Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Kulbir Singh · 06 Sep 2003

Following should be taken as an analogy. It is written in Mahabharata that when Kaurav prince - Duryodhan ordered that Panchaali i.e. Maharani Dropadi be stripped naked, her honour was kept by Sri Krishna. But according to baani, her honour was kept by the shakti of Guru Nanak Sahib (Guru form of Vaheguru). Inside the avtaars like Sri Rama or Sri Krishna was shakti or power of Guru Sahib alone. This is evident after reading Bhataan de Savaeeye in Gurbani. Gurmat belief about Sri Krishna, Bishana (Vishnu) or other Hindu gods has been cleared up in the following pankiti of Guru Gobind Singh jee maharaaj: Main naa Ganeshe pritham manaayoo|| Kishan bishan kabhoo naa dhiyaayoon|| (I don't worship Ganesh before starting any new task and I don't worship Krishna or Vishnu either) Please don't be misled by the analogy used herein. Anyway, coming back to this example, when Drupadi came home after her honour was saved, she came to the room where Sri Krishna met her and they started talking as follows: Drupadi came home after her honour was saved in Hastinapur - the capital of the Kaurav empire. At home she met Sri Krishna who gave her delibrate smile. His smile caused her to shy and she shyly thanked him. But at the same time she got a bit angry and started the conversation as follows: "Bhagwan, why did you take so long to come? Why did you allow that dusht Dushaasan (brother of Duryodhan, who dragged her by her hair to the Raj Darbar) to touch my body and pull me by hair to the raaj sabha?" "No Panchaali, this is not true. I did not take even one second to come and help you. As soon as you called upon me I immediately helped you. They pulled your saari but your saari did not end." "Bhagwan, when I saw a doot from Duryodhan coming to get me, I immediately remembered you in my heart. I had hope that you would come to my rescue." "But you also thought in your heart that what was the position of this doot(servant). You thought that you could handle him. This is why you just scolded him and sent him away.You were asking for my heart with full concentration" "Okay I agree. But when I saw that dusht (evil) Dushaasan himself coming, I really asked for your help. I feared that ruthless tyrant so much and did pray to you for help." "I agree that you called upon me but you also were thinking that what can Dushasan do. You relied upon your husbands' might. You had pride on mighty Bheema's strength and Valorous Arjuna's Gaandeev Dhanukh (bow). You also thought inside yourself that they would no doubt protect your honour", said Sri Krishna smiling at Panchaali who was now getting confused as to what Sri Krishna wanted to say. "But Bhagwaan when I went in the Raaj Sabha and realized that my husbands were helpless as they had turned into slaves of Kauravs, then I did cry out to you?" "Yes indeed I heard a stronger plea from you but you still thought that the great men of that sabha like Bheesham Pitaamah, Dronachariya, Kirpachaariya, and great women like Gandhaari would protect your honour" "Bhagwaan okay I agree here too but when he actually caught hold of my saari to pull it off, then I was terrified. I did pray to you in my heart at that time but you did not come" "You did pray to me but you also thought that you may be able to protect you honour by holding tight your saari. This is why you held your saari so tight. You had some reliance on your own personal might." "Bhagwan, I am baffled. I don't understand. So when did you actually hear my ardaas?" "I heard your ardaas when you gave up all zor i.e. gave up all hope of outside help and totally relied on me for help. I help only those who fully depend on me. Those who keep other hopes, get only that much phal (reward). Whoever does ardas in front of me, shedding all other hopes, gets my immediate attention and I help him leaving all my other tasks. When you closed your eyes and totally merged in my name, I immediately came to help you. Ones who shed other hopes, get my help. Remember Panchaali that I am Deena-bandhu (friend of opressed and poor), not balwan-bandhoo (friend of strong)" If we just substitute Sri Krishna with Vaheguru, everything that he said in his closing paragraph is true. I wrote up this imaginary conversation between Sri Krishna and Panchali to bring forth an important principle of Gurmat and Gurmat Ardaas. Unless we have 100% hope on Vaheguru alone, we should not expect 100% kirpa. Vaheguru is always there to help. He has all treasures and 18 sidhis on the palm of his hand, waiting to give them to us. We only have to know how to ask. Regarding all treasures and 18 sidhis here is the pankiti to prove that: Sabh Nidhaan, das-asht sidhaan, Thaakur kar-tal dhariya Nidhaan means treasures, das-asht means 10-8 i.e. 18, sidhaan means sidhees and kar-tal means palm of hand, dhariya means placed on his hand. Are we prepared to take advantage of "Aisa Hari"? Daas, Kulbir Singh (Inspiration to write this story came after reading an article of Sardar Raghbir Singh jee Bir)

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

pardeep kaur · 07 Sep 2003

Bhatt Kal in Svaiyay Mehl 5 on Pannaa 1390 sathajug thai maaniou shhaliou bal baavan bhaaeiou || In the Golden Age of Sat Yuga, You were pleased to deceive Baal the king, in the form of a dwarf. thraethai thai maaniou raam raghuva(n)s kehaaeiou || In the Silver Age of Traytaa Yuga, You were called Raam of the Raghu dynasty. dhuaapur kirasan muraar ka(n)s kirathaarathh keeou || In the Brass Age of Dwaapur Yuga, You were Krishna; You killed Mur the demon and saved Kans. ougrasain ko raaj abhai bhagatheh jan dheeou || You blessed Ugrasain with a kingdom, and You blessed Your humble devotees with fearlessness. kalijug pramaan naanak gur a(n)gadh amar kehaaeiou || In the Iron Age, the Dark Age of Kali Yuga, You are known and accepted as Guru Nanak, Guru Angad and Guru Amar Das. sree guroo raaj abichal attal aadh purakh furamaaeiou ||7|| The sovereign rule of the Great Guru is unchanging and permanent, according the Command of the Primal Lord God. Bhatt Gayandh in Svaiyay Mehl 5 on Pannaa 1402 vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahiguroo vaahi jeeo || Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Guru, Waahay Jee-o. kaval nain madhhur bain kott sain sa(n)g sobh kehath maa jasodh jisehi dhehee bhaath khaahi jeeo || You are lotus-eyed, with sweet speech, exalted and embellished with millions of companions. Mother Yashoda invited You as Krishna to eat the sweet rice.

