹਨ। [color=blue]ਸਿਮ੍ਰਿਤਿ ਸਾਸਤ ਬੇਦ ਵਖਾਣੈ ॥ ਭਰਮੇ ਭੂਲਾ ਤਤੁ ਨ ਜਾਣੈ ॥ ਬਿਨੁ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਸੇਵੇ ਸੁਖੁ ਨ ਪਾਏ ॥ ਦੁਖੋ ਦੁਖੁ ਕਮਾਵਣਿਆ ॥੭॥ [/color]Panna 114 Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Atma Singh · 15 Sep 2008

ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖ਼ਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫ਼ਤਹਿ bhain jee harjas kaur jee, you wrote: "...since Sikhi is derived from all the wisdom of the Vedas according to Gurbani. Quote: ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਨਾਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਵੇਦੰ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਰਹਿਆ ਸਮਾਈ ॥ guramukh naadhan guramukh vaedhan guramukh rehiaa samaaee || The Guru's Word is the Sound-current of the Naad; the Guru's Word is the Wisdom of the Vedas; the Guru's Word is all-pervading. ਗੁਰੁ ਈਸਰੁ ਗੁਰੁ ਗੋਰਖੁ ਬਰਮਾ ਗੁਰੁ ਪਾਰਬਤੀ ਮਾਈ ॥ gur eesar gur gorakh baramaa gur paarabathee maaee || The Guru is Shiva, the Guru is Vishnu and Brahma; the Guru is Paarvati and Lakhshmi. ~SGGS Ji p. 2" bhain jee, i genuinely can't remember the last time i saw a Du-panktee be so completely mis-interpreted in order to make a point. please explain how you arrived at this conclusion. this Du-panktee and the way you quoted it was challenged by myself and Veer Kulbir Singh Jee elsewhere but you insist on using it once again to make a bogus claim. here's a simple litmus test - see what Your Father says in Choupee Sahib regarding not recognising these scriptures and then re-interpet what the above is more liklely to mean, paying attention to the whole PauRee... we all need to use the Kaswatee of GurbaaNee to judge the rest of GurbaaNee. this is how to establish an overall consistent Gurmat context. the only other route open to us is to proclaim that GurbaaNee is contradictory. i really wouldn't advise anyone to start to or to continue to walk upon that cursed path. sadly, it seems some people already have judging by this and the other related thread.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 15 Sep 2008

xzik i suggest you read things carefully before responding to them, to stop yourself looking foolish in future. otherwise the only discussion you are having is with your own imagination. its the anti-hindu trend that continued the longest, starting from your singh sabha forefathers wanting to bootlick the Christian missionary mindset of the English Raj. even now sikhs boast about their presence in the english army- against their own des- like this is something to be proud of. Now in Guru Granth Hari is distinguished from from Vishnu ('Bisan' or 'Bisnu') to signify Akal. Even though Gurus use this Naam most they distinguish sikhs from Vaishnavas (e.g. pauris addressed to Vaishnavas in Sukhmani). Word Vaheguru is hardly used yet some sikhs take it upon themselves it insert it in translations. If you knew anything about the Vaishnavas you will know that they use the language associated with Vishnu to describe Akal Purakh, That above the Hindu trinity and Its Source. Again the Shaivites use Shiva to describe supreme Godhead above the deva Mahadev. In Dasam Granth it uses the words Mahakal and Kallika- this derive from Tantra where they mean much the same thing, Again when the Krishna-schools say Krishna they refer to Akal Purakh. These are language differences. Their whole trinity is associated with unifying 'Om'. Even the Shaktas use Shiva to name It (That behind shakti). To them Nirgun Durga is Agam Agochar just like Nirgun Brahm (or Vaheuguru) is to us, If you bothered to learn about these things you might understand this.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 15 Sep 2008

