Re: 'Chardee-Kalaa' Paath/Keertan
kulbir singh · 11 Sep 2008
There are at least three components for Kirtan. One is Gurbani. Second is Sangeet and third is Kirtaniya i.e. the one singing. All three cast effect on the listener. Gurbani is Gurbani and what to say about it. It's a given. The next component is sangeet i.e. the music aspect of it. If combination of sur, taal and sweet voice is reached then it helps the surthee to engage in Gurbani. But it should be remembered that if the sangeet aspect overshadows the Gurbani component, then it is hard to derive Hari Rass from it.
The third very important component is the kirtaniya. The jeevan of the kirtaniya and the emotion level of the kirtaniya at the time of singing kirtan definitely casts effect on the sangat. If the kirtaniya is dhilla plus at the time of kirtan his or her mind is wandering on something else, a proportionate effect will cast on the the sangat.
On the other hand imagine if the kirtaniya is an accomplished Gursikh with immense love for Guru Sahib and if such person does kirtan with focused mind, and has respectable command over sur and taal, how much rass it will give sangat.
Many times we see people are very trained in the sangeet aspect but lack spiritual jeevan. The rass-bhinaa kirtan is that kirtan that is sung by an accomplished Gursikh who is skilled in sangeet aspect as well. One of the kirtaniya who has both jeevan and skill is Bhai Jeevan Singh. I have not heard a better kirtaniya than them. Another good example is Bhai Sahib Harbhajan Singh Shatrana who currently reside at Anandpur Sahib. They too are just amazing kirtaniya. Third kirtaniya that I have listened to and in who's kirtan I found abundant bairaag is Master Joginder Singh Sandhaudwale. Rest Bhai apni apni pasand hai. I just wrote what I have experienced.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: 'Chardee-Kalaa' Paath/Keertan
Anonymous User · 12 Sep 2008
i heard some Gurbani Kirtan sang by Lata Mangeshkar (as a recording) and really enjoyed it. she probably doesnt know the slightest thing about sikhi (or didnt at the time- that recording must be quite old). but it sounded good due to her talent for signing i suppose. am i shallow?
on the other hand i heard Jagit Singh singing some non-kirtan verses from Dasam Granth and I found his sickly-sweet toning irritating and seemingly pakhand (Guru forgive me for saying that), also his 'praying' posturing in the video also made me feel sick.
I once heard some kirtan at a Guruduara- it was Anand paath. I dont know what it was about that paath- im telling you it was neither emotional nor dry- but it was AWESOME. i wish i knew who those guys were or even taped it. it was like waking up and seeing the sun.