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Kulbir Singh · 08 Sep 2003

Bhain jee Pardeep Kaur jeeo, what is it that you are trying to derive from your quote from Savaeeye Mahalle Pehle ke? Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

pardeep kaur · 08 Sep 2003

adding more gurbani to the topic of krishna which i have found veerji and i agree with the post you put up.

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Kulbir Singh · 08 Sep 2003

According to Mahabharata and other Hindu scriptures, the honour of Durpadi (Panchaali) was saved by Sri Krishna. When Dushasan started pulling her saari to strip her naked, she remembered Sri Krishna and Saari never exhausted on her body. Dushasan pulled piles and piles of saari but it would still keep coming and Drupadi did not get naked. Normal saari is only few metres long but this saari went 100s of metres. Anyway, the point I want to make is that it is well-known in India that Sri Krishna saved Drupadi’s honour BUT Guru Sahib says otherwise. Please read the following pankiti from Gurbani: PANCHAALI KO RAAJ SABHA MEIN, RAAM NAAM SUDH AAYEE || The use of “Raam” word is highly significant here. There is a reason why this word has been used, instead of a Krishna name like Mohan, Shaam, etc. The honour of Drupadi was saved by none other than Vaheguru or to be more precise – Guru Nanak Sahib. This is why Guru Sahib has used the word "Raam". At that time of distress for Drupadi, Vaheguru did kirpa and for that time, she realized "Raam Naam" and got her honour saved. Please read the following pankitis from Gurbani: AB RAAKHO DAAS BHAAT KEE LAAJ|| JAISI RAAKHI LAAJ, BHAGAT PRAHLAAD KEE, HARNAKASH MAARE KAR AAJ|| FUN DROPATI-LAAJ RAKHEE HAR PRABH JEE, CHHEENAT BASTAR DEEN BAHU SAAJ|| SODAAMA APDAA TEY RAAKHIYA, GANIKA PARAT POORAE TE KAAJ|| SIRI SATGUR SUPRASANN KALYUJ HOYE, RAAKHO DAAS BHAAT KEE LAAJ|| Bhatt addresses the Guru-jot in Siri Guru Raam Daas jee and begs it to keep his honour. He reminds the Guru-jot i.e. Guru Nanak Sahib’ jot in Siri Guru Raam Daas jee to keep his honour just as it kept honour of Bhagat Prahlaad jee and killed Harnaakash with his sharp nails. Bhatt jee goes on and addresses the Guru jot and begs it to keep his honour like it kept the honour of Dupadee whom Dushasan could not strip naked in the Raaj Darbar of Hastinapur. Bhatt does not stop here but also acknowledges that Sudaama the who was poverty stricken and Ganika who was sin-stricken were delivered by none other than Guru Sahib. In the end Bhatt jee again addresses Siri Satguru jee and begs him to keep his honour. In the light of these shabads, it is imperative that our Sikh veers and bhains come out of the illusion that our Guru Sahibaan are new in this universe. The “Kot Brahamand ko Thaakur” Guru Nanak Sahib is anything but new. Just because he came to this world our ours, in open form just 500 or so years ago does not mean that he did not exist before that. It would be extremely naïve to think this way. Our Guru Sahib is “Sabh tey Vadda”. He has been around ever since "AAd". He is the Guru form of Vaheguru. He is Vaheguru himself. The avtaars like Sri Krishan, Sri Raam Chander etc. were sent by Vaheguru time to time but the power behind these avtaars was that of our Guru Sahibaan/Vaheguru. That savaeeyeea that Bhain Pradeep Kaur quoted should be understood in this context alone. Yes Siri Krishna was very beautiful when he was a child and as stated in that quote by Bhain jee but we must not forget that it was Guru Nanak who was behind all that beauty. It was the beauty of Guru Sahib. His Kaval Nain (beautiful lotus eyes) and his Madhur Bain (sweet talk) was because of Guru Sahib. Does that savaeeya not make it clear that it was Guru Nanak Sahib who in all four yuggs enjoyed the Raaj-Jog? What more proof do we need about existence of Guru Nanak Sahib, before 1469? Please read that savaayeeaa written for Guru Nanak Sahib again and go in bliss. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 09 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Excellent Gurmat principle highlighted in the story put together by veer Kulbir Singh: We must always take refuge of Akal pukh's naam by reciting from the bottom of our heart and we must have full faith in that. We must not seek refuge of other than God's naam. However, I could not comprehend the role played by Guru Nanak Dev jee in the incident(Panchali). It can be comprehend if we say jot of Akal purkh(Satguru) always saves God's bagats, Which also came in Guru Nanak Dev jee. Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Knower · 09 Sep 2003

This is off topic… kulbir Singh as you know Krishan had many names. One such name is “Madhu Sudhan”… what does it mean?

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Kulbir Singh · 09 Sep 2003

Madh-soodan means killer of demon called Madhu. Krishna killed Madh named demon and since then one of his name is "Madh-soodan". Please bear in mind that in Gurbani, Madh-soodan is referred to Vaheguru and not Siri Krishna. Another interesting thing is that I have seen only Siri Guru Raam Daas jee using this word - Madhsoodan in his baani. Of course we have to interpret this as Vaheguru and not Krishna. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

kps · 09 Sep 2003

Bhai Kulbir Singh jee, Is it also fair to say that it was the kirpa and jyot of Guru Nanak that enlightened the other sages and saints of all faiths?