"the only other route open to us is to proclaim that GurbaaNee is contradictory. i really wouldn't advise anyone to start to or to continue to walk upon that cursed path." yes because some peoples petty intellect cannot handle such an idea lets just selectively quote from Dasam Granth, anything that doesnt agree with us we can just say that Guru didnt write.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

xzik101 · 15 Sep 2008

Navjot Singh, when did I say I'm anti Hindu? I'm probably one of the most pro Hindu people you would find on this discussion forum. Why don't you do a search on all my posts. Never I have I said anything against the Hindus or Hindu Dharm. But I wouldn't be pro to the extent where I start to distort the unique message of our Gurus and start to say shameless comments like our Guru's Bani is "contradictory". By the way, the translation I made on the top was not my translation. It was a translation from a Daulat Rai`s book Sahib e Kamal, and Daulat Rai is a Hindu, but I guess to you, Daulat Rai must also be anti-Hindu. But wait, how can that be since Daulat Rai was also a prominent Arya Samaji of his time! Brother Navjot Singh Jee, reading your post it`s obvious your understanding of Gurmat is far from perfect, or even Advaitism for that matter. You cannot do justice to Sikhi or Advaita by just having half knowledge about these subjects. They say that a semi literate man with half knowledge is more dangerous than a literate man with full knowledge. Sadly this seems to be the case with you.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 15 Sep 2008

blah blah blah your post is all slander no substance. what have you contributed here? are you just a kid? im not trying to be rude but this is how you come across. well if you are not your 'child-like-ness' is a good quality. what translation are you talking about? what translation of yours did i mention? why dont you go back to your Arya Samaj literature or whatever it is. but out of pity here read this it might help you understand my 'shameless' statement: Anekāntavāda, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anekantvada (shock horror its a jain artical! just read it)

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Anonymous User · 15 Sep 2008

By tha way, I am not disputing that Guru Granth is PERFECT. what i said about contradictions is not meant as slander or to create doubts in people minds. quite the opposite! As a sikh Guru Granth is PERFECTION to me.

