Re: Keertan From The Non-Panthic
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Gyani · 10 Jan 2009
I would leave aside the "excommunication but..formal or informal..." as all this is politics.
The reasoning by Sardar Atma Singh is the ultimate and logical reason to reject all those non-sikh non-panthic "keertan". This may sound like fanaticism..but its not. Only a SIKH who has complete FAITH in His GURU/GURBANI can perform Kirtan....and likewise only a SIKH who has Full Faith in His Guru/Gurbani will derive any benefit from such Kirtan. To all others..its just music/raag/kan-rass...entertainment...mostly. Once in a while a good soul who may be non-sikh gets touched by kirtan/gurbani..and begins his/her journey on the way to the GURU...like Bhai Lehna Ji..Bhai Amardass Ji....and many others..but such are few and far between..BUT IF one claims to be a SIKH and then questions the GURU...that is gone case.
Jarnail Singh