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Kahnuwalia · 09 Sep 2003

Sangat Jee: Waheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh There is a Gurbani Tuk on Panna Number 1008 of Shri Guru Granth Sahib Jeeo. This Sabad is by Mahala-9. This clearly says that "Har kaa Naam Sada Sukhdai ....". Immediately after Rahaaoo, it very clear that PANCHALI was saved by GOD's name and not by Krisha's name as we hear from Mahabharat story. I humbly suggest that Sagat must take GIAN from this Sabad. Bhul Chuk Muaaf. Waheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 10 Sep 2003

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh In order to understand, how Akal Purkh saved the hornor of Bhagat Panchali Jee(Dropati jee) It is important to understand the definition of Satguru. Following definition of Satguru is totally based on the Gurmat: According to the Gurbani in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Satguru is the intermediate link between the devotee and God. With God’s grace, the devotee follows the Gurmat path, and honestly puts more effort in meditating on God’s name. The path towards God opens up, the devotee’s sins are erased, and the devotee becomes free from the cycle of birth and death. Without the Satguru, no one has ever reached God, nor will anyone ever do so. God has placed self (God) into Satguru, and the spirit can be seen by the devotee through meditating on God’s name. The Gurbani tells us numerous characteristics of the Satguru: Satguru is complete, is spiritual, exists forever, has been existing forever, is free from the cycle of birth and death, is divine knowledge (Satguru ke Bani), is divine word (the Sabad/Gurmanter), is divine spirit (Jot), is residing in everybody, is the intermediate link between the devotee and God, and is the vehicle/channel to meet God, etc. The Gurbani has addressed Satguru using many names. Some of these names are: beloved, friend, companion, Sadh, Sant, etc. If the definition of Satguru is not completely understood as per Gurbani, this can lead to the worshipping of earthly “saints.” Understanding this principle is very important. Only this understanding can stop this spreading of dehdhari (bodily) Satgurus, Sadhs or Sants who are preaching their own holiness and misleading people. In the Gurus’ era, no one ever called each other Sadh or Sant. Instead they simply called each other Bhai (Brother/Sister). In some places in Gurbani, the term Sadh or Sant is also used to refer to God. Occasionally it is also used to refer to the people who follow the path of Satguru, the ultimate saint. In some places in Gurbani, these earthly Sadhs or Sants are called thugs (thieves), who mislead innocent people into rituals and away from the path of Satguru. The Gurbani, like a mother, cradles us, holds our hand, warns us from the wrong path, teaches us Gurmat, and re-enforces the importance of meditating on God’s name. It also tells us to be a Sikh of Satguru, to be humble, and to meditate on God’s name with great love and devotion. If we carefully read Gurbani, we can easily find the direction given by our Gurus and Bhagats in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji: Be humble, it is better to be called Gursikh, Bhai, or Bhain rather than Sadh or Sant. If we think ourselves superior to the rest of the mankind then it is extremely difficult to establish or keep a close relationship with God This write up is based on numerous quotations from Gurbani so that the true definition Satguru can be understood to dispel ignorance about terms. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh Definition of Terms: Satguru: Spiritual; Word; Divine spirit Sadh or Sant: Satguru Gurbani: Divine writing in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Gurmat path: Honest living, Sharing & Mediation on God’s Name Sabad/Gurmanter: Holy Word; God’s word; Satguru Jot: Holy Spirit of God; Satguru Gursikh: Sikh of Satguru The Gurus: The Ten Gurus; Bhagats: Those on God’s path Gurmukhi: The “alphabet” used in Gurbani Khalsa: Sikh; Devotee; God’s slave/servent

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

SSkhalsa · 14 Sep 2003

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh Very impressive String of messages.

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Janpreet · 15 Sep 2003

Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh Bhul Chuk Muaaf karna but would it be fair to say that Panchaali was Krishna's bhagat and she asked Krishna to protect her honour? If she didn't, then why did she, for that moment of need, lost her faith in Krishna? Are we saying that Guru Nanak Sahib helped a non sikh who believed in Krishna, not Vaheguru? [%sig%]

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Sher Singh · 16 Sep 2003

Kulbir Singh wrote: > > Please bear in mind that in Gurbani, Madh-soodan is referred to > Vaheguru and not Siri Krishna. > > Another interesting thing is that I have seen only Siri Guru > Raam Daas jee using this word - Madhsoodan in his baani. Of > course we have to interpret this as Vaheguru and not Krishna. > Could Guru Saab also mean that it was in actuality the shakti of Vaheguru that killed the demon madh?

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 19 Sep 2003

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh Veer Janpreet wrote: > Bhul Chuk Muaaf karna but would it be fair to say that > Panchaali was Krishna's bhagat and she asked Krishna to protect > her honour? Not according to Gurbani: Bhagat Panchali Jee(Dropati jee) is bhagat of Akal Purkh, She asked Akal purkh to protect her honor. please look at the following sabad and others in SGGS related to Bhagat Panchali Jee(Dropati jee). This Shabad is by Guru Tegh Bahaadur Ji in Raag Maaroo on Pannaa 1008 ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || maaroo mehalaa 9 || har ko naam sadhaa sukhadhaaee || jaa ko simar ajaamal oudhhariou ganikaa hoo gath paaee ||1|| rehaao || pa(n)chaalee ko raaj sabhaa mehi raam naam sudhh aaee || thaa ko dhookh hariou karunaa mai apanee paij badtaaee ||1|| jih nar jas kirapaa nidhh gaaeiou thaa ko bhaeiou sehaaee || kahu naanak mai eihee bharosai gehee aan saranaaee ||2||1|| One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: Maaroo, Ninth Mehl: The Name of the Lord is forever the Giver of peace. Meditating in remembrance on it, Ajaamal was saved, and Ganika the prostitute was emancipated. ||1||Pause|| Dropadi the princess of Panchaala remembered the Lord's Name in the royal court. The Lord, the embodiment of mercy, removed her suffering; thus His own glory was increased. ||1|| That man, who sings the Praise of the Lord, the treasure of mercy, has the help and support of the Lord. Says Nanak, I have come to rely on this. I seek the Sanctuary of the Lord. ||2||1|| Veer Janpreet wrote: >If she didn't, then why did she, for that moment of > need, lost her faith in Krishna? According to Gurbani: Bhagat Panchali Jee(Dropati jee) is bhagat of Akal Purkh, not of Krishna. She has faith in God, no body else. Veer Janpreet wrote: >Are we saying that Guru Nanak > Sahib helped a non sikh who believed in Krishna, not Vaheguru? According to Gurbani, Satguru(Jot of Akal Purkh) is doer of everything. please refer to my previous post dated 9-10-03 for detials of Satguru. Satguru is not only of Sikh but for whole mankind. Satguru aways saves Akal Purkh's Bhagats. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