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Harjas Kaur · 16 Sep 2008

[quote][color=brown]"since Sikhi is derived from all the wisdom of the Vedas according to Gurbani. " 'derived'? i dont think thats correct, nowhere have i heard or seen it said that sikhi is derived from Vedas. If that was so Guru Nanak would not have rejected the sacred thread ceremony. Sikhi came direct from Prabh/Vaheguru.[/color][/quote] [u]Derived[/u]: "Stemming from an original source." If Gurbani says Guru is the wisdom of the Vedas, and the Vedas are among the earliest scriptures in existance, then it is clear Gurubani is derived from original wisdom in scriptures revealed by Sruti to the rishis. Only when you try to do a tap dance to make Gurubani completely new and original, in order to politically dissociate it from it's Indic basis, which is derived from Indic spiritual teachings such as found in Vedas and Puranas and unmistakably spoken of throughout Gurbani, then you have to conclude Gurbani teaching is not something new... but ancient. It is ancient revealed truth taught in an entirely new way by the same Divine Jyot which has been eternally shining through the ages (yugas). Or are you suggesting that mankind was lost and without light, without hope, without mukti...until Guru Nanak was born to become the one and only Satguru for all time? Because Gurbani itself says that God's Light has been shining through the ages, and even in the das avataaras. If Gurbani says the nirgun Paramjyothi was shining in the das avataaras, why would any Sikh say that Bhagavan Krishna's Bhagavata doesn't shine light of God? If Gurbani says Guruji is avataar for Kaliyuga, and Hari Krishna was avataar for Dwapara yuga, how can Bhagavad-Gita NOT be related to Gurbani when clearly the same Paramjyothi has descended into sansaara through avataaras? [quote][color=blue]ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਦੀਸੈ ਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਪਸਾਰੁ ॥ guramukh dheesai breham pasaar || The Gurmukh sees God pervading everywhere. ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਤ੍ਰੈ ਗੁਣੀਆਂ ਬਿਸਥਾਰੁ ॥ guramukh thrai guneeaaan bisathhaar || The Gurmukh knows that the universe is the extension of the three gunas, the three dispositions. ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਨਾਦ ਬੇਦ ਬੀਚਾਰੁ ॥ guramukh naadh baedh beechaar || The Gurmukh reflects on the Sound-current of the Naad, and the wisdom of the Vedas. ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਪੂਰੇ ਘੋਰ ਅੰਧਾਰੁ ॥੧॥ bin gur poorae ghor andhhaar ||1|| Without the Perfect Guru, there is only pitch-black darkness. ||1|| ~SGGS Ji p. 1270[/color][/quote] A logical proof for this is Guru is nirgun God, the Creator. Every truth is derived from original universal Reality, which God is. Only political movements like Singh Sabha fully estrange from original sanatan origin of Gurbani. I do not even believe it is possible for someone to have proper understanding of Gurbani teaching without learning some basics of Vedic teaching, otherwise the interpretations of Gurbani will reflect modern political constructions and formulations quite out of character with revealed truth, and hence... wrong. As to the sakhi about Guru Nanak rejecting Janeo, and hence rejecting ritualistic Hindu religion, that is a material misstatement of the Singh Sabha reform intellectuals. First, Guru Nanak Dev Ji wasn't a brahmin. Brahmins wear a janeo which is made from silk. Kshatriyas wear a janeo which is made from cotton, to denote lowered social station. Shudras don't even get to wear a janeo. It is fully in keeping with Vaishnava reform of Ramanuja, Madhva, Nimbarka, Vallabha, Chaitanya that Guru Nanak Dev Ji rejected ritualistic caste distinctions when it comes to authentic bhakti. Nothing in this action, or correction against political brahminism moves Guru Nanak Dev Ji out of the Hindu fold as a Vaishnav, because it is completely in accord with pre-existing Vaishnav reform against caste discrimination of the day. Now this is not the same as the counter-reform of Tulsidas trying to brahminize Vaishnavism. But Vaishnavism did in fact reform