Re: Who is a Shaheed?
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Gyani · 16 Sep 2009
shaeedee is self willed.
all our shaheeds could have chosen to live..they chose death..even the most horrible tortures couldnt change their minds...
2. I am not sure about those who died....example... say in the 1984 Delhi Pogroms..were surrounded by Mobs and murdered...they were NOT given a chance to " change their minds"...they were MURDERED without choice ( but because they were SIKHS). Just how many would have agreed to shave and change their religion ?? no one really knows for sure...
Re: Who is a Shaheed?
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Gyani · 22 Sep 2009
When you pick up a sword..one is aware of the consequences...it could lead to death on the battlefield or one could return alive. Just as Baba deep Singh ji drew the line with his Khanda...only those willing to die cross over...( however certain death is in His Hands..its the WILL to DIE that is OUR CHOICE - consequences of that choice are in HIS HANDS ..IF He doesnt want you dead..it wont happen.)Baba Ji went on that offensive with the WILL TO LIVE..until he has reached Harmandar sahib..it was this WILL TO LIVE that resulted/consequence..of him carrying his severed head on his talee until he had reached his willed choice..Harmandar sahib..so even DEATH couldnt STOP Baba JI..many find it hard to see the difference...and think it s miracle..its NOT - its Baba Jis will to follow his chosen Path to success.
Akali Phoola Singh Ji ahd offered ardass to attack Multan fort. Maharaja Ranjit Singh learnt that his other forces were late and so wanted to wait...akali ji said NO WAITING as ardass had been oferred. He waded into the raging river on his horse..and his jatha followed him....
Bhai lachman Singh was also warned that the mahant naraionnoo was ready to burn all sikhs who came into nankanna sahib in 1920..and wanted him to trun abck from certian death..he said ardass ahs been done..I am going..certian death..so be it. He WILLED and left for Nankanna sahib and was indeed burned alive.
Re: Who is a Shaheed?
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Gyani · 23 Sep 2009
imho..its just a play on words...choice or commitment.
IF I have already CHOSEN I will NOT cut my kesh no matter what ( Bhai Taru Singh Ji) than is that a CHOICE or Commitment ?? To me its the same thing.
The CHOICE comes first..once its made..its commitment. A Sikh makes a choice to chhak amrit..then it becomes a comittment to remain a SINGH/KHALSA no matter what occurs.
We have CHOICES..BUT after a choice is made..the CONSEQUENCES are BEYOND OUR CONTROL..thats under His HUKM. Say I ask you to LIFT up your LEG. You have a CHOICE..lift up the LEFT leg or RIGHT LEG. Period. End of Choice. Now IF I see that you have lifted up your RIGHT LEG..and I ask you to lift up your LEFT LEG...you CANNOT MAKE ANY MORE CHOICES....without suffering the consequences..Becasue after you made the CHOICE of which leg to lift up..you are COMITTED....
Re: Who is a Shaheed?
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Gyani · 24 Sep 2009
A SIKH has to "pick up a leg" and take the First step Towards GUru Ji...and then Guru Ji takes a thousand steps towards him..
Guru Ji called for a Head..and Bhai daya Raam STOOD UP !! That is a First step..he had to stand up...and be counted.
Sikhi/Gurmatt is a 24/7 365 day affair..once a choice has been made its a life time commitment. no ifs and no buts..yes i agree.
Re: Who is a Shaheed?
Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Gyani · 25 Sep 2009
YES.
Re: Who is a Shaheed?
Sukhdeep SIngh · 31 Oct 2009
I often wonder why people like Bhagat Singh get classified as Shaheed in SIkhi? ITs unfair to place Bhagat SIngh in the same category as Shaheeds like Bhai Mati Das, BHai Sati Das, Baba Deep Singh Ji, BHai Mani Singh Ji, Bhai Taru Singh JI, Bhai Fauja Singh , Sant Jarnail SIngh.
The Singhs above where living matrys who offered their head to Guru Ji and died to destory the slavery of the people, while Bhagat did not offer his head or anything else to GUru Ji.