member · 22 Sep 2003

Veer Gurdaspuria ji, I don't think Dropati is considered as Bhagat Panchali Jee by Guru Sahib. No doubt there is only one creator according to gurbani and he is the one who helps all who remember him, but the shabad above does not mean that Panchali was Vaheguru's bhagat. Guru Tegh Bahaadur Ji is simply explaining that how Panchali, in her time of need, remembered (sudhh aaee) raam naam (the one she believed in as her savior before and after her honor was preserved) in the raaj sabha. Again, bhul chuk de muaafi. [%sig%]

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Harsimranjeet Singh · 22 Sep 2003

I'm confused. Was Guru Nanak Dev Sahib "alive" to save Daropadee ?

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

singh2 · 22 Sep 2003

We must all be careful in what we write on issues that have caused controversy within the Panth. The question of Panchalli remembering Raam Naam or Krishan the individual has led to certain people questioning Bhai Gurdaas Ji dian Varaan, so concise and learned reasoning in interpretation of Gurbani is important on this subject. On the matter of Guru Nanak's presence in other Yougs, again people need to be careful in their reasoning. In this thread Bhai Kulbir Singh has said >>>>>Guru Nanak Sahib is anything but new. Just because he came to this world our ours, in open form just 500 or so years ago does not mean that he did not exist before that ... The avtaars like Sri Krishan, Sri Raam Chander etc. were sent by Vaheguru time to time but the power behind these avtaars was that of our Guru Sahibaan/Vaheguru... Does that savaeeya not make it clear that it was Guru Nanak Sahib who in all four yuggs enjoyed the Raaj-Jog? What more proof do we need about existence of Guru Nanak Sahib, before 1469? Please read that savaayeeaa written for Guru Nanak Sahib again and go in bliss. <<<<<<< Whether this is correct or not I cannot say. How many of us can? However, in other threads, veer ji has argued that other yougs had only 'kirtam naam' and could not be delivered to saachkhand before Guru Nanak. Yet here the argument is that Guru Nanak was there all along. It was supposedly Guru Sahib's power behind all these 'incomplete' incarnations who could not deliver mankind to the ultimate realm. The picture is seemingly moved to fit different questions. I have no knowledge of the truth of this but whatever it maybe it has to be consistent. [%sig%]

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 22 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer Janpreeet You wrote: > I don't think Dropati is considered as Bhagat Panchali Jee by > Guru Sahib. No doubt there is only one creator according to > gurbani and he is the one who helps all who remember him, but > the shabad above does not mean that Panchali was Vaheguru's > bhagat. Guru Tegh Bahaadur Ji is simply explaining that how > Panchali, in her time of need, remembered (sudhh aaee) raam > naam (the one she believed in as her savior before and after > her honor was preserved) in the raaj sabha. According to Gurbani one who takes refuge of Akal Purkh's naam by reciting from the bottom of heart, have full faith in that and does not seek refuge of other than God's naam is true Bhagat of Akal Purkh. Our Gurus wrote these sabads with drib dristy, not based on stories. Following are some of quotation from gurbani about who is Bhagat? Panchali jee meets those requirements as Gurbani says. We should call all the Bhagats with utmost respect. Please donot confuse with the great Bhagats who also give us thier bani for our benifit which is listeded in SGGS. I am no position to judge any body who is Bhagat and who is not? But for sure Dropati/Panchali jee name came in SGGS a nuber of times. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Aasaa 451 har jug jug bhagath oupaaeiaa paij rakhadhaa aaeiaa raam raajae || In each and every age, God creates devotees and preserves their honor, O Lord King. Guru Amar Daas Ji Siree Raag 91 har bhagathaa no dhaee piaar kar a(n)g nisathaarian ||19|| The Lord blesses devotees withLove; sides with them and saves them. ||19|| Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Gauree 182 sagal bhagath jaa kaa naam adhhaar || God's Name is the Support of all devotees. Guru Amar Daas Ji Raag Gauree 246 aapae sathigur aap sabadh jeeo jug jug bhagath piaarae || God self is the True Guru, and God Himself is the Shabad; in each and every age, God loves devotees. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Gauree 305 jan naanak gun bolai karathae kae bhagathaa no sadhaa rakhadhaa aaeiaa ||2|| Servant Nanak chants the Glorious Praises of the Creator, who protects devotees forever. ||2|| Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Gauree 308 aapaniaa bhagathaa kee rakh karae har suaamee ni(n)dhakaa dhusattaa kae muh kaalae karaaeae || The Lord, our Lord and Master, preserves and protects devotees; God blackens the faces of the slanderers and evil-doers. Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 22 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer Harsimranjeet Singh You wrote: > I'm confused. Was Guru Nanak Dev Sahib "alive" to save > Daropadee ? Satguru Jot of AKal PurKh always saves Bhagats. For Sure, Guru Nanak Dev Jee was not there in Duooper Jug, Guru Nanak Dev Jee came in Kal Jug. According to Gurbani Satguru is: sathigur maeraa sadhaa sadhaa naa aavai n jaae || ouhu abinaasee purakh hai sabh mehi rehiaa samaae ||13||..SGGS 758 My True Guru, forever and ever, does not come and go. Satguru is the Imperishable Creator Lord; Satguru is permeating and pervading among all. ||13|| Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

member · 23 Sep 2003

Veer Gurdaspuria ji, I have full faith on the fact that Akaal Purkh helps the ones who remember him in need in any jugg. Indeed bhagats who japp his naam are the beloved ones of Satguru, but can anyone who asks his help during thick time be considered a true bhagat according to gurbani? All I am saying is that the above shabad doesn't mean Panchali was Vaheguru's bhagat. She was a Hindu princess, wife of five Pandavas, who believed in Krishna as her lord before and after the raaj sabha. She was only saved in the raaj sabha, Gurbani doesn't say that she was saved from jammdoots. Don't we believe that one can't jap Vaheguru's naam without taking Amrit but one can jap naam of who ever one have sharda cuz there is only ONE creator of us all. Bhul chuk muaaf. [%sig%]