making distinctions between castes on the basis of spiritual seeking, going so far as to say what Guru Nanak Dev Ji said in Gurbani, that a true brahmin wasn't born but was the sincere devotee who seeks God as bairagi. This teaching is also from original Vedas. So we see Gurbani in essence restored the original truths of Vedas. Nothing here contradicts Vedanta. And if we are to insert a little logic, the Vaishnava bhagats whose bani has been included in Gurubani and elevated to status of Gurgaddi... were the famous low caste bhakti Vaishnavs such as Kabir Ji, Namdev, Ravidas, etc. So clearly Guru Sahib was acknowledging the spiritual correctness of this teaching... which happened to have been a reform movement existing before physical birth of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, and therefore cannot be swept under a political carpet to pretend Vaishnavism did not reform caste discrimination and only Sikh Guruji did. Another tactic of Singh Sabha movement is to lump all Hinduism together to reflect what British Raj denounced it as... sati, caste discrimination, political ritualized brahminism, etc. And they characterized with false generalizations in the same way to Maharaja Dulip Singh in order to instigate his shame in Indic spirituality and conversion to Christianity. This is the mentality behind such flagrantly false generalizations. For one thing, Hindu religion (which is obviously many different philosophies sharing Vedantic basis) includes the very caste reform which Guru Nanak Dev Ji illustrated by refusing the janeo, not from rejecting ritualistic brahminism per se... but from rejecting caste distinctions in spiritual bhagti and thus degenerating spirituality to ritualistic brahminism. How anyone can misconstrue a clearly Vaishnav philosophy and teaching with rejection of the whole of Vedanta is clearly playing pawn to the false generalizations of the British Raj. [quote][color=green]"Does the wearing of a sacred thread make one a Brahmin? One who is devoted to God (Narayana) alone is a Brahmin." ~Ramanujacharya (1017 - 1137 AD)[/color][/quote] [quote][color=purple]ਸੋ ਬ੍ਰਾਹਮਣੁ ਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਜੋ ਬਿੰਦੇ ਹਰਿ ਸੇਤੀ ਰੰਗਿ ਰਾਤਾ ॥ so braahaman breham jo bindhae har saethee rang raathaa || He alone is a Brahmin, who knows the Lord Brahma, and is attuned to the Love of the Lord. ~SGGS Ji p. 68[/color][/quote] [quote][color=teal]ਖਤ੍ਰੀ ਬ੍ਰਾਹਮਣ ਸੂਦ ਵੈਸ ਉਪਦੇਸੁ ਚਹੁ ਵਰਨਾ ਕਉ ਸਾਝਾ ॥ khathree braahaman soodh vais oupadhaes chahu varanaa ko saajhaa || The four castes - the Kh'shaatriyas, Brahmins, Soodras and Vaishyas - are equal in respect to the teachings. ~SGGS Ji p. 747[/color][/quote] [quote][color=brown]ਏਤੇ ਜੀਅ ਜਾਂ ਚੈ ਹਹਿ ਘਰੀ ॥ eaethae jeea jaan chai hehi gharee || All the creatures of the world are in His House. ਸਰਬ ਬਿਆਪਿਕ ਅੰਤਰ ਹਰੀ ॥ sarab biaapik anthar haree || The Lord is diffused in the inner beings of all. ਪ੍ਰਣਵੈ ਨਾਮਦੇਉ ਤਾਂ ਚੀ ਆਣਿ ॥ pranavai naamadhaeo thaan chee aan || Prays Naam Dayv, seek His Protection. ਸਗਲ ਭਗਤ ਜਾ ਚੈ ਨੀਸਾਣਿ ॥੫॥੧॥ sagal bhagath jaa chai neesaan ||5||1|| All the devotees are His banner and insignia. ||5||1|| ਮਲਾਰ ॥ malaar || Malaar: ਮੋ ਕਉ ਤੂੰ ਨ ਬਿਸਾਰਿ ਤੂ ਨ ਬਿਸਾਰਿ ॥ mo ko thoon n bisaar thoo n bisaar || Please do not forget me; please do not forget me, ਤੂ ਨ ਬਿਸਾਰੇ ਰਾਮਈਆ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ thoo n bisaarae raameeaa ||1|| rehaao || please do not forget me, O Lord. ||1||Pause|| ਆਲਾਵੰਤੀ ਇਹੁ ਭ੍ਰਮੁ ਜੋ ਹੈ ਮੁਝ ਊਪਰਿ ਸਭ ਕੋਪਿਲਾ ॥ aalaavanthee eihu bhram jo hai mujh oopar sabh kopilaa || The temple priests have doubts about this, and everyone is furious with me. ਸੂਦੁ ਸੂਦੁ ਕਰਿ ਮਾਰਿ ਉਠਾਇਓ ਕਹਾ ਕਰਉ ਬਾਪ ਬੀਠੁਲਾ ॥੧॥ soodh soodh kar maar outhaaeiou kehaa karo baap beethulaa ||1|| Calling me low-caste and untouchable, they beat me and drove me out; what should I do now, O Beloved Father Lord? ||1|| ਮੂਏ ਹੂਏ ਜਉ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਦੇਹੁਗੇ ਮੁਕਤਿ ਨ ਜਾਨੈ ਕੋਇਲਾ ॥ mooeae hooeae jo mukath dhaehugae mukath n jaanai koeilaa || If You liberate me after I am dead, no one will know that I am liberated. ਏ ਪੰਡੀਆ ਮੋ ਕਉ ਢੇਢ ਕਹਤ ਤੇਰੀ ਪੈਜ ਪਿਛੰਉਡੀ ਹੋਇਲਾ ॥੨॥ eae panddeeaa mo ko dtaedt kehath thaeree paij pishhanouddee hoeilaa ||2|| These Pandits, these religious scholars, call me low-born; when they say this, they tarnish Your honor as well. ||2|| ਤੂ ਜੁ ਦਇਆਲੁ ਕ੍ਰਿਪਾਲੁ ਕਹੀਅਤੁ ਹੈਂ ਅਤਿਭੁਜ ਭਇਓ ਅਪਾਰਲਾ ॥ thoo j dhaeiaal kirapaal keheeath hain athibhuj bhaeiou apaaralaa || You are called kind and compassionate; the power of Your Arm is absolutely unrivalled. ਫੇਰਿ ਦੀਆ ਦੇਹੁਰਾ ਨਾਮੇ ਕਉ ਪੰਡੀਅਨ ਕਉ ਪਿਛਵਾਰਲਾ ॥੩॥੨॥ faer dheeaa dhaehuraa naamae ko panddeean ko pishhavaaralaa ||3||2|| The Lord turned the temple around to face Naam Dayv; He turned His back on the Brahmins. ||3||2|| ~SGGS Ji p. 1292[/color][/quote] [quote][color=darkblue]"Namdev (c.1270-c.1350 CE) was born in the village of NarasVamani, now located in the Satara District in Maharashtra. He was born to a tailor named Dāmāsheti Relekar and his wife Gonāi (Gunābāi). Soon after his birth, his family moved to Pandharpur in the Solapur district of Maharashtra, where the prominent temple of the Hindu God form Viththal or Vithobā is located. His parents were devotees of Vithobā... Since childhood, Namdev was an ardent devotee of Vithoba like his parents. According to a legend, when Namdev was five years old, his mother once gave him some food offering for Vithoba and asked him to take it and give it to Vithoba in the Pandharpur temple. Accordingly, young Namdev took the offering and placed it before Vithoba's idol in the temple, asking Vithoba to partake of the offering. When he saw that his request was not being met, he told Vithoba that unless his request was met, he would be killing himself. Vithoba then appeared in a personal form and partook of the offering in response to the utter devotion of young Namdev[citation needed]. (The place where, according to the legend, Namdev had waited for Vithoba to partake of the food offering is currently identified in that temple as "Nāmdev Pāyari".) Namdev traveled through many parts of India, reciting his religious poems. He is said to have lived for more than twenty years in the village of Ghuman in the Gurdaspur district of Punjab, where a memorial commemorates him. http://en.wikipedia.org/wi[/color][/quote] [quote][color=indigo]"Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born 15 April 1469 into a Hindu Khatri family,[2] in the village of Rai Bhoi Ki Talwandi, now called Nankana Sahibter the Guru), near Lahore, Pakistan. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki[/color][/quote] Clearly by the dates we can see there was no "Sikhism" during lifetime of Swami Nam Dev, and that he was clearly known as a Hindu. Why modern Sikhs try to make all the bhagats into modern day Sikhs, or even the Sufi bhagats who were part of Raamnaamis into some kind of orthodox Muslims when clearly they too were influence by Vaishnavism and hence considered heretical by orthodox Muslims is just the mental gymnastics of evading the factual history... Sikhism is influenced by Vaishnav philosophy. Gurbani is derived from the wisdom of the Vedas. It is very clear from within Gurbani itself. Where else do you hear the Naam of God as Jagannatha Gopala and try to convince yourself there is no Vaishnav influence? [u]Derived[/u]: "Stemming from an original source." Clearly. [quote][color=blue]ਤੂ ਸਚਾ ਸਾਹਿਬੁ ਸਚੁ ਸਚੁ ਸਭੁ ਧਾਰਿਆ ॥ thoo sachaa saahib sach sach sabh dhhaariaa || You are True, O my True Lord and Master; You uphold all that is true. ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਕੀਤੋ ਥਾਟੁ ਸਿਰਜਿ ਸੰਸਾਰਿਆ ॥ guramukh keetho thhaatt siraj sansaariaa || You created the world, making a place for the Gurmukhs. ਹਰਿ ਆਗਿਆ ਹੋਏ ਬੇਦ ਪਾਪੁ ਪੁੰਨੁ ਵੀਚਾਰਿਆ ॥ har aagiaa hoeae baedh paap punn veechaariaa || By the Will of the Lord, the Vedas came into being; they discriminate between sin and virtue. ਬ੍ਰਹਮਾ ਬਿਸਨੁ ਮਹੇਸੁ ਤ੍ਰੈ ਗੁਣ ਬਿਸਥਾਰਿਆ ॥ brehamaa bisan mehaes thrai gun bisathhaariaa || You created Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva, and the expanse of the three qualities. ਨਵ ਖੰਡ ਪ੍ਰਿਥਮੀ ਸਾਜਿ ਹਰਿ ਰੰਗ ਸਵਾਰਿਆ ॥ nav khandd prithhamee saaj har rang savaariaa || Creating the world of the nine regions, O Lord, You have embellished it with beauty. ~SGGS Ji p. 1094[/color][/quote]