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 23 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer Janpreeet, You have asked a lot of good questions. With Gur Kirpa I will insert my replay in your message > I have full faith on the fact that Akaal Purkh helps the ones > who remember him in need in any jugg. Yes, This is initial reqirement according to Gurbani >Indeed bhagats who japp > his naam are the beloved ones of Satguru, but can anyone who > asks his help during thick time be considered a true bhagat > according to gurbani? It is extremely hard to remember God if otherwise one believe in other things. Normally we say what we believe in difficult moments. Especially saying God's name one can not say withour God's Kirpa There are numerous quotes in Gurbani. God certainly do Kirpa on Bhagats. >All I am saying is that the above shabad > doesn't mean Panchali was Vaheguru's bhagat. She was a Hindu > princess, wife of five Pandavas, who believed in Krishna as her > lord before and after the raaj sabha. In this sabad and in many others Gurbani says Panchali Jee had full faith in God, Please review the quotes at the end of the message. Gurbani does not say that she believed in Krishna as her lord before and after the raaj sabha. >She was only saved in the > raaj sabha, Gurbani doesn't say that she was saved from > jammdoots. She must be very important that is why our Gurus and Bhagats used as an true example to make us understand their point. Rest I don't know. >Don't we believe that one can't jap Vaheguru's naam > without taking Amrit but one can jap naam of who ever one have > sharda cuz there is only ONE creator of us all. Gurbani says that there have been bhagats in each era, there is aways have been way to get Baptism(Khande de Pauhl or deekhea) before Sikhism , think about Bhagat Dhru and Pehlad. Bhul chuk muaaf Karne jee Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Gond 874 simaran dhropadh suth oudhharee || Contemplating the Lord, Dropadi was saved. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Nat Naaraayan 982 jio pakar dhropathee dhusattaa(n) aanee har har laaj nivaarae ||1|| rehaao || as You saved Dropadi from shame when she was seized and brought before the court by the evil villians. ||1||Pause|| Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Maalee Gauraa 988 dhuhasaasan kee sabhaa dhropathee a(n)bar laeth oubaareealae ||1|| In the court of Duhsaasan, You saved the honor of Dropati, when her clothes were being removed. ||1|| Guru Tegh Bahaadur Ji Raag Maaroo 1008 pa(n)chaalee ko raaj sabhaa mehi raam naam sudhh aaee || Dropadi the princess of Panchaala remembered the Lord's Name in the royal court. Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Maaroo 1082 dhropathee lajaa nivaar oudhhaaran || Savior of Dropadi's honor. Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Basant 1192 basathr shheenath dhropathee rakhee laaj || Even when she was being disrobed in court, Dropatee's honor was preserved. Bhatt Nal Svaiyay Mehl 5 1400 fun dhropathee laaj rakhee har prabh jee shheenath basathr dheen bahu saaj || And the Dear Lord God saved the honor of Dropadi; when her clothes were stripped from her, she was blessed with even more.

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

member · 24 Sep 2003

Jeer ji, Gurbani doesn't say Panchali was a bhagat or she had full faith in Vaheguru. Gurbani simply says that she was saved from being dishonored when she remembered (simar) the one who she believed in. God saved her honor through Krishna. You are saying that, according to gurbani, she wasn't a Krishna bhagat but I am saying is that gurbani doesn't say that she was not a Krishna bhagat. Do you believe that she was a true bhagat of Akaal Purkh Vaheguru? If she was then she would have been saved from jammdoots. Unquestionably there is only one God and he helps who remember him in need, regardless of their religion. It doesn't mean that they will get to sachkhand, but the Creator of all things does help. You mentioned that one could japp naam and be bhagat of Vaheguru (as Dhru ji and Pehlad ji) because people did got baptized before Sikhism. Since they got baptized, could they, by any chance, have achieved sachkhand thru bhagti? Bhul chuk de mouaafi [%sig%]

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 24 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer janpreeet, I think I have addressed all of your questions previously. You asking again and again same think. That is all I know, If you think differntly that is fine with me. You think jumdoots are big deal. Here are some tips then find your answer. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Aasaa 451 jo har har naam dhhiaaeidhae thinh jam naerr n aavai || Those who meditate on the Name of the Lord, Har, Har - the Messenger of Death cannot even approach them. Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Gond 874 simaran dhropadh suth oudhharee || Contemplating the Lord, Dropadi was saved. You have been saying Panchali jee is Bhagat of Krishana Can you give any Quotes from Gurbani to support that?????????? Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

member · 25 Sep 2003

Veer ji, I had to ask the same things again and again because they were never addressed. Anyway, thank you for taking the time to respond. There are only a few references to Panchali in Gurbani and none of them go beyond her being saved in the raaj sabha. Gurbani recognizes krishna's existence and Dropadi, along with Panj pandavas, was a bhagat of him. Vaheguru jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru jee Kee Fateh.

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 25 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer Janpreet Again You have been saying Panchali jee is Bhagat of Krishana Can you give any Quotes from Gurbani to support that?????????? Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Janpreet · 26 Sep 2003

Veer Gurdaspuria ji, Here are some of my earlier answers to your question, "You have been saying Panchali jee is Bhagat of Krishana Can you give any Quotes from Gurbani to support that??????????": There are only a few references to Panchali in Gurbani and none of those references go beyond her honor being saved. Gurbani recognizes Krishna's existence, and (I believe) Dropadi, along with Panj pandavas, was a bhagat of him. You are saying that, according to gurbani, she wasn't a Krishna bhagat but I am saying is that gurbani doesn't say that she was not a Krishna bhagat. Do you believe that she was a true bhagat of Akaal Purkh Vaheguru? If she was then she would have also been saved from jammdoots ( from the cycle of Karma). You mentioned that one could japp naam and be bhagat of Vaheguru (as Dhru ji and Pehlad ji) because people did got baptized before Sikhism. Since they got baptized, could they, by any chance, have achieved sachkhand thru bhagti? Vaheguru jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru jee Kee Fateh. [%sig%]

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

. · 26 Sep 2003

is there a shabad to say that one cud not acheive mukti liberation in previous yugas?

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Balpreet Singh · 26 Sep 2003

A re-post from an earlier thread at Is Sikhi the only Way to God The below shabad and its interpretation clear up all my doubts though: bilaaval mehalaa 3 || pooraa thhaatt banaaeiaa poorai vaekhahu eaek samaanaa || eis parapa(n)ch mehi saachae naam kee vaddiaaee math ko dhharahu gumaanaa ||1|| sathigur kee jis no math aavai so sathigur maahi samaanaa || eih baanee jo jeeahu jaanai this a(n)thar ravai har naamaa ||1|| rehaao || chahu jugaa kaa hun nibaerraa nar manukhaa no eaek nidhhaanaa || jath sa(n)jam theerathh ounaa jugaa kaa dhharam hai kal mehi keerath har naamaa ||2|| jug jug aapo aapanaa dhharam hai sodhh dhaekhahu baedh puraanaa || guramukh jinee dhhiaaeiaa har har jag thae poorae paravaanaa ||3|| kehath naanak sachae sio preeth laaeae chookai man abhimaanaa || kehath sunath sabhae sukh paavehi maanath paahi nidhhaanaa ||4||4|| This shabad, according to Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee shows the special nature of Gurmat vs. all other faiths (Gurmat Gauravta, 281). This shabad makes clear that in other Jugs, theose faiths were based on the transitory trai-guN, and none could give salvation. All adherents could not get salvation and had to come to Kaljug to be saved if they came onto the path of Guru Nanak. The rest of this post will be based on Bhai Saahib's Gurmat Gauravta. (interpretation) The perfect Vahiguru, creator has himself created the creation. Because it was created by Vahiguru, it is also considered perfect. In all this creation, only Naam's greatness has been kept central. This naam is only available in the Guru's house. Only by Gurmat Naam can one be saved. No other adherent of another faith should have the "gumaan" or ego that they can find true salvation. Whoever, through great fortune, get's wisdom from Vahiguru, that fortunate Gurmukh gets Gur-deekhyaa/Gurmantar from the door of the Satguru and is immersed in the true form of Guru-Vahiguru. Whoever has faith and trust in GurbaaNee from the heart, in side them, Gurmat Naam will take hold. The salvation of the 4 Jugs (epochs) will happen now in Kaljug. Humanity will get the one Gurmat Naam, and then they will be saved. Abstinence, controlling all sense organs, going to pilgrimage, etc. are all the faith of the earlier epochs, which was followed before. But these faiths were not salvation-giving by any means. In imitation of the religious acts of earlier epochs, even today in this epoch (Kaljug) there are countless misguided seekers who keep doing the old religious acts, but they cannot be saved by taking on these faiths. In Kaljug, whichever seeker repeats the praise of Gurmat Naam, they will be ferried across. The praise of Vahiguru's Naam is the true giver of salvation. Look and study the Vedas and Puraanas, and you will see that in each epoch there were epoch-specific religious acts/faiths that are stressed and none of these can help find Vahiguru. In this Jug, only that person is accepted who has received gur-deekhya from the Guru and has meditated on Gurmat Naam. Guru Nanak Sahib says that only such naam-drenched, Guru-blessed Gurmukhs have their love attached to Vahiguru and all ego is erased from their minds. Gurmat naam is so amazing that those who say and hear Gurmat Naam all find hapiness. By accepting and meditating on Gurmat Naam, the true treasure, Vahiguru, is found. kalijug oudhhaariaa guradhaev || mal mooth moorr j mughadh hothae sabh lagae thaeree saev ||1|| rehaao || thoo aap karathaa sabh srisatt dhharathaa sabh mehi rehiaa samaae || dhharam raajaa bisamaadh hoaa sabh pee pairee aae ||2|| (Gurmat Gauravta, 447) This Shabad makes clear that Guru Saahib has saved those in Kaljug, and htis has been happening since the time of Guru Nanak Saahib. Due to extreme ignorance and pollution, people had become fools, but they all have been attached to the sevaa of Akaal Purakh ie. bhagtee. The Bhagtee increased so much that Dharamraaj saw this and was astonished that all of creation has come to the feet of the Satguru ie. recieved Sikhi. This means that Guru Nanak's mission of saving souls will only finish when all of creation is saved. And then Dharamraaj will be shocked/amazed. this time will surely come, when the entire world will accept the Khalsa Faith. I was personally amazed to see that this shabad goes so far as to say: sathajug thraethaa dhuaapar bhaneeai kalijug oothamo jugaa maahi || Kaljug is the best of all the Jugs...this evil epoch is the best! Why? Because finally Guru Nanak, the giver of Gurmat Naam, has shown a path to Sach Khand and given the amazing gift of Gurmat Naam to humanity. We have an amazing treasure available to us...how unfortunate if we dont' take this opportunity and "loot" naam and find our true place with Akaal Purakh.