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kulbir singh · 16 Sep 2008

Here we have another misinformed post from Bibi Harjas Kaur, trying to prove that Sikhism was influenced by Vaishnaism and that Gurbani is derived from Vedas. [quote]If Gurbani says Guru is the wisdom of the Vedas, and the Vedas are among the earliest scriptures in existance, then it is clear Gurubani is derived from original wisdom in scriptures revealed by Sruti to the rishis.[/quote] Where does it say that Guru is the wisdom of Vedas? Gurbani does have pankitis that tell us that Guru or Vaheguru has created everything including the Vedas but this does not mean that Gurbani has been derived from Vedas. It’s a casual remark of Guru Sahib that the whole world including the Vedas have been created by Guru Sahib. In any case, obviously Bibi jee has her own views. Her views are mubarik to her but we disagree. Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

Khalsaspirit · 16 Sep 2008

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Bibi jio, [quote]Clearly by the dates we can see there was no "Sikhism" during lifetime of Swami Nam Dev, and that he was clearly known as a Hindu. Why modern Sikhs try to make all the bhagats into modern day Sikhs, or even the Sufi bhagats who were part of Raamnaamis into some kind of orthodox Muslims when clearly they too were influence by Vaishnavism and hence considered heretical by orthodox Muslims is just the mental gymnastics of evading the factual history... Sikhism is influenced by Vaishnav philosophy. Gurbani is derived from the wisdom of the Vedas. It is very clear from within Gurbani itself. Where else do you hear the Naam of God as Jagannatha Gopala and try to convince yourself there is no Vaishnav influence?[/quote] Kal Taran, Bhagat vashal, juga(n) jugantra(n) de palanhaar, HIMSELF NARAYAN, Kuljug de Avtaar Sahib Sri GURU NANAK DEVJEE MAHARAAJ knew that people like you will claim his SHABAD GURU SURAT DUN CHELA sidhant is the part of Hinduism or Islamism so to deny all these claims in simple language yet in bold letters he rejected all those bogus claims. Please ponder upon what Jugo jug Atal Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji say to counter your newly accepted philosophy. [color=red]ਪੂਜਾ ਕਰਉ ਨ ਨਿਵਾਜ ਗੁਜਾਰਉ ॥ ਏਕ ਨਿਰੰਕਾਰ ਲੇ ਰਿਦੈ ਨਮਸਕਾਰਉ ॥੩॥ ਨਾ ਹਮ ਹਿੰਦੂ ਨ ਮੁਸਲਮਾਨ ॥ ਅਲਹ ਰਾਮ ਕੇ ਪਿੰਡੁ ਪਰਾਨ ॥੪॥ [/color]Panna 1136 I perform not Hindu worship, nor offer I Muslim prayer. One Formless (nirankaar) keeping in my ridai (may called as mind or heart or naab Kamal), I make obeisance unto Him there.I am NEITHER A HINDU, NOR A MUSLIM. My body and breath (or life) belongs to Him, who is called God of Muslims and the Lord of Hindus. Just in case here it is again: [color=red]ना हम हिंदू न मुसलमान ॥ अलह राम के पिंडु परान ॥४॥[/color] So do not try to throw mud on Guru's identity. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Sant Harkhowal jee's thoughts on merging into Vaheguru