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 27 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer Janpreet wrote: > There are only a few references to Panchali in Gurbani and none > of those references go beyond her honor being saved. Yes, there is: Please look at following sabad which says Dropati jee was saved by doing Simran, The sabad does not say anything about Raj Sabha. Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Gond 874 simaran dhropadh suth oudhharee || Contemplating the Lord, Dropadi was saved. Veer Janpreet wrote: >Gurbani recognizes Krishna's existence, and (I believe) Dropadi, along > with Panj pandavas, was a bhagat of him. Yes,Gurbani recognizes Krishna's existence but does not say Dropati jee was Krishna Bhagat. Veer Janpreet wrote: > You are saying that, according to gurbani, she wasn't a Krishna > bhagat but I am saying is that gurbani doesn't say that she was > not a Krishna bhagat. Do you believe that she was a true bhagat > of Akaal Purkh Vaheguru? If she was then she would have also > been saved from jammdoots ( from the cycle of Karma). Please find your answer from the sabad page 874 Veer Janpreet wrote: >You mentioned that one could japp naam and be bhagat of Vaheguru > (as Dhru ji and Pehlad ji) because people did got baptized > before Sikhism. Since they got baptized, could they, by any > chance, have achieved sachkhand thru bhagti? Why not according to Gurbani?????????? Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Janpreet · 28 Sep 2003

Veer Gurdaspuria ji, You have referred to this tuk (simaran dhropadh suth oudhharee || from page 874) a few times. Yes, her honor was saved but I don't believe that this shabad means her janam maran de bandhan being cut by Vaheguru. Here is some of what I have said in my earlier posts: There are only a few references to Panchali in Gurbani and none of those references go beyond her (honor) being saved. (I believe) Dropadi, along with Panj pandavas, was a bhagat of Krishna. Gurbani doesn't say that Panchaali was not a Krishna bhagat. Do you believe that she was a true bhagat of Akaal Purkh Vaheguru? If she was then she would have also been saved from the cycle of Karma (Jammdoots). I respectfully agree to disagree with you Veer ji. Veer Balpreet Singh ji, thank you for your insightful response.

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 29 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer Janpreet You wrote: > You have referred to this tuk (simaran dhropadh suth oudhharee > || from page 874) a few times. Yes, her honor was saved but I > don't believe that this shabad means her janam maran de bandhan > being cut by Vaheguru. According to the sabad (simaran dhropadh suth oudhharee from page 874): The person who says God's name from bottom of heart. 1) Gets salvation 2) Never see Jam doots. In this sabad the Bhagat jee explained with a number of true examples with his Drib drisstee. If you don't agee with that that is fine with me. Again the sabad does not mention Raj Sabha, simply says got salvation. http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=&ShabadID=3266&Format=2 Janpreet wrote: > There are only a few references to Panchali in Gurbani and none > of those references go beyond her (honor) being saved. (I > believe) Dropadi, along with Panj pandavas, was a bhagat of > Krishna. Gurbani doesn't say that Panchali was not a Krishna bhagat. What a base less point are you making? You have not given a single Gurbani's tuk that give any clue that Panchali jee was Krishana's Bhagat. I have mentioned so many Gurbani tuks which are saying that she had full faith in Akal Purkh. > Do you believe that she was a true bhagat of Akaal Purkh > Vaheguru? If she was then she would have also been saved from > the cycle of Karma (Jammdoots). I don't know what else you want the Gurbani to say in order her to qualify as a true Bhagat of Akal Purkh???????????? Bhagat Naam Dev Ji in Raag Gond on Pannaa 874 is using her as a role model and making us to understand, how to do Bhagati of Akal Purkh. The result of the Bhagti is also mentioned in Rahoo tuk of the sabad: har har karath nehee dhukh jameh ||1|| rehaao || Calling the Name of the Lord, Har, Har, you will not be tormented by the Messenger of Death. ||1||Pause||874 Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Janpreet · 30 Sep 2003

Veer Gurdaspuria ji, Bhagat ji does give number of examples in this shabad but I Don't agree with you that the tuk "Simaran dhropadh suth oudhharee||" means "The person who says God's name from bottom of heart 1) Gets salvation, 2) Never see Jam doots." This tuk means (to me ) that, by remembering, Dropati was saved. You said: You have not given a single Gurbani's tuk that give any clue that Panchali jee was Krishana's Bhagat. I have mentioned so many Gurbani tuks which are saying that she had full faith in Akal Purkh. With all due respect, none of the tuks you mentioned says that she had full faith in Vaheguru, or she was a true bhagat of Akaal Purkh Vaheguru, or she got salvation, or she never saw jamdoots. Again, Gurbani doesn't go into details and there are only a few references to Panchali in Gurbani, and none of them say that she was not a Krishna bhagat. As I said earlier, I believe that she was Krishna bhagat. He came in Dauwaper and was called Krishan. I am not making any baseless point. Bhagat Naam Dev ji isn't making Panchaali a "role model" bhagat. He is giving example of how, by remembering, she was saved. I do know how Gurbani praises the power of bhagti and naam japp. Vaheguru jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru jee Kee Fateh.

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Kulbir Singh · 30 Sep 2003

I must say that I am enjoying this scholarly debate between Veer Janpreet Singh and Veer Gurdaspuria. Whether we agree with Veer Janpreet Singh or Veer Gurdaspuria or disagree with both, we must admit that this is an interesting debate. I want to make some comments: 1) The word “Udhaar” means deliverance from danger. It does not always mean deliverance to Sachkhand. It could mean deliverance from a bad situation, or 8.4 million life forms or some danger. 2) My personal stand is that whether it was Siri Krishna who killed Kansa, or Ram Chander who killed Raavan, it was the power of Satguru the Guru-form of Akaal Purakh, also known as Siri Guru Nanak Dev Sahib jee, that worked behind all the miracles of Siri Krishna, Raam Chander, Baavan Avtaar or any other avtaar of previous juggs. The greatness of Kalyug is that in Kalyug, the Guru Form of Akaal Purakh came out in open under the name of Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj, while in the previous juggs Guru Nanak Sahib or the Guru-form of Akaal Purakh – Satguru – stayed behind the scenes and this way enjoyed Raaj-Jog. Only in Kalyug, Guru Sahib came out in open. It is naïve for some to suggest that prior to Guru Nanak Sahib’s avtaar, Guru Nanak Sahib did not exist. They don’t know. I wish they studied and did paath of Bhattaan de Savaiyeeye. The above has been written based on the writings of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and on basis of my understanding of Baani. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 30 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer Janpreet You wrote: > Bhagat Naam Dev ji isn't making Panchaali a "role model" bhagat. He is >giving example of how, by remembering, she was saved. I do know how >Gurbani praises the power of bhagti and naam japp. I know, you will not admit, You have answered your own questions. one can't deny the facts: 1) according to Gurbani who can remember God? Answer: only those who has God's blessing Jis jan appne kirpa Dhare so jan rasna Naam ucharei....SGGS Kamie milie akhan tera Nao.................SGGS 2) According to Gurbani, to whom God saves during difficult times Answer: only Bhagats (God's but not Krishna's) Har jug jug Bhagat upaeia Paj rakhada aeria Ram raje.................SGGS Bhagat Naam Dev Ji in Raag Gond on Pannaa 874 is using her as a role model and making us to understand, how to do Bhagati of Akal Purkh. The result of the Bhagti is also mentioned in Rahoo tuk of the sabad: har har karath nehee dhukh jameh ||1|| rehaao || Calling the Name of the Lord, Har, Har, you will not be tormented by the Messenger of Death. ||1||Pause||874 Based on the Ragoo's tuk Bhagat Naam dev jee will never use Panchali jee as an example if she also was punshied by Jamdoot. You Probabily Know: Message in rahoo is the central idea of the message. Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 30 Sep 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer Kulbir Singh jee It felt good that we not wasting our time. Thank you for your kind encouraging comments You wrote: > 1) The word ;Udhaar; means deliverance from danger. > It does not always mean deliverance to Sachkhand. It could mean > deliverance from a bad situation, or 8.4 million life forms or > some danger. > Please review the following Gurbani tuks and others, which expand the meaning of Udhar, I believe mostly this word came in this sense in Gurbani. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Maaroo 995 kalajug naam pradhhaan padhaarathh bhagath janaa oudhharae || In this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, the Naam is the supreme wealth; it saves the humble devotees. Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Gond 874 simaran dhropadh suth oudhharee || Contemplating the Lord, Dropadi was saved. Bhatt Gayandh Svaiyay Mehl 5 1401 sree prehalaadh bhagath oudhhareea(n) || Satguru saved the devotee Prahlaad, Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Janpreet · 01 Oct 2003

Veer ji, You Wrote: 1) according to Gurbani who can remember God? Answer: only those who has God's blessing 2) According to Gurbani, to whom God saves during difficult times Answer: only Bhagats (God's but not Krishna's) There is no denying of the fact that not even a leaf can move without God's kirpa. Most people do remember God during difficult times BUT that does not make them bhagats of Vaheguru. If that was to be true, almost everybody would have been called "true bhagats". There are so many faiths. People believe in so many avtaars. There small wishes do get granted. But it doesn't mean that they are saved from jamdoots or that their janam-maran de bandhan are cut or that they achieve salvation. There is a difference. I agree with Veer Kulbir Singh that behind every avtaar or prophit, be in Krishna, Rama, Jesus, Mohammed or anyone else for that matter, it's the Shakti of Akaal Purkh Vaheguru that runs everything including this Universe. He is One, the "Karta Purakh". He can do anything. I believe that Dropadi, the beti of Panchaal raaj, was a Krishna bhagat. Veer ji, I get the central idea of the shabad but I don't believe that Panchaali was a true bhagat of Akaal Purkh Vaheguru. Vaheguru jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru jee Kee Fateh [%sig%]

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Dilbagh · 01 Oct 2003

WGJKK, WGJKF, I am very much disappointed by the narrow mindedness of us people. It is righ that Guru Gobind Singh Ji instructed us not to worship Lord Krishna and and Lord Rama as they are the Avtaars of Vishnu and whom we consider are below Akal purkh (god). Guru Ji also instructed us not not worship Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself or even Guru Nanak Dev Ji or other Guru sahibans instead of God. Those who follow this path will go to hell. I t does not mean we need not pay respect Gurus or lord Krishna and lord Rama ore other Avtaars. We know that Guru Nanak dev Ji were himself god with all the powers of god embibed in him, still we should not concentrate or recite only on Guru Nanak dev Ji but the god. It is clear that we should recite only vaheguru vaheguru and not jai guru Nanak or dhan guru Nanak, Dhan guru Nanak. Lor Krishna and lord Rama are no less than god himself as they were sent by god to accomplish certain prescribed missions with limited powers as required that time. They are equally respectable as our Gurus. But we have a hukam to worship only one god. It does not mean that we ignore the very existance or other Avtaars. This is my way of thinking as the wisdom to me by god. WGJKK, WGJKF.

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Gurdaspuria · 01 Oct 2003

Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh Veer Janpreet You wrote: >I don't believe that Panchaali was a true bhagat of Akaal Purkh Vaheguru. That is your opinion which you could not support with any tuk from Gurbani. I provided numerous Quotation from Gurbani which are saying she has full faith in Akal Purkh. Our Gurus and Bhagats used her as an example to show us the power Naam Jap. If we look at the terminology used by Bhagat jee in the following tuk, which indicate she was in very high spiritual stage(simran). Then, One can easily figure out what it take to get there. Naam jaap is initial of a devotee Dyana in the next then Simran, Live,............ Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Gond 874 simaran dhropadh suth oudhharee || Contemplating the Lord, Dropadi was saved. If we read Gurbani carefully we can easily find out that at what spiritual stage what happens, I leave that upto you to find out. Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Sri Krishna and Panchaali

Janpreet · 01 Oct 2003

Veer Gurdaspuria ji, What more can I say now. I guess we just disagree on this particular issue. Thanks again for taking the time to respond to my posts. Vaheguru jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru jee Kee Fateh