kaur007 · 16 Sep 2008

Saadh Sangat ji, when this Harjas Kaur left this forum last time she was complaining that this forum is becoming too pro-rss. Look at her now, how she has made 180 degree turn and came back as pro-rss and pro-snatan. And Chandra Singh is all happy because she was used to be her number one opponent here and now she is his number one proponent. I was used to admire her for her knowledge but I am so disappointed now. All that knowledge can't save you. Guru sahib loves bhola bha(innocence), not all this cleverness. Moderators should be careful how far they want to let this go. I think they shouldn't give plateform to these kind of people. It is very confusing for young impressionable minds. She should be more than welcome to change her views but why is she back here preaching her newfound spirtuality. She should go to some snatan sikhi forum and share her knowledge there. Why is she telling us where she took amrit from and who her punj piyares were. That doesn't matter because she is not following what they told her. I wish her good luck on her new path. This forum is not the same as it used to be. More inspiring post should be posted. I miss all those good posters like "shaktishali..", pwalla, Dilraj Kaur, Roop kaur, Balpreet Singh, singhni miri piri and many more. They should support Bhai Kulbir Singh and Bhai Atma Singh ji. In the end I want all of us to ponder upon this Shabad: This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 11 gurisKI bwrIk hY KMfy Dwr glI Aiq BIVI] gurasikhee baareek hai kha(n)ddae dhhaar galee ath bheerree|| The discipleship of the Guru is very subtle like a sword edge and narrow alley. EQY itkY n Bxhxw cil n skY aupir kIVI] outhhai ttikai n bhanehanaa chal n sakai oupar keerree|| Mosquito’s and ants cannot stand there. vwlhu inkI AwKIAY qylu iqlhu lY kolHU pIVI] vaalahu nikee aakheeai thael thilahu lai kolhoo peerree|| It is thinner than hair and as the oil of sesame is obtained after crushing it in the crusher with great difficulty, the discipleship of the Guru is not obtained easily. gurmuiK vMsI prm hMs KIr nIr inrnau cMiju vIVI] guramukh va(n)see param ha(n)s kheer neer nirano cha(n)ji veerree|| Gurmukhs are descendants of swans and separate water from milk with their beak of thoughtfulness. islw AlUxI ctxI mwxk moqI cog invIVI] silaa aloonee chattanee maanak mothee chog niveerree|| Like licking of the salt-less stone they pick up the rubies and jewels to eat. gurmuiK mwrig clxw Aws inrwsI JIV auJIvI] guramukh maarag chalanaa aas niraasee jheerr oujheevee|| The Gurmukhs repudiating all hopes and desires move on the way of detachment and tear down the veil of Maya. shij srovir sc KMif swDsMgiq sc qKiq hrIVI] sehaj sarovar sach kha(n)dd saadhhasa(n)gath sach thakhath hareerree|| Holy Congregation, the abode of Truth and throne of the True Lord is the manasarovar for the Gurmukhs. ciVH iekIh piq pauVIAw inrMkwru gur sbdu shIVI] charrih eikeeh path pourreeaa nira(n)kaar gur sabadh seheerree|| Climbing the steps of non-duality they adopt the Word of the formless Guru. guMgY dI imiTAweIAY AkQ kQw ivsmwdu bcIVI] gu(n)gai dhee mit(h)iaaeeai akathh kathhaa visamaadh bacheerree|| They enjoy His divine story like they enjoyment by a dumb person of the sweets. gurmuiK suKu Plu shij AlIVI ]5] guramukh sukh fal sehaj aleerree ||5|| Through the natural Devotion, the Gurmukhs attain the fruit of delight.(5)